12 ms·
Mac SE/30 logicboard recreation
- nsxwolf 6y agoVery nice even with the SCSI mistake. Plenty of production systems shipped with more bodge wires than that.
- RodgerTheGreat 6y agoLooks like decent progress being made on cooking up modern replacements for some of the custom chips, too. The prospect of being able to make fully-populated logic boards from off the shelf parts is exciting!
- rezmason 6y agoIf this is ever for sale, I'm buying it.
- kkylin 6y agoIt makes me wish I had kept my SE/30.
- krallja 6y agoPreserving or recreating the logic boards is important for historical recreation of antique machines — as the originals get destroyed, there’s less opportunity for new research. Having recreations like this lets more people play with these historical machines.
- sitkack 6y agoAnother cool part is that those old boards could get extended so that we can more easily sniff the buses or pause and visualize main memory, etc. So that we may better lift these artifacts into a purely symbolic space.
- superjan 6y agoNice project. Tip: for high quality CRT photos make shutter time is equal to a multiple of the refresh period. 1/60th, 1/30th, 1/20th and so on.
- wanderingjew 6y agoThe vsync of the se/30 is 59hz so good luck with that
- theatrus2 6y agoStop down and take a long exposure. You just want to avoid the focal plane shutter or digital rolling shutter, and capture one beam paint, or lots of beam paints to even out the intensity.
- im_down_w_otp 6y agoThe person working on that project does incredible work. I have one of his upgrades that added a 40 Mhz 68040, 128k cache, and Ethernet to my old SE/30, and it's been fantastic. I run System 7.1 on it to play around with HyperCard, Word 5, Excel 4, and a couple other old programs. It's fun to make things in HyperCard as a great interactive and immediate feedback teaching tool for introducing my kids to programming. More than that though it's nice to sit down and draw inspiration from an era and implementation that went out of its way to take a handful of very well researched UI & UX metaphors and deploy them consistently and thoroughly. When I fire the thing up and poke around it feels like having the Software Engineer & Product Designer version of a serene Japanese garden. The transition from a little 9" B&W screen to my dual 27" LCD workstation is always jarring, and I always feel like the clarity of my thoughts and focus suffer immediately.
- dhess 6y agoDoes Bolle sell those upgrades? Got a URL?
- im_down_w_otp 6y agoHe makes small batches of them at a time. Some of them depend on old ASICs from companies like DayStar digital, so I think supply is sometimes constrained by ability to acquire those old chips. The best way I know of to get ahold of him is to become a member of the linked forum.
- hakfoo 6y agoWhat I'm hoping for, and this extends to all the reproduction-PCB projects (aside from the Mac ones, I've seen a replacement Atari 800XL and some Amiga designs) is that we can come up with a way to reproduce the ASICs rather than scavenging them from dead units. For some machines, there may be an ample supply to scavenge (old Macs being famous for barfing their batteries in a way that destroys the PCB but leaves the chips intact), but some other designs have far more limited supplies of spares. Plus there's the attrition risk-- something is gonna get damaged while parting out some percentage of the time. The introduction of replacement ASICs would allow us to grow the total population of a rare platform. I could imagine offering a turnkey kit-- a PCB plus every part necessary to populate it and have a working vintage Mac/Amiga/Atari/etc, with fresh capacitors and enthusiast quality sockets and PCB materials. They were able to offer such a kit for the IBM PC, but that was famous for not using custom components.
- monoideism 6y agoReally, the best way to solve this is likely with FPGAs, not ASICs. If you're not using an original chip, does it really matter if it's an FPGA or not? Already, most of these reproduction PCB projects, including this one, end up using PLDs to replace hard-to-find specialied ICs (and even those PLDs are at risk of EOL). So it's not like they're using 100% original chips, anyway. I understand the urge, but unless the cost of ASIC manufacturing drops dramatically, I don't see this as being practical for small runs like hobby reproduction boards. Edit: I forgot to add: this is impressive work, nonetheless!
- zeckalpha 6y agoFurther in the article, there’s a discussion of replacing custom PAL logic with modern Atmel chips.
- monoideism 6y agoI mentioned that ("including this one"). Problem is, they're Atmel chips that are still in production, but I wouldn't call them "modern". Most competing PLDs are now out of production, and it wouldn't surprise me to see the atmel f16v8 series follow. More and more people just use cheap CPLDs or FPGAs (which unfortunately aren't available in DIP packages and so not pin compatible with the old custom ICs used in the 80s).
- gigel82 6y agoI appreciate this for academic purposes but in reality, unless you have a really unique / odd peripheral that only works with the antique machine's interfaces, it's much much easier to emulate in software.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- williesleg 6y agoWhy the F would anyone do this? There's plenty of stuff already around.
- imglorp 6y agoWhere does somebody get the ROMs for one of these?
- dmolony 6y agoYou can get an improved ROM from https://www.bigmessowires.com/mac-rom-inator-ii/ https://www.bigmessowires.com/mac-rom-inator-ii/
- imglorp 6y agoIt's nice of Apple to license/allow/overlook this, whatever the case is. Adobe is going after 27 year old historic artifacts. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26474032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26474032
- pcdoodle 6y agoWow! Impressed that he was able to get away with 4 layers. I wonder why apple needed 6 layers? More grounding?
- Someone 6y agoMy 100% guess would be 30 years of improvements in automatic PCB layout software and CPU power to run it (it wouldn’t surprise me if the original was partly/largely/fully laid out by hand, but that’s a guess, too. It wouldn’t surprise me because I know very little about this)
- repiret 6y agoAuto layout is still pretty terrible and used sparingly. I would guess it’s more 30 years improvement in CAD - it’s easier to keep fiddling with the layout until you make it work than it used to be.
- azalemeth 6y agoDon't forget the improvement in the design rules in the fabs as well -- the minimum distance between traces can be dramatically reduced safely compared to the past, as (presumably) can be the digital resolution of the gerbers (i.e. curved traces, however horrible to the eyes of some EEs, are allowed!). Also, yuckies such as via-under-pad and the like are all now commonly accepted (but I didn't see any on his layout).
- phibz 6y agoMaybe my dream of a Mac SE/40 can finally be realized, all one board. No add on accelerator.
- savoytruffle 6y agoWell old Macs with a PDS slot, the sky is the limit since it is bare CPU bus address lines configured as an expansion slot!
- Bud 6y agoWho needs a re-creation? I just pull my SE/30 off the shelf. Still boots! :)
- nullc 6y agobetter check the battery...
- II2II 6y agoInspect that critter carefully and regularly. Leaking batteries are common and will destroy the machine (e.g. corroded PCB traces and IC pins). It is also from an era which used capacitors were leaky. I don't know if the latter will destroy the computer, but careful repairs are required to keep it running.
- jandrese 6y agoI'm impressed you can still get all of the components to populate the board. I'd expect a bunch of the support components to be basically unavailable by this point.
- varispeed 6y agoWhat is the likelihood of Apple dropping an army of lawyers on this? These PCBs are probably copyrighted. My understanding is that schematics are fair game as long as they don't look the same in terms of component placement (but connections can be identical), but a PCB can be protected the same way as a painting?
- wang_li 6y agoAccord8mg to the site this board is four layers. The original board was six. Presumably it’s different.
- perl4ever 6y agoI vaguely had the impression that the original boards tended to fail over the years due to the capacitors. I'm wondering, if this replacement board doesn't have them, how was that done?
- hakfoo 6y agoI suspect the solution is that 1) you're going to assemble the new board with a fresh set of capacitors, resetting any wear/degradation clock, and 2) modern capacitors are likely improved from the early-generation surface-mount ones in many old Macs.
- perl4ever 6y agoI'm very hardware illiterate - I meant that I didn't see any of the big cylindrical ones and wondered if there is some story behind why they're not needed. Like this: http://pc-restorer.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/SE30-bad-capacitors.jpg http://pc-restorer.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/SE30-bad-c...
- ejolto 6y agoThe caps in your linked photo are 47μF. The orange squares in the jumper wire photo are 47μF tantalum capacitors, that won't leak. You don't need those big cylindrical ones for such low capacitances anymore.
- mastax 6y agoIt's uncanny seeing a CPU that looks so serious and complicated but yet has almost no decoupling capacitors while my microcontroller has let me check 32.
- throwaway2048 6y agodecoupling caps are pretty seriously overrated, there are cheap grey-market re-manufactured Chinese Intel core series motherboards that have essentially zero passives (except on stuff like VRMs) They still work fine. https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32941784993.html https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32941784993.html
- owly 6y agoExcellent!