5 ms·
I was re-reading (ok, actually trying to finish yet again) Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance and I think some of what Pirsig says at the beginning of th
by the_af 6y ago
I was re-reading (ok, actually trying to finish yet again) Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance and I think some of what Pirsig says at the beginning of the book applies here.
Namely, the division between people who just want things to work and hope "somebody" else will step in when a fix is needed, and those who understand the abstraction sometimes leaks, and you need to be able to dig in and at least know how to solve some problems "under the hood". He makes a whole philosophy of "romantics" vs "classics" out of it, but I think that's irrelevant here: what matters is that no-one should be forced to be powerless about the hardware they own.
This is obviously related to the right to repair. Pirsig wasn't thinking of Apple, but he does mention John Deere!
- gcanyon 6y agoFirst: I can't imagine not finishing Zen -- it is among my top ten books. Second: I agree, no one should be forced to be "powerless" about the hardware they own. But right to repair is exactly that: I don't want a phone with a detachable battery and upgradable memory -- that means the phone isn't waterproof and/or is much thicker and heavier. I don't want to force people to have the phone I prefer, but I also don't want the kind of phone right to repair would force me to have.
- fartcannon 6y agoI'll be you they find a way to keep the phones looking the way you want while still making them repairable. I'll bet you all that cant-be-done stuff is excuses and bullshit.
- the_af 6y ago> First: I can't imagine not finishing Zen -- it is among my top ten books. Well, I'm making a second attempt. I really liked it the first time, but it requires a certain state of enjoy -- skim reading it just won't do. I think Pirsig would understand why it took me years. He makes a point about slowness and not rushing things, the journey vs the destination. > I also don't want the kind of phone right to repair would force me to have. So you're in John Sutherland's camp, with his trusty BMW R60 that requires no involvement on his part -- till it does, of course, and it frustrates him.
- bzzzt 6y agoJust wondering: if there was a 'right to repair' on computers in the 60's, would Intel have made an integrated microprocessor? I mean: you can't just fix a dead register by replacing it anymore... Lots of electronics have become more reliable by being fully integrated units. I prefer a durable phone to a repairable phone that needs constant replacements.
- ghaff 6y ago"Right to repair" doesn't mean that everything has to be actually repairable down to replacing things at the lowest level of component. It means making the same tools and information available that an authorized repair center has access to. But if the standard of repair is swapping out an entire device or PCB there's no requirement to go above and beyond that. A lot of people seem to confuse "right of repair" with modularity/ease of repair.
- ehnto 6y agoI think the new EU right to repair laws require appliances to be repairable for up to ten years, this article at least seems to suggest that the intention is for a level of ease of repair especially in regards to fasteners and fittings: > Under the new EU rules, manufacturers will have to ensure parts are available for up to a decade, though some will only be provided to professional repair companies to ensure they are installed correctly. > New devices will also have to come with repair manuals and be made in such a way that they can be dismantled using conventional tools when they really can't be fixed anymore, to improve recycling. https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/eu-right-repair-technology-decade-b1809408.html https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/eu...
- setr 6y agoRight to repair doesn’t mean that everything must be repairable; it means that manufacturers can’t block you from installing a replacement part (eg by requiring a key from CORP) That is, if you could have repaired it, YOU could have repaired it
- 6y ago
- vbezhenar 6y agoThere’s another distinction. Some people will replace broken parts with new parts. And some people will repair that part, sometimes inventing and building new tools on the fly. Former is relatively easy and one should just follow manuals to succeed. Latter is some kind of art, which requires flexible mind and tons of experience.
- illwrks 6y agoThat reminds me... I was converting some VHS tapes for a family member and one was of an event on a farm where a trailer had tipped over in a slope damaging something on the axel. Cut to a short time later and the clip continues with the farmers welding and repairing using logs to prop up parts of it. They would have been seriously impacted if they needed too wait for days/weeks for a appointment to have it repaired. There is no excuse for having something not be repairable, especially if you have the knowledge and need to be able to repair your things.
- freedom42 6y agoThe thing is even if people don't wanna repair themselves they might wanna change a battery. Or get something minor done cheaply by a 3rd party. But Apple goes so far out of the way to kill third party repair. They even put special screws in their machines to screw you. Edit: The EU pushed right to repair, right? Now see what Apple did to screw France [1]. Their latest and greatest devices somehow have a repairability score of around 6.5/10. How is it possible? [1] https://appleinsider.com/articles/21/02/26/apple-now-displays-iphone-and-mac-repairability-scores-in-france https://appleinsider.com/articles/21/02/26/apple-now-display...
- bullosB 6y agoThe score is based on 5 categories: 1.documentation available 2.ease of repair 3.availability of spare parts 4.price or spare parts 5.category specific to the product (not the same for a washing machine or a computer). Each of them give you a score out of 20, and the total is divided by 10. So you can have 0 on the 2., making the phone hard to repair, but still having a 8/10 score. In the end its similar to Booking reviews, where 6/10 is very low and you want to avoid this hotel. Details (in French) https://www.ecologie.gouv.fr/indice-reparabilite https://www.ecologie.gouv.fr/indice-reparabilite
- freedom42 6y agoThanks for explaining. That's unbelievable. That's a really stupid law right? I mean elementary-school-kid-bypassable kinda stupid.
- rasz 6y agoBut apple: 1.doesnt provide any repair documentation at all 2.even Apple themselves dont repair in house, and instead replace devices. 3.doesnt offer spare part at all _unless_ you sign up to their "share all of your clients personal data and your accounting books with us" program, and even then its only batteries and screens at massive margins (more than whole working used device). 4.see above 5.no idea what goes there So we end up at 4 x 0.
- yohannparis 6y ago
- hnick 6y agoOur 13 year old Miele dishwasher broke last week. I had a service call booked but cancelled because it wouldn't be worth the parts and labour costs of multiple hundreds (good chance something else will break next year). I had a lot of fun tearing it apart and seeing how it's made and as a longshot to fixing it myself. I think I could have fixed it myself if I had access to parts and some blocks to put it on to look underneath when it's running, but alas I don't have any of that so it's probably going to be tossed. But the nice thing is, it was always an option to spend the time to fix it. I feel like I learned something and if anything else breaks I'm more confident. At least I learned something, enjoyed myself despite a cut finger or two, and saw all the general wear and tear in various parts which made me feel better about replacing the whole thing.