10 ms·
Detroit DIYer cooks up stronger, lighter steel, shames scientists
- djcapelis 15y agoThe linked article was pretty small, so I went and tried to get a bit more information: * http://www.bainitesteel.com/ http://www.bainitesteel.com/ - the company making the product * http://www.gizmag.com/stronger-steel-in-a-flash/18882/ http://www.gizmag.com/stronger-steel-in-a-flash/18882/ - a longer and better writeup * http://nextbigfuture.com/2011/06/flash-bainite-is-strongest-most-ductile.html http://nextbigfuture.com/2011/06/flash-bainite-is-strongest-... - another writeup Looks cool! Though not sure about the flamebait title from the original article. :)
- pedalpete 15y agoThe gizmag article points out a great potential in marketing of this steel too. I had assumed as I read it, that the process would be more energy intensive, but it is actually less, which could mean a reduction in at least comparable cost to current steel solutions. 'Cola also says his process is also environmentally friendly as it consumes less energy per kilogram of steel processed compared to traditional methods and uses water instead of oils or molten salt.'
- guelo 15y agoWow amateur metallurgist sounds like a hardcore hobby.
- crocowhile 15y agoPeople have the weirdest hobbies. Have a look at this guy: http://www.themysteryworld.com/2011/02/tatara-project-guy-makes-blade-out-of.html http://www.themysteryworld.com/2011/02/tatara-project-guy-ma... Making knives starting from the very scratch (that is, making their own steel to start with)
- craigmccaskill 15y agoFascinating article, thanks.
- eru 15y agoAnd actually, if hacking with computers wasn't so common, it would be perceived as quite awesome, too.
- hugh3 15y agoI'm sure you'd like to think so, but unless you have a blast furnace in your garage you're not as cool as this guy, sorry.
- cincinnatus 15y agoHow about a CNC mill, laser cutter or reprap? :-)
- eru 15y agoYes, unfortunately.
- nebaneba 15y agoThis looks like the original: http://www.arscives.com/bladesign/tamahagane/main.htm http://www.arscives.com/bladesign/tamahagane/main.htm Also has additional information on it.
- shii 15y agoA friend of mine is 'bio hacker'; he works with different microbiological organisms to learn about them and build better ones with specific traits. This article describes it better than I can: http://www.nature.com/news/2010/101006/full/467650a.html http://www.nature.com/news/2010/101006/full/467650a.html
- crocowhile 15y agoI am a biohacker too, actually. I just submitted a paper on how to build a Drosophila lab with little budget, for schools or biology lovers.
- shii 15y agoCool, do you have a link I can share or something? Sounds fascinating.
- crocowhile 15y agoAs soon as the paper is accepted I will write more here on HN. Cannot do much before as for editorial requirements, sorry.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- gaustin 15y agoI'm an amateur bladesmith. This guy posts regularly on one of the forums I participate in. He's chronicled his research there in very accessible, but rich detail. Really brilliant stuff (from my layman perspective).
- joshwa 15y agolink?
- sbierwagen 15y agoJust in case anyone is leaping to wrong conclusions: This is neat, but it's not a miracle material. Tensile strength of 1900MPa is quite high for a steel, but it's half as strong as glass fiber. The big advantage here is that it's tougher, and cheaper to make, than fiberglass composite.
- mattdeboard 15y agoEr, what conclusion is there to jump to other than an accurate one? It's 7% stronger than traditional steel and 30% lighter, with a greatly decreased manufacturing cost. Ok, fine, it's not a "miracle" material since it's not curing the sick or raising the dead. But as long as testing continues to support the conclusion of both the manufacturer and researchers at tOSU (and elsewhere), this seems like an impressive engineering feat.
- patrickaljord 15y agoThe title is ridiculous though, didn't they use science to make stronger steel or did they make them out of magic?
- learc83 15y agoI'm sure the title meant professional, established scientists, not that he didn't use the scientific method.
- Nrsolis 15y agoWhole careers are made on improving some existing process by a few percent. Kudos to that guy.
- econner 15y agoSo is it going to be called Rearden Metal?
- jodoherty 15y agoThat brings up another question: How much will it cost and how can I buy some?
- eru 15y agoWhy would you buy a lump of steel?
- killerswan 15y agoMetallurgists do this. I've held lumps of the steel used in power plants (which doesn't burn when the coal does), and even a pop can sized cylinder of Beryllium. :D
- gaustin 15y agoTo turn it into something that isn't a lump of steel.
- jodoherty 15y agoI dunno about lumps, but with a little welding knowledge I can imagine a lot of things I could try building if I could buy prefabricated shapes and sheets of the stuff.
- hammock 15y agoRearden Metal, anyone?
- michaelleland 15y agoFirst thing that came to mind. That's it, I'm starting a new railroad.
- eru 15y agoYou should ask Mr Buffett about some pointers. He recently bought one.
- Evgeny 15y agoFirst thing I did, searched this (comments) page for "Rearden".
- bherms 15y agoSame, haha. I wonder how long until the state science institute seizes it.
- gardarh 15y agoI didn't know there was much steel in laptops.
- ptrf 15y agohttp://www.engadget.com/2011/06/11/detroit-diyer-cooks-up-stronger-lighter-steel-shames-scientist http://www.engadget.com/2011/06/11/detroit-diyer-cooks-up-st... The title links to the mobile page of engadget for some unapparent reason.
- riledhel 15y agoSame story appeared before on HN: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2642780 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2642780
- tokenadult 15y agoAt least this write-up http://www.physorg.com/news/2011-06-lighter-stronger-steel-.html http://www.physorg.com/news/2011-06-lighter-stronger-steel-.... based on a press release mentions a journal article (as does one of the write-ups linked in the reply by djcapelis). A quick search on Google Scholar http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=bainite http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=bainite didn't immediately turn up the new journal article, but shows that bainite has been the subject of prior literature on heat treatment of steel for a long time. What is unclear so far, based on any of the write-ups linked to from this thread, is what trade-offs in mechanical and thermal characteristics and price the variety of steel mentioned in the current press releases will have in comparison with the hundreds of existing specialized varieties of steel. What industry response there may be depends greatly on what steel characteristics particular users of steel are most interested in.
- srean 15y agoIn spite of our understanding of chemistry, metallurgy still has quite a few mysteries in store for us. Some of them go back thousands of years. For instance we still have not been able to come up with a convincing reproduction of Damascus steel, the prized material that middle eastern swords were built of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damascus_steel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damascus_steel. Another supposedly related and "lost" steel is wootz steel. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wootz_steel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wootz_steel Perhaps a good term to describe the study of these materials would be forensic metallurgy. My closest brush with metallurgy was in a high-school chemistry text-book, which to be honest bored me to death. But at a different level it instills respect for the ingenuity and persistence of humans. Those methods are by no means simple and the bronze-age and iron-age men figured it out. Among other things that make recreating these materials hard, is that in cooking them you not only need to get the ingredients right, but also get the sequence correct, sometimes to the minutest detail. Impurities in parts per million or the lack of can have significant effects in determining the properties of the material. Same goes for the process of making it. We understand properties of individual components well enough but the physics that dictates the properties of alloys is different, difficult, non-smooth and very non-linear. Statistical physics have played a huge role in trying to model these behavior. Another historical-metallurgical curiosity is the surprisingly corrosion resistant iron pillar in Delhi. It has been out there, in the open, facing the corroding elements of tropical weather for 25 centuries, but with little or no corrosion damage. Edit: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_pillar_of_Delhi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_pillar_of_Delhi
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- hugh3 15y agoIndeed. The other problem with metallurgy is that it's awfully complicated on all sorts of scales from the atomic to the micron scale. Most materials and chemicals out there we now have a pretty darn good understanding of, thanks to being able to sit there and simulate the atomic structure of the material in the computer. But metals like steel are far too complicated since you're not just interested in hundreds or thousands of atoms at a time. To understand steel and predict its properties you need to understand all the impurities and the grain boundaries -- these things occur on scales which are far too large for simulation. So metallurgy remains somewhat like baking a cake. We can bake all sorts of tasty cakes, but there are other cake recipes out there yet to be discovered which might taste even better and we have no idea how to get there from here. (And for this analogy to not completely break down let's just assume that "tastiness" is both objective and measurable even though it isn't...)
- moultano 15y agoCan we remove the "shames scientists" bit from the headline? This guy is a scientist by definition if he has any experimental validation, and I didn't see a citation for anyone being shamed.
- riledhel 15y agoSecond this. Don't understand why a sensationalist headline should translate as is to HN.
- sudont 15y agoBecause it feels like there’s a strong distaste for amateur scientists (those without degrees, not those who don’t know the scientific method) coming from both professional engineers and PhDs, anyone that has academic accreditation. The sensationalist title appeals to the autodidact that learned how to earn 100k+ without college through programming.
- enko 15y agoAs one of these non college educated $100k+ autodidacts I feel no particular attraction to the title, in fact it is faintly annoying. Yes, I do vaguely dislike people who value academic success over any other. However, as a (also self-directed) student of history I know how much real science has been done by the hobbyist and so the "tweaking the nose of the establishment" angle doesn't really work for me.
- amcintyre 15y agoI'm an autodidact that managed to earn ~100k without formal education with programming, and then got some formal education in something else just for the fun of it. I don't like it when people use their adacemic experience (or lack of it) to bludgeon people that have backgrounds different from their own. I think drawing those kinds of distinctions in headlines is unproductive and foolish.
- learc83 15y agoYes he used the scientific method, so by definition is a scientist. However, I'm sure the title is using the popular definition of scientist (a professional researcher) in contrast to an amateur hobbyist.
- politician 15y agoI think it's fair to point out that /this/ is an acceptable process to patent. I'm sure that's obvious, but HN does spend a lot of time denouncing software patents (rightly so). EDIT: Not really sure why I got down-voted; nevertheless, I do think it's important to point out cases where patents can be applied as originally intended.
- Devilboy 15y agoPersonally I feel that even stuff like this should not be patentable and that all patents should be abolished but I know many here disagree.
- cheez 15y agoHow would you suggest society repay the guy who invented the material? I can't think of any way except a temporary monopoly on its use.
- noonespecial 15y agoThe problem is that as it stands now, someone like Intellectual Ventures will have a patent like "cooling metal with water", and either force him to sell for a few hundred bucks or just interfere with anyone else who actually tries to do this. It'll be 20 years before anyone figures out a way through all of the legal mess and starts production. Even then, it will cost more, not less thanks to this.
- hugh3 15y agoWell no, because nobody does or legally could possibly have a patent on cooling metal with water. So I'm not sure what your point is. It strikes me that many of the folks who most stridently object to patent law don't actually know much about it.
- noonespecial 15y agoIt's an example. And hyperboly at that. But you'd be surprised (at least I am) at the patents that are granted that really shouldn't be, but once they are have nearly magical powers given to them by existing laws to resist being overturned. The point was that it's possible to have an extremely stupid patent that really shouldn't have been legal or possible get granted anyway and cause big problems to small guys like this. He's got a great idea but not much money or clout. The patent system will almost certainly do him more harm than good. It strikes me that many of the folks who defend patent law as it stands now most stridently are largely oblivious to the innovation that is being stifled by it's operation.
- jtchang 15y agoThis what I love about human ingenuity: we constantly strive to improve upon something even if other people say it can't be done.
- D_Alex 15y agoI might have to disappoint you all... An Australian company, BHP (my employer at the time), was working on this method of steel production in the early 1990's. They had big hopes and put a lot of R&D investment in it, but were unable to commercialize it as the sheets of metal produced did not have consistent ductility and were prone to cracking. So - the idea is not new, and the challenges of going from a concept to commercialization are serious, and were beyond the capabilities of one of the world's largest steel producers. The Bainsteel website indicates that they are still in the R&D phase. Best of luck to them, hope it works, but it is vaporware until it is on sale.
- intended 15y agoCould you share more information? A description of the process perhaps? Is there any difference between what BHP was working on and his process? (I realize that you may not have information now that you aren't working there.) There is something about the parent article that doesn't sit entirely well with me. It might just be my inner skeptic, though.
- D_Alex 15y agoThe process was conceptually identical, AFAICT. Actual implementation differed insofar as coolant was sprayed onto the hot strip rather than being contained in a bath as shown in the linked graphic. BHP's steelmaking research in the early 90's was IMO pretty leading edge - google "BHP Project M" for example. Unfortunately, the accountants decided that there was little future in steelmaking in Australia, and spun off BHP's steelmaking arm as a separate company (OneSteel) in yr 2000. The R&D focus died off around the same time. Back to Flash Bainite - I am not totally dissing it, since some particular combination of steel composition and time-temperature path through the alloy phase diagram might produce an especially good result. What I am saying is that analogous heat treatments have been extensively studied in the past - but not implemented commercially due to problems the researchers were unable to overcome.
- Adam503 15y agoMy dad had a PhD in metallurgical engineering from a Big 10 university. I heard more about steel growing up up, than... well. you know. Anyway, I got curious about steel in samurai swords one time, and I asked him about that. He said there's lots of legends about this material or that could be remade at the research lab my dad worked at that were not feasible to be mass produced. Process too costly, or too toxic, or maybe too dangerous when you have to make several thousand tons of it. If my Dad had been given two weeks to just go and play at his company's lab, he could have walked out the door with Excalibur.
- jurjenh 15y agoI would imagine there would be a limited market for this, by necessity it would be a high-end / high-cost / high-value market, much like exclusive furniture for the rather well-off. Any idea whether there are actual Excalibur smelters around?
- nsomaru 15y agothat's just awesome.
- unwind 15y agoNow, who has the number for the Nobel Prize committee? Easy: http://www.kva.se/en/contact/Committees/Nobel-Committee-for-Physics/ http://www.kva.se/en/contact/Committees/Nobel-Committee-for-.... :)
- TylerBrock 15y agoHank Reardon... is that you?
- nosse 15y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bainite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bainite