6 ms·
> the cause of many of humanity's biggest problems is humans As opposed to elephants or sea urchins? How can humans not be the cause humanity's biggest problem
by adolph 6y ago
> the cause of many of humanity's biggest problems is humans
As opposed to elephants or sea urchins? How can humans not be the cause humanity's biggest problems?
The Buddha taught there are three kinds of dukkha [usually translated as “suffering”]. The first kind is physical and mental pain from the inevitable stresses of life like old age, sickness, and death. The second is the distress we feel as a result of impermanence and change, such as the pain of failing to get what we want and of losing what we hold dear. The third kind of dukkha is a kind of existential suffering, the angst of being human, of living a conditioned existence and being subject to rebirth.
https://tricycle.org/beginners/buddhism/what-did-the-buddha-mean-by-suffering/ https://tricycle.org/beginners/buddhism/what-did-the-buddha-...
- paulintrognon 6y agoAs opposed to external non-human controlled factors, such as meteorites, I suppose.
- inglor_cz 6y agoTBH the perspective that humans will learn to control meteorites is a bit frightening. Because I would like to believe that this capability will only ever be used to protect the Earth from them, but our history says otherwise. Anything that can be used as a weapon will ... well, at least enter the arsenals, and only fear of devastating retaliation will stop people from actually using it. Or has, so far.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jjtheblunt 6y agoi suspect the assertion was thought of as "nowadays", whereas 150 years ago infectious disease might have been humanity's biggest problem.
- airza 6y agoAs opposed to other externally-caused problems like natural disasters, beating eaten by lions, etc. I would guess that a large chunk of human history was dominated by these problems.
- xkjkls 6y agoOr just hunger in general. Before the agriculture revolution starvation was the primary cause of human death.
- fjeoyk 6y agoI would have thought the opposite would be true, hunter gatherers are generally well fed from a variety of food sources, would have lived in low densities and would have been highly mobile, so in the event one food source become scarce they could move elsewhere, or switch foods. Early agriculturalists would have been stuck in once place reliant on a single, or few, food source/s and therefore vulnerable to failed harvests for a variety of reasons, droughts, natural disasters, theft (of stores, if they are lucky enough to farm food that can be stored) etc.
- soledades 6y agoYou would be correct. Preagricultural peoples exerted reproductive control so they were not vulnerable kind of population crunches that affect other species. Diverse food webs were also more reliable and nutritious than what was available to the early agriculturalists, as you say.
- jacobr1 6y agoAre there good studies that show this? Like a big survey of recovered bone/dental evidence over centuries? It certainly seems plausible to me, but I'd be fascinated to review the data and how it correlates to time and geography.
- ckosidows 6y agoWas it? I know a couple books[1] that suggest life prior to the agricultural revolution wasn't nearly as famine-stricken as we tend to think it was. These books claim hunter gatherers were quite proficient at finding enough sustenance. Obviously starvation was still possible and likely, but was it the primary cause of death? Is there some more evidence that humans were suffering from starvation before agriculture? Wouldn't populations thin out and stabilize accordingly if starvation was such a problem? [1] - _Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind_ and _Sex at Dawn_
- castlecrasher2 6y ago>How can humans not be the cause humanity's biggest problems? Think in simpler terms, like a technology used at work, or a tool used at home; I've been in enough changes in the former that tell me many people believe a new thing will be better than the old thing, even after going through that same process several times. The introspection needed to understand that people will break the process if they want or need to is hard to come by.
- jk7tarYZAQNpTQa 6y ago> How can humans not be the cause humanity's biggest problems? That's a pretty good indicator of a civilization's state. For an advanced one, the answer to your question would be "it's nowhere near the top worries". All human-made horrors (war, climate change, etc.) would be left far behind. If we were as smart as we think we are, our biggest problems would be rogue asteroids, solar storms and aggressive aliens, not human geopolitical bullshit, poisoning our water, or destroying our own ecosystem.
- mrmanner 6y agoTrue, but also the other way around: A less advanced civilization would have much more trouble with elephants, sea urchins, bacteria, and other natural factors than with humans.
- notum 6y agoDamn those sea urchins!
- toomuchredbull 6y agoStepping on a sea urchin is no beuno. I remember one time snorkelling and I was being pulled by a rip tide and I was like no big deal, I can just slowly head a different direction until I started being pulled barely past sea urchins on corals and then I was freaked out. They are dastardly.
- notum 6y agoI heard they taste pretty good though.
- klodolph 6y agoOnly fresh, they quickly start to smell off.
- libraryatnight 6y ago
- SiempreViernes 6y agoOne year into a worldwide pandemic affecting every aspect of life and you have a hard time finding examples of really bad things not caused by human? That's some committed misanthropy, I got to give you that.
- newsbinator 6y agoThe jury’s out on whether this one was our own fault too. Maybe we made it in a lab, or even if we didn’t, maybe we should have been much smarter about preventing or containing it. It’s not like an alien virus we never predicted and can’t understand. Experts had been warning about this exact thing for years.
- ncallaway 6y ago> maybe we should have been much smarter about preventing or containing it. That doesn't mean humans were responsible for the pandemic, though. That means humanity might bear responsibility for not as effectively containing the pandemic. If an asteroid strikes the earth, and causes a mass casualty event that doesn't mean humans caused the asteroid strike (even if we maybe should have invested more in preventing the asteroid strike). I think it's reasonable to expect more effective human preventative measures, without confusing the disaster for ones caused by human activity.
- nickelcitymario 6y agoNaw, even the mildest and laziest of misanthropes could find reasons to blame humanity for the pandemic and all its effects. Commitment not required.
- triceratops 6y agoThe virus either originated in a human lab (unlikely) or jumped cross-species in an environment created by humans (exotic animal markets with poor hygiene controls). So...yeah this one is kinda on us.
- adolph 6y agoIs a virus a problem or is it a new challenge for humanity to take on, just as our understanding of molecular biology has become ready to address it? I respect the loss of people just as I respect the loss of all who have gone before, soldiers, explorers, pioneers, even those who did not intend risk but lived unknowingly under risk that existed nonetheless. These “problems” are opportunities to serve.
- Justsignedup 6y agoThe cause of most problems for any biological creature on earth is external. All animals compete fiercely for survival among the elements, among other creatures, among each other. Survival is the biggest problem for all animals. Except humans. More humans die each year due to other humans, or due to things other humans have created (for example humans ignoring mask mandates). Point is, we are the only specie who has become its own worst enemy. Idk, what am I saying? I think we can improve eachother's lives quite a bit if we just kick out the assholes from power.
- mutatio 6y agoEvolutionists like Dawkins pose that most organisms are in fiercest competition with members of their own species. You and I compete for identical resources: mates, jobs etc.
- ncmncm 6y agoOther species have mostly arranged not to kill one another in these competitions. E.g. vipers & komodo dragons don't bite while wrestling. Walruses get pretty ripped-up, but usually don't die. Ganging up to kill seems to be mostly a primate thing.
- inglor_cz 6y agoFighting is only a subset of competition. Male lions will kill cubs fathered by another male without remorse. It is not the same as our primate instincts of war, but remarkably close to ethnic cleansing.
- mbesto 6y ago> I think we can improve eachother's lives quite a bit if we just kick out the assholes from power. What other species creates scalable, global solutions to large scale problems? Example (not real, but realistic) - a group of scientists in India create a vaccine that a company in Germany manufactures, so that people in the US can avoid a deadly virus. Only one I can potentially think of is Fungi, as they appear to have large scale symbiotic relationships, but nothing is comparable to humans.
- ncallaway 6y ago> As opposed to elephants or sea urchins? How can humans not be the cause humanity's biggest problems? Dinosaurs' biggest problems was asteroids. There are plenty of externalities outside of human control, or that humans are only marginally responsible for (asteroids, gamma ray bursts, volcanic eruptions, famine due to crop diseases, pandemics, etc).
- colechristensen 6y agoIt's always important to remember that we live in a thin sheet of self-sustaining complexity in a cold, hostile universe, perhaps unique and if not incredibly rare. The "human" problems are a luxury when our fragile existence seems like little more than an accident.