5 ms·
Do we want government getting into the chip business?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Daishiman 6y agoThat ship has not only sailed away, it was never on port in the first place. The article gets the reasons for this increased interest in chip technology wrong; it has nothing to do with COVID recovery and everything to do with keeping a competitive edge in a world where China has a national policy of developing competitive state of the art CPUs. Secondly, chip manufacturing was always in the eye of the US's strategic interests for blindingly obvious reasons. It's a garbage article that has random lines of government blaming and the garbage editorial line of the Murdoch-owned WSJ where the state can do nothing right and private actors deserve all credit.
- boh 6y agoAmazing how little substance this opinion article has on either side of the argument. "Government bad bcs misallocation of resources", meanwhile the reason why the US doesn't have much of the industry they themselves developed is because market forces love short-term solutions (so outsourcing everything and depending on foreign firms for key tech is the better resource allocation strategy apparently). Without government backing, there is no chip industry in the US (or not much of it anyway). It doesn't really matter how WSJ feels about it.
- missedthecue 6y agoComparitive advantage isn't "short termism"
- boh 6y agoEcon 101 will only get you so far. Reductionist models attempt to reflect the real world but the real world rarely reflects reductionist models. Comparative advantage for who? The US? The industry? The human race? Or the value of a legal entity for a short period of time when a reduction in costs gets them a bump in share value as the company gets hollowed out from the inside out. I don't know who decided to make mid-century Economics into an ideology, but we should try to evolve at this point.
- chriselles 6y agoI definitely want government to support onshoring items in the supply chain deemed to be of national critical importance. https://steveblank.com/2020/06/18/the-coming-chip-wars-of-the-21st-century/ https://steveblank.com/2020/06/18/the-coming-chip-wars-of-th... How government does it? I don’t know. I don’t think government should own chip fabs, but if local governments can entice sports teams to move with sweetheart deals, then national government can do the same to entice critical supply chain onshore.
- dirtyid 6y agoEvery government should be in the business of industrial policy.