3 ms·
There is absolutely not enough evidence from this particular doctor to justify the claim. It's irresponsible to publish this.
by dekhn 6y ago
There is absolutely not enough evidence from this particular doctor to justify the claim. It's irresponsible to publish this.
- dsnr 6y ago> In collaboration with experts in the field from the University Hospital of North Norway HF, we have found specific antibodies against blood platelets that can cause these reactions[...] So the evidence is definitely not from only „this particular doctor“, but from a group of experts on the matter.
- DoingIsLearning 6y ago> we found specific antibodies against blood platelets So are they claiming that this is actually due to the vaccine formulation itself, i.e. does this finding exclude the initial hypothesis of a Quality issue or a specific 'bad batch' of the vaccine?
- dekhn 6y agothe news article doesn't say; it attributes a quote to the doctor saying "it's the vaccine" but it's unclear whether that means "bad batch". Personally, if 3 health workers all go to the same hospital in a remote region complaining of clots, it's more likely that something local happened (as you say, QA, or any number of other sources).
- kwhitefoot 6y agoThe article is a very poor quality summary. The articles in VG are much better. I put a quote from one and a translation elsewhere on this HN page.
- dekhn 6y agoI've read all of them so far and I still think the professor was being irresponsible in his wording and the press is being dumb for amplifying it.
- dsnr 6y agoIt‘s not local, there have been similar cases in Germany and Italy, with confirmed deaths.
- dekhn 6y agoThe committee "concluded that the vaccine is not associated with an increase in the overall risk of thromboembolic events, or blood clots," Cooke said.
- dekhn 6y agothe article doesn't say the "experts in the field" agree with the doctor, just that they collaborated, on a technical part of the experiment. Again, this is such a small sample and out-there group that it's not representative and there are many explanations that are more likely than "the vaccine causes blood clots".
- dekhn 6y agoHere's a better article, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/15/health/astra-zeneca-vaccine-blood-clots-bleeding.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/15/health/astra-zeneca-vacci...? """Calculating further, he said, roughly 1 percent of the 1,000 to 2,000 daily blood clots — 10 to 20 a day — would occur in the vaccinated patients just as part of the normal background rates, not related to the vaccine. “Only if epidemiological data show that that rate is higher, would one start to wonder about a causative relationship,” Dr. Moll said. """ AKA, base rate fallacy strikes again.