12 ms·
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade EGA/VGA Comparison
- jbverschoor 6y agoThey should really use a crt filter for proper comparison. I really enjoy the dark scenes in blue monochromatic. It gives a really good athmosphere. Somethings that's lost in the 'upgrade'
- gbil 6y agoWhile I played this game on an Atari 1024ST which I believe used an EGA like display I remember a (not so) similar graphics quality situation with Space Quest V which I started playing in a CGA monochrome monitor and at some point Roger was supposed to mop a floor with a yellow - if I remember correctly - logo that changed from dark yellow to shiny yellow while cleaning it. I had to buy a EGA color monitor to get through this part of the game as no matter the path I chose, I couldn't really see any changes with the monochrome one in order to complete the task...
- timbit42 6y agoEGA can display 16 colors from a 64 color palette. The Atari ST can display 16 colors from a 512 color palette. The Atari STe can display 16 colors from a 4096 color palette. The Amigas can display 32 colors from a 4096 color palette.
- mrob 6y agoAnd in the 320x200 mode used by these games, standard EGA can display only 16 colors from a 16 color palette, for backwards compatibility with CGA monitors.
- aruggirello 6y agoNitpicking, but the OCS ("classic") Amiga can also display 64 colors (in half brite mode) or even the full 4096 color palette (in hold and modify/HAM mode). That's what made people's jaws drop back then.
- LocalH 6y agoAlthough the earliest A1000s didn't include EHB mode
- the_af 6y agoNever owned an Amiga. HAM was used for static screens and photos, right? What were the screen modes used for actual games?
- LeoPanthera 6y agoWith extremely unusual exceptions, no games used HAM, because it took several frames to completely redraw the screen. 32-color was the standard.
- Lio 6y agoThe Amiga also had HAM mode that could display all 4096 colours but it was somewhat limited in what you could use it for. When I first saw that it looked like witchcraft. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hold-And-Modify https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hold-And-Modify
- aidenn0 6y agoI had a similar issue with conquest of camelot. I was playing on a monochrome display, and you had to find an amulet in the catacombs. I spent hours looking for it, then I played it on my dad's computer with EGA, and it was bright yellow on gray and glaringly obvious.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cousin_it 6y agoYeah. I never played this game, but the EGA scenes feel evocative and the VGA ones don't. Similar to the Loom discussion the other day. Mostly it feels like the EGA artist was better at dramatic lighting. For example, in the EGA version of the dead templar, the neck area is pure black for a reason: it makes the skull, the focal point of the image, stand out more. But in the VGA version they decided to paint something there, so the image became less focused.
- subbz 6y agoIt feels like the EGA is the original.
- soenkeliebau 6y agoI don't know, in the EGA version the sarcophagus is much more prominent, which takes away the focus from the face quite a bit. To me the VGA version actually feels like it is more focussed on the face and shield by making the background less intrusive..
- Agingcoder 6y agoTry it! I have very fond memories of this game. It's maybe not on par with fate of Atlantis, but still really good.
- mosdave 6y ago> It's maybe not on par with fate of Atlantis, but still really good. thanks, I was hoping someone would comment on this. I haven't played this one, but FoA is one of my favorites.
- theklub 6y agoThis was one of my favorite games as a kid and I still have love for it.
- Storm-Bringer 6y agoAgreed, such a brilliant game
- fullstop 6y agoI think that I enjoyed Fate of Atlantis more, especially because it had the three paths to give it some more ways to play. I avoided the "Fists" path because my keyboard didn't have a number pad. I went back to both of them, decades years later, and found Last Crusade to be much more challenging in a way that games no longer offer (besides Dark Souls) -- they let you make mistakes which hinder or make completion almost impossible. You could get pretty far in to Last Crusade and not have the required items to progress further.
- the_af 6y agoMany gamers hated this kind of "getting irreversibly stuck" situation of early adventure games, and in fact Lucasarts made a conscious effort to avoid it in later games (e.g. Full Throttle, Monkey Island, etc). You couldn't even die (yes, I know about the dying easter egg in Monkey Island). This was in contrast with Sierra Online's adventures, which had plenty of surprise deaths and deadend situations. This led to saving frantically at every step, which isn't particularly fun. I loved Sierra games -- the first three EGA Space Quest games are my favorites -- but I see the point of avoiding player frustration.
- fullstop 6y agoI don't like getting stuck permanently. Even in Dark Souls there are no ways to get irreversibly stuck, although you can make it significantly more challenging by killing certain NPCs along the way and losing the ability to use the services that they once offered.
- mgraupner 6y ago
- TLightful 6y agoNo ticket.
- Grustaf 6y agoI find it very hard to quickly see which is which, the two versions are so different. It would be nice with a more explicit side-by-side layout.
- chrisseaton 6y agoNot sure if you're being sarcastic... you know you only see the VGA one when you hover over it with your mouse? You know which is which because you know which one you're pointing at, right?
- distances 6y agoOr on mobile, tap the image. TBH I was also wondering for a good while where the other images are.
- chrisseaton 6y agoMaybe people are confused about the animation as well - the images are animated but these minor things like doors moving around aren't the changes they're talking about.
- Grustaf 6y agoHow would I know that?
- scoutt 6y agoFrom TFA > Hover the cursor over the images to see the remastered VGA version. If you're on a iOS device, you can simply tap the images
- Grustaf 6y agoAh, I just opened the page and scrolled down, saw what looked like pairs of images but couldn't really tell if one had more colours than the other. The text didn't help to enlighten me either. But now I see the description in the intro.
- tommica 6y agoHah, was just playing this game, and the fist-fighting is impossible - no idea how anyone managed to successfully play that minigame
- fullstop 6y agoI think that you were supposed to mostly rely on stealth. You don't have to fight the big guy in the castle -- you can get him very drunk take him down with one punch. edit: just for fun, here is the scene -- https://youtu.be/9ivNLD75rAU?t=2854 https://youtu.be/9ivNLD75rAU?t=2854
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rob74 6y agoI originally played the Amiga version back in the day, but it was (as far as I can see) 100% identical to the EGA version and therefore looked pretty bad compared with Amiga-native games or better ports. To their credit, Lucasfilm put more effort into later games (Indy IV, Monkey Island I/II etc.). The Amiga's graphics were in between EGA and VGA (palette of 4096 colors, but only 32 colors at the same time without further tricks), so it wasn't really straightforward to port a PC game...
- rlv-dan 6y agoEGA has terrible colors yet I am strangely drawn to this esthetics. Of course a big part of this is that the artists at Lusasfilm where amazing.
- the_af 6y agoEGA Monkey Island is similarly beautiful. I feel EGA forced artists to work within the limitations of the available color palette, and good artists created awesome stuff (like shown in this case). Once they had VGA, some artists rushed to use every color gradient they could get away with, and this ruined their art till they got the hang of it. Something similar happened with the transition from pixel art to 3D games -- games were 3D because they had to, whether necessary or not. And many suffered from it. (Arguably, many still do!) Of course, I hold the extremist opinion that even some CGA (4 colors!) games were beautiful in their own way. I don't think more is always better, a lesson that seems to be lost on some game developers...
- Akronymus 6y agoCGA shines on a crt, usually. Some CGA games just look stunning with CRT/composite https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHXx3orN35Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHXx3orN35Y
- the_af 6y agoIndeed. I found out about CGA's amazing composite output only recently, watching a video by The 8 Bit guy. I was completely unaware of this back in the day...
- babypuncher 6y agoIt shines on a CRT with composite input. It's still the same eye-piercing nastiness people are familiar with today if you used an RGB monitor like the IBM 5153, which IBM marketed for use with the CGA card.
- short_sells_poo 6y agoPerhaps I'm just looking at things through rose tinted glasses, but I very much agree with this. I like to think that good pixel art works with the imagination. The artist puts down the broad strokes and lets the imagination fill the rest! There is a huge amount of skill that goes into good pixel art. It's not enough to have attention to detail, but an intuition about engaging and working with imagination. The more realistic the graphics, the higher the risk that it falls into the uncanny valley trap. The brain is already half fooled that it is seeing reality (or something that is supposed to be real) but if it's only slightly off, there'll be a feeling of unease. Of course, early 3d games were far off from feeling real, but they were already a step up and there was less headroom for imagination. The low polygon count models just look janky instead of endearing. Pixel art completely sidesteps this uncanny valley by not trying to be realistic, instead it tries to engage the brain to fill in the details. It's perhaps halfway between reading a book and watching a movie. E.g. looking at early 3d games, they just feel dated. One cannot help but compare them to today's 3d graphics and of course the oldies fall short by a very far margin. Comparing pixel art games to a modern AAA 3D game title is just so obviously apples to oranges that there is no struggle due to loss of fidelity. Again, perhaps my view is biased because I grew up with the pixelated games of old. Still, I'd like to assign the excitement of the early 3d titles more to the novelty (at the time) than from the fidelity of the graphics. I think the pixel art style will (or already does) have much more staying power.
- croes 6y agoPlayed it on CGA
- aasasd 6y agoI now felt alarmed enough to check which version of Maniac Mansion I have in the ‘to-play’ pile. Don't know if there are marked differences in V2: PCGamingWiki notes that it has ‘moderately improved graphics with more overall colors’. Still looks pretty EGA to me in the opening sequences. However, it turns out that by default the V2 displays wrong in ScummVM, while accurate to the hardware limitations. You need to switch the ‘render mode’ to Amiga to get intended colors: https://www.pcgamingwiki.com/wiki/Maniac_Mansion#Higher_quality_graphics_in_V2_.22enhanced.22_version_.28ScummVM.29 https://www.pcgamingwiki.com/wiki/Maniac_Mansion#Higher_qual...
- sigmaprimus 6y agoIm pretty sure I have the retail box and floppies for this game. Going from 16 to 256 colors does seem to make the scenes look prettier but for me the 1st game that stands out in my memory showcasing the VGA improvement is a simple breakout game called Bananoid. These images brought back some powerful memories, one in particular is hearing the chorus of the song Self Control by Laura Branigan comming out of my friends C64 in or around 1986. The next time I heard a simmilar example was a .wav file of the song Daisy but that was years later.
- mmastrac 6y agoBananoid was awesome because it could make use of the VGA offset registers for smooth scrolling. I was blown away when I saw it.
- the_af 6y agoOne VGA with multidirectional smooth scrolling that really impressed me, back in the day, was a shoot'em up called Zone66 [1]. It was hard to get running on DOS, but it was a beauty -- and fun, too! [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zone_66 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zone_66
- fullstop 6y agoDo you remember "VGA ART" ? https://archive.org/details/msdos_shareware_fb_VGAART https://archive.org/details/msdos_shareware_fb_VGAART I remember being very excited for Zone66 since I had seen other things by Renaissance and it used protected mode to squeeze every ounce of processing power out of my PC. In the end, though, the game just wasn't very fun. It had a cool introduction, though!
- pygy_ 6y agoThe VGA versions of the games could be played on EGA hardware, the 320x200 x256colors graphics were displayed, dithered, in 640x200x16colors mode. The EGA versions had distinct 16 colors graphics. I guess you had the VGA versions
- 6y ago
- fho 6y agoQuick ... someone train a network on that ;-)
- babyshake 6y agoI would be so happy if there was a good Python library to apply a realistic looking EGA filter to images or videos.
- _dps 6y agoIf you have an interest in this kind of art, this GDC presentation by Mark Ferrari "8 Bit & 8 Bit-ish Graphics" gives lots of great detail about the art process, tools, and practices of the time (Ferrari worked on the EGA art for Monkey Island, among several others). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcJ1Jvtef0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcJ1Jvtef0
- corysama 6y agoWhen I was a kid in high school and considering a career in art, Mark Ferrari was kind enough to invite me to hang out in his home studio and chat about making art for games. Apparently he had to fight with the engineers over switching to a dithered art style because at the time they were using run length encoding for compression. But, he re-painted a few scenes to be dithered and the improvement was so obvious that the engineers gave in and “made it work” (switched to LZW compression).
- megameter 6y agoThe art for Indy 3 in EGA definitely shows signs of dither being desired but not used, which I always found made it feel sparse and unfinished, even in VGA. Mind, I was coming to this from the standpoint of really getting into the Lucasarts adventures after LOOM. It's likely that on this game they were stretched for space regardless, since it spans a lot of scenes.
- kjrose 6y agoHonestly, one of the best things I learned when I was doing work on complexity with Stuart Kauffman was the idea of enabling constraints. The fact that in many circumstances putting constraints can actually lead to more complex and better situations when there is creation. Essentially, the enabling constraint has the effect of putting more of the creation on the line of criticality and thus suddenly you get far more creative growth. These EGA/VGA comparisons (this is the second I've seen so far) almost demonstrate this perfectly. It's really quite fascinating.
- dpeck 6y agoWhat a great game, I remember playing it for many many hours on our family’s 286 computer. I’m not sure I ever got to the end, but I definitely remember crashing that biplane :)
- jl6 6y agoIt’s the same story all through the history of computer graphics: good artists can make something look good even with constrained tools. Conversely, increasing the technical capabilities of the tool does not guarantee a good art style.
- qwerty456127 6y agoI never had an actual EGA GPU and only experienced EGA through switching to the EGA mode as some games offered. Nevertheless I feel like there is something oddly special/atmospheric/psychedelic/whatever in the EGA pictures. I'm glad I have seen this kind of graphics. EGA is pixel art squared, it is to colour what pixel art is to actual graphics so never seeing EGA is the same kind of loss as never seeing pixel art.
- the_af 6y agoDitto, and fully agreed with your post. Though it's odd seeing EGA called a "GPU"... that's later terminology, back then this were graphics adapters or, in our street parlance, "graphics cards" ;) There was also an odd time where every graphics card got called a "VGA" in its broadest sense, unrelated to actual VGA modes. I feel it's time to talk about the beloved Hercules adapter and SIMCGA!
- danans 6y agoI used to love the credits at the end of old video games - they were half the motivation to get to the end of the game. Some of them had surprisingly good, almost cinematic music - I can still remember the credits music from the end of Sega Master System's "Ys The Vanished Omens" like it was yesterday. Q for players of modern video games: do they still have great ending credits scenes like that?
- danaliv 6y agoOh, I loved Ys. Ys III on Genesis was one of my favorite games from that era. I only play a select few contemporary video games, so my sample is somewhat limited, but none of them have had the sort of credits scenes that we enjoyed in the '80s and '90s. Nowadays it's just another cutscene like all the others sprinkled throughout the game. In fact, when I finished the main quest line in Assassin's Creed: Valhalla, I wasn't even sure I was done! This might be particular to open world games though, which don't really have an end, per se; you just sort of run out of things to do.
- ergot_vacation 6y agoNot even a cutscene in a lot of cases: just the standard text on black background like you'd see in a movie (though some of them will do the movie thing and have little "hidden" scenes cut into the credits at points).
- ergot_vacation 6y agoAs someone who grew up playing in VGA, EGA was always the "outdated" option I was glad to avoid (and let's be honest, most EGA artists did not have the skills of Steve Purcell). But this makes a pretty damning case in favor of the original art. The thing this immediately brought to mind for me was the way Silent Hill 2 was absolutely massacred a few years back in its supposed "remaster" (they left out the FOG): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silent_Hill_HD_Collection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silent_Hill_HD_Collection. This seems to be an eternal pitfall: "Upgrading" graphics while failing to realize that impressive visuals are about artistic skill and effort (often MOSTLY), not just technical stats.
- Razengan 6y agoUsed to fantasize about this game after seeing its ads in magazines, trying not to feel bad about my Commodore 64. Think I actually got to play Fate of Atlantis before Crusade and that game still blows me away.
- eecc 6y agoEGA... the instagram filter of the '80s.
- brandonmenc 6y agoLots of rose colored glasses here. Yes, looking back on the EGA graphics, there is definitely a level of skill and stylization that I took for granted at the time and have a certain nostalgia for, but when the VGA versions of these games came out they were all mind-blowing and you just kind of had to be there - no one was selecting the EGA option if they had a VGA card. I remember the VGA version of Indiana Jones in particular being awesome in VGA, on a CRT, live in motion.
- dharma1 6y agoyep. I had EGA and played most of these games on it - I remember seeing the same games on my friends VGA screens and they were sooooo much better on those. Looking at them now, the EGA ones have a certain amount of nostalgia, but I vividly remember 16 colours being really limiting, especially at those resolutions where dithering was really noticeable.
- flanbiscuit 6y agoI remember when I got my first VGA card, I was so excited and the games did look so much better to me! It's also how I felt about getting my first audio card (the original Sound Blaster) Even looking at the comparisons in that post I still prefer the VGA versions over the EGA versions. Guess I did not get enough exposure to EGA to have that much nostalgia for it. My family got a computer around '91 and I think the VGA card came within a year after purchase
- miohtama 6y agoIt was very early for VGA, or more technically MCGA 300 x 200 x 256 colour mode. Artists had not yet figured out how to utilize 256 colour palette to the best of art.
- 1wd 6y agoExactly right. I specifically remember someone excitedly telling me at the time that the VGA Indiana Jones "is completely photo-realistic!"
- darkwater 6y agoThe "EGA is better" crowd makes me think of the "vinyl is better" one. Sure, albums produced with the vinyl as the target, verbatim put on CD, were better on real vynil. But that doesn't mean the vinyl is better per se, at least not technically. Here is almost the same, due to its limitation EGA needed some creativity that VGA didn't need. But in the end VGA was also mastered and produced some masterpieces (for example Monkey Island 2 to remain into the LucasArts realm).
- JdeBP 6y agoEGA isn't better. The point is, at least in the articles at hand even if not in the Hacker News discussions, that the artists who redrew things for VGA didn't do that very well, and made lighting mistakes or overused gradient fills. The articles at hand make the point that this was in turn in part because they hadn't really learned how to draw for VGA yet. But some of the errors are just basic drawing errors and nothing to do with the medium. If the sunset is behind the tree, then the front of the tree is in shadow, for example, not filled in because EGA-to-VGA means rôte filling in every black void just because it is there.
- bzzzt 6y agoWhile it's easy to attribute that to the artists, seeing those pictures it seems they got the (thankless?) task to give the EGA pictures a new coat of paint. Sounds more like factory line work to me than 'artistic vision'. Some of the EGA graphics stand out more, but I think the VGA graphics do exactly what they are meant to do: more colourful pictures to show off your new video card in all their gradient glory ;)
- favorited 6y agoThose old SCUMM/Lucasfilm Games titles have such a distinctive aesthetic. All it takes is one glance and you know who made that game. Or maybe it's just Ron Gilbert.
- simplerman 6y agoNever played that games but wow that was so nostalgic. For some reason, I never get that feeling when playing modern games designed in retro/8-bits style.
- nobrains 6y agoI looked and looked and looked and for the life of me could not see the excessive gradients that he was talking about in the image captions. And then towards the end of the article, as my mouse was gliding over one of the images, I noticed it change :) And then I enjoyed the article all over again. Properly this time.
- eloeffler 6y agoI was too young to play the first version of the game and I never realized they changed it. I chuckled at the Sam and Max addition back then, but for me the games were all there already. The hook on the skeleton's arm... It seems like the game was a bit more serious before :) Anyway, what I miss most from Lucas Arts games are the running gags to decipher, so I guess this way was better for me.