3 ms·
You point out some very real consequences, but that does not negate the possible advantages. Weighing the net effect really depends on your organizational objec
by s1artibartfast 6y ago
You point out some very real consequences, but that does not negate the possible advantages. Weighing the net effect really depends on your organizational objectives.
For example, I know people who are damaged from growing up in incredibly hard abusive environments. They Have shot people and still occasionally beat people bloody due to anger issues. If I had to choose someone to be in a life or death combat situation alongside, I would easily choose them over my less "damaged" friends.
In a similar vein, the Japanese were also known to be remarkably ferocious and obedidiant fighters and it is unclear if Japan would have done better in WWII if they had a less abusive military.
It is entirely possible that the optimal mental state of a soldier is not the same as a healthy and productive member of society.
- leokennis 6y agoSure, there might be advantages like you describe. But then you’re describing damaging people for life, only to extract 5-10 years of possibly more effective military service out of them. If that is truly a decision you want to take as a country/military, it says a lot about the kind of society you’re part of.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoIt certainly does say something about the society. Currently and historically there are many societies willing to damage or kill their citizens to further greater goals, such as defending themselves from being conquered or conquering others.
- jimbokun 6y agoGetting two cities vaporized followed by unconditional surrender and your enemy rewriting your entire governing structure does not seem like a successful military outcome.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI never said it was
- leokennis 6y agoWhile you indeed never said that, it is true that the Japanese military brought out a special kind of longing for harsh revenge in the US army, likely caused by their brutal military tactics.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoThis is true. I have never heard that revenge had an impact on the decision making for nuclear bombing, so I missed the connection you were making
- leokennis 6y agoThe bombing was not revenge per se, but the Japanese never surrendered even when outnumbered 20 to 1. Even worse, the last Japanese standing would probably blow himself up with a grenade to take out a few Americans with him. In this light, the Japanese basically “forced” the US to literally go with the Nuclear option: using such outrageous force on an already weakened enemy, just to get them to surrender.