3 ms·
I've seen this take a few times and I don't really buy it. How exactly is school setup in a way that's more suitable for women compared to men? Everything you'
by endisneigh 6y ago
I've seen this take a few times and I don't really buy it. How exactly is school setup in a way that's more suitable for women compared to men?
Everything you've stated (following rules and instructions, etc.) also applies in the workplace, so if you were correct you would the same sort of discrepancy in the workforce.
- visarga 6y agoThe difference in teaching style is putting accent on cooperation vs competition.
- xhkkffbf 6y ago* Lots of sitting still. My local school canceled recess several years ago to make sure the kids had more studying time. * Fine motor skills like good handwriting are rewarded, often explicitly as part of the grade. * Verbal skills are often explicitly rewarded, even if they don't have much to do with a subject. My local school asks students to write and make a presentation about their math answer. It doesn't matter if they get the right answer as long as the presentation is professional and impressive.
- aviraldg 6y agoThe rules and grading are different. In school, the rules that students are rewarded for following are "softer" and harder to justify directly. eg. You must submit a project with a cover with beautifully handwritten title of this specific size, or you lose marks (This is real guidance that was provided for my school and college projects.) At work, while these kind of rules exist, it's typically okay to break them, and performance is mostly rated on actual impact, not pointless rule-following.
- endisneigh 6y agoNone of this explains why women are capable of following these rules and men are not. Are you saying men are biologically predisposed to not follow such simple rules?
- aviraldg 6y agoI was answering your question about why this difference exists. I don't know about the reason, but if I had to guess I'd say it's not biology, but culture/upbringing. I think girls are culturally expected to follow rules, and boys encouraged to break them.
- AussieWog93 6y agoI'd suspect it's biological, since boys in (almost?) all human societies are more prone to challenging authority. It's the same story in elephants, chimps and wolves too. I wouldn't be surprised if it's the case in all species of social mammals.
- imtringued 6y agoNo, it sounds like female teachers make rules that are easy for female students to follow. Meanwhile some boys simply don't like the rules and thus don't follow them.
- endisneigh 6y agoYes I've seen this comment many, many times. Where's the proof? Women crush men in college (see link below) yet most professors are men. People are just spouting unsupported nonsense. Heck my link understates the difference as it is old. https://theop.princeton.edu/reports/wp/ANNALS_Conger,Long_Manuscript%20(Feb%2009).pdf https://theop.princeton.edu/reports/wp/ANNALS_Conger,Long_Ma...
- BlargMcLarg 6y agoThere is at least the "women are wonderful" effect covering both why female as well as male teachers may favor girls over boys, including subjective grading methods. That seems enough of a point to counter this being "unsupported nonsense". Additionally, pointing out most professors are men does not counter the argument. Merely the transition of going from a highly cooperation- and rule-following-favored environment to an extremely competitive environment should give some indication as to how multifaceted this problem can truly be.
- hitpointdrew 6y ago>At work, while these kind of rules exist, it's typically okay to break them, and performance is mostly rated on actual impact, not pointless rule-following. Exactly this. Doing something simply because "it's a rule" and doing something where you see actual impact/results is world of a difference.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe word for the former is "authoritarian." Relationships are defined by power imbalances, hierarchy, and superficial displays of conformity, not by outcomes.
- ameister14 6y ago>Everything you've stated (following rules and instructions, etc.) also applies in the workplace, so if you were correct you would the same sort of discrepancy in the workforce. That might be true if you ignored development, but we're talking about children here. A 12 year old boy is not the same as a 23 year old man.
- endisneigh 6y agothis would be true, but these patterns still exist in college. https://theop.princeton.edu/reports/wp/ANNALS_Conger,Long_Manuscript%20(Feb%2009).pdf https://theop.princeton.edu/reports/wp/ANNALS_Conger,Long_Ma...
- 1_player 6y agoPerhaps, presuming OP's assumption that women have an easier time to follow the rules and there are more women in education than men is correct, that school has a lot of rules and not enough freedom. I have no real opinion on it, just that my memory of school was a really strict place compared to real life and work. There are plenty of plan B options, alternatives, ways to think outside the box in real life, but not in school. You could only use your brain on the task but not to get out of the task or complete it in a different way than your teacher had intended you to. As if I had left a traumatic situation, I vividly remember enjoying a lot finally having time for myself after work the first few years after I dropped out of high school. I had to put real effort 8 hours a day, then nothing else was expected of me.
- hc-taway 6y ago> As if I had left a traumatic situation, I vividly remember enjoying a lot finally having time for myself after work the first few years after I dropped out of high school. I had to put real effort 8 hours a day, then nothing else was expected of me. Same. I slacked a lot in high school (in hindsight, I'd have gone actually-nuts otherwise) but it was still by far the hardest consistent work I've ever done, largely due to the sheer amount of time it took and the constant, overlapping, usually-very-short ("due tomorrow") deadlines. College was a vacation. Work is easy. High school did little to prepare me for "how the real world works" (always the excuse for deadlines and requirements and such in school) but did harm me psychologically in ways that took more than a decade to get over—and I wasn't even bullied or anything like that, it was mostly just the strict schedule, extreme lack of freedom (asking to go to the bathroom, stuff like that), and crazy workload.
- dec0dedab0de 6y agoEverything you've stated (following rules and instructions, etc.) also applies in the workplace, so if you were correct you would the same sort of discrepancy in the workforce. In my working life every time I brazenly break the rules and ignore instructions I end up getting a raise, or promotion. This is across 5 or 6 jobs stretched out over 23 years in small businesses, and fortune 100 companies. This is because I always back it up with results In school, any deviation, regardless of intention or outcome, was perceived by my teachers as being disrepectful to their authority, and was quickly punished. To be fair, I went to catholic school in the 80s/early 90s, so following rules was probably a bigger emphasis than most people's experiences.
- endisneigh 6y agoYour anecdote is interesting, but without knowing how often women also break the same rules and ignore the same instructions and get results it's pretty meaningless. I mean, good for you I guess?
- xiphias2 6y agoWomen started breaking the rules as well now, as that’s what’s coming from the media. The problem is of course when somebody does it without providing results / breaking rules that they shouldn’t (some of the firings from Google happened because of this). I expect this to normalize though.
- theropost 6y agoI agree totally - if you brazenly break the rules, you tend to get punished.. unless you back it up with real results. Disrupters tend to be the innovators in society. School does not value disrupters in the same way as a business might. In a school setting, someone who listens, follows the rules, and does not challenge the structure of the institution is highly likely to receive excellent grades. In a business setting, this person may be an employee who contributes to the team by doing their job, and doing it accurately and consistently. A disrupter may work in the same job, and challenge the way things are done - they may fail in doing so, and be repremanded or fired, or they may succeed in their disruption, and allow for a change in the process or job, resulting in greater efficiency. This is the trade off in my humble opinion.