12 ms·
> So the book argues that when developing countries are pressured into free trade agreements This should have been obvious since the Opium Wars and the Opening
by oblio 6y ago
> So the book argues that when developing countries are pressured into free trade agreements
This should have been obvious since the Opium Wars and the Opening of Japan (see Commodore Matthew Perry).
All developed countries are pro free trade for markets where they are strong and fiercely protectionist where they are not (or they consider those markets strategic priorities).
I'm from Romania. Romania joined the EU in 2007, so we had to liberalize everything. It has generally been good for us (higher wages, economic growth, overall development), but I know all the German, French, Belgian supermarket chains.
Do you know why I know them? Because there are 0 (zero!) local supermarket chains left. They've all been bought by foreign companies.
Similar story for banks, car companies, whatever.
During the 2008 economic crisis Erste, Austrian banking group, repatriated all the local profits (from BCR, former major Romanian bank) to Austria so that the local banks would not be impacted. Similar story for OMV, Austrian oil and gas group (from Petrom, former major Romanian oil and gas company).
It's a mixed bag, really. You need some foreign investment to kickstart things, but if you don't start blocking stuff off, you'll never go over the middle income barrier, at best. At worst you practically become someone else's colony, or in the olden days, you actually were their colony (and what happened in Bengal in 1941 and Ireland in the 1800s comes to mind).
- DSingularity 6y agoWW3 was fought with soft power and economics. Now some countries own other countries and nobody is complaining.
- smolder 6y agoI hear quite a lot of complaints from all sorts of people about their economic victimhood. I've got complaints myself about what global economics are doing for our prospects as a species.
- baryphonic 6y agoConsidering that at the end of WWII, large swathes of global population were subject to colonial rule, particularly in Africa and Asia, I wonder how the current situation you describe compares.
- permo-w 6y agoSoft power and economics have been used as weapons for centuries Do you really think that their current or recent use is enough to warrant the moniker “WW3”? I don’t
- kar1181 6y agoSimilar things are happening in Croatia.
- pjmlp 6y agoTo the point that when I traveled around a couple of years ago along the coast, most people I met along the way seemed to be more confortable speaking German than English.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoSerbian/Croatian/Bosnian/Kosovar familiarity with German is something that dates from the era of Yugoslavia, it has little to do with corporate sway in the modern EU. Yugoslavia 1) allowed its people to freely work in the West, and many people chose to go to West Germany, and 2) Yugoslavia built up extensive tourist infrastructure in Croatia and Montenegro that drew predominantly German-speaking holidaymakers (and not so many English-speaking ones -- UK holidaymakers went for e.g. Spain or Greece during this era). All this made German seem like the language for communicating with foreigners, though among younger generations it is already giving way to English.
- pjmlp 6y agoYeah this was about 10 years ago. Thanks for the overview. Althought I did see enough Lidl and Aldi around.
- mrkramer 6y agoAs far as I know the history of my country Croatia familiarity with Germanic nations dates from Habsburg Monarchy[1] meaning 300+ years. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Habsburg_Monarchy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Habsburg_Monarchy
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoIn Hapsburg times, only a fairly small elite outside of Austria knew German. Most people in the Empire knew only their own language (or sometimes e.g. their own language and some degree of Hungarian). It wasn’t until after the fall of the Austro-Hungarian Empire that the average person – due to modern state-schooling curricula, business contacts with German speakers, or going to work in Germany – began to know German. There is quite a body of scholarship on the sociolinguistics of the Austro-Hungarian Empire, if you are curious.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoRomania still has at least one local supermarket chain I can think of: Oncos. I’m not sure how many locations they have outside of Transylvania, though. Sadly, Romania’s competitiveness in building its own businesses in Europe is weakened by being left out of Schengen. Considering that Mark Rutte’s party just won reelection in the Dutch elections, sadly nothing is likely to change on that front for years – he is the biggest force vetoing Romanian accession to Schengen.
- oblio 6y agoThat's on our government. We should just start vetoing some of those important treaties or other big agreements. We need to start pressuring the other EU members into pressuring the Netherlands for us.
- Florin_Andrei 6y agoWell, it's a matter of leverage, isn't it?
- jopsen 6y agoAre those supermarkets really all that French or Belgian anymore? In practice, many large companies are owned by investors from all over the world looking for diversification.
- skocznymroczny 6y agoThe specific ownership and the details are irrelevant, what matters is that a large chunk of their profits is extracted out of the country and doesn't get reinvested.
- Blackstone4 6y agoIs that really true? The international supermarkets may chose to invest by open new stores....secondly, they had to buy the local supermarkets in the first place...that went somewhere...maybe that was reinvested locally. It is not clear cut.
- labawi 6y ago> they had to buy the local supermarkets in the first place When foreign owners extract profits to recover their investment or pay whomever, wealth is in fact leaving the country - because they still own the capital (stores) yet get money back. It's not clear cut based on this. They could have invested beyond price, brought knowledge, improved efficiency ... It's also possible they are in effect extracting wealth colonialist style, which is something to beware of - at scale it can have severe consequences for local economies.
- viro 6y agoThats not how the economy works. Walmart profits don't get "invested" in the States. They get invested into Walmart. The wages and taxes those wages fuel always gets applied locally. Nothing is being "extracted". Thats just nationalist bullshit used to fuel protectionism.
- oblio 6y ago
- killtimeatwork 6y agoThat's where China was smart I guess. They didn't sign any treaty which forced them into free trade or IP protection, but instead slowly allowed their industries to build up via IP theft and strong protectionism. Now they have giant companies on par with the West's. Whereas everyone who joined the EU in the decade of 2000 (and the Washington Consensus before that in the nineties) is now a pawn of the Western capital with no clear path of escaping the trap of mediocrity. So far, the standard of living in post-Soviet EU countries is still higher than in China, but that's because of the much better starting point and also because it's just hard to provide wealth for over a billion people in a modern, heavily automated economy. However, even with their gargantuan population size, I see China potentially overtaking Poland or Czech Republic in terms of quality of living in the next 50-100 years.
- khuey 6y agoThey did sign those treaties (e.g. with WTO membership), they just ignored them.
- oyashirochama 6y agoAnd no one cared, it something that needs to be reckoned with.
- yorwba 6y agoThey didn't exactly ignore them. A WTO member can either comply with their treaty obligations (e.g. reducing barriers to trade) or have other members apply their own remedies (e.g. punitive tariffs.) If the effect of compliance is worse than the punishment (e.g. underdeveloped industry eliminated by foreign competitors vs. continuing to operate despite high tariffs) they'll not comply. If the punishment is worse (e.g. industry is basically competitive, but tariffs would make products hard to sell in foreign countries) they'll choose compliance. At the bilateral level, there's not much difference to the pre-WTO situation, which might make you wonder whether it's all pointless. The advantage of the WTO is that it provides a shared target for compliance: if a country follows WTO rules, pretty much every other member will be happy with that. Which is a bigger incentive than having to please every trading partner individually.
- starfallg 6y ago>I'm from Romania. Romania joined the EU in 2007, so we had to liberalize everything. It has generally been good for us (higher wages, economic growth, overall development), but I know all the German, French, Belgian supermarket chains. That's already known factor though. The reason of the free movement of labour to make up for capital movements like these.
- zz865 6y agoI'm from a country where there are several locally owned supermarkets. They're all very nice but eye wateringly expensive. I'd love if Aldi/Carrefour/Costco moved in.
- treis 6y agoThis is the counter argument. By protecting an inefficient sector you make it harder for every other sector to operate. If Ghana moves to protect their Chocolate manufacturing that will likely come at the expense of their Cocoa growers. The best way seems to start with low level work and move up the chain.
- jopsen 6y ago> that will likely come at the expense of their Cocoa growers. It'll be interesting to see. Making good chocolate certainly isn't easy. Nor is compliance with food quality standards.. But if they control enough of the chocolate production, I guess foreign manufacturers may choose to setup a processing factory in Ghana. Of course, it's not without risk. Foreign manufacturers could perhaps invest into farming equipment to make neighboring Ivory Coast more productive at farming cocoa.. But doing this certainly creates uncertainty and instability, which is rarely good.
- SyzygistSix 6y agoI think the quality of beans in Ghana is improving but they are still significantly behind Central and South America. As someone who worked making high quality chocolate in the US, people are less likely to invest in exploitative cacoa production just as much as low quality beans. If you are buying an $9 chocolate bar, in addition to quality, consumers are also looking to support fair business models. So improving the labor conditions, something many European companies seem to show little interest in, is as much a part of finding better partners as increasing quality. And more and more, these issues are just as important as quantity.
- refurb 6y agoThis. People in the US love to talk about how sad it is when mom and pop groceries stores close but people are just voting with their wallets.
- AdrianB1 6y agoIn 2002-2005 I worked with all the supermarket and hypermarket chains in Romania, I still have a couple of friends in CxO positions in the top 5 companies; you are missing the full picture on what happened there, but the story is too long for a comment here; the 2007 change had zero impact of what already happened in the early 2000s.
- oblio 6y agoI wanted to keep it simple for non-Romanians. The process started as Romania was implementing the EU acquis, after 1999. I'd be interested in the story, if you have time, but my only comment for everyone else reading this, these are technicalities, regarding the gist of my comment. They only change the timeline, but the main idea is the same.
- AdrianB1 6y agoThat is the point, the main idea is wrong. The 2 major factors were lack of experience of the Romanian owners (I had very close friends that worked at the failed Univers'all chain, it was total chaos) and capital to build the right format at the right quality.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- foobarian 6y agoI've been in Massachusetts for a while, which is a small American state. And guess what? 20 years ago there used to be many more local supermarket chains, that over time were increasingly absorbed or destroyed by massive national chains. I feel like this same story plays out all over the world, except that when you have countries like in Europe it feels like a more personal type of event e.g. "those foreign superchains are out to get our local wholesome stuff." But in reality maybe it's mostly just business.
- jldugger 6y ago> Do you know why I know them? Because there are 0 (zero!) local supermarket chains left. They've all been bought by foreign companies. It depends on your perspective really. When I lived in Oregon, there were Fred Meyers all over the place, but they're all owned by Kroger (HQ in Ohio) now. Are they 'foreign' because they're from another state inside the USA? AFAIK, Kroger keeps the local brands, so IDK why none of the local Romanian brands were kept. If it's anything like China or USSR, probably not a lot of faith in the local brands I guess?
- DubiousPusher 6y agoSort of yes. While a lot of the benefits of the development that comes with the growth of the grocery industry in Oregon will stay local, the surplus will not. It ends up in Ohio or inside pensions or investor pockets. But this isn't a great analogy because the U.S. federal government keeps interstate trade much more homogeneous than the EU.
- jldugger 6y ago> the U.S. federal government keeps interstate trade That's part of it, but there's actually also a set of interstate compacts (that still have to be "allowed" by Congress constitutionally) and also Uniform Codes (which don't). Particularly the uniform commercial code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Commercial_Code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Commercial_Code Basically, a think tank from the 50's decided to convince all the states to pass laws which just all happened to look alike because they copied from the same source. No interstate agreement required, they just all did it, no congressional thumbs up required. I... don't think the EU is quite on that level of unity yet =)
- leto_ii 6y agoAlso a Romanian here. My take is similar to yours, but I would go even further in saying that the 90s were even more catastrophic in terms of privatization and liberalization. Remember the 'shock therapy' years? Prices doubling every few months? Entire industries collapsing, prized factories being sold for scrap metal? Millions losing their jobs etc. - a lot of that stuff didn't have to happen that way. A lot of it was forced via Washington Consensus type reforms. To my mind the EU was our salvation not so much because of its economic nature, but because of its political one. The free market was the price we had to pay in order to be able to travel, work, study abroad, earn real wages that we could use to invest back into our own country etc. The EU also insured a decent degree of geo-political, strategic stability. Without the EU we may have ended up like our neighbors to the North/East.
- jopsen 6y agoIn the long run, free trade might not be a cost... Adjusting to a new trade regiment will always be painful in the short term. But many factories have moved labor intensive parts of production to eastern europe. Which wouldn't have been possible without the EU.
- majgr 6y agoIn Poland some share similar sentiment, but it was better to get rid of of all these inflexible, low quality companies than providing them with life support. Problem was with management and technology. You would need to get rid of whole management hierarchy, and at that time there was nobody who could replace it. Some relicts from communism still lingers here and there, for 30 years after fall of communism unable to turn profit. Or corrupted managers moving ideas or technologies to “friendly” companies outside. If you allowed these companies to exist there would be a more chance for forming oligarchies like in Ukraine, instead of that we have more robust middle class.
- leto_ii 6y agoI don't know the situation in Poland very well, but I think in general in Romania you (assuming you're Polish) are perceived as a success story. In Romania it's actually quite hard to buy products and services that are not provided by some foreign company. Most banks, all big shopping chains (as GP noted), lots of the food and clothes, agri-business, almost all the telcoms are foreign. As a matter of fact, even though we have our own currency, a lot of products are pretty much directly priced in euros: cars, home appliances, electronics, apartments, land, rents, utility bills. All of these go up when the euro goes up (they don't go down when the euro goes down - and the euro never goes down).
- lostinquebec 6y agoDo you have a counter factual? It seems to me too early to predict a lot about Eastern Europe. < 20 years is not a long time. 2007 means that the first children born after Romania joined the EU are 8 years away from leaving university. You could very well be correct, but I'd want to see some countries that tried this a lot longer ago.
- oblio 6y agoIt's hard to say, but... Almost all the cases of countries going from underdeveloped/developing to developed did it through various forms of protectionism: Japan, Singapore, Taiwan, South Korea, China, Hong Kong. I'm trying super hard to think of a country that did it by liberalizing fully. Eastern European countries might be the examples you're looking for, but it's too early to say. If you think about any sport, or any activity in general, it makes sense. You never expose the hard parts, you only expose what you can easily defend or what can defend itself. Or if you're China, you fake exposing the soft parts and then you catch everyone in your tar pit :-))
- Barrin92 6y agoNeither Hong Kong or Singapore are or were particularly protectionist and largely utilized their location to be entrepôt economies and port cities. They both lack a domestic industrial base and heavily rely on being attractive location for multinationals.
- WalterBright 6y agoAs a counterexample, the US has 50 states, and no internal protectionism. Yet there are no "colony" states.
- nytgop77 6y agopuerto rico?
- WalterBright 6y agoIs not a state.
- oblio 6y agoThe starting point for the US states is/was much closer than that of random countries around the world, to each other. US states, despite what Americans tell themselves, are culturally/socially/economically a lot more homogeneous than random countries around the world are to each other. And US states are all protected by the same federal government. None of them can really be abused by outside forces with little/no repercussion. They really can't be compared (US states vs countries around the world).
- WalterBright 6y agoThe original 13 colonies were pretty diverse. For example, some of them had slave economies and some didn't. That's a huge difference. Even today, some states are much larger than others, some are very populous compared to others, some are resource intensive others are manufacturing intensive, different ethnicity populations, etc. Their economies are diverse. > They really can't be compared Sure they can. They show that a diverse set of "countries" with no trade barriers results in mutual prosperity. It's one of the great ideas of the United States.
- oblio 6y agoYou sidestep the security aspect. Plenty of nations around the world are bullied. The US and the banana republics (which sounds a lot like arrogant victim blaming from the Americans!), Eastern Europe and Russia/the Soviets, Afghanistan and everyone, etc. US states don't have that problem. When was the last time Idaho had to defend itself from foreign interference, invasion, trade embargoes, etc?
- paganel 6y agoFellow Romanian here, a person very close to me died of heart-failure in the middle of the street in downtown Bucharest 10+ years ago, not a block away from her employer's HQs at the time. She was in her early 40s, her employer was BCR (the bank that had just been acquired by Erste), and said close person had had a few fights with the new Austrian rulers to be, she was part of the bank's trade-union body, she didn't want her colleagues' jobs to go away after the purchase. The jobs did go away after the purchase, in droves. A person even closer to me used to work for OMV immediately after they had purchased Petrom (our former State-run oil company). The stories I could hear back then could fill many pages, I still remember seeing the papers with hundreds of people's names on them, people who were supposed to be laid off the following days. And that was just from one company division. To say nothing of the fact that the Austrians had no oil drilling operations, no oil drilling specialists, nothing of the sorts, while Petrom had been in the oil drilling business for decades. Or how OMV had (I think it still has) as its major shareholder the Austrian State, so in fact we managed to sell our oil state company to basically another state.
- kaliszad 6y agoMy far relatives (but still the same last name) drilled oil in Romania before you could even call it really drilling, it was more like bucketing from what I was told. Maybe it was a bit exaggerated though the job was probably quite dangerous anyway as my relative almost burned to death. He was really lucky to survive with the burns he had - almost his whole skin was gone. The positive thing was, he grew a continuous layer of new skin and until his death looked very young. It doesn't seem Romania is drilling much these days, more like refining imported crude oil before exporting the products. Judging from what was left of a different communist regime the last 30 years haven't been easy but most people seem to be much, much better off now than before the fall of the iron curtain probably also compared to the general QoL development in the world, I haven't looked up any statistics but it definitely seems like it. The quality standards now are much higher in every respect, the work in a factory is much safer for the workers. You are usually looking at many years of retirement even when you generally retire later where I hear stories about people from factories dying quite early probably because of the working conditions, many small injuries over the lifetime, fumes, dirt, smoking everywhere and all the time etc. If you get injured at work in Germany and haven't done anything against the protocols, it is a big problem for the company - you will be compensated usually very well for your trouble. Companies try to avoid injuries as well as they can in my experience on seeing the shop floors of a steel foundry, where safety really matters, else you are likely to get hurt fatally. That said, no corporation is always doing the smart thing from the business or management perspective. There is usually internal politics, management strategies and more involved. There are also more and less competent people at every position. Maybe OMV should have kept some of the specialists and maybe educate them about the modern technology and methods. Generally the previous regimes were not very efficient with personnel and other resources so it is really hard to say what OMV should have really done.
- pgsimp 6y ago"They've all been bought by foreign companies." But were the local owners forced to sell? And is there an actual issue with them selling to foreign companies?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- petre 6y agoSo keep your money in a Romanian bank and buy locally sourced goods when there are alternatives available. I'm not talking about bananas.
- golergka 6y ago> Do you know why I know them? Because there are 0 (zero!) local supermarket chains left. They've all been bought by foreign companies. Is it a bad thing? I was under impression that these were exactly the kinds of businesses that operate better at larger scale.