6 ms·
And its back. Look, I think this whole GME thing is stupid: but following the price is also stupid. I guess if its your first bubble, this is exciting stuff, b
by dragontamer 6y ago
And its back.
Look, I think this whole GME thing is stupid: but following the price is also stupid. I guess if its your first bubble, this is exciting stuff, but these things come crashing down eventually.
Hertz is a better saga to follow, since that saga is almost done. I don't know if any news on GME has come out recently, but nothing is quite as final as bankruptcy court (in the case of Hertz).
If you look at the timescales at which stocks meme / move, its on the order of years. Decades even, in the case of Enron and literal scams like Madoff. GME isn't even a scam, its just the market doing its thing.
For Hertz, it entered meme status AFTER it started bankruptcy proceedings last year. Those proceedings are still not over yet. It just goes to show how long things take in the world of finance.
The daily ups and downs are largely noise. Try not to be distracted by them.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> GME isn't even a scam, its just the market doing its thing. Short-term scams do exist. Identifying and leveraging a potential squeeze situation is standard market behavior, but taking to twitter to rally the masses into a stock is really just a confidence trick. Pump and dump is a real thing.
- runarberg 6y agoThe categorization of scam is interesting in this context. Why isn’t gamestop considered a scam? Why is Enron? From the point of view of a worker which gets their profits diluted in dividends payed to shareholders, the very existence of a stock market very much looks like a scam. Another interesting aspect is various cryptocurrencies (or—as per recent discussion—NFTs). I guess whatever the establishment is uncomfortable with will be labelled as scam. Perhaps future will look at GameStop as a scam. But from my point of view, trading in stocks is always a scam.
- dragontamer 6y ago> From the point of view of a worker which gets their profits diluted in dividends payed to shareholders I hate Tesla, but their IPOs and SPOs are a great example of what the stock market offers, and why a dividend (or other reward) is necessary. Without raising $5 Billion from investors back in 2014, Tesla wouldn't have had the money to build their Nevada Gigafactory. ------ Banks offer loans, which depend on interest rates. Shareholders don't want money, they want a share of the future profits. As such, the "promise" you make to a shareholder is more flexible, longer-looking, a better deal for most people involved. If you can't make money this year, or next year, or 5 years from now... shareholders are forward looking enough to still give you money. As long as that share they received truly benefits 5, 10, 15, or 20 years from now. ---------- Owning a right to future profits and a vote for the board-of-directors is a powerful thing. Shareholders become one of the owners of the company, with all the rights associated with that. --------- So. Lets timetravel back to 2014. Tesla needs money. It wants public money: willing to give you a piece of ownership (aka: future dividends and a vote for the board-of-directors). It promises to use that money to build a Gigafactory in Nevada. Today: we now have a company, and set of shareholders, who BOTH benefit from the situation. That's the magic of the stockmarket. It turns out that the "promise of future profits + voting rights" is a powerful item to trade.
- runarberg 6y agoThis still doesn’t make things look less like a scam. An anecdote of where the scheme worked for some people in the past is a very common thing for a scammer to tell future victims in order to persuade them into the scam. Example: [Person A] was a single parent living paycheck to paycheck, then they started selling [pyramid product X] and now they’re sending their kids through collage on the profits alone. Shareholders not making money is akin to saying that pyramid scammers don’t make money, off course they do... Otherwise they wouldn’t be spending their time and energy doing this. Every dollar you earn by doing nothing is a dollar made by someone else they didn’t get.
- dragontamer 6y agoThere's no payoff for a pyramid scheme. They just pile money somewhere, without actually doing anything with it. A pyramid scheme is literally the "Wicked and Evil" 3rd servant from the parable of the talents. They waste the huge pile of money by burying it and not really making it work for their masters. The expectation of the Stock Market is to do something with the money. For Amazon, the IPO allowed them to buy servers. For Google, same thing: tons of computers cost tons of money. For Tesla, they bought a Nevada Factory. The money disappeared into a Factory, and then the Factory made money later (which is then used to increase the value of shares and make everyone who participated richer). ---------- This is allowed in part, because it works. It makes society stronger. It rewards risk-takers who would otherwise do nothing with their money. It provides thinkers with money and capital when they need it most. If the scheme doesn't work out, the investors lose, but they're still happy that they got to partake in the experiment. Stocks are the original "Kickstarter". And I argue that they're far more fair than kickstarter. Owning a vote for the board-of-directors + a share of the promised dividend is worth a hell of a lot more than stupid keychains.
- runarberg 6y ago> There's no payoff for a pyramid scheme. They just pile money somewhere, without actually doing anything with it. Agreed, the stock market is not a pyramid scheme. I only used pyramid scheme as an example for a scammer’s rhetoric. However it still looks like a scam to me (albeit not as bad of a scam as the average pyramid scheme is). Having worked for a company which increased in share prices exponentially while I worked there on minimum wage, I cannot agree with the statement that the shareholder/worker relationship made “everyone who participated richer”. The average worker certainly didn’t. The only people that got richer were the shareholders (and perhaps some contractors). I experienced this exponential growth as a scam. The value of my work was being extracted into rich people’s pockets. See the stock market might look to an outsider as an arrangement where everyone benefits, but to a worker it always looks like a scam. Especially when you consider an alternate arrangement where the shareholder returns control of the profits of the company back to the workers after they’ve made up the money they gave originally to the business plus some fees and interest. The very fact that the shareholders keep control even after they’ve made their fare share of the profits, multiple times over, is what makes this look like a scam in the eyes of the workers.
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago> From the point of view of a worker which gets their profits diluted in dividends payed to shareholders, the very existence of a stock market very much looks like a scam. Only if the worker doesn't understand that the initial sale of stock raised the money that let the company buy the tools that the worker uses to make the profits. Getting that money without paying dividends looks like a scam where the stock owners are the suckers.
- runarberg 6y agoTo me this looks like predatory lending. I.e. selling stocks in order to raise money to get means of production is for all intents and purposes the same as getting a loan which you are never allowed to pay back, and your lenders will continue to collect interests, tied to your profits, indefinitely. Still very much looks like a scam.
- joshuamorton 6y agoIts not a loan though. If you fail to make money from your venture, you don't owe the "lender" anything. So you remove the risk to you (you can't owe someone $1 million without any way to pay it). The tradeoff is that you sacrifice some of the upside.
- runarberg 6y agoThis still looks like a scam though. A predatory lender which never accepts paying down the capital, but assumes risks where some of their clients might not turn a profit and therefor is a net loss, will simply raise the interest (or—in the case of an investor—the share of the profits) from the profitable clients to counter the loss. This is exactly the behavior of shareholders, and to my eyes it still very much looks like a scam.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoThe shareholders don't set the amount of the dividends. That is, in your analogy, the lender doesn't get to raise the interest rate. That kind of blows up your analogy. But by all means, tell us again how it looks like a scam. Maybe we'll start to agree with you if you repeat it a couple more times.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 6y agoGME is... very much a bubble. But its not a scam because there's a nugget of truth here still. GME's board of directors is planning to transform the company from a mall-based retailer into an online distributor of games. This will require money, and... well... a high-stock price will allow GME to make a secondary offering to fund the development of a new webpage, that will become the cornerstone of this new online-distributor business. This isn't exactly a venture I'd put my money on. But hey, some people clearly are willing to play the game. (Whether they know what's going on is another question) -------- Just because there's a bunch of dumbasses throwing money at this doesn't necessarily mean its a scam. Don't get me wrong, I think they're all wasting their money (so I'm going to stay away from it). But you know what? If it works out for them, good for them! I honestly am rooting for them to be successful. I mean, really, think about the chances here. They look low, but are they as low as say... Star Citizen actually getting released? From a video-game perspective, the long-shot chance of Gamestop becoming an online powerhouse is probably more likely than Star Citizen ever coming out (or insert any other dumb kickstarter idea in here)
- z3ncyberpunk 6y agoEven if it is a scam, the public is entirely justified in seeing it through, considered how the so-called Wall Street elites that you pointed out do it on the daily and space zero repercussions ever. Please stop worshiping billionaires
- smnrchrds 6y agoI'm certain the GME bubble will burst at some point. I am almost as certain that when this inevitably happens, those who lost their money will blame hedge funds, short sellers, Wall street, elites, the system, etc. instead of looking into the mirror.
- dragontamer 6y agoEnron and Madoff are examples of what "some time" means. Yeah, all bubbles / ponzi schemes run out of money eventually. But 17 years (Madoff) is longer than most people's radar. If you decide to go short, you gotta be right not only in the direction of the stock, but also in the timing of it. Timing is everything. Unfortunately, timing is also the most random.
- gruez 6y agoenron/madoff isn't really comparable because there's a mastermind behind both of them. GME? not so much.
- sandworm101 6y agoJust because you cannot see the mastermind doesn't mean that there isn't someone pulling strings. And the Madoff scam wasn't a single person. There were lots of naïve participants/benefiters enjoying the profits of that scam. In that sense it is a parallel to gamestop: A small cadre of people influencing things, and lots of little people participating in what they should reasonably understand to be a pyramid. The situation has Fyre written all over it..
- svachalek 6y agoA certain unprintable Redditor with initials DFV?
- filoleg 6y agoAh yeah, the guy who moved the entire stock market and beat the hedge funds with only $50k invested, despite GME stock trading volumes in billions of dollars per day. /s If someone seriously thinks that DFV (or the entirety of WSB, for that matter) would even physically be able to notably move a ticker such as GME, then I don't have much to say to them, because this is completely inane. With some penny stocks that have almost no trading volume? Sure, technically possible. But with something like GME, it is quite not that simple. For a solid frame of reference, the entire holdings of GME that DFV had after the gigantic pump were about $50mil, one of the largest retail traders by far. Institutional traders? They did individual GME trades in volumes of $700mil+ each on a daily basis. Not $700mil+ for all institutional investors combined, but individually. Cannot be bothered to find a citation for it now, but iirc institutional investors also held about 75-80% of all outstanding GME shares throughout the entire pump.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoIt's just frustrating to see otherwise reasonable people start tossing out crazy conspiracy theories about the Day of the Short Squeeze when GME will go to infinity and we'll take all the hedge funds' money. I can't even escape from it by staying off social media, because a quarter of my friends are in on it. I'm a lot less troubled than I was the first time around because there doesn't seem to be any severe systemic risk, but I still really wish I could figure out how to convince people to knock it off.
- dragontamer 6y agoFor most people, this is a gambling thing. For them, its not much different than spending $100 or $500 on blackjack and slots. Its entertainment to them. Sure, some of us are trying to do work (aka: properly price things, determine which companies deserve our money, etc. etc.), and these events are distracting... But if its just a bubble, I don't think there's much harm in letting it run its course. Let them gamble, as long as no sharks swim by to illegally try to extract money from their fun. Of course, if someone in particular you know has a gambling problem (and might lose their life savings), that's a different story.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoYeah, I agree with all of that - it doesn't seem like there's any huge number of people putting their life savings into it. I'm just vaguely annoyed by gambling in general and don't like when I have to hear about it all the time.
- capableweb 6y agoMaybe rather than seeing GME as a crazy event that even made your "reasonable" friends non-reasonable, could it be that you thought they were more reasonable than they actually were?
- runarberg 6y ago> this whole GME thing is stupid: but following the price is also stupid. I will top that by stating: “Nothing that happens in the stock market is stupider then the fact that the stock market exists.”
- twirlock 6y agoHertz memestock tulip le wtf i hate Reddit now Elon Musk is a snakeoil salesman.
- zamalek 6y ago> I guess if its your first bubble The bubble is/was at both ends. I honestly have to agree that it was undervalued at the time that the original GME posts were made, but it's also very overvalued right now. GameStop has limited immunity from the problem other brick-and-mortars are facing: console games purchased through digital content delivery platforms cannot be transferred to friends, where-as games that are purchased at GameStop typically can be. There's also hardware to be purchased and other goodies. GameStop is not intrinsically doomed to failure, if they proactively differentiate from digital content delivery. That being said, it's highly doubtful that GameStop will outpace digital content delivery platforms (like Steam/PSN/XBox Live/etc.), unless they build their own. In my opinion, they do potentially have a sustainable 8-9 figure market cap. This bubble is going to pop, just as much as the squeeze had to happen.
- capableweb 6y agoGameStop is not just competing with digital content and delivery, they are also competing against established all-in-one stores like Carrefour and Fnac, that typically carries everything GameStop (currently) carries plus more. If they can make themselves different enough to give people a reason to buy their PS5 at GameStop instead of at Carrefour, remains to be seen.
- rualca 6y ago> I guess if its your first bubble, this is exciting stuff, but these things come crashing down eventually. Portraying gamespot's case as a bubble is either ignorant or disingenuous. It's a game of chickens between hedge funds using glaringly obvious market manipulation to drive their shorts and retail investors who spotted how the hedge fund's overplayed their hand. > Hertz is a better saga (...) Hertz has zero to do or in common with gamespot's saga. Hedge funds cornered themselves by shorting over 100% of gamespot's stock, and thus forcing themselves to buy over 100% of gamespot's stock back for whatever the market will be asking to be able to deliver on their contracts. Hertz was a company already in bankruptcy.
- Triv888 6y agoThat whole GME thing is not stupid... institutions are holding 106% of GME stocks... not sure how much non-institutions are holding. What is stupid is what the government is allowing institutions to do. > % Held by Institutions 106.22 https://invest.ameritrade.com/grid/p/site#r=jPage/https://research.ameritrade.com/grid/wwws/research/stocks/summary?c_name=invest_VENDOR&symbol=GME https://invest.ameritrade.com/grid/p/site#r=jPage/https://re...
- aeternum 6y agoHolding 106% can be perfectly rational, it happens just because shorts create a loan. Suppose we have a company and an institution has analyzed the books and knows is worth $10/share, shares are currently trading at $5. Suppose this is an unusually small company and there are only 100 shares outstanding total. Institution buys them all up since it's such a good deal. Along comes Citadel who decides the company is going bankrupt and decides to sell the company short. Borrows 50 shares from the institution's broker and puts them up on the market. Now the institution sees that 50 more shares are available again at $5. Still the institution knows they are worth $10/share.. it's completely rational to purchase those shares and increase the holding to 150 shares even if the official shares outstanding is only 100 shares. Institution can sell all 150 for $10 a share assuming they are eventually right about the validation and Citadel will be the one that needs to make up the difference.
- jfengel 6y agoThe noise is precisely why people are distracted. A lot of people would love to get rich by buying low and selling high within that noise. The more noise there is, the more opportunities there are. That's gambling, not investing, but people love gambling. As with gambling, the house always wins, but some people come out ahead anyway. Like lottery winners, that makes people dream. In this case there may even have been some house disadvantage: too much pessimism by investors not only made opportunities for legitimate investing wins, but the quirks of the rules left them open to having to materialize losses. Any such advantage to investors is long since gone, but it amplifies the lotto excitement.
- zenbane 6y agohttps://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/gamestop-stock-price-retail-trading-reddit-wallstreetbets-net-purchases-2021-3-1030170484 https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/gamestop-sto... First time might have been retail traders but this is all about big whales. Shorts are pinned - all shorts must cover. Writing this off as a retail pump and dump is ignorance.