6 ms·
The US government basically claims jurisdiction over the entire global financial system. There are philosophical problems with this stance, but simultaneously t
by roenxi 6y ago
The US government basically claims jurisdiction over the entire global financial system. There are philosophical problems with this stance, but simultaneously the government seems to be trying to lock its own citizens out of that system.
The strategy here, if there is one, baffles me. There seems to be a real cost to taking on US customers. This is just one small facet of a crazy problem.
Do people in America seriously consider it an acceptable trade-off when "Binance blocks U.S. residents from its website"? This just looks like own goal after own goal.
- secfirstmd 6y agoThe cost of taking onboard US customers is always a big issue. Particularly related to insurance. We build open source mobile apps to help people learn about and manage digital security. When we first setup our company in the UK we easily got insurance coverage across the EU and rest of the EMEA for about a few hundred pounds. Want to get if for the US also for a new company? Oh that'll be in the tens of thousands of pounds.
- teekert 6y agoIt makes for good Lawyer and Hospital series, the US legal and healthcare systems are filled with emotional (and particularly financial) drama for normal people.
- chii 6y agoi'm interested in is why it's so much more expensive in the US. Is it monopoly? Why couldn't similar prices be reached in the US, if the insurance offered the same in the EU region?
- londons_explore 6y agoCompanies in the US have a far higher chance of losing big expensive lawsuits. In Europe lawsuits tend to be both cheaper and rarer.
- secfirstmd 6y agoExactly.
- austhrow743 6y agoI feel like big government types who like lots of regulation probably don’t see the inability to use binance as a loss.
- jl2718 6y agoTwo subtypes: 1. I’m poor and I don’t want to see anybody else getting rich. 2. I’m super-rich and I want everybody else to be poor. Who exactly does this help?
- jb775 6y agoThe strategy is to maintain control of the global financial system, and therefore control of the entire world. They don't need to worry about people or organizations already within the realm of arrest/extradition/freezable-assets, they can squash them whenever. It's only the people and orgs outside that realm that pose immediate risk...especially when the org's product involves holding large chunks of wealth. I think binance was allowed to run a separate USA-specific operation, but this was simply to keep everything within the mentioned realm.
- webinvest 6y ago> The strategy is to maintain control of the global financial system, and therefore control of the entire world. I disagree because it sounds more limited to only control over US citizens. US citizens are the biggest losers in this arrangement.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Do people in America seriously consider it an acceptable trade-off when "Binance blocks U.S. residents from its website"? This just looks like own goal after own goal. The people who decide these things are not accountable to the public.
- arcticbull 6y agoSure they are. This just isn’t an issue the public cares about. Citizenship based taxation has been the law of the land since it was brought in to punish deserters in the civil war. Americans broadly don’t care though. They should - America is the only country on earth to do this - but they don’t. Apathy towards an issue you care about isn’t the same as lack of accountability, IMO.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoYeah I’m not seeing the accountability.
- arcticbull 6y agoThey’re accountable to people who don’t care about your issue, that’s not a lack of accountability. Accountability doesn’t always mean you agree with the direction or outcome.
- joshuaissac 6y ago> America is the only country on earth to do this Eritrea taxes overseas citizens as well.
- arcticbull 6y agoQuite right, although they are of course not in a position to enforce this; certainly not in the way America is. I suspect while they say they do, the number of returns they actually get can be counted on one hand. So yes in theory, probably no in practice. I’ve always wondered though if you have some data I’d love to see it!
- gnopgnip 6y agoBinance created the subsidary binance.us for US customers, they have some restrictions due to US laws. Generally the US market is too valuable to be ignored entirely, even when there are significant restrictions. So US residents aren't really missing out or blocked entirely.