20 ms·
>Another important factor for me, was the protection from inflation. Food prices go up during inflation, so my farm is worth more. this is a moot point because
by gruez 6y ago
>Another important factor for me, was the protection from inflation. Food prices go up during inflation, so my farm is worth more.
this is a moot point because literally any other thing you invest it (short of maybe government bonds) protect you from inflation.
- lettergram 6y agoNot quite. Stocks, gold, Bitcoin, a house you live in (not rent) don’t produce anything (unless your stock has a dividend). You want something that produces. Say I buy $300k worth of gold, 10% inflation hits and there’s no change in demand and its now worth $330k. Say I buy a $300k farm. 10% inflation hits and there’s no change in demand. It’s now worth $330k... but the value of production of said farm is also up 10%. This makes an opportunity. If I take a loan on my farm in year 1, I can buy a larger farm (say on 3% interest). If inflation hits I can pay down that farm loan at an ever increasing rate. This allows someone to leverage the inflation and debt to make larger purchases. It protects your INCOME from inflation. Not just your investments.
- smeyer 6y agoWhat you're describing isn't specific to farms. If you take out a fixed-rate loan, you'll benefit from increases to inflation (since it makes the inflation-adjusted interest rate lower). This is true whether you use that loan to buy a farm, a house, gold, et cetera. Other than the loan, it makes sense to work in real dollars (inflation adjusted) not nominal dollars (non-inflation adjusted). In real dollars, you $300k farm doesn't change in value and your income also doesn't change. In real dollars, gold (in your example) also doesn't change. Gold is a poor and weird investment for a variety of reasons, but it's not like farms are magically better than other asset classes (like regular old stocks).
- eej71 6y agoPerhaps I'm deeply misinformed, but as a hedge against a modest amount of regular inflation, stocks generally perform quite well over the long term - especially when compared against other asset categories.
- milesvp 6y agoYou’re not misinformed. This is kind of a weird thread. Generally, if you want to hedge against inflation, you buy anything but dollars. If you want a very safe hedge against inflation you buy US government bonds. They are considered the lowest default bond, and as such will generally be priced at expected inflation. Next up, if you want about 1% above inflation (and the associated risk) you go with corporate bonds. And if you want about 3%, and more risk, you go with stocks. Generally you should know the higher the interest the greater the risk. Some of the risk is short term risk, like not being able to liquidate. Some of the risk is longer term, like a company becoming insolvent. To get good returns from the stock market, you need diversity, and long time lines, and growing companies. Else luck.
- gruez 6y ago>Stocks, gold, Bitcoin, a house you live in (not rent) don’t produce anything (unless your stock has a dividend). Houses: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imputed_rent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imputed_rent Stocks: You're literally owning a share of a corporation that produces stuff. Producing a dividend (or buybacks) isn't guaranteed, but that isn't that much different than owning a farm, which can also fail to produce a profit (if costs exceed expenses).
- lettergram 6y agoPerhaps you missed "a house you live in (not rent)" I agree with the idea renting a home would be similar to a farm. The whole thing is you have to generate an income from the asset. Stocks are, as you mentioned, kind of similar - but IMO not precisely the same. Often companies have expenses that also inflate, so it's more similar to gold or holding something static. When you own the means of production it's a tad different. Personally, I'd consider stocks somewhere in-between. Better than gold, less good than production your own. However, owning a farm or means of production does come with more risk.
- gruez 6y ago>Perhaps you missed "a house you live in (not rent)" It's not giving you cash every month, but it's saving you from having to pay rent, which is effectively the same thing. This is what imputed rent is. >Stocks are, as you mentioned, kind of similar - but IMO not precisely the same. Often companies have expenses that also inflate, so it's more similar to gold or holding something static. and farms don't? You need to buy fuel, fertilizer/feed, equipment, all of which inflate. There's also the opportunity cost of your labor, which also inflates. There also exists a much simpler way to see the equivalence between the two: what's the difference between owning a farm, and owning a share in a corporation that operates a farm?
- imtringued 6y agoWhat you are missing is that a farm is an amazing hedge against hyperinflation because hyperinflation is generally what happens when there is a shortage of food and the government keeps issuing money that exceeds the production capacity of the nation, namely to import food from other nations. Since you are producing your own food you obviously get something to eat before anyone else and you only have to sell your surplus. The only problem with owning a farm as a hedge against hyperinflation is the government may be highly corrupt and repossess all farms and thus cause a food shortage that way. Something you won't own during a crisis may not be a good hedge after all.
- WalterBright 6y agoEven if the stock doesn't have a dividend, the stock rises to reflect when the company produces value.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoThe other inflating asset is the $500k real estate. Here in the midwest, 40-acre farms a few dozen miles away from cities are constantly being converted into 40-unit residential housing complexes that sell at $500k/unit. Zillow and comps in my neighborhood say that my 50-year-old suburban ranch, which I bought 5 years ago, is worth more than double what I paid for it. Buy the farm at $500k, sell it for $1M in a few years to another farmer or a developer, and you'd make double the profit of the cow farm itself. Or spend $200/square (which is itself insane) to build houses on it for a total of $24M and, if current trends continue, sell them all at $1M each for $16M profit. With that insane real estate market status, the cows and lumber at $60k/year are almost a moo point. It's like a cow's opinion, you know, it just doesn't matter. It's "moo". Not that the current real estate bubble isn't guaranteed not to pop. But there are a lot of powerful people and institutions which are highly incentivized to pretend it's not a bubble and make every effort to keep it from popping, so I think it's unlikely to do so.
- imtringued 6y agoThis isn't a bad gamble if don't mind running the farm if the bet doesn't pay off.
- imtringued 6y agoHow on earth can you not know why those things protect you from inflation? Precisely because they are productive investments that return money in the future and that future money is higher, precisely because of inflation. The mechanism that protects a stock and a farm from inflation is exactly the same which is why it's not a moot point, it's the entire reason why we have inflation as a policy goal. You're supposed to go out there, work and expand your business, hire people and make the economy productive again!