14 ms·
I’d rather see them implement the European supergrid frankly. PV in the Sahara and high voltage lines up to Europe. Think that would be a win for everyone
by Havoc 6y ago
I’d rather see them implement the European supergrid frankly. PV in the Sahara and high voltage lines up to Europe. Think that would be a win for everyone
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoThat’s sort of a brute force approach. And the Sahara is warm, but solar irradiation varies far less than temperatures. It’s going to be a lie mix of many of these promising ideas, blended in such a way that is, hopefully, not too expensive, not too insecure, not dirty in a new way, and not not at least a little bit fun.
- ThomPete 6y agothe fact that you have to blend them is what makes them expensive and for what? Less than 20% of our energy need is electricity.
- bildung 6y agoRight at the beginning of the study it is stated why that is no alternative: The seasonal production/consumption patterns could lead to "excess PV production in summer on a local, national or even international scale". As Sahara PV is still on the northern hemisphere this would not solve the problem the study tries to tackle.
- tda 6y agoI would like to see the numbers; how much overbuilding would be necessary. Even if you need to install say 50%-100% extra capacity to meet demand in winter, solar power would still be perfectly economically viable. And I'm sure a valid use for excess power in summer can be found, e.g. desalination. Fresh water demand is surely higher in summer in the Sahara, and otherwise fresh water is easily stored
- stdbrouw 6y agoI looked up the numbers for Aswan in the south of Egypt. Roughly 360 hours of sunshine or a bit more in the summer, 290 hours in winter months [1], so about 80% of max. If we look at direct normal irradiance instead, a more appropriate metric, it varies between 7.93 kWh/m^2/day in June vs. 5.51 kWh/m^2/day in December [2], so about 70% of max. Hour-to-hour and day-to-day fluctuations are another thing altogether, and higher demand in winter (e.g. for heating) yet another consideration, but if we're purely interested in some sort of "seasonal correction" I guess you'd want to overbuild by 40% or a bit less if you set the angle of the panels in such a way as to optimize winter production at the expense of summer production, a common strategy. The closer you get to the equator, the less it matters whether you're in the northern hemisphere or the southern hemisphere. Aswan is at 24°N, a latitude at which you can still find a lot of smaller cities, but as you go to the south of that, infrastructure disappears and it might not be economical to build PV or solar thermal installations in the absolute middle of nowhere. Seems to be about the latitude to which DESERTEC proposes to lay HDVC connections. Not an expert though, just someone who can look up some numbers. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aswan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aswan [2] https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Average-Direct-normal-irradiance-of-Aswan-Egypt_fig3_324538284 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Average-Direct-normal-ir...
- konjin 6y agoThe only people who think that solar in a desert is a good idea are the people who have never had to clean a solar panel in a desert: https://www.thenationalnews.com/uae/science/dust-can-dramatically-reduce-effectiveness-of-solar-panels-in-arabian-peninsula-us-study-finds-1.664896 https://www.thenationalnews.com/uae/science/dust-can-dramati...
- imtringued 6y agoCleaning is already fully automated for solar panels. Are you complaining on behalf of the robots?
- konjin 6y agoLinks please. Specifically for how it's solved for grid scale solar in deserts.
- j-pb 6y agoMore panels actually brings down the cleaning cost. Build them all in a large strip, side by side. Attach a blower on rails at the top. Done. C'mon this isn't rocket science.
- posix_me_less 6y agoIt is not possible to blow off very fine dust. Liquids are needed.
- j-pb 6y agoI've yet to encounter non organic dust that doesn't get blown away by high pressure air. Even if you had 25% losses after a month as the linked article suggests, cleaning them "well enough" once a week should give you enough efficiency to just add 10% more area and call it a day.
- 6y ago
- pjc50 6y agoThe political problems of that are far worse than the technical ones.
- cbmuser 6y agoYes, because there is absolutely nothing wrong to have your infrastructure and economy exclusively depend on a politically unstable region. The lengths of bizarre ideas people are coming up with just so they can avoid nuclear power seriously have no end.
- gehsty 6y agoThe politics around nuclear is a real hurdle (rightly or wrongly) so it makes sense to look at other solutions. Lots of energy in Europe is supplied from countries you may not want to be reliant on (Russian gas for example).
- ThomPete 6y agoif politics is the problem, it would indicate that not even the politicians mean there is a problem. If they were truly concerned with CO2 emissions they would find ways to solve for the criminalization of nuclear we are seeing.
- gehsty 6y agoUK is currently building new nuclear. Can’t think of anywhere else. For me people seem to have an either or opinion - we should build renewables or nuclear or whatever (I don’t think this is your stance though). Reality is that we should be deploying none CO2 producing energy as quickly as possible, and if that means building solar / wind farms then build them, if we can build nuclear then build it. Hopefully politics will enable future low risk low waste etc nuclear to thrive.
- fuoqi 6y agoIt's for European countries to decide from whom they want to import energy and not, isn't it? But for some reason the biggest opponent of this "reliance" is the US, not the affected European countries.
- gehsty 6y agoI think the annexation of Crimea certainly increased tension between Europe and Russia. I’m not sure how it effected energy policy however.
- ovi256 6y agoThe Sahara and the access to it already belongs to some countries, that may not be stable enough to host such critical infrastructure.
- tda 6y agoThough not so nice, there are ways to "stabilize" sovereign foreign countries to ensure energy stability. Just look at US middle eastern politics. Not saying we should, but I'd rather have the effort got to solar power in the northern Sahara than extracting fossil fuel from Saudi-Arabia
- Hammershaft 6y agoSahara to Berlin is ~5,000 km over land and would pass thru ~7 countries (including syria & potentially lebanon). Assuming no electricity theft, high transmission powerline losses range between 0.5% - 1.1% per 160 km [1], and losses are generally higher on hotter days, leaving us with a probable loss of between 20% - 35%. I've argued this before, but I would rather avoid unproven storage concepts entirely and fasttrack nuclear reactors. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission?wp...
- D_Alex 6y agoWhat if we move the aluminium smelters to Sahara?
- baybal2 6y agoUnions will protest
- chr1 6y agoWhy do you need it to be overland? Cables can go under the sea without much problem.
- raverbashing 6y agoWho says it has to be over land??
- ben_w 6y ago~3000km if you put an undersea cable in the Mediterranean. Also, lower losses at higher voltages. I have no idea what HVDC underwater cables cost, their maximum voltage, nor their losses, so let’s go with your original figures, and the worst case: 35% losses. The average of the BNEF 2021, Lazard 2020, and IRENA 2020 studies says that utility scale solar costs $48/MWh while nuclear costs $164/MWh: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source#Global_studies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source#... 35% loss would make that $73.8/MWh. At these distances I must assume the grid itself is a non-trivial cost, and estimating that cost certainly deserves a lot more careful thought than I can put into one comment, but that grid would have to cost effectively more than $90/MWh to be worse than nuclear.
- Lio 6y agoWould Spain’s Tabernas Desert be a better bet? It’s closer and Spain is part of the EU and politically stable.
- patrickk 6y agoThat is one option, another is baseload geothermal power from Iceland routed to the UK or Ireland[1] and perhaps onwards to mainland Europe (this option was explored in the past but seems to have fizzled out). Yet more options are the Danish artificial island for distributing wind power and the UK huge offshore wind projects. All these are possible with today's tech and could dramatically reduce the need for batteries while still getting to net zero. The Sahara idea is a non-starter due to geopolitical risks, no way the EU would agree to having critical infrastructure coming from North Africa. There was a discussion recently on the EU supergrid[2]. If politicians were serious about solving the climate crisis we'd already be building out all this infrastructure instead of everyone wringing their hands about the cost. And meanwhile the likes of Nordstream2 is powering ahead. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26389042 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26389042 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26386529 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26386529
- fuoqi 6y ago>And meanwhile the likes of Nordstream2 is powering ahead. While you cry about environmental impact of burning Russian natural gas (even though Nord Stream 2 physically can not increase its export to the EU by more than 10% and probably will be used to simply re-route existing supplies from middle-man countries like Poland and Ukraine), the likes of Poland generate 70% of their electricity from coal. But, hey, they don't pay to Russia so it's fine! Until we will have a viable geography-independent solution for grid-level energy storage (which ideally should be able to store several days worth of consumption), massive renewables (aprox. more than 20-30% of a total generation capacity) always will be backed by fossil plants. Well, unless of course you want for blackouts to become a common occurrence. If you indeed care about ecology and climate, then the choice between coal and natural gas should be obvious.
- hannob 6y agoMuch more likely that there will be PV in the desert to produce green ammonia, which can then be shipped. We'll need plenty of that, and it's far easier to do than building a several thousand kilometer transmission line. Also don't forget: The Sahara is in a worl region where plenty of people don't have an electricity grid yet. So yes, by all means, build solar power there, but a significant share of it needs to be provided to the people living there.
- patall 6y agoAny PV supplying europe would probably in the northern sahara region. In countries like Tunesia, Algeria, Egypt or Morocco. All of which have electrification rates beyond 99%. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_electrification_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_electrifi...
- sandworm101 6y ago>> PV in the Sahara Classic deserts aren't the best place for solar. They may be sunny but wind-blown dust covers panels. Sand+wind etches glass. And heat reduces PV efficiency. A better option might actually be the high north. It gets plenty of sun for at least half the year and when it isn't getting sun it is getting wind.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoAlso the kind of geoengineering that turning large parts of the sahara black would be is estimated to cause warming due to albedo changes. https://thenextweb.com/science/2021/03/02/solar-panels-in-the-sahara-could-boost-renewable-energy-but-raise-temperatures-worldwide-syndication/ https://thenextweb.com/science/2021/03/02/solar-panels-in-th...
- Chris2048 6y agoIsn't that somewhat tech-specific? Couldn't you make solar panels that reflected more light back?
- ses1984 6y agoThe point of a solar panel is to absorb light and turn it into electricity, so no, not really.
- Chris2048 6y agoAccording to the linked article: only a fraction (around 15%) of that incoming energy gets converted to electricity So a solar panel design that reflected more of that 85% back would still produce energy.
- dragontamer 6y agoIIRC: Molten Salt "solar towers" work well in desert environments. Your point remains however: Desert solar-power is a different beast than normal solar-power. PV won't work well in a desert, you need to change your methodology entirely. A "Solar tower" consists of a tower (which is just a standard thermal power-plant: usually a steam engine), and a ton of mirrors that heats the tower to 500C. The hotter the environment, the better a solar tower design gets.
- danaliv 6y agoI see Europe is still drooling over the chance to strip-mine Africa.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- freeflight 6y agoThe European supergrid will be based on hydrogen [0] as an energy storage and transfer medium. [0] https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy/news/gas-grid-operators-unveil-plan-for-european-hydrogen-infrastructure-backbone/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy/news/gas-grid-operat...
- fy20 6y agoNo need to go so far. There's enough desert type land in Spain that isn't really useful for anything else. Covering it with solar panels may actually improve the ecosystem, as shrubbery could grow underneath it (or use semi-transparent panels mounted 10m above the ground, and you'd have a nice greenhouse). Musk claimed the entire US could be run on solar power with a 100 square mile (258 km2) patch of land - that's smaller than Malta. Batteries to ensure a continuous supply would need 1 square mile.