9 ms·
> I always felt their donation drives were very deceitful since the money is not actually going to supporting the wiki (that's already funded) The servers don'
by bawolff 6y ago
> I always felt their donation drives were very deceitful since the money is not actually going to supporting the wiki (that's already funded)
The servers don't buy themselves. You could argue that WMF doesn't spend money effectively if you want, servers are a small part of the budget after all and like any org there are parts of the budget that are of questionable value, however its a bit much to claim its not going to supporting the wiki.
[Disclaimer: i used to work for WMF a while ago. I dont anymore. My opinions are my own]
- slooonz 6y agoDon’t they ? Don’t the interests on their endowment cover the cost of the technical infrastructure ?
- garbagetime 6y agoThe notices give a sense of urgency and uncertainty. They also use that insinuation, as well as the fact that proportionately few users donate, to guilt readers into donating. That's unkind, unpleasant behavior that makes me like Wikipedia less (along with increasing issues with the content of the website - at least the English articles).
- kaba0 6y agoWhat issues do you have with content?
- garbagetime 6y agoGwern says it best: https://www.gwern.net/In-Defense-Of-Inclusionism https://www.gwern.net/In-Defense-Of-Inclusionism
- JamesBarney 6y agoDamn, he always does. Good read. I feel like the same thing happened to stack overflow.
- geoduck14 6y agoWhat is happening with Stack Overflow?
- brokenmachine 6y agoIt's toxic. Just try asking a question.
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoCommonly cited problems are the lack of neutrality, which is well reflected by how different the political tone of different language versions is. — the Russian article on Vladimir Putin is quite a bit less critical than the English article, and in reverse, the English article on Barack Obama is quite a bit more lauding than how other languages treat him. But that is unavoidable for articles written by men, rather than some truly neutral artificial intelligence. My gripe is that I find that Wikipedia does not acknowledge the issues enough, and seems to mostly assert that it is fairly neutral.
- blueblisters 6y agoI believe the bias generally comes from the sources - "reputable" (and generally liberal) English language sources tend to take a deferential tone towards Obama, even while criticizing him, because of the political significance of his presidency. This is likely exacerbated by the fact that there are very few "reputable" right-wing English language sources that can be cited on Wikipedia. Similarly, sources from the Middle-East or Russia, which are less likely to be cited, would probably take a less charitable view as well.
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoWell that would be the problem with the U.S.A. culture war: — there are two sides, and both consider themselves “fair and balanced” and the other unreliable, and from where I'm standing as a European, both are unreliable, because politics is not about reliability, and truth is not a weapon in politics and never has been. English language Wikipedia of course has a disproportional number of editors from the U.S.A. and most of them have a particular side in this culture war. But it touches upon another issue of All voices must be repræsented, proportional to their weight.. — does this mean all voices currently on the planet? all voices that have ever been on the planet? or only English voices on the English-language Wikipedia? In particular, I find it somewhat odd that, for instance, English-language Wikipedia will speak of the “critical consensus” surrounding a Japanese work of fiction, using only English-language reviews thereof, while there are probably more Japanese-language reviews and fans of the work, and the critical perception is often very different in different cultures, but English-language Wikipedia very often speaks of “critical consensus” for what should be called “Anglo-Saxon critical consensus”, and dare I say that it is often not even that, but chiefly a U.S.A. consensus.
- sqqqqrly 6y agoRead the communism page. Does it mention the hundred million plus dead because of communism? Only "Excess deaths"...
- Const-me 6y agoI'm from Ukraine. In the 20-th century communists killed several of my relatives. I will never forget about that, and there're many million people like me all over the world. I do observe tendency in modern world to white-wash communism, and cancel facts about crimes committed by communist regimes. I know it sounds crazy and I don't have any evidence, but one possible explanation of the trend - Russia's or China's state-sponsored propaganda.
- garbagetime 6y agoIf it sounds crazy AND you haven't any evidence - why bring it up?
- Const-me 6y agoBecause I don’t know other possible explanations of the observed phenomenon. Do you?
- klibertp 6y agoAuthoritarian regimes tend to commit atrocities. Unchecked power tends to lead to abuse of power. This is true regardless of what ideology helped the regime take root. Recognizing this fact is not whitewashing anything. To give you a less personal (to you) example, the Islamic State of Irak and Levant filmed and uploaded executions of hundreds of people, and killed many, many more people off-screen. They have "Islam" in their name. Should the page about "Islam (religion)" put ISIL front and center, despite them existing for less than a 1‰ of time Islam existed, and having similarly little adherents in comparison to global population of muslims?
- 6y ago
- h_anna_h 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Biden%E2%80%93Ukraine_conspiracy_theory/Archive_3#DKIM_email_verification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Biden%E2%80%93Ukraine_con...
- hedberg10 6y agoThe banner is moving (thus moving the whole text below it) and loads after ~a sec. I don't give money to people who intentionally try really hard to annoy me.
- isoskeles 6y agoYour comment just made me realize Wikipedia is using dark patterns to try to get me to donate.
- Itsdijital 6y agoThey probably have a fundraising team on staff that does all the standard fundraising "tricks" that the rest of the fundraising industry does.
- fomine3 6y agoThey do A/B testing. https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fundraising_2010/Banner_testing https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fundraising_2010/Banner_test... https://diff.wikimedia.org/2013/04/08/intro-to-the-statistics-of-ab-testing-with-wikimedia-fundraising-banners/ https://diff.wikimedia.org/2013/04/08/intro-to-the-statistic...
- konjin 6y ago>The servers don't buy themselves. You could argue that WMF doesn't spend money effectively if you want, servers are a small part of the budget after all and like any org there are parts of the budget that are of questionable value, however its a bit much to claim its not going to supporting the wiki. Purchase of computer equipment: (3,709,426) At 3% return they need 100 million in the market to cover it, their short term investments are 95 million. Wikimedia does not need to raise money ever again if the only thing they are about are servers: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/f/f7/Wikimedia_Foundation_FY2019-2020_Audit_Report.pdf https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/f/f7/Wikim... Wikimedia is the perfect example of a bureaucracy expanding to meet the needs of an expanding bureaucracy.
- estaseuropano 6y agoWikimedia/pedia also has constantly new challenges and tasks. Would you want them to not ever change the software, management, ...? WMF has a mission beyond wikipedia, all of them related, in the public interest and transparently done.
- konjin 6y agoWikimedia is welcome to raise money for wikimedia. Their fundraisers on wikipedia are however as much a dark pattern as anything google and facebook do on their privacy.
- pydry 6y agoThe more money it takes the more it will end up relying upon large donors and the more will kowtow to the interests of those donors. So, yes, I'd rather they were extemely conservative about software and management. Running PHP and having a non visual editor is less of a big deal than having to tweak donor Wikipedia pages to remove awkward facts to keep the $$$ flowing and salaries paid.
- rvba 6y agoThe servers are relatively low when compared to the rest There is an essay called "wikipedia has cancer" about its balooning costs that grow like a tumor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_Signpost/2017-02-27/Op-ed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_Signpost/2...
- Qub3d 6y agoFYI, the user who wrote that keeps an annually-updated version on his own userpage: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Guy_Macon/Wikipedia_has_Cancer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Guy_Macon/Wikipedia_has_C... It includes updates as of March 2020.
- fomine3 6y agoThis post should be pinned for this topic.
- bawolff 6y agoI've read it. I think its misleading. Hosting costs were less when wikimedia had no money, but speed was much lower, downtime was constant, there were no backup data centers (and the data center was literally in a high risk hurricane zone), and the sites had exponential growth since then. I'm not sure if that chart includes salary cost, but there's also the difference between paying all the sysadmins vs largely volunteer sysadmins. Maybe there's an argument that its better to stick to volunteers if at all possible, but at the end of the day there are quality improvements when you have 24/7 on call coverage vs hoping some random volunteer with a day-job is available to bring the site back up when it explodes (not to mention burn out is not sustainable in the long term). At the end of the day, wikipedia's hosting is much higher quality now than it was in the beginning. Wikipedia used to go down so much there was literally an external website dedicated as a scratch pad for users to write articles on until the real website came back up. Back in the day, when WMF had no money, they cut every corner they could to make it work. The result was something that was always on fire but got the job done. Now we have much better quality. But quality costs money. Whether or not the trade-off is worth it is debatable, but lets not pretend that wikimedia hosting costs are buying the same thing as they were in 2005. Last of all, i would encourage a comparison to any other site of similar size/popularity. Wikimedia hosting is orders of magnitude cheaper than industry norms. [Disclaimer: used to work there but not on the infra team. I dont work there anymore. My opinions are my own]
- h_anna_h 6y ago"Hosting wikipedia accounts for roughly 2% of their total expenses" Last time that I posted about it I ended up getting mass-downvoted though https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26056276 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26056276
- garaetjjte 6y agoTheir fundraising banners are obnoxious and A/B tested to death, worded such that it seems they are so cash-strapped that they will shut down tomorrow if you don't donate. In reality they raising a LOT more money than necessary to operate servers.
- thunkshift1 6y agoThere would not be nothing to put on those servers is not for the volunteers.