7 ms·
ETH is a bad example. It had critical bugs and is more vulnerable to 51% attacks.
by croes 6y ago
ETH is a bad example. It had critical bugs and is more vulnerable to 51% attacks.
- zionic 6y ago[citation needed] Perhaps you meant ETC?
- twox2 6y agoI would also like to see this claim backed up or at least offered with more context.
- croes 6y agohttps://bravenewcoin.com/insights/bug-causes-chaos-on-the-ethereum-blockchain https://bravenewcoin.com/insights/bug-causes-chaos-on-the-et... https://our.status.im/vitalik-escalates-eth-2-0-merge-as-miners-plan-a-51-attack/ https://our.status.im/vitalik-escalates-eth-2-0-merge-as-min...
- Scoundreller 6y agoWasn’t present-day ETH a 51% attack against now-called Ethereum Classic (ETC) because they wanted to roll-back a transaction/vulnerability they didn’t like?
- crazydoggers 6y agoNo. ETC was simply a hard fork of a minority of people that didn’t like a change to the blockchain that fixed that DAO contract bug. A 51% attack involves a group acquiring 51% of the hashing power in order to confirm transactions that otherwise would be rejected (like double spends) Any group of miners (less than 51% in the case of ETC) are free to update or not update their clients as they choose. When any set of groups begin to diverge, then you have a hard fork. The difference being with a 51% attack there’s one chain everyone agrees on, however, someone’s been able to get everyone to agree on fraudulent transactions. A hard fork creates 2 chains that those two groups then maintain totally separate transaction histories on.
- Scoundreller 6y agoOkay, but which coding errors/vulnerabilities get on the agenda to fix via rollback and which don’t? That couldn’t be the first or last contract bug like this. If I come across a bug, will it only be fixed if I only exploit it to a large degree? What’s the limit to “sorry for your loss”?
- crazydoggers 6y agoIt’s a democracy. If you can convince enough people that it makes sense then you can implement a change. The ETC fork occurred because ETH was in its infancy and it was deemed by that majority that there was a legitimate bug that wasn’t in the interest of anyone to allow to go unfixed. Anyone is free to disagree. The value in the blockchain is in its democracy. As soon as you fork, if you have enough people you still maintain value in both forks, so it’s no loss to anyone.
- Scoundreller 6y agoSounds like a terrible place to execute MY code. A rollback has occurred and there’s no policy on when/why they’d encourage it again.
- crazydoggers 6y agoIt’s not YOUR code. It’s a PUBLIC blockchain. The contract you publish is public! Your gifting your code to the world in the hopes it solves a real world problem, and it depends on me and everyone else who runs your code on my/their computer with my/their resources to care or agree. There’s not “code roll back”. That’s not a thing, that doesn’t exists. A hard fork is possible, which is very different; it requires the consensus of millions of miners. The contract and transactions and history still all exist. And why would your little contract get changed? Why would that happen? It wouldn’t. Again, it’s public, it’s consensus driven. These are just uneducated straw man fallacy fud stuff that gets passed around. If you don’t understand how the blockchain works on a fundamental level then please spare us all from political comments. Let’s talk about facts and technology. Educate yourself before you comment. Read something other than Twitter and Reddit. I give up.
- croes 6y agohttps://our.status.im/vitalik-escalates-eth-2-0-merge-as-miners-plan-a-51-attack/ https://our.status.im/vitalik-escalates-eth-2-0-merge-as-min...