11 ms·
What happens when investment firms acquire trailer parks
- vintagemodel 6y agoA way to resist powerful forces like investment firms seems to be to found cooperatives: https://www.mutualinterest.coop/2021/02/a-boom-in-trailer-parks-converting-into-community-owned-cooperatives https://www.mutualinterest.coop/2021/02/a-boom-in-trailer-pa...
- stormqloud 6y agoWho knew "own nothing and be happy" involved crushing rental fees to wall street.
- zionic 6y agoThey said you will own nothing, not them. They also said "and you will be happy", which was an order.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoAt some point revolution will probably become inevitable.
- alacombe 6y agoDon't worry, the same rulers with ensure the People remains unarmed.
- PeterisP 6y agoIf the poor get their basic needs and entertainment (bread and circuses, as the Romans said) then that's generally sufficient to prevent revolutions. And western societies in general are so wealthy that people can stay (or become) relatively very poor while still getting enough so that they won't really risk their lives in a revolt. They'll complain and protest, sure, but it takes a literal threat to their lives because of hunger or violence to spark a proper revolt. The bottom decile of americans are nowhere near as poor as the poverty that sparked, for example, the Arab Spring revolutions, and very likely (and hopefully) never will be.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoReady Player One and the dystopian future of trailers that are packed on top of each other reaching up like sky scrapers.
- frongpik 6y agoThe dystopian future is towers of sleep boxes that the poor rent to sleep 8 hours a day (so 3 persons per day). Something in the Matrix style. The sleep boxes are poorly built, but thanks to the laws limiting the supply, the workers have to pay thru the nose to rent those boxes. These towers are built on compact lots of land and around it there are 1 sq mi lots with proper houses for the rich 0.01%. This is essentially the exponential growth turning inwards.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoRemember an episode of an sci-fi anthology show of a dome city on Earth where resources are limited. There is a sleep pod that is shared by two people. One person works during the day while the other person is put into some sort of hibernation and they swap places at midnight.
- kfarr 6y agoI'm going to guess on the record before reading article: debt based financing of the sale, PE firm steadily increases rent and lowers investment into facilities, bankruptcy and evictions ensue
- quickthrowman 6y agoIt’s the standard PE playbook, and you’re correct. In this case, they wait for the tenant to default on the ground rent, then seize the mobile home and resell/re-rent it. Repeat ad infinitum. The manufactured home itself depreciates in value like a car or RV, so even if you don’t get fucked by your landlord, you get fucked on depreciation. At least in an apartment you don’t pay for maintenance or depreciation!
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago> then seize the mobile home and resell/re-rent it. Repeat ad infinitum. That's basically the Buy Here Pay Here(TM) car lot business model.
- jjoonathan 6y agoAnd remember, kids, this creates value, because the market weights value according to wealth.
- mywittyname 6y agoYou should read the article, it's very well done. I mean, yeah, family-owned trailer parks have been "under-utilized" for decades, and you're pretty spot on in what is involved in properly "utilizing" them. However, there's a human side to it as well. Plus, there's a plot twist where Republicans introduce bills in a state to enhance tenants' rights.
- dayofthedaleks 6y agoNew Yorker paywall kicks in after a few views: https://archive.is/NJbuh https://archive.is/NJbuh
- senkora 6y agoFor those who like John Oliver’s presentation style, he has also covered this topic in video form: https://youtu.be/jCC8fPQOaxU https://youtu.be/jCC8fPQOaxU
- 8fGTBjZxBcHq 6y agoI'm not done and it's a pretty grim read but I definitely got a smile from this about halfway through. 'A video of the speech went viral, prompting an Australian writer, Chloe Angyal, to publish a piece for the Web site Feministing titled “Marry Me, Zach Wahls.” In 2013, Angyal and Wahls met in New York; they are now engaged.'
- black_puppydog 6y ago> The financial industry[...] is undermining one of the country’s largest sources of affordable housing. 1. Yeah, I made an opinionated omission there. Sue me :D 2. That last part (the country’s largest sources of affordable housing) is even more damning than the rest. :( In a country that big, and that rich, with a frontier ethos like that, how the f*k does anyone think this is acceptable?
- FooHentai 6y agoAcceptable that trailer parks are the country's most affordable housing, or that it's being allowed to be squeezed for profit?
- black_puppydog 6y agoFair question IMO. Of course trailer parks are (hopefully) always among the most affordable housing options. However, living in one should be a choice of the individual, and the fact that there is a notable population in these places tells me that these are not exactly free choices à la "I shall live frugally" but rather a systemic problem. So: "acceptable that trailer parks are more than a mere curiosity of vanishing proportion in the story of housing in the US in 2021."
- CalRobert 6y agoBuilding a basic house is pretty simple. Larry Haun put out a great book with Habitat for Humanity to do it for about $40,000, and irishvernacular.com/ outlines how to do it for €25,000. But we induce scarcity in the housing market because if everyone had a comfortable, decent home, they might not work so hard, would they? Imagine how much less value would be created for assetholders, how much less stuff we would make, if families felt free to survive on one income.
- quickthrowman 6y ago> Building a basic house is pretty simple. Larry Haun put out a great book with Habitat for Humanity to do it for about $40,000 Sure, if you have free labor. I’d guess 99%+ of houses were built by a paid crew, so uh, it does not cost just 40k for a house. It costs $200/sq ft to build a house (in a midsize metro area of 3 million), without buying land.
- hprotagonist 6y agoPredition: Nothing good. Resident-Owned Communities seem by far to be the best answer here, and I encourage folks to read up on it and see what you can do to help if you're so inclined: https://rocusa.org/ https://rocusa.org/ is one such nonprofit, but there are several.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoHow can individuals compete against institutional money? Housing prices are skyrocketing in my area and there are stories on the news about investment firms buying up homes and putting them up for rent. What's to stop these well financed institutions from buying up more and more real estate and forcing more people into renting?
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoThey can't. Nothing and they are already are doing it. Blackrock raised billions during COVID on the idea that once the evictions kick off, lots of homeowners will lose their homes and those tenants with black marks will have to pay more and more to rent. Every person abusing the COVID moratorium just to screw over the "landlord" who owns one property is just one more nail in the US clusterfuck coffin. Edit: it's Blackstone.
- TrackerFF 6y agoNot just in the US. Here in Norway, businesses are entitled to financial aid if their income has been affected by COVID. Meanwhile, the real-estate market is white hot at he moment, while the rental market is slow/stagnating. People with money want to purchase, while poor people can't afford to rent. Turns out, rental companies and investors have speculated that if they just keep their rental units vacant, instead of lowering rent and attracting new tenants, they can apply for financial aid. win/win for them - they can sit on appreciating assets, without having to deal with wear/tear, administration, etc. on their units. All while getting bailed out by the gov. And once small landlords/owners can't cover their costs due to broke tenants going for months/years without being able to pay their rent, no doubt there are investors and REPE firms lined up to buy those units. Just another transformation of wealth.
- evancox100 6y agoYou must be talking about Blackstone, the private equity/LBO group, not BlackRock, the ETF provider. I don't think there is a Mobile Home Index ETF, not yet at least. I think there is a lot of hate directed to BlackRock, which is really meant to be directed at Blackstone. BlackRock is an absolutely huge financial company, to be sure, but is soley in the business of ETFs and asset management, which aren't exactly abusive or extractive. And no it doesn't help that the names are so ridiculously similar. Edit: just learned that BlackRock started as an asset management arm within Blackstone, and the similarity was intentional. I think the operations have diverged enough since then that there's a worthwhile distinction between the two.
- Shacklz 6y agoThe US are such a weird country... on one hand, Silicon valley et al, producing the coolest tech & the shiniest toys, and on the other hand... people who can only afford to live in trailer parks, even with a full time job. It never ceases to amaze & depress me simultaneously.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoIt's the same reason those same Silicon Valley companies hire security guard companies at $15/hr and have the security guards take the food to the dumpster, and lock it. That security guy probably could use that food more than the dumpster.
- dylan604 6y agoAt $15/hour, that security guard is probably close to double the income people living in trailer parks earn.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoAdjusted for cost of living, that security guard is poorer than the person living in a trailer park or very close to it. There's been a large rise in people living in campers in California due to high rents.
- dylan604 6y agoAs we all know, how things are in CA does not evenly apply to the other 49.
- DaedPsyker 6y agoBut the security guard lives in SF, which increases his living costs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- phkahler 6y agoHousing can not be both affordable AND an investment. Interest rates need to rise, and soon.
- FooHentai 6y agoI'm not sure you're entirely correct. A lot of people plan on downsizing their housing when they reach retirement age - Move somewhere smaller because you don't need to accommodate the kids any more, and further out of an urban center because you don't need to commute any more. This is a net positive - It frees up more valuable real estate in urban centers for working-age citizens to utilize, and extracts capital from the property for retirement-age citizens to finance their retirement. In this way, housing has been a stable and reliable investment for many for some time, and in a way that's beneficial to society as a whole. Quite different to what we're seeing here, an evolving dynamic which also threatens this model and puts people's retirement prospects in peril.
- clairity 6y agothat's a false dichotomy. you can support freeing up urban real estate and retirees downsizing without assuming a house is an investment. for instance, if the economic system acted to stabilize home values neutrally rather than explicitly promoting increasing valuations (through interest rates, and other mechanisms), you could still have those positive dynamics without the negative externalities.
- FooHentai 6y agoYou're right. Ops position was that housing should not be seen as any kind of investment. My point was that, for retirees, housing is a valid investment vehicle and that dynamic is valuable to society as a whole. But on reflection, I'm thinking in the wrong terms here. I could better view this as housing being an important store of value for retirees, rather than an investment generating financial return for them.
- clairity 6y ago
- chad_strategic 6y agoI didn't read the article because I already saw the movie by John Oliver. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCC8fPQOaxU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCC8fPQOaxU
- mywittyname 6y agoI spent my early years living in a trailer park, and to be honest, it wasn't bad at all (at least back then). We knew most of our neighbors and most people looked out for each other (like helping out people suffering from food insecurity). That place had some of the most generous people I'd ever met. I have pretty fond memories of living there. I got my first bike from a really, really nice single mom who noticed that I didn't have one. I mean, it was a crappy garage sale find that was rusted and had weird 1970s-stylee handle bars, but she got it specifically for me.
- celticninja 6y agoWould you live there by choice?
- mywittyname 6y agoThe neighborhood? Yeah, probably. In a trailer? No, they aren't very well built. I actually live in a relatively low-income area now. I just like the general "realness" of working class people and don't much care if people look down at me when I tell them where I live.
- dtwest 6y agoHaving spent a decent amount of time in one of these myself, I much prefer the term "trailer park" to "mobile-home community". The article uses the term interchangeably, but they explain this important detail themselves: "The homes in the park are not as portable as its name implies; they’ve been placed on foundations, and their hitches have been removed." In my experience, in older parks especially, there is no way to economically move the trailer. Which means you don't really own a "mobile home", you own a slot in the park with a worthless trailer on it. This allows the park to have the negotiating power. I just wanted to point out this key detail to people who may not be aware of the situation.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mc32 6y agoWhat people tell me is that it stops being mobile after you “park” it. So basically mobile from the dealer lot to the park and not so much after that.
- pram 6y agoThe term I always heard is “manufactured home” which makes more sense. I grew up in a double wide. Once it’s set up you quite obviously can’t move it again without wrecking everything lol
- milkytron 6y agoI've heard that term as well, and I suppose it's useful to have a different term for that type of home vs one that is built on its foundation from the start. But the term manufactured home seems odd to me, aren't nearly all new homes nowadays "manufactured"?
- bityard 6y ago"Manufactured" means built in a factory and can be transported on a semi. As opposed to most buildings (in the U.S. at least) which are built on-site by a contractor.
- SavantIdiot 6y ago"In the past decade, as income inequality has risen, sophisticated investors have turned to mobile-home parks as a growing market. They see the parks as reliable sources of passive income—assets that generate steady returns and require little effort to maintain." Man, this is just... gross. I realize mortgage bond trading has been a ~$100 trillion dollar windfall since the mighty 80's under Volker (and Liars Poker), but the "little effort to maintain" just cries foul.
- alacombe 6y ago"little effort to maintain" really means foot the bill to the renters...
- dhbradshaw 6y agoAfter a cold snap recently I went out to visit an older couple in a trailer who had had their plumbing burst due to freezing. The trailer was in really rough shape. They were huddling under blankets because heating and insulation were inadequate. And now they had no water. Two things make me angry about the trailer park situation. 1. people living there who only get poorer from it. They own the portion of the home that decreases in value and rent the part that appreciates. If you're rich, sure. You can afford to own a depreciating asset and forgo the appreciation. But they're poor. 2. By having the lot renter own the trailer, they avoid many of the laws that protect renters with basic livability requirements. And yet those people are still paying rent alongside having to pay maintenance costs for their homes. In the end at least in my area of the country it's much less expensive to buy a modest home.
- dfsegoat 6y agoAnd then when you have a natural disaster strike, you aren't necessarily guaranteed access to your home, even after disaster declarations are lifted: https://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/news/fire-survivors-from-santa-rosas-journeys-end-feel-like-weve-been-abando/?gallery=7CDEE642-79E8-4433-B1A7-861C2DE53236 https://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/news/fire-survivors-fr...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bityard 6y agoWhere I live, there are many levels of quality when it comes to "trailer parks". I know of a few that are essentially slums: very low-income residents, crowded, dirty, noisy, and packed with trailers from the 50s and 60s. I don't know who would _choose_ to live in these places. Maybe it's a case of poor people being poor because they make poor choices. Or simply aren't aware that there are better options. On the other end of the spectrum, there are communities with HOA rules, well-kept common areas, a clubhouse, etc. My mom lives in one of these. Honestly, it's not a bad place to live. I could totally live there if needed to. I tried to talk her out of buying it based on the economics alone ($400/mo lot rent plus around $60k for the house) but she went ahead with it anyway. It doesn't make financial sense to me, but maybe she sees something about the situation that I don't.
- CivBase 6y agoI recently bought my first home in Iowa. I was only a couple years into my career and wanted to start with something small which would allow me to build up equity so I could eventually trade up for something I'd want to keep long term. At first, I considered a few mobile homes, but I soon learned to ignore them. The houses themselves were cheap, but the association fees were outrageous. I ended up getting a town home instead, which was valued much higher but the monthly payments ended up being comparable thanks to the much lower association fees. I have more property rights, more of that money goes into equity, I get a much bigger and nicer home, and I don't have to worry as much about tornadoes, derechos, and other nasty Iowan weather so much. With the prevalence of town homes and cheap housing here, I don't know how trailer parks keep their residents.
- ctdonath 6y agoTable Mound Mobile Home Park https://goo.gl/maps/8h7fxu7WjWsYzTSj9 https://goo.gl/maps/8h7fxu7WjWsYzTSj9 The Park is about 90 acres. Article claims about 400 homes on site. Much laments the living conditions and abusive corporate ownership. Why do the concerned not facilitate affordable ownership, instead leaving it up to investment firms to provide the service (badly)? Under 2 miles away is a >150 acre parcel available for $6,000,000. Divided by 600, that’s $10,000 per quarter-acre; paid $100/mo, rent-to-own style, it’s bought outright in 10 years (or earlier as cash flow allows). Seems a very solvable problem for a budding social-minded entrepreneur.
- alacombe 6y agoIf it does not include a 10-year mastermind bait-and-switch business plan, I doubt any VC/bank will put a dime toward it.
- ctdonath 6y agoChallenge Progressives to put their money where their ideals are: crowdsource it. Buy the subdivided lots and give them to prospective residents. Or some form of creative financing. Change the game; 1/4 acre lots for $10,000 are just sitting there waiting for someone to make 600 happen all at once. It’s doable. Those pining for better treatment and cheaper options should step up and make it happen.
- bobyrne 6y agoYou forget subdivision regulations which will require roads, curbs, a drainage system (lines, catch basins, retention ponds). You'll need an engineer. You may need a sewer system or, if you install septic tanks, you'll have to go to half-acre lots. You'll have to file a plat in the Recorder's Office, so you can sell lots. You can't do that without planning commission approval.You'll need a surveyor. Whether the roads are public or private, they still require the same public standards, because fire trucks have to drive on them and, because the county may have to acquire them to maintain so they'll want them to meet a certain standard. All of these costs have to be paid upfront. There's more but you soon begin to realize that you can't get 600 lots on 150 acres nor will your costs be limited to $6MM.
- peter_d_sherman 6y ago>"The Mobile Home University Web site states, “Mobile home parks are the hottest sector of real estate right now, due to the endless decline in the U.S. economy.” The site points out that thousands of baby boomers are retiring each day, and that they will receive around fourteen thousand dollars a year in Social Security income: “Mobile home parks are the only segment of real estate that grows stronger as the economy weakens.”" PDS: A potential (or actual): inverse-correlation... How interesting!
- amelius 6y agoDoes anything good ever happen when investment firms acquire anything?
- danans 6y agoSome companies are trying to move manufactured homes from the lowest quality rung into housing with better quality/design, like: https://www.palmcanyonmobileclub.com https://www.palmcanyonmobileclub.com Granted, these are marketed toward retirees, which is why they are in Palm Springs, but it nonetheless shows that with a little investment in design and materials (which doesn't have to be very expensive), the format of manufactured homes can be separated from their historical associations with low quality.
- mchusma 6y agoI'm sure different trailer park owners are a mixed bag, some good some bad. The real issue is government limitations on the supply of housing (height, min parking, setbacks, etc). Housing could be high quality and relatively cheap. From first principles, a 3 bed 2 bath apartment could easily be <$500/mo in any expanded metro area of the US, if you were allowed to build. Allowing more competition for low cost housing would solve almost all of the systemic issues in this article. But as other posters have mentioned, the US promotes the opposite - home ownership as a wealth building tool. Housing is a cost, we should work to reduce it.
- dave333 6y agoSome parks are resident owned meaning they own the land in common so have control of their future. Some cities have rent control e.g. San Jose where it's about 3% max increase per year. The space rent is roughly the same as real estate taxes for regular homes and the price per sq ft is about a quarter. For seniors on limited fixed income a rent controlled mobile home park makes a lot more sense than paying rent or moving into the boonies. Some parks are horror stories e.g. the one next to Natural Bridges State Park in Santa Cruz where the space rents went through the roof (like $5k/month) when a billionaire investor (one of John Oliver's "assholes") bought it. Admittedly they are on the ocean.
- crowf 6y agounrelated, but why is the URL 2021/03/15 . Has this article not been released yet?