6 ms·
The alliance of necessity between social liberals and racial justice advocates creates this problem. There is not anything inherent about “people of color shoul
by rayiner 6y ago
The alliance of necessity between social liberals and racial justice advocates creates this problem. There is not anything inherent about “people of color should be treated equally” that also requires buying into “we should disrupt the nuclear family.” That’s just how the political alliances have worked out. The latter ideology in practice works to undercut the former ideology. The contribution to racial inequality is stark: the poverty rate for Black, Latino, and Asian children in two parent households is 1/4 to 1/2 the poverty rate for white children in single mother households.
As a south Asian person, I find the aggressive push to move Asian Americans to the left quite troubling. The intense social norms in south and East Asian culture in favor of two parent households is an incredible advantage we should not give up lightly. But it’s almost taboo in socially progressive circles to say that family structure matters (even though this is obvious to Asians).
- throwaway6734 6y ago>But it’s almost taboo in socially progressive circles to say that family structure matters (even though this is obvious to Asians). You must hang in some especially woke circles
- ceilingcorner 6y agoDoesn't seem that extreme to me. Even saying that divorce should be avoided at all costs and a two parent household is vastly superior to a single parent one is enough to get labeled as a conservative by many.
- throwaway6734 6y agoDefinitely not by the average American. Twitter and San Fran/Portland are a small minority of the US.
- ceilingcorner 6y agoCollege students too, unfortunately.
- throwaway6734 6y agoSo a small minority with almost no experience raising children?
- ceilingcorner 6y agoThe question isn't whether they are correct (clearly they aren't) but if they are influential in culture and government. Many/most social movements start on college campuses, so I would consider it pretty relevant.
- monoideism 6y agoTry saying that you believe that two-parent households are better for a kid that single-parent households in the presence of anyone who considers themselves social justice oriented or left-wing.
- zeruch 6y agoI live in the very liberal Bay Area, and I have indeed said that repeatedly, and rarely do I get pushback. The biggest question is "do those parents have to be a hetero couple?" to which I reply "nope, but unless the single parent has amazing cash means or a large extended family to support them, then generally regardless of much else, 2 is better than 1". I've never otherwise had a difficult time supporting that position in front of young SJWs at all.
- throwaway6734 6y agoDoes left-wing include the majority of Biden's base? Woke twitter is a small minority.
- jimbokun 6y agoSeems to include the policy setting part of Biden's base.
- throwaway6734 6y agoWhich policies and who?
- jimbokun 6y agoThe American Rescue Plan Act is being called the most significant progressive legislation, maybe since the New Deal. Not saying that makes it bad, but it's certainly boldly progressive.
- monoideism 6y agoThe media is Woke twitter, or at least a large part of it. And if you don't believe that the media doesn't have any influence on people, particularly Biden's base, try reading Chomsky's _Manufacturing Consent_, or even Walter Lippman, if you want to read someone who thinks this influence is a positive thing.
- rayiner 6y agoYes, but you’d be surprised how woke some circles have become: https://freebeacon.com/campus/northwestern-law-administrators-confess-their-racism-in-online-diversity-session https://freebeacon.com/campus/northwestern-law-administrator.... That’s from my quite business-oriented law school.
- tptacek 6y agoWe've been through this argument, recently, and I'm a little disappointed that you're framing this observation as if that discussion hadn't occurred already. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23766155 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23766155 The implication of your comment is that the alternative to "the nuclear family" is "single-parent families". But the other alternative to nuclear families is "extended families", which you yourself have written about on HN numerous times. There is an important racial justice issue involving nuclear vs. extended families; to wit: high-status municipalities (and their school systems) discriminate against them, both by mandating single-family housing and by working to exclude students who reside with extended family care networks. That's a thing we're grappling with in Oak Park, where I live just outside of Chicago, right now. It's not random; it's in fact a lot more legitimate than other BLM grievances (against, for instance, capitalism writ large).
- pluto9 6y agoSo what, you set him straight and now he's never allowed to hold that opinion ever again? Maybe he didn't accept your argument. What a ridiculously pompous comment. Tptacek has spoken, everyone. The matter is settled. We can all go home.
- tptacek 6y agoI just checked, and that's definitely not what I meant.
- pluto9 6y agoHow else should one interpret this sentence other than, "I've already corrected you on this, so you should know better"? > We've been through this argument, recently, and I'm a little disappointed that you're framing this observation as if that discussion hadn't occurred already.
- tptacek 6y agoI don't know, but we can be sure that I didn't mean it that way; we now have an authoritative citation for that.
- chmod600 6y agoBut why does that alliance exist, I wonder? What is necessary about it?
- rayiner 6y agoIt’s simple. A disproportionate share of racists and nativists are in the conservative wing, and more to the point conservatives are ideologically resistant to potentially aggressive government interventions to eliminate discrimination. So racial minorities are forced to ally with white social liberals. But that alliance doesn’t come for free. Social liberals insist on driving the bus on non-civil rights social issues, such as norms around marriage, child bearing, and premarital sex. (To this day, Black Democrats are far more likely to call premarital sex immoral compared to white Democrats. On that and similar issues they’re actually as conservative as Republicans. But that aspect of the culture is muted as a result of the alliance with disproportionately white social liberals over civil rights issues.)
- jjeaff 6y agoIt's also much better to grow up with enough money rather than not enough money. But what good are you doing by going around announcing that? You speak as if single parent households are that way by choice. I'd wager 99.99% wish they had a stable partner helping them out.
- rayiner 6y agoClearly “choice” is a sliding scale here that’s based on prevailing social norms. The US has double percentage of single parent, households compared to Germany, https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/12/12/u-s-children-more-likely-than-children-in-other-countries-to-live-with-just-one-parent https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/12/12/u-s-childre..., almost five times the rate compared to India, and almost eight times the rate of China.