4 ms·
That's two people very angry at crypto energy consumption I see in the same week. I find the emotion quite surprising.. I don't see the same amount toward othe
by agumonkey 6y ago
That's two people very angry at crypto energy consumption I see in the same week.
I find the emotion quite surprising.. I don't see the same amount toward other forms of pollution. Consumerism is also a bit absurd these days and global trade is a large producer of CO2 too.
Now I find the crypto world a bit absurd and surely if they could kill the energy requirements then good.. but climate change is certainly not a consequence of btc miners.
- lxgr 6y agoThe difference is that proof-of-work is intentional waste of energy, rather than incidental. Take your favorite evil mega-corporation: If you can offer them a way to perform the same task using half the energy, they'd immediately jump at the opportunity. Bitcoin miners, on the other hand, would just... mine twice as fast, consuming exactly the same energy as before.
- chii 6y ago> intentional waste of energy, rather than incidental. is it a waste if the result was useful? Why do you get to decide, rather tha whoever was paying for the electricity?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lxgr 6y ago> Why do you get to decide, Because this waste has externalities and I'd argue that in a democracy, people should have a say in that.
- ric2b 6y agoPretty much any energy use has externalities though. I agree that in a democracy we all have a say in what we allow or not, but let's stop with this constant narrative that killing cryptocurrencies would significantly help with stopping climate change, it would barely make a difference, there are much more important things to focus on if that's really your goal.
- lxgr 6y agoVery true, mining is nowhere near the top of any list of climate concerns. But I feel like addressing it as a problem now rather than a few years down the road might be a good idea. Socially and politically normalizing the idea of intentionally wasting energy in exchange for financial gain seems like the wrong signal.
- ric2b 6y ago> normalizing the idea of intentionally wasting energy in exchange for financial gain That's true of basically any industry.
- chii 6y ago> people should have a say in that. not every issue can be democratically decided. I am a proponent of market forces - price into energy all externalities, and let those who find the cost worth the result decide.
- agumonkey 6y agoIsn't that a fallacious choice? Everybody beside btc is moving to proof of stake. Who knows if btc/pow will still be the main crypto in 5 years.
- ric2b 6y ago>Take your favorite evil mega-corporation: If you can offer them a way to perform the same task using half the energy, they'd immediately jump at the opportunity. > Bitcoin miners, on the other hand, would just... mine twice as fast, consuming exactly the same energy as before. Both situations are the same, in your first example the mega-corp would just use the increased efficiency to produce more and sell more of whatever they sell, as long as there was demand for it.
- estaseuropano 6y agoThere are many things to like and not like about crypto and this is a biggie. The Bitcoin energy impact is huge compared to it's real-world utility, which plainly, is zero as other systems exist that can do the same things more efficiently. Any crypto enthusiast should dump bitcoin for any proof of stake coin. It has the brand recognition, but it cannot possibly last.
- agumonkey 6y agoFrankly the fact that most alternatives are staking is a sign of things to come.