3 ms·
I almost always at least skim an article before diving into the comments. Many times I will read the whole thing, especially if it is short, as this one is. I d
by mitchdoogle 6y ago
I almost always at least skim an article before diving into the comments. Many times I will read the whole thing, especially if it is short, as this one is. I do believe that most probably don't do that. It's often possible to tell which commenters have read it and which haven't, i.e. if a comment mentions something not even present in the article, or if it mentions something clearly refuted in the article.
I think it's important to read the things you comment on, and I think it's important to expect others to do so as well. Ignorance is tolerated too much these days, especially considering that knowledge is easier to obtain now than ever before.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoThe number of commentators who have read the article decreases exponentially as a function of length. A good case in point is the biggest ideas in Statistics paper that's hovered around the front page for a while.
- ryandrake 6y agoA lot of long form articles are like online recipes though: A giant barely-related narrative about the subject’s home town and hobbies and life philosophies, and hidden within are the 5 lines showing ingredients and how to cook the food.