3 ms·
Ew. How about we leave people’s heads alone during a video call. I think I’d much prefer a compressed view of someones actualy head and pose, to the eerie mons
by Aeolun 6y ago
Ew. How about we leave people’s heads alone during a video call.
I think I’d much prefer a compressed view of someones actualy head and pose, to the eerie monster that is created by this alghorithm.
Of course it’s research, and not practically in use yet, but...
- numpad0 6y agoHaving heads in a call at all is stupid enough
- heipei 6y agoI disagree. I am often in calls with half a dozen folks from a customer, none of whom I've met before, all with English names that I have more trouble telling apart than my native German names, and due to their audio setup and the different language I might have trouble distinguishing their voices. Worse, Microsoft teams just shows a bubble with initials in it. Having some kind of visual anchor, like this kind of virtual representation, would really help me remember people and calls a lot better, and nobody would have to share their video if they just got out of bed.
- xur17 6y agoI agree. In addition to a visual anchor, I find that it makes handoffs a lot easier - there are visual queues that can be used to see when someone is about to talk, which makes it easier to avoid talking over each other and knowing when to stop talking.
- sp332 6y agoOn Google Hangouts, people can upload a static avatar image that shows in place of their initials. And when they speak, there is a visual sound level indicator so you can tell which person is talking. I haven't tried this in Teams but the process looks very similar.
- retrac 6y agoI'm hearing impaired. The visual channel contains useful information for people like me, at least when there's adequate framerate and quality. (I have a feeling something like this synthesized video is going to be an anti-pattern for accessibility though in practice.)
- pmayrgundter 6y agoBasically agreed. As if home video work isn't creepy enough. Otoh, the more virtual our projections become, the easier it will be to manipulate them for fun :)
- dchichkov 6y agoIf you are using a compression algorithm, you want to use optimal algorithm, right? That is performing compression nearly optimally, right? Well, this is a step in this direction. Compression is an AI-complete problem :)
- alkonaut 6y agoThe transmitting side should be able to compare this version to the ground truth and if it diverges too much then it tells the receiving end to fall back to “normal” blocky compression artifacts instead of keeping the eerie one. So long as the face-specific-compression faithfully reproduces the ground truth, it should be fine. In a way it’s similar to voice-specific compression for audio. Knowing what’s transmitted (a head) is information that should be used. I’d love to see one of these algorithms used for other context specific areas where there is much less to “lose”: sports. Compressed streams of a grass pitch with players running after a ball has horrible compression artifacts when the camera pans at low bitrates. But the receiver should know what the pitch looks like where the camera pans - it’s static, and we had it on screen a moment ago!