2 ms·
Conveniently the author excludes house prices from his definition of inflation.
by HPsquared 6y ago
Conveniently the author excludes house prices from his definition of inflation.
- throw0101a 6y agoBecause that is not "inflation". There is another economic term for that phenomenon, and conflating the two only creates confusion: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_bubble https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_bubble Inflation/CPI is (roughly) about the cost of living determined via a basket of goods and services that one needs on daily/weekly/monthly basis. Financial assets are not needed to live: the bottom-half of US wage earners have no/little financial assets and yet are effected by inflation when they go shopping. And while shelter is, it is taken into account via rent or rent-equivalent (mortgage carrying costs): * https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-and-rent.pdf https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-an... I'm not sure where and when the idea of financial assets being included into the concept of inflation started, but it's a first world 'problem' of the wealthy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- HPsquared 6y agoDon't average people buy houses? It's a bit of an artificial distinction to exclude them. Inflation is also defined as expansion of the money supply (monetary inflation), and mortgages are a major source of money creation - the rate of this process being closely related to house prices.
- Majromax 6y ago> Don't average people buy houses? It's a bit of an artificial distinction to exclude them. When an average person buys a house and lives in it for a decade, they still have the house. Inflation is defined by consumption expenditures. I buy food, eat it, and no longer have that food to sell. I pay the power bill, having consumed power that cannot be resold. The consumed portion of housing is rent. And that is included in price indices; statistical agencies have to go to the trouble of modelling an owner-equivalent for owner-occupied housing. If you're still concerned about the technical definitions of what goes into a consumer price index, then you have plenty of others to choose from. The GDP deflator (a price index based on everything produced in the economy) shows trends very similar to the consumer price index over the medium-term. > Inflation is also defined as expansion of the money supply (monetary inflation), And those two concepts are not in fact equivalent. Going from an observed change in the money supply to changes in prices requires more intricate assumptions about how the economy works. The same money-supply increase can cause an increase in price levels in one country (say Venezuela) rather than another (the United States) depending on beliefs about permanence and the background state of the economy.
- throw0101a 6y agoTaken into account; see the BLS.gov link. * https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2020/07/mortgage-rates-are-insanely-low/ https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2020/07/mortgage-rates-are-... Some places have negative mortgage rates: * https://www.theguardian.com/money/2019/aug/13/danish-bank-launches-worlds-first-negative-interest-rate-mortgage https://www.theguardian.com/money/2019/aug/13/danish-bank-la... Homes seem to have had consistent carrying costs over the decades, and that is what determines the CPI. Yes, prices have gone up, but (a) interest rates have dropped, and (b) people are getting a lot more housing for their money (e.g., (average) square footage up).
- yanderekko 6y agoUh, mere growth in asset prices is not a strong indicator of a bubble. How much would property prices have to decline for this asset class to no longer have supernormal returns for the past 20 years? Do you actually think that that's going to happen?
- bildung 6y ago> onveniently the author excludes house prices from his definition of inflation. Beause that is appreciation, not inflation. Investment vs. consumption. If you bought Tesla stock at $100, and now it is at $200, that's appreciation. If the price of a kWh of electricity goes up, that's inflation.
- imtringued 6y agoAsset appreciation is exactly the word I was looking for! Asset inflation has the problem that it's not the asset that is inflating. It's dollar inflation in relation to the asset in question. Asset appreciation is the exact same concept with terminology that cuts straight to the point.
- bildung 6y agoBut it isn't the case (asset appreciation as hidden dollar inflation). Assets among practically all classes appreciate, but consumptive commodities don't. So it isn't devaluation of the dollar, but really just appreciation of the assets. Expansion of M1 alone doesn't make inflation[0]. For inflation to occur one also needs rising wages across the board and thus more demand than supply. What the US (and to a lesser degree many European countries) experience is the result of decades of stagnant wages means more than half of the population is decoupled from the gains of asset appreciation, but the assets themselves actually behave more or less normal. Have a look at the last 100 years of stock growth, for example: https://www.macrotrends.net/2324/sp-500-historical-chart-data https://www.macrotrends.net/2324/sp-500-historical-chart-dat... The asset prices don't really rise (much) faster than in previous decades! The current trend is pretty much identical to the growth between 1980 and 2000. [0] Otherwise we would see it all the time, because the money supply is theoretically infinite already, without QE, because banks are actually the instutions creating new money via credits they offer. It's just that banks were frightened and stopped giving out credits post 2007/8, which created an illiquidity that QE tried to compensate.