14 ms·
Is Consciousness Everywhere?
- dukeofdoom 6y agoThis channel has lots of content on this topic. Including interviews with all the top people. https://www.youtube.com/c/CloserToTruthTV/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/CloserToTruthTV/videos To me it seems like consciousness can only be passed from one being to another. And since we are all just a collection of cells, and everything that we are is coded inside a cell. It seems to me that consciousness must exist at the cellular level.
- skohan 6y agoIs there a reason you think consciousness can't simply be explained as brain activity?
- kkoncevicius 6y agoI don't think consciousness can be explained as brain activity. To me that would lead to consciousness being a form of computation.
- anthk 6y agoWell, physics work on a cause-effect basis, so does your brain.
- skohan 6y agoThere are more neurons in your brain than stars in the galaxy, and each one of them is a chemical computer. I don't think it's so far fetched that such a system is capable of a computation as complex and nuanced as consciousness.
- dukeofdoom 6y agoMy thoughts on this: 1) Your brain cells are just a special type of cell. How these brain cells send and receive signals, interact and make connection, is coded at the cellular level. Software without hardware to run on, is just text. 2) You are born with certain conscious behaviours that you don't need to learn. This behaviour must be passed between generations using DNA/RNA. Therefore the coding for that later behaviour must already be present when you were just two cells.
- skohan 6y agoSo I guess it depends on how you want to define consciousness. It's a biological reality that once sperm meets egg, you will have all the genetic information required to create your central nervous system represented there. But in my mind, this represents the potential for consciousness, not consciousness itself. In my mind consciousness implies self-awareness and subjective experience. You might then be able to say that a phagocyte has some rudimentary form of consciousness, because it has a "behavior" of pursuing and destroying undesirable bacteria and particles in the body, so it must have some level of "perception" over which entities are to be targeted, and which to ignore. But at that level you can trace the behavior to chemical signaling and sub-cellular machinery, and it's possible to trace the phagocyte's behavior to simple cause-effect relationships in terms of physics and biochemistry. So I think it's hard to imagine that a phagocyte has "experience" in any real way. I think when we talk about human consciousness, the content on which our subjective experience operates includes things like sensory information, verbal information and memories. And these types of information have neural representations which are quite clearly understood. And even for the task of consciousness, which is to interpret and contextualize all the sensory information coming into the brain, you can point to a brain region like the thalamus, which contains inputs from your senses, along with almost every other brain region, and make a reasonable argument that this might represent the physical manifestation of what we call consciousness.
- triska 6y agoThis seems related to Conscious Realism and the conscious-agent thesis: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00577/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.0057... Both articles address the combination problem. However, the one I linked to goes into more detail about it and in fact addresses two separate combination problems: “The first is the combination of phenomenal experiences, i.e., of qualia. [...] The second problem is the combination of subjects of experiences.”
- KingFelix 6y agoDon Hoffman and Bryan Keating conversation came out a few days ago https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cMJ03rzPVHE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cMJ03rzPVHE
- gilbetron 6y ago"shifting from evolutionary biology to quantum physics" - always a bad sign to find this, it just means some woo-woo explanation based on a very poor concept of quantum physics.
- thom 6y agoA powerful reminder of why I quit my philosophy degree after a year, thank you.
- KingFelix 6y agoFrom what I remember Koch and Tononi measure consciousness in Phi ( and phi is complexity) I remember a conversation at Towards a Science of Consciousness conference about this. If Phi is measured in complexity you could make a glass window complex and that is conscious. Also during Tononi's talk a guy walked through the isle and said something along the lines of 'Phi is the answer, Phi is god, Tononi is our savior' Thoughts on Phi?
- django77 6y agoCan you really make glass window that much more complex? It's still the same molecular structure with maybe a more complicated shape, but how it interacts with the outside world is still pretty much the same
- hntrader 6y ago"If Phi is measured in complexity you could make a glass window complex and that is conscious." If true, that sounds like a reductio ad absurdum of the hypothesis.
- animanoir 6y agoI would recommend Llinás book "I of the Vortex" which explains a pretty interesting reason for the existance of "consciousness". Also Wittgenstein has some thoughts about it too.
- KingFelix 6y agoAlso I am a strange loop - Hofstadter
- mellosouls 6y agoA nice summary from one of the main proponents of the pansychic approach, but curiously omits mention of David Chalmers and contemporary philosophy which the modern renaissance of interest in the idea owes so much to. Discussed regularly in this forum. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=%22integrated%20information%20theory%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=%22pansychism%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- vaer-k 6y agoSam Harris' thoughts on free will in his books, app, and podcast transformed the way I think about consciousness. Alan Watts talked about the consciousness of a daffodil, and that too had a profound impact on my feelings about myself and the universe.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoI tried a lot of guided meditation apps like Calm, etc. None of them - NONE of them - compare with Sam Harris' Waking Up app. To call it an "app" does not do it justice -- it is a container of content, to which he and others contribute regularly. The theme for all content is always consciousness. If you think free will exists, listen to Sam Harris's 1 hour series of audio on the topic. It will change your mind. I wish we taught introspection and self-examination in public schools.
- misterkrabs 6y agoWhy is this downvoted? Just honestly curious - I've never read these guys but I'm always hearing about Sam Harris.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoI don’t know but my guess is that both Sam Harris and Alan Watts are not science-based, peer-reviewed scientists. And the HR audience seems, to me, skewed in that direction.
- ThothIV 6y agoYes but for the love of gods can you stop trying to become bees? AGAIN?!? Honey bees are not conscious. They use their hive for computation, it acts as half of one brain, for each bee has its own half. See thoth.substack.com.
- gilbetron 6y agoIf you want to read a scientifically-based examination of our current understanding of conscious processes, I highly recommend: "Consciousness and the Brain" by Stanislas Dehaene. https://smile.amazon.com/Consciousness-Brain-Deciphering-Codes-Thoughts/dp/0143126261 https://smile.amazon.com/Consciousness-Brain-Deciphering-Cod...
- geophile 6y agoI have been hearing about Koch, and Tononi, and panpsychism, and phi for years now, in these articles summarizing consciousness for laymen, (a group that includes me). And these very long articles bloviate but never go any further than giving a facile description of phi, claiming that this IIT "theory" is testable, and then not saying how it could be tested. The articles from five years ago and this one seem interchangeable. I call bullshit. Could someone please explain what I'm missing?
- cambalache 6y agoYou are no missing anything. Reputations in academy are not only made by being correct and inventive. You can go pretty far if you know how to dress-up bullshit.
- kkoncevicius 6y agoI have one problem with consciousness is everywhere argument. Namely, if everything down to ants is conscious - how lucky are we to end up experiencing the world as humans? The chances are just too small for me to accept it at face value.
- namero999 6y agoAn easy resolution of this doubt lays in definition. Do not mix up phenomenal consciousness with meta-consciousness or self-referential consciousness. Clearly, only humans are meta-conscious. Homo sapiens-sapiens, the man who knows that knows. It's our defining characteristic and leads to all sorts of amazing things are we can witness. Mere phenomenal consciousness is anywhere _in living creatures_ so that even a bacterium can be said to be conscious (it reacts to light sources, for example, and is able to detect nutrients).
- TedDoesntTalk 6y ago> Clearly, only humans are meta-conscious. I like how you clearly define these differences. But tow do you know other creatures are not meta-conscious?
- namero999 6y agoShort answer: no other creature has developed complex languages, written books or made art. Long answer: there is a plausible argument that consciousness might be a gradient. Certain creatures might express some level of meta consciousness, yet still far from what humans can do. For instance, elephants, primates or even just a dog might express some sort of empathy or more subtle mental states that do not equate with the experience itself, which would be mere phenomenal consciousness, but they do not appear to articulate to themselves those mental states and do anything more than simple reactions with those states. Ultimately the claim comes from empirical observations: there's an immense evolutionary gap between humans and everything else, so that we can plausibly claim that we are the only fully meta-conscious creatures.
- kkoncevicius 6y ago
- TriNetra 6y agoA verse comes in Chandogya Upanishad: "Sarvam Khalvidam Brahma" (all this is consciousness)
- namero999 6y agoFor a superb and rigorous account of the ontological basis of consciousness, and why it might be superior to panpsychism while being more in line with scientific evidence, check "The idea of the world" by Bernardo Kastrup (or any of his work/youtube interview). Really compelling case. He used to work at CERN, and was the youngest executive at ASML, till recent when he decided to dedicate himself solely to philosophy. He's not your regular wanna be woo-guru for sure.
- coolspot 6y agoIt is well-known that people working in ASML don’t have soul, as it is etched out by Extreme Ultra-Violet.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoHe's a really good Platonist! Hardly anyone is these days. Too bad—he is easily the greatest philosopher of all time. I made a doc that introduces Plato and uses a keyword search to show his understanding of "Harmony" as the nature of goodness, pleasure and experience. Comments welcome https://docs.google.com/document/d/1lqXpXgWI5YMBCz1O0gCmrEwzfw65MD7-WZG1FL0fPPU/edit?usp=drivesdk https://docs.google.com/document/d/1lqXpXgWI5YMBCz1O0gCmrEwz...
- alyx 6y agoI also vouch for Bernardo. I have read all his books. His approach, reasoning and explanations have been very appealing to my analytical Mind.
- tgv 6y agoBy what possible commonly agreed upon definition could consciousness be equal to experience? The only result of accepting that definition would be having to invent a new name for what I (and I believe many with me) call consciousness, as badly defined as it is. To put it in the words of Syndrome: if everything is conscious, nothing is.
- warent 6y ago> To put it in the words of Syndrome: if everything is conscious, nothing is. I think what you're using as a counter argument is really a foundation of buddhist emptiness or vedanta brahman. i.e. that the percieved duality is an illusion
- tgv 6y agoYou're reading too much in my words, but I don't agree, I think: if it's perceived as X, there is something in it that makes it stand out as X. It may not be exactly what we think it is, but it does exist.
- seph-reed 6y agoThis seems like another one of those debates where there's a spectrum and a bunch of people disagree about where on that spectrum it's okay to use a certain word.
- 613style 6y ago> By what possible commonly agreed upon definition could consciousness be equal to experience? I'll turn the question around: What aspect of your consciousness is not an experience? What aspect of your experience is not a part of consciousness?
- tgv 6y agoI don't have an issue with experience being a necessary part of consciousness. My problem is that it doesn't seem to be sufficient, by a long shot.
- 6y ago
- waterheater 6y agoOne of the stranger theories of consciousness I've come across over the years is that of John Grandy. His primary hypothesis is that DNA itself is the source of consciousness. He tends to self-cite (rarely a good approach and only weakens his ideas from the perspective of an independent observer), but comparing the ideas in OP's article with Grandy's has got me thinking. "The Role of DNA in Conscious Systems" by John Grandy: http://publicationslist.org/data/john.grandy/ref-42/The%20Role%20of%20DNA%20_QBS%206%20(1)%20139-147.pdf http://publicationslist.org/data/john.grandy/ref-42/The%20Ro...
- Animats 6y agoFor small values of "consciousness". The author writes "Consciousness is any experience, from the most mundane to the most exalted." One could call that "input". Still, the author is a serious neuroscientist, not a philosopher. He did, however, start with a Jesuit education, which biases one towards thinking that humans are special. I personally think that trying to understand "consciousness" should be deferred in favor of trying to understand "common sense", or "how to avoid doing bad stuff in the next few seconds". Once we have a handle on that basic survival mechanism, seen in all mammals, then we might be able to address consciousness. Also, we could build robots able to keep themselves out of trouble. Biggest unsolved AI problem right now. It's the basic reason computers do stupid stuff sometimes. Trying to understand "consciousness" without the ability to emulate basic common sense results in philosophical tail-chasing. There's a lot of that around. I got too much of this going through Stanford CS in the mid-1980s. This was during the "expert systems" period, just about when expert systems turned out not to be that useful. The philosophers were still in charge. One exam question was "Does a rock have intention?", which gives a sense of where the faculty was coming from back then. (The reviewer meant "adduce", not "abduce". "Abduce" is just moving your limbs outward. The muscles that power such movements are called abductors.)
- visarga 6y agoI agree about common sense and keeping safe. Without consciousness I would not wake up to eat something in the morning, and I would die in a few days. Consciousness keeps me alive.
- jahnu 6y agoIf you'd like to start to understand the topic and the issues surrounding it this podcast episode is a discussion between Sean Carroll and a proponent of panpsychism, Philip Goff https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2019/11/04/71-philip-goff-on-consciousness-everywhere/ https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2019/11/04/71-p... Mindscape is the absolute best science, philosophy and culture podcast I've found so far.
- driggs 6y agoI've long pondered the idea that consciousness is inherent to all "things" - animal, vegetable, mineral; atom, planet, solar system - in that things experience _being_, whatever that means for a given thing. A recent oral surgery gave this hypothesis pause. I was given Propofol as an anesthetic, and upon awakening had an extremely impactful existential experience. My very consciousness had been extinguished, instantly, as if by a lightswitch, and for 45 minutes there was nothing but oblivion. If consciousness is inherent to being, then how could it so easily be nullified to the point of oblivion, and then brought back online?
- acruns 6y agoThere can be no oblivion if you experienced it. I would suggest reversing the idea that conscience is part of a being and instead suggest that consciousness is inherit in everything because it is everything. Within or without a being.
- driggs 6y agoPardon my inability to express accurately with words, but I most certainly did not experience oblivion. I am using the word "oblivion" to describe the state of absolutely no experience whatsoever. It was practically religious/mystical/psychedelic in that it truly felt that I had not existed at all during that time. (And, no offense, I get the George Harrison reference, but saying that consciousness "is everything" begs the very question of evaluating panpsychism critically. I'm posting this because it is counter to my own longheld beliefs that consciousness is inherent to being.)
- loopz 6y agoSeparate the blank stage, from the actors and scenery. For something to fill and empty, you know there's a vessel. It is integral and unseparable. Feelings, thought, emotion, drama, will always change and are tools for seeking.
- acruns 6y agoNo offense taken. But isn't nothingness or no experience an experience? It seems you did experience something, that something might equate to nothingness or the void or oblivion but there was an experience? It sounds similar to "experiencing" a thought. It happens and we can all agree they do, but what is it to experience a thought? Can you smell, touch, feel a thought?
- dr_dshiv 6y agoWe all start as single cells. When does the consciousness fairy come and turn the global workspace on? When neurons fire? Because no emergent property seems powerful enough to produce feeling — and because both sheep and snails seem to have different levels of feeling—i subscribe to the panpsychic view. For now.
- visarga 6y agoWhat is feeling? It's an expectation of reward following some action and situation you are faced with. Feeling is dependent on the content, the "game" the agent is playing. It represents a way to evaluate good and bad actions in order to maximise reward. Thus, even though feeling is generated in the brain, it is not about neurons firing. Having a life, something to win or to lose will automatically be the source of feeling, the brain itself is just a component.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoI think there is a lot more. I think a triangle feels different from circles. All forms have feelings in the embodied mind.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoMy consciousness (I won't speak for yours) is integrated yet contains many parts. It is hierarchical — and I am aware that there is much that I am not aware of. For instance, with some effort I can notice that a white wall is made of millions of blinking colored neuropixels. But normally that is below my awareness. When I meditate, sometimes I can notice that I'm thinking verbal thoughts—suggesting that verbal thoughts transpire subconsciously, as well. When I engage with people, there is a sharing of consciousness—and though I'm not aware of all that the others are experiencing, I recognize that my own experience is just the tip of the iceberg of "experience."
- mtalantikite 6y ago> When I meditate, sometimes I can notice that I'm thinking verbal thoughts—suggesting that verbal thoughts transpire subconsciously, as well. Something similar was coming up recently in my meditation practice, where I'd be aware of a vague impulse of a thought or idea arising before it became verbalized. Then I realized that I had had that experience before, when I was a kid and playing music a lot, where I'd notice the sensation of a thought beginning to arise but would put it away before it could get verbalized, since playing music needs a lot of attention and discursive thoughts will certainly make you mess up. I'm not really trained in Zen, but in reading a book by Katsuki Sekida a while back he referred to thought impulses by varying degrees of 'nen', with the first 'nen' being a thought impulse of pure experience before it is recognized by a second or third degree 'nen'. This sort of felt related to that experience.
- retrac 6y agoI have always had the rather unsettling feeling that my internal monologue is a post-hoc justification or rationalization for what my subconscious just caused me to do, and was not the cause.
- tomComb 6y agoUnfortunately I think there is a degree of consensus that that is how it works, and this is used as evidence for the lack of free will.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoThe Pythagoreans believed that soul (greek: "psyche") was different from conscious sensation. Philolaus, for instance, wrote that the interaction of soul and body produced feeling. Soul referred to the immaterial nature of eternal reality — immaterial and eternal in the sense of mathematics. For instance, spheres and triangles are never perfectly instantiated in the material world, yet they are very real. This I find fascinating — that perhaps a certain soulful software needs to interact with material phenomena in order to create feeling. I don't know that I believe it, but it is a sensible reason to believe that consciousness is not pervasive.
- visarga 6y ago> perhaps a certain soulful software needs to interact with material phenomena in order to create feeling In other words embodyment is a necessity for consciousness. The ability to explore, interact, make experiments, test theories, they all depend on having an able body to move around and a rich environment to explore. A body also brings necessities - the agent needs to work to keep itself alive, and has goals, positive and negative rewards. These are ingredients without which there would be no point for consciousness to exist.
- morpheos137 6y agoBefore we can ask intelligent, falsifiable questions about consciousness we need a rigorous definition of what consciousness is. Personally I think the word is a vague term and that a rigorous definition is impossible. Therefore, if my hypothesis is true, we can not not scientifically investigate "consciousness" any more than we can scientifically investigate "divinity" or "spookiness." If you disagree with my hypothesis then I challenge you to define the term in a non-circular, objective way. My hypothesis is that consciousness is not an objective thing. It is merely an experience of the mind, thus it is an amorphous amalgam of feeling, memory, sensation, thought, embodiment.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoWell, remember, we can't even rigorously define something like "life". Doesn't mean we can't scientifically investigate it.
- morpheos137 6y agoSure we can. Biological life is something that replicates autonomously using DNA contained inside the apparatus of at least one cell. Viruses are not alive because they can not replicate on their own and do not produce their own cells. More abstractly life is something that follows the Darwinian program as demonstrated on Earth. If you had competing, replicating programs in a virtualised Earth-like environment I would say they were alive too if they could fully reproduce and establish resource economising ecosystems on their own.
- rhn_mk1 6y agoYou seem to be able to, but it doesn't seem to generalize to scientists in general: https://www.quantamagazine.org/what-is-life-its-vast-diversity-defies-easy-definition-20210309/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/what-is-life-its-vast-diversi...
- morpheos137 6y agoI was creating an operational definition. Of course others disagree. That is how words work. They have narrower and broader meanings to different people or in different contexts. The fact the others disagree with my operational definition does not invalidate my operational definition which stands on its own. Gp asserted "We don't know how to define life." I put forth a closed definition of life that makes sense. Others may have a less restrictive definition...my definition demonstrated that sufficient conditions exist to define life.
- statstutor 6y agoI imagine my consciousness as a communion of all my cells... a central decision-making council, if you like. If my cells are in conflict or disagreement about what action to take (which I presume they often are), my consciousness resolves this by taking a decision. As such, I find it likely that this sense and experience of consciousness is shared by all, or almost all, multi-cellular organisms on the same evolutionary tree of life.
- boonware 6y agoTest
- boonware 6y agoWhile Tononi's theory is interesting, it cannot be a complete explanation of conciousness at any level; it does not answer the Hard Problem of Conciousness. Fundamentally, we need to understand why we have inner subjective experiences that feel the way they do. It sometimes keeps me awake at night troubling over how we could even begin to cast an explanation for this intimately subjective phenomenon in the objective language of mathematics and physics.
- frongpik 6y agoThis sounds like the bottom up approach, i.e. that "consciousness" is more like a medium that's everywhere, even an atom has a bit of this consciousness, and when such small bits assemble together, a bigger consciousness emerges. In this approach, I'm tempted to equate consciousness with the electromagnetic field - it's this field that allows us to experience the world. However human mind is something entirely different: it's a self-conscious something built on top of "raw consciousness".
- visarga 6y ago> I'm tempted to equate consciousness with the electromagnetic field There would be no point. Consciousness has a purpose related to replication, it's not just a background field.
- ryandvm 6y agoI find the "individual atoms are conscious" to be kind of dopey, but I do like the idea that consciousness is a sort of gradient. I would describe consciousness as the ability for an information processing system to model the world around it, and importantly, said information processing system's place in it. As I sit here, my model of the world around me is humming along nicely. I believe I am quite conscious. My dog is sitting here beside me (awake) seems to be experiencing consciousness. My other sleeping dog is not conscious - perhaps it is dreaming, but that's not really modelling the world around it. And as we move down the scale, I become less and less convinced that various creatures are conscious. Birds? Sure. Fish? Maybe. Ants? Hmm. Bacteria? No. At the lowest level, creatures that simply respond to stimuli are not conscious. But there's a lot of wiggle room between a bacterium and me. Right before I wake up in the morning, my model isn't really working. I would say at that point I'm not conscious. But within a few seconds, the model is running and I understand my place in it. That isn't an on/off situation. It's a gradient that I quickly pass through; becoming ever more conscious along the way. And every night (or if I get a deteriorating neuronal disease and my neurons start to die off), the whole thing plays in reverse. My consciousness dwindles down to nothingness.
- visarga 6y agoI don't think so. Let's be logical - consciousness, what is it good for? It protects the body, keeps itself alive. Then you can't have consciousness everywhere. It needs self replication, evolution and learning in order to exist. You need to have agent and environment in order to have consciousness, an agent with goals and needs, just any rock will not make a decent agent.
- tim333 6y agoI agree an evolutionary approach seems a good way of looking at the thing. Being conscious of what is going on around you is obviously an advantage over not. Also from a how the brain works point of view you have billions of neurons recognising things in parallel and the data seems to narrow down from that to awareness of a small number of things which you can logically reason about. I'd imagine a lot of the conscious experience comes from that - the neural net highlights as it were. Like if you're in the woods your pattern recogniser bits may be going there's a leaf there, there's a twig there, there's a bear attacking, there's some moss on the tree etc. and then the bear bit will get highlighted so you can think 'ah pepper spray' or what have you. The highlights being what we experience as consciousness. It implies you get human like consciousness from that kind of mechanism so yes for a mouse, no for a carrot. It also differentiates stuff going on in your brain that you are aware of and respond to but are not consciously aware of to that which you are. Say you are being chased by the bear and run. The logistics of running - path dips 2cm, raise left leg 5cm... you will not be consciously aware of because the highlights and logical reasoning bit will be busy with 'shit -there's bear what next?' type issues.
- randomsearch 6y agoWhat is consciousness? I have the feeling of experiencing things. Is it not possible that such a phenomenon can be produced within a machine? When I try to answer this question, after coding for decades I can’t tell you how this phenomenon can be possible within a Turing machine. So it seems obvious to me that (a) brains must be machines and (b) a machine cannot be conscious and so I conclude that (c) I don’t know what I’m talking about.
- ohazi 6y agoWhat is a feeling?
- visarga 6y agoHave you ever had a moment when your program was more complex than you could grasp? Consciousness is just too complex to grasp, not transcendent. It's physical like everything else.
- proc0 6y agoLol, I was thinking along those lines... we are talking about consciousness with language... which was created by it long before we posed the question. I'm trapped trying to explain to myself how explaining to myself is even possible without language which was created by that which I'm trying to explain with language.
- Mattasher 6y agoFor those looking for a deep (audio) dive into the details of panpsychism, I interviewed author and researcher Tam Hunt about the subject last year: https://mattasher.com/2020/07/19/episode-11-tam-hunt-on-consciousness-resonance-and-why-cats-fight-their-own-tails/ https://mattasher.com/2020/07/19/episode-11-tam-hunt-on-cons...
- srameshc 6y ago> Some distinguish awareness from consciousness; I don’t find this distinction helpful and so I use these two words interchangeably. We treat everything as an object, even mental thoughts and experiences. When we think of awareness, we objectify that awareness using one of the sense experience. But consciousness transcends awareness and in consciousness exits awareness. Consciousness is not an object of experience and that is why it is difficult to understand.
- hilbert42 6y agoWhether one shares Christof Koch's views on consciousness, panpsychism and or agrees or disagrees with the other postulates he makes in this essay - and there's a great deal to argue about - one would have to conclude that this is a remarkable piece of writing. Koch not only writes from a position of possessing great knowledge of the subject but also he does so in a most coherent and lucid manner. Moreovr, he simultaneously conveying his own convictions with ease, eloquence and finesse. Koch's analysis is certainly the most comprehensive of any short analysis of this subject material I've read, it was also the most understandable and enjoyable.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ncmncm 6y agoSaying everything is conscious is exactly like saying nothing is conscious. To make distinctions, you need differences. The confusion people experience around consciousness amounts to a language problem. We want nouns to refer to things, but nouns can equally refer to activities. What happens to your consciousness when you die? What happens to your breathing when you die? What happens to the speed when the car stops? If consciousness is an activity, then it can come and go, like sleeping can subside and be replaced by eating. The sleeping hasn't gone anywhere, there's nothing to go and nowhere for it to go to.
- mssundaram 6y agoTo answer the title's question simply from a Hindu perspective - yes, definitely, consciousness (God) is everywhere and in everything.
- anthk 6y agoprove it.
- ivan_ah 6y agoI'm not sure if it is a "proof" of any sort, but I find the ideas in the माण्डूक्य उपनिषद् (Mandukya Upanishad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandukya_Upanishad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandukya_Upanishad ) to be a very interesting point of view. This short text discusses the theory of four states of consciousness: Waking \ Dreaming > Turiya ≝ pure consciousness illuminating these Deep dreamless sleep / These two lectures were very good: - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eGKFTUuJppU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eGKFTUuJppU - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F0dugc4TrlE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F0dugc4TrlE And you can read the original text here: https://universaltheosophy.com/sacred-texts/mandukya-upanishad/ https://universaltheosophy.com/sacred-texts/mandukya-upanish...
- mssundaram 6y agoSwami Sarvapriyananda is really good. You might enjoy this lecture, too - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjBJPz8hF_M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjBJPz8hF_M
- anthk 6y agoThat's pseudoscience, sorry.
- mssundaram 6y agoWhy? But here's one approach to that - https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EjBJPz8hF_M https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EjBJPz8hF_M
- tim333 6y ago>defining it is actually straightforward. Here goes: Consciousness is experience. Doesn't seem very useful to me. A bit like brexit means brexit. I mean machine learning gains from experience of new inputs - does that mean the thing is conscious?
- Jeff_Brown 6y agoWhat is a "maximally irreducible cause-effect structure"?
- Jeff_Brown 6y agoThe claim that a more complex system is capable of a richer experience seems like exactly the sort of baseless chauvinism that the article begins by taking on. Also "richer" seems like it could use a definition.
- ilaksh 6y agoWhat does he mean by causal? The normal connotation kind of implies that you feel something if you are an organism that acts on the world. Or something.
- Jeff_Brown 6y agoI love this idea, and yet it seems completely useless, untestable, unfalsifiable. Maybe everything has experience. Maybe every subset of everything has experience. We can't know.
- gverrilla 6y agoMit Press 2021
- TrispusAttucks 6y agoHere is a link to Panpsychism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panpsychism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panpsychism As an aside to all the comments regarding a definition and defining consciousness: It's possible for things to not be reducible to objective language constructs. The nature of subjectivity is that it can't be defined. I fear (at least in science contexts) we will chase our tails forever!
- loopz 6y agoEither 1: Consciousness is everywhere and all. Or 2: Consciousness is nowhere. Who is it that is asking the question? The answer is purely existential. The question is childish!
- diibv 6y agoDonald Hoffman has already been mentioned in the comments. Here's his interesting talk "Realism Is False" on Edge.org: https://www.edge.org/conversation/donald_d_hoffman-realism-is-false https://www.edge.org/conversation/donald_d_hoffman-realism-i...