7 ms·
There's a lot of high minded philosophizing in the piece including the notion that not having children is some kind of subconscious death wish of liberal modern
by Barrin92 6y ago
There's a lot of high minded philosophizing in the piece including the notion that not having children is some kind of subconscious death wish of liberal modernity, but I want to propose a much simpler answer, what if people have fewer children simply because they want to, with no deep sinister ideological underpinning?
It's not like people in impoverished nations have half a dozen children because of some deep intrinsic philosophical vitality, they have that many children because family is both social security and primary source of labour. In 'liberal' societies, but more accurately to say is developed societies (because the trend is the same in Japan and China etc), investing more resources in fewer kids is what pays off, and all material reasons aside grants more freedom to women in particular.
The whole tone of discussions about low birth rates always contains this implicit assumption that there's anything wrong with it. My spouse and I also don't want kids, and it's not because we're doing coke every weekend and can't wait to die, it's because we never felt like we wanted kids, and only in recent times do people actually have the kind of liberty to live that way.
- RestlessMind 6y ago> what if people have fewer children simply because they want to > The whole tone of discussions about low birth rates always contains this implicit assumption that there's anything wrong with it First, only certain societies have only recently arrived at a value that there is nothing wrong with having more kids. Traditionally, having babies and raising them was considered to be of utmost importance. Second, it still is of utmost importance given how our societies are structured. You want to work until your 60's, then retire and live until mid-80's? Fine. But who is going to work/pay for your food, entertainment, healthcare, security and general societal infrastructure? All those things need humans which you are not going to raise. So "developed" societies seem to convince themselves that there is nothing wrong with not having babies, while at the same time utterly reliant on "underdeveloped" societies to import people from. > investing more resources in fewer kids is what pays off How do you plan to balance Social Security and budget with fewer people working?
- Barrin92 6y agoI think the most straight-forward answer is that the working age needs to be raised, budgets need to be balanced, people need to be self-reliant and responsible for their own future, and if all else fails we have a safety net. I don't actually think that retiring at 60 is reasonable in a society like this, but I also don't think this is a huge problem because many people don't want to retire that early, myself included. In a society with fewer kids we'll need to plan ahead more, but we also are much more productive, so I don't see this as a problem, and most importantly not in conflict with liberalism. Subjecting personal choice about how many kids to have to welfare debates or population planning to me is the opposite of liberalism if anything.
- tom_mellior 6y agoI hate this narrative of "a pyramid scheme was set up by people who were bad at math and/or knew they would be dead before the consequences hit; now you must produce babies to feed the monster they created". There are so many other ways of stabilizing retirement systems. If by "Social Security" you specifically mean the US system, there is this interesting fact: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_(United_States)#Ways_to_eliminate_the_projected_shortfall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_(United_States... "If workers and employers each paid 7.6% (up from today's 6.2%), it would eliminate the financing gap altogether." (Also, the payroll ceiling is ridiculously low, and why does it even exist anyway?)
- gruez 6y ago>(Also, the payroll ceiling is ridiculously low, and why does it even exist anyway?) Political support. Currently social security is framed as a forced retirement plan. You pay into it while you're working and once you're retired, your payout is roughly proportional to what you've paid in. If you change it to something resembling transfer payments (ie. what you put in is unlimited but what you get back is fixed) republican support will evaporate.
- RestlessMind 6y agoSocial security's solvency depends on a continuous flow of immigrants to the US, which proves my point. Also, that is one aspect. There are multiple others where US depends heavily on immigrant labor (eg. agriculture industry heavily dependent on illegal immigrants). You also need young workers for other functions of the society. If everyone decides not to have babies, then societies have a very precarious future.
- sanp 6y agoAlso, liberal societies (correlated with higher income societies) have a higher opportunity and actual costs associated with having kids. Potential loss of income and cost of raising kids arw both significantly higher than in lower income societies.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIt's not a death wish for you and your spouse. It's a death wish for society as a whole (anthropomorphized). For you and your spouse, sure, have kids, don't have kids, nobody cares either way. Do whatever floats your boat. But if the society as a whole consistently doesn't have kids, then the society as a whole is headed to be replaced by a different society that does have kids.
- philipkglass 6y agoSure, if it goes on without end then a society will go extinct. That idea leans heavily on nervous extrapolation. It's like the people who saw a few decades of rapid population growth and imagined apocalyptic fiction like Soylent Green or The Population Bomb in response. Japan was early to demographic contraction. The UN estimates that its population will shrink to 85 million by the year 2100 if things keep going on like this [1]. That would be about the same as its population in the early 1950s [2]. Is that considered dangerously underpopulated? I understand the argument that it's risky not having enough healthy young workers to take care of the aged. But an ever-wider population pyramid just delays the problem and makes its absolute magnitude greater. There are a few ways to theoretically deal with the needs of the old without continual population growth: - Let them go without. People would die sooner after they become unable to work. A decades-long "retirement" period later in life would be unusual. This was the pre-industrial norm. (Not a good option, but the default!) - Increase the health span of people so that they can continue to take care of themselves later in life. This could be currently science-fictional projects like Strategies for Engineered Negligible Senescence or just instilling healthy habits to prevent diabetes, reduce cancer risk, maintain muscle mass and heart health, et cetera [3]. An elder-heavy but otherwise healthy population places fewer demands on younger people than elderly long time smokers, drinkers, or diabetics. - Deliver medical care and other support services with more machines, less human labor. This is also a bit science fictional but at least takes advantages of existing trends. Environmental alterations can also make it easier for elderly people to continue to perform routine self-care tasks like cooking and bathing. [1] https://qz.com/1295721/the-japanese-population-is-shrinking-faster-than-every-other-big-country/ https://qz.com/1295721/the-japanese-population-is-shrinking-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Japan#Vital_statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Japan#Vital_st... [3] I'm not sure if it is more outlandish to hope that medical interventions will prevent debilitation by old age or that people will adopt healthy habits en masse.
- Konohamaru 6y ago> My spouse and I also don't want kids, and it's not because we're doing coke every weekend and can't wait to die, it's because we never felt like we wanted kids I guess Sub-Saharan Africa is the future of humanity then. Because they are the only ones who are having children.
- CogitoCogito 6y ago> I guess Sub-Saharan Africa is the future of humanity then. Because they are the only ones who are having children. Is it a problem if future humans' genetic makeup is more Sub-Saharan African than it is today?
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoThis doesn’t seem like a problem to me.
- libraryatnight 6y agoDINK life is pretty damn awesome.
- brnt 6y agoRegardless of spins of pundits, most scientific analysis agree: its due to career demands outweighing everything in ones twenties and traditional support nets not sufficiently being compensated for with alternative support. Altought a career is a way to self deploy and actualise, and as such is great that we increasingly can, its worth balancing it out against other worthwhile ways to do it. It also has led to an economy in which its increasingly unaffordable to not have two full time workers per family. It is argued this balance is lost, and therefore birthrates suffer. I'd love it if me and my wife could work each 50 or 60%, we in practice we can't. Employers find it unusual, it is going to cost you because governments model their financial structures on the assumption of full time work.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Regardless of spins of pundits, most scientific analysis agree: its due to career demands outweighing everything in ones twenties and traditional support nets not sufficiently being compensated for with alternative support. Most analyses I've seen agree it's due to nonfamily social support systems shifting economic incentives away from having children as a form of personal support insurance, which is why it isn’t more pronounced, among liberal economies, in societies with greater young adult career pressure but instead those with stronger social safety nets.
- watwut 6y ago> its due to career demands outweighing everything in ones twenties and traditional support nets not sufficiently being compensated for with alternative support. What I have seen all repeated the same thing - education and accessible birth control for women lowers the amount of children to be born. The large amount of children is pretty often a result of not having all that much choice. Raising many of them is quite difficult in reality, even if you can afford food for them.
- brnt 6y agoNo, I disagree. The primary reason is that we keep defining self actualisation through full time careers climbing silly ladders where you can never stall because up or out. If fulltime employment was 25hrs, and/or we wouldn't have to compete with people (mostly men because of the imbalanced parental leave in many places) being able to focus solely on work, nobody would have problems raising children's in their 20ies
- jariel 6y agoOf course most people are not making 'children decisions' around national or ideological objectives. And yes, it's possible to be 'overly concerned'. But there is something to be said about a species that doesn't replace itself, that's an existential question. More importantly: the rate of decline is enormous in the grand scheme. If you plot a curve of human population it trends up correlating with industrial power, education, advancement etc. - but then it hits a sudden wall and falls straight down. If you extend the 'downward trend' of population decline outwards several decades it looks problematic. It looks like an extinction event. For context, if you care one bit about the 'greater good' and humanity, life etc. beyond your own life, then you'll likely have some degree of concern about 'extinction' or evaporation of people, culture, knowledge wisdom. People that do have a sense of 'greater good' would naturally have some anxiety over this.
- CogitoCogito 6y agoI think you're being overly dramatic. Humans will not go extinct due to this apparent drop in birthrate. If we lost 10% of the world population every 50 years for 500 years straight, we'd still have one third the current population. I.e. billions of people. I.e. more than 100 years ago. I see no reason to feel anxiety for our species. I'd recommend reserving that for the rest of earth's species.
- jariel 6y agoLosing 2/3 of the population over 500 years is the blink of an eye in historical terms. The issues is the speed but also the 'leveling out' threshold, i.e. if it drives downward, what's to say that won't stop. Finally, we have 'many cultures' on this planet, and most will go extinct at that rate, and we really don't know what an ideal situation would be for population on Planet Earth. Remember we want to build in some petty heavy safety factors into the numbers as risk mitigation. We literally just took hold of the reproductive process over the last few decades - this is a very big deal, like getting fire from Prometheus, and the first thing we've done with it is put ourselves on a hard downward slope. That's scary unless we know where that equilibrium will land.
- mk81 6y agoSurely it should be obvious that lower-than-replacement birthdates are a one-way ticket to the dustbin of history. "Primitive" peoples inherently grasp that we are nothing without our children. Only we "modern and enlightened" people do not.
- throwawaymanbot 6y agoHysterical to blame "liberal Societies" when in places like the US, the GOP have made health Insurance so un-affordable with the removal of regulation (which obama at least tried to address), allowing CEOs and investors to profit from a known unfair system. The GOP have also made sure in GOP "run" states to try and suppress worker wages while at the same time legalize owners tax breaks to enrich themselves at the expense of everyone. Its no secret how we got to where we are. so I ask anyone, who in their right mind would have kids? Its simply becoming un-affordable to purchase a home, have kids, and health insurance and some sort of life. Stop property speculation and REITS purchasing homes to drive up their other property investments. Bring in socialized healthcare like in the UK (and most of the rest of the world) and stop the insane medical HI pricing (check for basics like insulin in the US compared to everywhere else, its gouging.. plain and simple.) .. and then.. maybe... would consider it.