7 ms·
According to one source [1], Spotify users stream on average 25 hours a month. Assuming an average song is 3 minutes [2], that's 500 streams per month. Going wi
by Cthulhu_ 6y ago
According to one source [1], Spotify users stream on average 25 hours a month. Assuming an average song is 3 minutes [2], that's 500 streams per month. Going with the $9.99 per month rate, users pay about $0.02 per stream. Currently, the artists see only $0.0038 per stream, or less than 1/5th of what Spotify makes.
I think that with a 50% profit margin, Spotify should be very happy. Of course, it's not that easy / straightforward, all conditions and caveats apply, etc etc.
[1]: https://www.businessofapps.com/data/spotify-statistics/ https://www.businessofapps.com/data/spotify-statistics/
[2]: https://www.music-jobs.com/uk/article/news/news-pop-songs-are-getting-shorter-a-new-study-finds https://www.music-jobs.com/uk/article/news/news-pop-songs-ar...
- NopeNotToday 6y agoHow much of Spotify's revenue goes towards songwriters, labels, distributors, publishers, as opposed to the artist?
- Denvercoder9 6y agoThe quoted $0.0038 is the total of what Spotify pays out to the distributor, who then distributes it between themselves, the artist, songwriters, their labels, etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- UnpossibleJim 6y agoI tried to look into what radio paid out to these same people as a comparison, but the information I found seemed to be purposefully obtuse: https://soundcharts.com/blog/radio-royalties https://soundcharts.com/blog/radio-royalties I couldn't actually find out what was paid, but it did look to be that, artists weren't really paid. It was song writers and publishers who were paid. Performing artists, however, only generated word of mouth which generated ticket sales - so far as I could garner.
- smachiz 6y agoYes, ignoring all other costs isn't great. Their revenue per subscriber is also substantively lower - including free users, discounted EDU users, and family memberships. Excluding free users, it's probably ~$5 per user. That being said, Apple Music pays .75p/stream, Tidal is 1.25p/stream. They can probably figure it out.
- stephenhuey 6y agoIf they cannot pay the artists more, a long-term freemium plan might not be a great business model then. If free users are seriously cutting into profits, should they change the free plan to a limited free trial? I was around in the 80s 90s and we didn't really have free cassettes and CDs and radio paid studios & artists with ad revenue. Spotify is well known enough now that it could be argued an unending free tier may no longer be necessary.
- mrgreenfur 6y agoTotally agree. Maybe spotify should look like an app store with fees in the 30% range at the top end (shopify/apple/steam). Their role is very similar: distribution and discovery. They probably could wi points giving better payouts per stream to smaller artists too, like steam does. Hopefully competition will force it down too (eg epic vs steam vs apple). We might need open access to back catalogues and not exclusive deals, but its a start
- mattnewton 6y agoThe App Store for music exists many times over and users (including myself) prefer a lower cost streaming model. There is simply too much cheap or free music out there now for me to value it at iTunes singles prices.
- wtetzner 6y agoOf course, and users would prefer completely free music over cheap music too. That doesn't mean it's sustainable, though.
- mikepurvis 6y agoThe other issue that has been raised a number of times is that I believe the revenue is still divided up based on overall listens across the platform, which means it's dominated by artists who feature heavily in popular playlists and automation-driver radio/recommendations. These listens are often passive and should not be considered as valuable as those of someone listens only a few hours a month, but spends all of that time listening to specific artists (indie or otherwise). Basically the argument is that if I spend $9.99 on a Spotify sub, the entirety of that cash (minus Spotify's cut) should be directed to the actual artists I listened to. Here's an articulation of this perspective from 2014: https://medium.com/cuepoint/how-to-make-streaming-royalties-fair-er-8b38cd862f66 https://medium.com/cuepoint/how-to-make-streaming-royalties-...
- natdempk 6y agoI agree and I think this is really the key demand that they should have organized around. Splitting up the revenues based on what you actually listen to is really how things should work from a fairness perspective to artists. It also is likely more compatible with heavier listeners than their demand of 1c per stream. To put that number into context, I listen to ~1000 songs per month on Spotify and I pay $2.50 for Spotify each month using a family plan. I'm not sure how the economics of 1c per stream are supposed to work out there. Soundcloud has already gone in the direction of paying out based on what you actually listen to, and it would be great to see Spotify and other platforms follow suit. See http://fanpoweredroyalties.com/ http://fanpoweredroyalties.com/ for more details on Soundcloud's implementation.
- anchpop 6y agoIf there's two groups of people, one who listens to pop music for 10 hours a month and one who listens who indie artists for 20 hours a month (which could easily be the case if their recommended playlists are mostly indie artists as mine is), then switching to the model you propose would reduce how much money indie artists make, right? It seems more fair to me that artists would get a set amount of money per stream, rather than the amount they get being dependent on how many other songs their listeners listened to.
- 6y ago
- grumple 6y agoYou think that the developers and every other party involved costs less than 50% here? Devs cost a lot. Bandwidth and servers don't cost that much, but for large scale data transfer like spotify, it does. Running the company costs a lot. Maybe the fair price is double what it currently is. But that might result in the artists making less than they currently do, not more (this is, in fact, my suspicion - if Spotify could increase profits by charging more, they would already be doing so).
- mortenjorck 6y agoThe $0.0038 figure is probably due in part to the way Spotify calculates royalties, dividing a pool of all subscriber revenue among all streaming activity, rather than dividing the revenue from each subscriber among each subscriber's streaming activity. Some have pointed to logistical challenges in the latter model, but it's clearly not impossible, as SoundCloud just announced it will be the first service to adopt it: https://press.soundcloud.com/197001-soundcloud-introduces-fan-powered-royalties https://press.soundcloud.com/197001-soundcloud-introduces-fa...
- lumost 6y agoThe problem is that most artists do not own the distribution rights to their own music, these are owned by various record labels. Many top tier artists create their own record labels and shoulder the cost of advertising/promotion while also dramatically increasing their cuts. The fact that individuals aren't able to break out via self-publishing music is an oddity in the internet age. Why aren't there more avenues to hear "random new artist that matches my tastes"? or is it self-perpetuating that labels sign all successful artists who can go mainstream?
- brabel 6y agoI like to listen to jango.com which tries to "push" new artists while you listen to some "station"... I've found a few good "completely unknowns" there, but most stuff they push is really low quality. I think that a platform where you could discover new artists easily using a system similar to this (play mainstream artists, mostly, but throw in a few songs from unknown artists that play similar genres), but then had an option to "upgrade" to get stuff like offline access to artists you like, could become very successful.
- tekromancr 6y ago> play mainstream artists, mostly, but throw in a few songs from unknown artists that play similar genres Isn't that just "radio"?
- derivagral 6y agoThis is Pandora, right? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandora_(streaming_service) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandora_(streaming_service)
- indigochill 6y ago>Why aren't there more avenues to hear "random new artist that matches my tastes"? Because Bandcamp is perfect at this and nobody can beat them. I say that with tongue in cheek, but they have been the platform for average musicians to self-publish on for a while. They've even totally foregone their cut periodically during the pandemic to help artists. And unlike Spotify, artists are able to apply their own branding to their pages. I've never met a musician with a bad thing to say about them or their platform.
- 015a 6y agoThink about a strategic decision like this: Spotify decides to pay-out a $0.005/stream rate to Taylor Swift. That's more than most artists make, but its what Taylor demands, and Taylor holds some cards here because she's popular. Let's say that Spotify says No. Spotify's argument is, in effect, all artists are sharing a piece of the same pie; if they give Taylor Swift a higher than average rate, it lowers the average payout for every other artist. By saying No, in this hypothetical universe, Spotify is standing up for indie artists. Taylor (more accurately, her rights holders) does not put her music on Spotify. Customers who come to Spotify for Taylor Swift's music no longer feel that their subscription is worthwhile; they stop paying. Now, the pie is smaller. Indie artists receive a bigger chunk of a smaller pie. Customers are left without the music they want. Spotify's revenue is lower. Everyone loses. Its easy to place the blame at Spotify, and I'm sure they deserve some, but we've known for about half a century that the record industry is a hive of shit, and this is just another symptom of this. The disparity in income between the popular artists and average artists is huge, and its mostly because of gatekeeping that the popular artists actively engage in to protect their nine-figure fortunes. Spotify could have stood up for smaller artists, but I'm not convinced they'd even exist today if they had; it was really their willingness to work with the record industry that turned them into the force they are. I do have some hope that Square's purchase of Tidal could be a catalyst for change in the industry. In other words, if they maintain Tidal's high(est) revenue share with artists, improve the user experience (a lot), leverage their existing industry relationships to keep enough popular artists on the platform, and work with indie artists... it could be very good. I'm optimistic. I think Tidal's core investors being artists themselves and a traditionally low-margin payment processor is actually very healthy, versus Spotify who effectively is just a middle-man that needs to extract enough to survive.
- zdragnar 6y agoAre only paid plans paying out royalties? I used to pay for spotify, but cut it after a budget rebalance since we just didn't use it enough. I still use it about 50% as much as when I paid.
- Eridrus 6y agoI feel like you should take Spotify's audited financial statements about how much they make and how much they return to rights holders (~75% of revenue) more seriously than your back of the envelope estimates: https://investors.spotify.com/financials/default.aspx https://investors.spotify.com/financials/default.aspx
- smnrchrds 6y agoAgreed. The above calculation for example does not account for the fact that Spotify pricing varies significantly between countries and can be as little as 1.60$ per month. https://edm.com/industry/spotify-premium-prices-by-country https://edm.com/industry/spotify-premium-prices-by-country
- SpaceCenturion 6y agoIndeed! I have a family account for 6 people here in Brazil and I pay around 0.77 USD per person.
- incrudible 6y agoIf Spotify is in fact spending 75% of its revenue on royalties, but according to you less than 25% of it arrives at the artist, what does that tell you? Either your calculation is wrong, or somebody who is not Spotify is pocketing the difference.