58 ms·
Literally every time you see a startup release a product that seems trivial it's because that's not the full story. You're judging without complete information.
by onion2k 6y ago
Literally every time you see a startup release a product that seems trivial it's because that's not the full story. You're judging without complete information. For example, the public face might be a simple Mac calendar widget, but that could be the gateway to calendar sharing, native office apps, meeting booking, event management, ticket sales, corporate flight sales etc.
Building an audience with a cheap tool that solves a tiny pain point for a lot of people is a great way to build a direct relationship with a market that you can then sell other services to.
I'm not saying that's the case here. Maybe their business is actually a widget. I'm saying that most businesses do far more than you can see from the outside.
- nvrspyx 6y agoWhen they started YC they were "a video lecture platform for professors"
- onion2k 6y agoThey pivoted. It happens. That doesn't tell you anything about what their plans are now.
- rvz 6y agoJust ask AstroPad and f.lux who both have been targets of being 'sherlocked'. I can only see that these guys are at risk of being sherlocked by Calendar.app, Google Calendar and Calendar.exe. Wonder what their answer to YC was when they were asked about that risk.
- the-dude 6y agoFor the curious : https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=sherlocked https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=sherlocked
- harperlee 6y agoThanks a lot! Could you paste it here? Work firewall blocks that site.
- cbsks 6y agosherlocked to have developed a product and just started shipping it, only to have Apple come along and provide exactly the same functionality in a system update. It happened to Karelia Software twice. Once with Sherlock and again with iWeb.
- SAI_Peregrinus 6y agosherlocked To have developed a product and just started shipping it, only to have Apple come along and provide exactly the same functionality in a system update. It happened to Karelia Software twice. Once with Sherlock and again with iWeb. I'll bet the Pro HDR folks groaned and got drunk after the Apple event yesterday where they showed the HDR functionality built in to the OS. They got Sherlocked! by franketh September 02, 2010
- no_wizard 6y agosherlocked: to have developed a product and just started shipping it, only to have Apple come along and provide exactly the same functionality in a system update. It happened to Karelia Software twice. Once with Sherlock and again with iWeb.
- onion2k 6y agoWonder what their answer to YC was when they were asked about that risk. "Apple buy hundreds of companies every year. Being bought by Apple is a potentially a valid exit strategy."
- mattnewton 6y agoMaybe, but Apple did not buy Sherlock.
- FireBeyond 6y agoMost companies (the majority, I'd wager) who were Sherlocked were _not_ bought by Apple. Most companies basically got a "sucks to be you", that they found out along with everyone else at an Apple launch event where Apple had, sometimes shamelessly and brazenly, cloned their product. Sometimes, to add insult to injury, Apple would then remove that company's product from App Stores as "duplicating OS functionality".
- onion2k 6y agoAllegedly Apple's strategy is often to make an offer to buy the company and acquihire some devs who understand the problem and have experience solving it, and if the answer is a no they implement the feature themselves. I have no idea if that's actually true, or if it happens a lot, but it could be the case that being "sherlocked" is what happens if you turn down an offer. If true, that would make being "sherlocked" irrelevant if the plan is to exit by being bought by Apple.
- ttul 6y agoI commented on this risk. The founder smartly replied that they have much broader plans than just calendars. Still, anything that lives in the menu bar and serves such a core purpose as notifications is at risk of being “Sherlocked”.
- notyourday 6y ago> Wonder what their answer to YC was when they were asked about that risk. if (yolo(money)) { pivot_me(money) } else { shutdown() }
- krapp 6y agomore like (if (yolo money) (pivot-me money) (shutdown))
- tim333 6y agoIndeed the founder says: >We’ve only solved a small part of a bigger problem. The SaaS platforms we use for work don't work well together. It shouldn’t take cycling through ten different apps and Chrome tabs to stay on top of everything. >We’re now looking to bring Slack and GitHub into a unified notification inbox in the menu bar. We want to better organize everything you use as we’ve done with Google Calendar.
- MattGaiser 6y agoIf they build a unified notification inbox, I will pay for that. I had one of those when I used a Blackberry and I miss it as I now have to check 10 sites periodically to stay on top of things.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoYeah, I worked at BB during that time when the Blackberry Hub on BB10 came out. Shit was awesome to see internally.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThat was excellent and I stuck with my Z30 for a long time because of it.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoI still have a special Z10 that I was allowed to keep after working there. It's a red Z10 running an unlocked bootloader which allows you to hold down volume up-volume down and boot into Android 5.0 environment. Sadly "Project Exodus" was considered inappropriate at the time just like the original Android Player on BB10 since it was considered inappropriate to think anything other than BB10 was the greatest thing since sliced bread. Edit: 2 years after I left, Blackberry devices became Android devices... so I guess I was ahead of the curve or something?
- 6y ago
- 2cb 6y agoExactly. Also, if you want to make money selling software to consumers, Apple's platform is the one to target. Mac and iOS users are the most likely by far to actually pay for software. It's far more difficult to sell an app for actual money to Android or Windows users. Again talking specifically about the consumer market here, not enterprise.
- nonplussed 6y agoThis was a marketing myth put out by Apple in the early days of the app store. It's not true.
- tootie 6y agoLo these many years, Twitter still seems like an utterly trivial application.
- spacemanmatt 6y agoyou aren't the customer
- NotPavlovsDog 6y agoI have to put this on my wall. I made this point to a "designer" in love with the trend of the full-splash intro video. They wanted to use it on a website targeting managers. Trying the demo on three middle-aged individuals, two did not have the habit of hitting page down or scrolling. So, two out of three did not find the "obvious" content of the website below the video. Who are the audience and what are their true needs? is what we have to concentrate on when we sell products. I am sitting in zoom sessions with individuals that complain about their "wireless" headphones failing / discharging. Yet they happily paid for them, hundreds of dollars. Consumers are magic. I suggested they use a wired headset. They will not spend 10 dollars to buy one. One should contemplate deeply why, if one wants to sell to people like this. Observe them in their natural habitat. They can't explain why. This is why having a digital product out in the market with paying customers is valuable in itself. You get to observe and measure, and pivot if you're lucky. The userbase is the resource, and the paying userbase is gold.
- tootie 6y agoI'm purely talking about it from the perspective of user value. Whether users are customers or products, what are they getting out of the platform that drives them to use it regularly? Or more generally, what are they getting out of it that they couldn't get on 100 other platforms? Or an RSS feed? At this point, the answer is just network effect, but that certainly wasn't the case when it was new.
- 411111111111111 6y agowhile its true that the base functionality itself is extremely easy to implement with any CRUD framework (spring/django/RoR/phoenix/whatever), the created app would not be able to scale to the degree twitter has been scaled at this point. vertical scaling only works to a degree, and horizontal scaling while keeping the data as close to real-time as possible is nontrivial.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- okprod 6y ago> Literally every time you see a startup release a product that seems trivial it's because that's not the full story. Sometimes it's also just a startup pivoting due to a misfire or system, e.g, regulatory, problems
- dagmx 6y agoI think the best example is when Dropbox was announced and how many people scoffed at the triviality of cloning data around.
- ekianjo 6y agoDoes not mean that the scoffing is wrong every time.
- grifball 6y agoIf there were an easy indicator of justified scoffing, investing would be a lot easier.
- yccs27 6y agoWell, is there some _specific_ reason to scoff now? I'm not saying that's the case here. Maybe their business is actually a widget. I'm saying that most businesses do far more than you can see from the outside.
- barbazoo 6y agoFor me that's still what it's best at and what it should focus on. "Paper", Signatures, Password, to me that feels like they're desperately trying to find something to not just be a reliable external hard drive for people. Oh and of course their number one ambition, trying to convince me to upgrade to whatever more expensive plan they have.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoDropbox could have carved out a niche for itself as a platform for backup and sharing of files. However, the amount of investment capital doesn't allow them to be just a successful medium sized enterprise.
- scubbo 6y ago> Dropbox could have carved out a niche for itself as a platform for backup and sharing of files Serious question - hasn't it? I know there are other players in the space, but it's absolutely the #1 solution I think of.
- brundolf 6y agoOn top of that: doing something that you could hack together 80% of the way over a weekend, but then providing careful attention to detail in terms of user experience and integrations, quality and responsive customer support, and a general intimate awareness of your customers' needs can make it into a valuable product. Many products could be dramatically amplified in their usefulness by way of a couple tiny UX tweaks, driven by understanding of users' problems. In fact this is a main factor in Apple's success, IMO.
- adkadskhj 6y agoYes, thank you. A handful of years back i realized every huge startup's new product was 90% empty air. Ie, startups would bite off more than they could chew - even huge startups. Doing one thing well is so much better to me than 100 things poorly. And there's still a ton of complexity and work to do the one thing well, usually. Be it integrations, sub features, whatever - i vastly prefer a full experience with a narrow scope than a "out the door" experience with a huge scope.
- brundolf 6y agoAnd especially today, when tech megacorps attempt to copy every successful product on any of their platforms, doubling-down on doing one thing extremely well is your best defense because that's what they struggle with
- achenatx 6y agothis is how you compete against walmart and possibly amazon.
- monkey_monkey 6y ago> Building an audience with a cheap tool Absolutely. It's a common startup tactic to release a product that costs more and does less than existing alternatives to get market share and brand awareness. This is just basic stuff. Marketing 101.
- vbezhenar 6y ago$10/month is not a cheap tool. I'm paying $90/year for Intellij Idea which is my main development tool. IMO that cost is extremely prohibitive for most users and it's definitely not a way to get plenty of people on board to monetize it later.
- api 6y agoIntelliJ IDEA is one of the best software values for the money I have.
- regularfry 6y agoIt is, however, a way to get a validated group of people who are price insensitive (compared to you, anyway) and willing to pay money for that specific sort of tool. Whether that's enough for a YC hail-mary to work is a them-problem.
- Grustaf 6y agoWhy though? People who are price insensitive enough to pay 120 bucks a year for a menu bar widget are not your target audience, they are a tiny tiny minority.
- regularfry 6y agoThey might be a minority. They might be a minority you're not in. So (I'm guessing) is the minority that buy genuine Louis Vuitton handbags. The question isn't the size of the market in total audience numbers, or the proportion of some arbitrary population they represent, it's the readiness with which they can be parted with a sizeable chunk of cash in aggregate. Proving that the total addressable wallet is sufficient to sustain a YC company is a) non-trivial, and b) their problem. If there's one thing I've learned, it's that there can be remarkably large markets in remarkably unexpected places, so while yes, this one looks like a totally conventional small-software-shop play, and the 75th percentile outcome across all YC companies is crater-shaped, I'm not going to second-guess whether they might have something.
- zffr 6y ago
- kllrnohj 6y ago> Building an audience with a cheap tool that solves a tiny pain point for a lot of people is a great way to build a direct relationship with a market that you can then sell other services to. A cheap tool to build an audience makes sense, absolutely, but this is very nearly the exact opposite of that. How many users is a $10/mo calendar widget only on MacOS and only with Google Calendar really going to attract? It's expensive, and the audience is a subset of a subset of a subset. Got to start somewhere, of course, but this is like the result of a weekend hackathon, not something that a significant audience is going to drop $120/year on.
- phsource 6y agoThis. From my YC experience, I know that starting with a niche is good advice and advice they likely would have gotten. Looking at the Launch HN [1], I think the question should instead be "has YC lost it's way when its latest company is founded by 4 University of Waterloo students?". When phrased that way, the answer seems obvious, given that YC started out funding current college students in Boston. Having gone through YC in W19 with Wanderlog (https://wanderlog.com https://wanderlog.com), I think one of its best parts is how it invests in founders who are outside the typical VC hobnob. I remember meeting folks who'd worked in utilities in Texas all their lives, multiple groups of university students taking a leave, and other groups to whom VCs would simply say "you need more traction" Like most early stage investors, they're not investing in an idea -- they're investing in founders! I do have to say that YC partners probably encouraged the founders to pivot (like we had been told), but the ultimate choice of what to pivot to is the founders'. So like another comment said, cut these 20-year old university students some slack! [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26425318 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26425318
- 908B64B197 6y ago> "has YC lost it's way when its latest company is founded by 4 University of Waterloo students?" It's interesting to see they are branching out to smaller, lesser known more regional schools. Pretty far from their debut in Harvard/Kendall Square.
- 2arrs2ells 6y agoWaterloo is a well-regarded engineering powerhouse & has been well represented in YC going back to my batch (s12 - BufferBox) if not earlier.
- akhilcacharya 6y agoI can’t tell if this is a joke but Waterloo is the Stanford of Canada and is on par with the top American CS undergrads
- 908B64B197 6y ago
- cratermoon 6y agoSkeptical me says it's for collecting data about the users. The data and the analytics would be the actual value. Not the users, though, only to the investors.
- rbranson 6y agoInstagram's initial value prop was an easy way to share your photos across Facebook, Twitter, etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- iujjkfjdkkdkf 6y agoI can see this going one of two ways: either nobody signs up, they get made fun of a bit, get the message and pivot, or the publicity they're generating gets the app in front of the niche they are targeting, they get users, feedback, and the ear of people who put this kind of value on the productivity boost they get. Either way, I don't see the harm in putting it in front of people now, and I see a big downside to either polishing it more, or pivoting without having tested it on people.
- maram 6y ago>most businesses do far more than you can see from the outside It’s enough that they made it into YC to conclude that there is a lot more going inside. They filled out an application and had to have many milestones hit before they were accepted... Regarding focusing on a niche it was a lesson I learned when I was filtering startups for investments I wrote about about my lesson before and how dumb I felt for passing on startups because they were too niche https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22507122 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22507122
- Judgmentality 6y ago> They filled out an application and had to have many milestones hit before they were accepted... Plenty of people get into YC with nothing more than an idea. Getting into YC is sort of like getting into Harvard. Yeah, lots of people there are impressive, but not all of them. YC doesn't have a perfect filter. FWIW I got into YC without anything remotely resembling a business, and I don't think I'm that impressive. My company failed almost immediately.
- andi999 6y agoI would claim it also doesn't want a perfect filter. Maybe the team is great and they expect the (future) pivot leading to success. Also failures are cheap for YC, they live on their successes.
- Judgmentality 6y agoSure, but YC has definitely diluted its brand over the years. I don't think most people hold it in the same regard as they did a decade ago. I certainly don't. I get why they do it. It's an easy way to make more money. But the average YC founder today is nothing like the average YC founder a decade ago. They will argue otherwise, but I disagree based on personal experience. And everybody knows YC was really started by pg (I am fully aware of the entire history), and he hasn't been actively involved for years.
- ineedasername 6y agoAnd there's no reason the Mac widget could just be their MVP as they work on versions for other platforms. It may be "Mac first" rather than "Mac only".
- tryitnow 6y agoYes, you're right. In fact the founders practically say as much in their Launch HN post. I'm assuming the reddit post is by someone who is just really unfamiliar with YC and modern tech entrepreneurship. Hopefully, their question was sincere and they'll receive sensible answers. As for the question of whether YC has lost its way - most institutions lose their way at some point, so it's a fair question, but I don't think it's fair to single out this particular company.
- tannedNerd 6y agoI actually posted this on reddit (mainly to get other viewpoints besides the HN echo chamber), and I’m not new to the tech entrepreneurship scene. I’ve launched 3 startups, two bootstrapped that are chugging along quite well and a third one VC funded that is doing just ok. This is less an attack on Superpowered as it is a critique of YC. I think the idea of a unified Notification Center is interesting but the space is quite simply too crowded. You have slack, plus all of the companies like station trying to solve the same problem with much more features and a much bigger moat. YC used to pick companies that were more or less going to be at least decently successful even if they had never encountered YC, while this one seems like it wouldn’t have been successful without YC. It seems like YC has fully switched to the shotgun model of fund everything and see what sticks instead of the boutique smaller cohorts of the past. Not that there is anything wrong with that, but that also comes with a reputation change as well.