11 ms·
Across the Internet, a Game of Whac-a-Mole Is Underway to Root Out Extremism
- knowaveragejoe 6y agoI am (again) saddened to see how much of HN appears to be engrossed in right-wing grifterism. The GOP is literally playing with the fire of stochastic & headless terrorism, driven by a sophisticated & well-documented misinformation campaign that has convinced many millions of people that the election was stolen and that donald trump(of all people) is anointed by god to root out a global satanic, pedophilistic cabal that is responsible for all of the world's woes. A lot of these people think the world is ending and it's now or never. These same people showed up at the nation's capital with every intention of taking hostages & holding show trials. But you know what the real problem is? Groups of young, ineffectual leftists who don't even show up to vote let alone participate in government.
- TMWNN 6y ago>These same people showed up at the nation's capital with every intention of taking hostages & holding show trials. Is that the current description? What happened to "attempted coup"? Oh wait, maybe five armed people out of 150 who entered the Capitol != coup attempt by any level of common sense, so I guess now the above is the description du jour. Never mind the preposterousness of such a group also "taking hostages & holding show trials". Perhaps in another few months the MSM consensus will finally get to what was and is obvious to anyone who isn't histrionic: 150 idiots (the vast majority unarmed) who illegally trespassed into a government building. They can and will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law ... As far as "illegal trespass into a government building" can go, at least. (And no, the Capitol police officer who died wasn't "killed by a fire extinguisher" wielded by said idiots. He died at home from unknown causes and apparently wasn't assaulted by anyone https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/02/politics/brian-sicknick-charges/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/02/politics/brian-sicknick-charg... .)
- knowaveragejoe 6y agoI'm not sure if you watched the events unfold that day, but I did via multiple live streams. Your attempt to downplay what occurred rings hollow. In fact the only thing I'd agree with is that the people involved are idiots - they legitimately think the election was stolen, and that it was now or never to take it back. The organized(but separate - probably not aware of each other) groups that used the crowd as a cover had every intention of taking hostages at a minimum. One can make an educated guess from the mountains of evidence collected from their cesspools online and from chatter amongst the participants themselves during the riot that they intended to go even farther than that. I'm not sure how the beating of officers with fire extinguishers(which did occur and is documented in photos & videos) became connected to Sicknick's death. Noting the initial reporting was wrong is not the gotcha or rebuttal you think it is.
- 1cvmask 6y agoIt’s funny how the elites use this ploy to stamp out any differences from the dominant narrative - from the alleged left or right. Freedom of speech is a danger to elites when you have freedom of reach (distribution). Opposition American politician, Eugene Debs, with over a million votes (alleged extremist) imprisoned by autocratic President Woodrow Wilson for passing out pamphlets against the war entitled “ Anti-War Proclamation and Program”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debs_v._United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debs_v._United_States In the ultimate twist of fate the advocates for censorship get censored by Facebook: https://twitter.com/jimmy_dore/status/1354572535799504901 https://twitter.com/jimmy_dore/status/1354572535799504901? An academic conference on censorship gets censored by Youtube: https://www.mintpressnews.com/media-censorship-conference-censored-youtube/274918/ https://www.mintpressnews.com/media-censorship-conference-ce...
- simonh 6y agoThat's a mischaracterisation. Debs was convicted of encouraging violations of the law, specifically the draft laws. His arguing against the war was held to be perfectly legal.
- emodendroket 6y agoThis used to be more or less exactly my attitude but then my mom got really into QAnon nonsense and the whole Capitol raid thing unfolded and I've become a lot more sympathetic to just banning people raving about Chinese Manchurian candidates from social media. Honestly, even when alternative news sources are easily accessible nobody reads them.
- newsclues 6y agoMy mom got sucked into the RussiaGate hoax, so we should look into shutting down CNN and other propaganda outlets
- knowaveragejoe 6y agoIt was not, in fact, a hoax at all. 10 years ago if you told me people who describe themselves as patriots would be embracing Putin's disinformation campaigns in the US, going so far as to attack the capital to overturn an election, I wouldn't believe you. But here we are.
- tejhra 6y agoIs there any evidence to backup the claim that the person referenced is “far right” and “racist”? It appears that these terms have lost meaning and are fair game to throw around regularly in articles about Trump supporters or conservatives.
- ike77 6y agoThere are plenty and they are easy to find. It's hard to believe that your comment was made in good faith.
- aokiji 6y agoIt's also hard to believe that you are casting doubt on the real problem that is political McCarthyism targeting Trump supporters and people who oppose One World Government directives.
- hn8788 6y agoHis wikipedia article gives a bunch of examples, including saying that Trump supporters have no recourse but to kill government officials.
- milkrocks 6y agoThe left believes anyone who doesn't have xir/xim pronouns and marches at BLM rallies is far right and racist.
- aokiji 6y agoThis just part of the ongoing campaign to implement social control and censorship inspired in the model of China. No thanks.
- spazrunaway 6y agoExtremism is relative. The opinions of an average American in 2008 would be labelled "far-right" today (see: opposition to gay marriage, transgenderism, support for colorblindness, I could go on). Sooner or later, people will see that it's a fool's errand keeping up with this runaway train of an overton window.
- betterunix2 6y agoThe average American in 2008 was not walking into a synagogue and murdering people. Let's not pretend that far-right extremism is something other than what it actually is.
- readflaggedcomm 6y agoBut they are now, correct? which Fuentes condoned, I presume.
- betterunix2 6y agoThe average American is not a terrorist. Extremists are a small (but very dangerous) minority of the country.
- leesalminen 6y agoThe average American in 2008 wasn't setting fire to courthouses. Let's not pretend that far-left extremism is something other than what it actually is.
- waterheater 6y agoMirriam-Webster defines "extremism" [1] as "advocacy of extreme measures or views : radicalism" By this definition, extremism and radicalism are equivocated. However, I know many people on the "left" presently identify as radicals (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radical_left https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radical_left). The article differentiates between the terms "extremism" and "radicalism" by assigning a "political-right" label to "extremists" and a "political-left" label to "radicals". Stifling the extremes of one "side" while supporting the other "side" is how you implement cultural revolution. It is quite literally a repressive tactic. The term "Whac-a-Mole" assigns a sense of childishness and fun to the extremism elimination efforts, which disarms "moderates" and dehumanizes cultural revolution. [1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/extremism https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/extremism
- emodendroket 6y agoI think you have to play pretty fast and loose with the groups involved to come to these conclusions.
- jtdev 6y agoPlease explain what you mean by this.
- emodendroket 6y agoThe Democrats beat back a left-wing challenge from their base quite handily and Joe Biden was proud to say so. When I consider this and the generally contemptuous attitude of Dems toward their more progressive supporters, I find the notion of a Red Guard reshaping America in their image something like a fever dream and not a serious analysis. To my mind the Capitol raid is playing a much larger role in their minds. The thought isn't "we need to create a far left America" but "we came way too close to the peaceful transfer of power being usurped."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 2lwxxtj 6y agoHow is a democracy in which the elite ultimately control which political ideas circulate through the electorate any different from an oligarchy?
- leesalminen 6y agoIt's been like this for a while. https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/files/gilens_and_page_2014_-testing_theories_of_american_politics.doc.pdf https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/fi...
- s9w 6y ago"extremism" is just the latest made up word after "hate". They really mean "things I don't like"
- it 6y agoInteresting how the article doesn't mention any game of whac-a-mole to root out leftist extremism.
- stormqloud 6y agoLeftist extremism doesn't exist. Look how many years they spent telling us Islam is a religion of peace and calling every islamic attach on society a lone wolf attack. Cognitive dissonance. Populations doesn't know what to think anymore if they think at all.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- emodendroket 6y agoBecause there's no serious left-wing insurgency anybody is worried about. There are people who like posting guillotine images on Twitter but little real-world impact.
- seneca 6y agoThere were left wing rioters burning down buildings all summer and pushing for extreme policies to be instituted in our government. I'm quite worried about that, and the fact that many power centers fell in line to pretend it wasn't happening.
- knowaveragejoe 6y agoOf course, these efforts have effectively gone nowhere. I'm more worried about the multitudes of heavily-armed radicals who believe in the election Big Lie or QAnon.
- emodendroket 6y agoAnd what impact have they had beyond a bunch of anodyne "we support black lives" statements? It's not even clear to me that the rioters were particularly well organized or politically engaged so I'm not sure that social media targeting would make much difference (with I guess the possible exception of censoring any police violence videos).
- milkrocks 6y agoWhat a loaded article, NPR should be defunded for putting out something so biased.
- sneak 6y agoWhat exactly is the "whac" that is intended for people with views outside of the mainstream?
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoWhac-A-Mole is an arcade game for children. It has holes in the playing surface, and a mallet or hammer that the player holds. Mechanized moles pop up out of these holes, stay up for a moment, and then go back down. The player attempts to hit the mole with the mallet while the mole is up out of the hole. The difficulty is knowing which mole (or which hole) is going to be the next one you need to hit.
- sneak 6y agoIndeed. What is the action that corresponds to "hit" in your explanation, and who is undertaking it when the extremism "pops up"? Deleting someone's account doesn't remove them from society, and doesn't change their views, and doesn't prevent them from using other websites, talking to people offline, organizing groups, et c. In whac-a-mole, you boop it and it goes down/away, you having scored a point. What do people want to do when online extremism is detected, and why do they think that will be an effective technique for their goals?
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoAh, sorry, I read your comment as not knowing what the game was. "Whac", in this context, is to delete or block an account. That doesn't remove the person, just as in the literal game whacking a mole just drives it below the playing surface. The whole point of calling it Whac-A-Mole is that blocking people or suspending accounts doesn't actually change anything or remove the people, it just temporarily drives them back underground. They'll pop up again soon enough.
- kazinator 6y agoOnce there is money involved, people will be dogged. Nobody is going to take it sitting down if they're making tens of thousands of dollars and you shut them down.