4 ms·
> If it's OK to print money to pay for some things why are you not doing it more? Why not make everyone a millionaire? If one slice of cake tastes nice why wou
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> If it's OK to print money to pay for some things why are you not doing it more? Why not make everyone a millionaire?
If one slice of cake tastes nice why wouldn't you enjoy eating a million slices of cake?
- j7ake 6y agoBecause the size of the cake is fixed (analogy to the economy), and cutting that piece of cake into 10 slices or a million slices (analogy to increasing money supply) is not going to make a difference in the amount of cake there is for people.
- harryh 6y agoThe size of the cake is not constant. It grows over time. We are much richer now than we were in the past.
- j7ake 6y agoYeah that is true. Maybe I'll just say that the size of the cake (economy) grows but is fairly independent of how you slice the cake. So printing money doesn't increase the size of the economy.
- harryh 6y agoYes, but with a larger cake, it makes sense to have more slices. There are other reasons that inflation is good too, having to do with sticky wages and recessions. I'm not sure how to work that into the cake analogy though.
- j7ake 6y agoYeah the reality is that the size of the cake changes, and slicing the cake in different ways can feed back to the growth of the cake. The perceived value of each slice relies a lot in the psychology of the public. It's the job of the central bank to make sure the slices are proportioned properly and the perceived value of each slice of cake is maintained.
- imtringued 6y agoThe entire reasoning behind inflation is that thanks to productivity increases there is always a slice left behind. If nobody eats the slice then the cake shop will make smaller cakes with less slices. If we give someone money to buy the last slice then the cake shop is incentivized to make another left over slice until it is so busy making cake that it cannot make more.
- jedharris 6y agoKey observation. In recessions (liquidity crunches) the cake grows more slowly. Maybe if we increase liquidity a lot (i.e. print money) and give it to the bottom tiers who will spend it (increase velocity) then the cake will grow faster! We don't have good models for how the economy actually works. Until 2008 most models didn't even have a financial sector. Currently economic models can't accurately predict the velocity of money or even explain changes after the fact very well. We still have no consensus among economists as to what causes recessions. So this is an experiment but the claims that it is "obviously" going to lead to inflation are flat wrong. We are going to learn a lot from this experiment. If we need to pull back to bring down inflation, we have tools for that.
- rdm70 6y agoOK. So what are the limiting principles for money creation? When does it shift from being a good thing to too much of a good thing? This seems to be completely absent from the public debate.
- dkjaudyeqooe 6y agoThat's entirely dependent on the economic situation. The same question can be asked of interest rates. And the answer is when you get bad outcomes. You have to assume the Fed knows what it is doing, but most people seem to think they know better.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> OK. So what are the limiting principles for money creation? If you gave everyone a million dollars would they all be able to buy a million dollar home? No? Why do you think not? Because the price of million dollar homes would go up because everyone would now be able to bid for them. You can literally give everyone a million dollars, but you won't be giving them a million dollars of purchasing power relative to before you gave them the money.
- missedthecue 6y agoThat's the point the parent is making, except he thinks it doesn't take as much as a million dollars for that effect to take place. His question is why is $8 trillion of money printing since last March A-OK when $100 trillion isnt? Is the line $8 trillion? $25T? $50T?
- OscarCunningham 6y agoThe Fed has an inflation target of 2%. That is precisely when printing money shifts from being a good thing to a bad thing.
- jsmcgd 6y agoYes exactly. Why is it bad to make everyone a millionaire? It's bad because making everyone a millionaire by decree, or printing more units of currency is necessarily the same thing as devaluing the currency. Such that the population as a whole has exactly the same amount of buying power, and now each unit of currency is worth much less. The inflation of the M0 money supply, base money, WILL lead to an increase in consumer prices for everything including essentials like food. The only reason people can try to convince themselves otherwise is because of the time lag between when the money is printed and when it shows up in consumer prices. So when the government quadruples the base money supply and the price of a loaf of bread doesn't quadruple in price, people start to think this inflation is no big deal. Well just wait. That loaf of bread will more than quadruple in price. And it will happen all of a sudden. The majority of the printed money is going into assets like equities. These have increased massively in value, despite the fact that revenues have not increased that much, or have even decreased. This is a bubble and it will collapse. When that happens, then you will see all those printed dollars. Investors will rapidly divest themselves of their shares and will be putting those dollars into others assets that are seen as much safer investments like commodities including food. By this point governments have no ability to reverse course, in fact they are committed to exacerbating the situation. Printing money is necessary to plug the deficit of government spending. You could turn off the money supply but it will mean devastating cuts to government spending. So they won't do it. Instead they will start implementing wide-scale, all pervasive capital controls in an effort stop people divesting themselves of the rapidly weakening dollar. This is an economic straight jacket and will shrink the economy further, massively stunting tax revenues, in turn reducing government spending, in turn shrinking the economy further. Calls to 'tax the wealthy' will be eventually implemented, but there isn't anywhere near enough wealth there to tax to cover the effects of a money supply that has grown exponentially. Regardless new tax bills will be introduced. The very wealthy will have already moved their wealth into non taxable assets, domestic and overseas. (This is already happening). The law makers know this, yet regardless this taxation burden will fall squarely on the rapidly diminishing middle classes and ballooning lower classes. You can read the above again to see exactly how printing money is a highly effective tax in it's own right and it did not require any legislation to write. At this point the world is caught in an economic death spiral and it won't recover until the currency has completely bottomed out and begins again with a new currency and confidence slowly returns. There is no telling how much long term economic damage will have been done by this point. There is no magic or mystery here. This is not complicated. It is not new, unknown and to be determined. This will be a carbon copy repeat of exactly the same follies experienced by numerous economies in recent history. The only open question is, much like a coming earthquake, when? The answer unfortunately is very soon.