23 ms·
The EMA Covid-19 data leak, and what it tells us about mRNA instability
- hannob 6y agoI had looked at these emails when they leaked. To be clear: If you'd offer me one of those mRNA vaccines like right now I wouldn't hesitate for a second and take it. But I do think this raises some questions around transparency. If the EMA has concerns about the production of these vaccines then I think this is something that should be discussed in public - so the scientific community can weight in and review this issue. If the EMA thinks that this is a solved issue - which the emails imply is what they thought before they authorized the vaccine - then that's what they should communicate.
- YinglingLight 6y ago>To be clear You know you're in a cult when you must preface your fealty before voicing the softest of logical hardballs. This entire thread is 50% prefacing. We've lost our ability for true discourse.
- coldtea 6y agoIf we can't entertain the idea that drug companies lie about their results and efficaccy to gain multi-billion contracts, their managers cover their arses either way, fast-track vaccine orders are problematic, and that it's at least suspect that vaccines that took decades to be created for other variants were now made in less than a year to be the "truth" - and we consider rational to proclaim that we'd "take" the vaccine "without hesitation", then yes, we've lost our ability for true discourse...
- FpUser 6y agoIn here I think this is direct result of downvoting.
- johbjo 6y agoIt's a technical concern. Publishing will only cause fear and doubt. In any case, it's a matter of weighing risks. Even if there's a 10⁻⁶ probability of complications, giving the vaccine and stopping serious illness/deaths is still a better decision overall. Even if it means hundreds of cases of complications across Europe. And then, the complications might turn out to be statistically difficult to discern from uniform random anyway. A probability of 10⁻⁶ is difficult to conceptualize so if it is published with scary words, people might interpret it as "will probably happen to me". Then if that affects vaccine roll-out negatively, publishing might be a bad decision. Millions of people in the UK have received the AZ vaccine, which has demonstrated safety and efficacy. The efficacy metric means protection against infection, which is not complete. But as far as I've heard, not one person who has received either Pfizer or AZ has become seriously ill or died. In other words, it "flattens the curve" instantly.
- matwood 6y ago> people might interpret it as Unfortunately we/they are in a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation. If it was published, you can be sure the misinformation around what it meant would be through the roof. Having it hidden, and now come out may end up lending more credence to the conspiracy theories.
- cheaprentalyeti 6y agoIf you take the approach that it's going to be leaked by Chinese and/or Russian intelligence anyway, you might as well tell the truth to begin with rather than let Ivan or Winnie 'reinterpret' it for you.
- coldtea 6y ago>It's a technical concern. Publishing will only cause fear and doubt. And who appointed them as arbiters or censors of truth for "the public's own good" as opposed to researchers that should make their results public whatever they are?
- flyinglizard 6y agoOn weighing risks, in a pandemic like that your choices are statistically limited to either getting vaccinated or getting ill. Not getting either, over time, is not a viable option.
- hkktlgkfdn 6y ago> If you'd offer me one of those mRNA vaccines like right now I wouldn't hesitate for a second and take it. Why do you think that means anything. Some don't hesitate to base jump, take crystal meth or get covid infected.
- quantumwoke 6y agoSo Pfizer is not transparent with the contents/stability of their mRNA envelope and AstraZeneca causes blood clots. Who can we trust?
- atomashpolskiy 6y agoOur instincts.
- eddieroger 6y agoMaybe, but I'm concerned about the sample size. Guess I'll stick to the science.
- atomashpolskiy 6y agoI'm all for science, but as one of the other comments points out, you can't ignore other factors at play and just exclude the humans from the equation. It's not like science is brought upon us from the heavens above. If some product cost billions in R&D and still does not work quite as planned, you may rest assured that the owners will go to all lengths to cover the losses and persuade buyers to ignore the facts as long as possible. This is simple logic, isn't it?
- YinglingLight 6y agoScientists got mortgages, too.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoMy instincts still raise the hair on the back of my neck every time I go up the basement stairs. What was once a good survival mechanism millennia ago is now a vestigial distraction.
- junon 6y agoAnti-vaxxers. (/s)
- 6y ago
- meepmorp 6y ago> EMA says the leaked information was partially doctored, explaining in a statement that “whilst individual emails are authentic, data from different users were selected and aggregated, screenshots from multiple folders and mailboxes have been created, and additional titles were added by the perpetrators.”3 Worth noting
- throwaway4good 6y agoDid they (ema) publish exactly what was doctored?
- isitdopamine 6y agoAnyone would say that a leak is doctored... Even the Clinton team tried to say the Wikileaks were doctored, despite the vast majority of them having a DKIM signature confirming their authenticity. The ball is in EMA’s field now: they have to demonstrate the leaks are doctored. There’s pretty damning information in there, it’s in their interest to demonstrate it’s false.
- raverbashing 6y ago> they have to demonstrate the leaks are doctored. So the victims of a cyberattack have to prove their data has not been manipulated? Cool > There’s pretty damning information in there No, there isn't, unless you're buying manipulated information and believe in 5G vaccines. The data presented sounds like a regulator doing its job and not rubberstamping every decision (cough cough 737Max)
- itchyjunk 6y agoThe question wasn't if they were victims or not though. They are. The question is about the validity of data and questioning is just fine. You might not have seen anything useful in what was presented but it doesn't mean someone else can't. Comparing it to "5G vaccines" to discredit the parents point isn't the right way to challenge their interpretation.
- program_whiz 6y agoHey I'm all for the vaccine, but lets be real about it. Humans struggle with productization. Games, phones, cars, and everything else we make have problems initially (and frequently after any small changes) because we have to come up with a repeatable and robust process for producing, packaging, shipping, delivery, etc, which may have totally different requirements from prototyping and development. Furthermore, these processes have a myriad of unknown unknowns -- with failure points we don't anticipate until they happen (complex systems). This is another (very very) complex system with a relatively untested technology in an extremely noisy deployment environment. Every user is running a different OS basically, and every deployment corrupts the deployment image to some degree (RNA breakdown). Problems were bound to occur, and yes, the extent of those challenges are likely being downplayed to avoid panic and to get people to take the vaccine. On the question of motivation: global pandemic, billions in R&D spent, pressure from people on politicians, etc. The usual set of unavoidable human reasons to release products before they are 100% tested (since 100% testing can only really happen in the wild anyway). Combine that with politicization of every topic, and the inability of the public at large to handle any nuance (e.g. "there may be some problems in production, but we believe overall it is worth the risks and won't pose a major problem because of X, Y, and Z.")
- maxerickson 6y agoHumans have relatively little genetic variation, you overstate things with the weird analogy to operating systems.
- yomly 6y agoAnd you are under appreciating the myriad ways differences can express themselves in nature. We share 50% of the same DNA as a banana, and we're 98.8% the same as a chimpanzee. Spurious examples aside, the pandemic has highlighted ethnic differences in reactions to both pathogen and vaccine. And from personal experience in the field, seemingly "random" confounding factors can have drastic effects - supposedly safe gadolinium based contrast agents caused NSF if you happened to have bad kidneys. Aggregation occludes all nuance, essentially by definition. Decisions that are correct for the aggregate can often be wrong for the individual. But I guess that kind of thinking is why the pandemic has been such a crapshoot in the first place.
- ArkanExplorer 6y agoThe risk profile for vaccines overlaps almost perfectly with the risk profile for COVID. That is, the age groups most at-risk from the virus (ages 70+, with comorbidities) are also going to live the shortest, and so suffer from fewer side-effects as well as not reproducing. So why aren't the rollouts focused on vaccinating the elderly first? By the time this is done the kinks will be ironed out.
- maxerickson 6y agoOn a per country basis, the roll outs are focusing on the elderly.
- usrusr 6y agoAre there rollouts that don't focus on the elderly?
- EdwardDiego 6y agoWell, in NZ the elderly come third, but that's because we're trying to keep it out, rather than contain an existing infection. (MIQ = "Managed Isolation/Quarantine") > Group 1 – Border and MIQ workers and the people they live with > Group 2 – Frontline workers and people living in high-risk settings > Group 3 – People at higher risk of serious outcomes or illness > Group 4 – General population https://www.health.govt.nz/our-work/diseases-and-conditions/covid-19-novel-coronavirus/covid-19-vaccines/covid-19-getting-vaccine/covid-19-our-vaccine-rollout-plan https://www.health.govt.nz/our-work/diseases-and-conditions/...
- purple-again 6y agoIn the US at least they absolute have been doing the oldest first and then lowering the age bracket slowly as more vaccines have ramped up.
- bronco21016 6y agoThere certainly was a large effort to reach the elderly first. For a host of reasons though the population was not vaccinated 100%. Issues with scheduling appointments, getting people to clinics, doubts over safety, etc. At some point the number of doses still coming in is increasing but the number of those for example 70+ began to dwindle and so it has to opened up so these doses can be put in people’s arms.
- passerby1 6y agoThe question is why the leaked information was classified if it's so important for the public good.
- londons_explore 6y agoThe question is why we allow information about a patented innovation to be kept secret, when the very point of a patent is that the inventor gets exclusivity in return for disclosure.
- possiblelion 6y agoWait, so what effect does potential RNA instability really have?
- maxerickson 6y agoThe mRNA is the instruction that the body follows to produce the viral proteins that lead to an immune response. If the mRNA in a batch of vaccine degrades more than they have allowed for in the treatment protocol, it may not work. (This is one of the reasons they have very specific handling rules and throw out vaccine that is improperly handled)
- walterbell 6y agohttps://www.modernatx.com/about-us https://www.modernatx.com/about-us > Welcome to Moderna. We believe mRNA is the “software of life." Every cell in the body uses mRNA to provide real-time instructions to make the proteins necessary to drive all aspects of biology, including in human health and disease. What's the metaphorical software equivalent of "mRNA instability": undefined reference, memory corruption, incomplete download, installation failure, program crash, ...?
- nobrains 6y agohttps://remyhax.xyz/posts/bitsquatting-windows/ https://remyhax.xyz/posts/bitsquatting-windows/
- maxerickson 6y agoThere isn't one. Mitochondria won't decode the corrupted mRNA and it will be broken down into constituent parts that are reused by the body. Edit: Oops, ribosomes, not mitochondria.
- DSingularity 6y agoHow do we guarantee that? Is there a biological equivalent of a checksum?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hef19898 6y agoSomehow I always have to think about the articles from a while ago covering Russian propaganda campaigns against Covid vaccines. Leaking emails would fit.
- fuoqi 6y agoNot a surprising reaction after the (mostly baseless) smear campaign against Sputnik V.
- dehrmann 6y agoLet's just hope Sputnik V goes better than Sputnik II.
- trhway 6y agoCovid being a global thing has thus naturally become another battlefield in the modern cold war : from an official US HHS report https://www.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/2020-annual-report.pdf https://www.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/2020-annual-report.p... " OGA coordinated with other U.S. government agencies to strengthen diplomatic ties and offer technical and humanitarian assistance to dissuade countries in the region from accepting aid from these ill intentioned states. Examples include using OGA’s Health Attaché office to persuade Brazil to reject the Russian COVID-19 vaccine,"
- pacman2 6y agoWhere can I download the leak? I am very interested in the production methods since I have some ideas how to improve them. Would appreciate a link.
- raverbashing 6y agoNot a "Data leak", it's a cyberattack plus editorialization/manipulation Of course the details of drug approval are not "discussed in the open" because a) trade secrets b) the public doesn't know how sausages are made and can (and do) make a mountain out of a molehill mRNA instability is probably not such a big deal. Sure you want a high number because that's going to cause the immune reaction, if you have a lower number it's potentially less targets. But having imperfect mRNA strands are not a big deal. The vaccine does not have to be 100% "perfect", it has to be safer than the virus. I know where to take my chances.
- fuoqi 6y agoIs there a good way to test that an mRNA vaccine batch was stored improperly and in result has reduced efficiency? In the US supply chain may not be a problem, but if exported, in some countries it's possible that people will get near useless vaccine shots, thus hurting reputation of mRNA vaccines in general.
- topynate 6y agoIntactness of 55% vs 75% should make no real difference to your view either of efficacy or of danger. Because: Efficacy: the mRNA vaccines have a large margin for error with respect to dose. 55% of several times more than enough is still more than enough. Danger: suppose the danger of broken-up mRNA to increase linearly with the amount given. Then the increase of danger would be by a factor of (100-55)/(100-78) ~= 2. The substantiated near-term danger of Pfizer is very low. We're at 5.2 million people vaxxed in Israel now… Twice of very low is very low. In order to argue for "too much" danger you have to argue either for non-linearity or for long-term high danger. If you argue for the latter then you already think the danger to be high, so there's no real difference between your view now and your view before. If you want to argue non-linearity of danger then you are arguing for a very remarkable biological coincidence. You also have to explain why the occasional 5x overdoses, which happen when a someone is given a whole vial by mistake, don't seem to be doing any harm. Never mind that it would have come out in the animal trials.
- ppf 6y agoIt's not the percentage of intact mRNA that's the problem, it's what the other bits of mRNA happen to do.
- et2o 6y agoEncode smaller bits of the same protein? Who cares. Otherwise, the mRNAs aren’t present in high enough quantities to do significant signaling or silencing things, and it’s going in the deltoid... not really a medically interesting place. You could inject 1mL of dilute HCl there and it wouldn’t be a big problem.
- ppf 6y agoI'd rather not be injected with bits of mRNA that encode random bits of proteins, thanks. The deltoid is "medically interesting" enough to produce Covid spike proteins.
- timy2shoes 6y ago
- molticrystal 6y ago> the agency told The BMJ that the levels of truncated mRNA “and the amounts of a potential protein produced by the truncated mRNA would be too low to constitute a safety risk.” I still plan on getting vaccinated, but I always wondered about the failure modes of the mRNA as it decays and what materials it could produce. I'm hoping prions are not possible, but are they? The story also asks what happens to the lipid nanoparticles, but I am wondering about another aspect of these crafted mRNA sequences. The "U" in the mRNA has been replaced 1-methyl-3’-pseudouridylyl, denoted by Ψ in their sequences. What happens to the Ψ and its byproducts as it decays or is metabolized?
- hkktlgkfdn 6y ago> What happens to the Ψ and its byproducts as it decays or is metabolized? I had the same question. What I found in a long paper about mRNA vaccines is that they do not really know, but they assume you'll be fine, since they didn't see any immediate effects and because the quantities are tiny.
- cfu28 6y ago> Ψ Ψ is naturally found in tRNA, so its not really something to be concerned about. Edit: scratch that, confusing pseudouridine with 1-methyl-3’-pseudouridylyl
- baxtr 6y agoWhy would you assume prions? Isn't mRNA a standard cell product, which can be found in any of your body's cell at any time?
- Izkata 6y agomRNA encodes instructions for creating proteins, and prions are mis-folded proteins. I think the concern is more, our bodies' natural mRNA is unlikely to create prions or it would be a common occurrence, but lab-created mRNA isn't made of the same parts and doesn't have that millennia of evidence behind it.
- rediguanayum 6y agoHey guys- This data leak looks like the work of a misinformation campaign. The very first thing this article says is the data is from a cyberattack on European Medicines Agency (EMA), and the data was sent anonymously to journalists. A Reuters article claims that the Russian and Chinese are behind this: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-cyber/russian-chinese-hackers-targeted-europe-drug-regulator-newspaper-idUSKBN2AY0F1 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-cyber/russian-chinese-.... May be it's true that there is mRNA instability, but the efficacy data says the Moderna vaccine works extremely well. mRNA in intrinsic in your cellular biology with all of its instability, and your body manages to deal with it just fine.
- rolph 6y agoinstability of mRNA is not an issue under the following proviso, the truncated fragments of the whole mRNA must not destroy the structure of the epitope regions; and beyond this level there are still PAMPs [pathogen associated molecular patterns] that will trigger an immune response pathway as well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Innate_immune_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Innate_immune_system
- renaudg 6y ago> May be it's true that there is mRNA instability, but the efficacy data says the Moderna vaccine works extremely well The efficacy data was based on clinical trial batches though, and the challenge seemed to be with lower manufacturing quality in the large scale commercial batches : "changes were made in their processes to ensure that the integrity was improved and brought in line with what was seen for clinical trial batches." To be honest, we do also have real world data now (Israel mainly) that confirms the benefit/risk balance to be extremely good.
- abacadaba 6y agoalso the 2nd dose reaction, some of it's getting through at least
- crocodiletears 6y agoEverything looks like a misinformation campaign perpetrated by 'them' anymore. This well could be. It also might not be. The data could have been manipulated. It might not have been. We do what we can with what information is offered to us. Lies, half-truths, and all.
- buttholesurfer 6y agoNo fucking way am I taking the vaccine.
- ping_pong 6y agoI have taken the Moderna vaccine. So I'm obviously not an anti-vaxxer. However, it does concern me to a great deal about all of this, and it reflects my previous worries. My biggest concern is that from the article, these mRNA strands appear to have not only degraded but formed into new "species". What if the mRNA causes the body to produce prions that leads to something like Mad Cow Disease? The fact that Moderna isn't saying anything is very disconcerting.
- rolph 6y agoin this case "species" is in the context of Molecular species. suppose we grabbed a molecule and then cut it in half, do this many times so you have a collection of first halfs, and second halfs. Each of these is a species of ribonucleic acid. It may sound sinister but its just tech jargon.
- ping_pong 6y agoIt's not molecular species. The full quote is: "truncated and modified mRNA species present in the finished product". It's specifically truncated and modified mRNA species.
- rolph 6y agoif you are accustomed to reading or in any way communicating with a biochemist, or molecular biologist you will know, that what you have said is not in context of the professsion. i know what was written, however that makes sensationalist and alarmist connotations when the meaning of species is defined by popular conceptions you are wrong, this submission is speaking about molecular species. also the prion concern is not valid, prions are a specific protien sequence and do not arise out of mRNA sequences of determined function.
- happyconcepts 6y agoAll the mRNA you speak of .... is wrapped in fat that is really, really small. Would you not be more worried about all that lipid nanoparticle in your body?
- AbrahamParangi 6y agoIt is worth being aware that according to the US state department, Russia and possibly other states are currently involved in vaccine disinformation campaigns. Your mileage may vary but beware anonymous data.
- xaduha 6y agoI hope it's not too political to say, that using tried and true methods is better in an emergency, shouldn't be time for experiments on people. mRNA vaccines seem to be more expensive and harder to store, so what are the benefits? Or who benefits?
- dehrmann 6y ago> what are the benefits It was faster to produce candidate vaccines. There are also some production benefits because it doesn't involve replicating a virus in eggs.
- xaduha 6y agoI don't think it involves eggs, they do it in bioreactors. As for candidate vaccines, didn't end up mattering much, did it? https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/science/coronavirus-vaccine-tracker.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/science/coronavirus...
- stonogo 6y agoBioreactors aren't magic, there still needs to be a growth medium. The question is what media are involved.
- raadore 6y agoWhat the data leak tells us about mRNA vaccine: it is manufactured in the same fashion and by the same types of executives as Boeing 737 Max 8. “Ladies and gentlemen, fasten your seatbelts and prepare for takeoff”.