8 ms·
> NFTs make perfect sense for representing a claim on things that can be used, like event tickets or in-game virtual goods. There’s absolutely no reason for th
by arcticbull 6y ago
> NFTs make perfect sense for representing a claim on things that can be used, like event tickets or in-game virtual goods.
There’s absolutely no reason for that to be decentralized, only one party can honor the tokens anyways. Like most things crypto they don’t actually make sense for anything.
- jayd16 6y agoYou still might want to hand out tokens to third parties to trade but not copy. I agree that a decentralized structure is not necessary.
- arcticbull 6y agoIf that’s what you want throw a “transfer” button on your site. There’s already a button to do this on the Ticketmaster app.
- jayd16 6y agoAgreed. I still think there's some charm to the idea that it can be supported passively but as you say the fulfilment is ultimately not passive, so it doesn't really gain you all that much.
- throwaway_kufu 6y ago> If that’s what you want throw a “transfer” button on your site. Well when you buy a ticket from ticketmaster you can’t exactly dictate what features they offer through their platform...not to mention ticket master is a 3rd party service that they take a massive cut. blockchain is cutting these 3rd parties out in these use cases, allowing the event holders to easily mint the admission tickets and users take advantage of peer to peer open source technology. Meaning easily trace the tickets and buy/trade/sell without relying on Ticketmaster.
- calciphus 6y agoThe thing that makes ticketing difficult is not minting and selling unique items of inventory - that's a well understood problem with many viable solutions. Nor is verifying at any given moment if a single piece of inventory is valid and who owns it - again, that's a solved problem. The secondary markets in ticketing exist because there's an excess of demand and entities who can exploit access, speed, or technical know-how for arbitrage. Blockchain ticketing companies don't fundamentally change that statement - they enable it. No one likes Ticketmaster - but to call them a 3rd party service that takes a massive cut is inaccurate. Ticketmaster is owned by Live Nation, which usually owns both the venue and the artist's tour schedule. And owns the primary and secondary ticketing sales. So Ticketmaster is usually the first, second, and third-party in ticketing. Blockchain doesn't magically fix this. It doesn't change the deep relationship Live Nation has with labels and artists, their fodness for excluding artists who play at rival and independent venues, their habit of defining contract requirements that can only be fulfilled by Ticketmaster software... Blockchain is solving all of the wrong problems in ticketing. I don't need a distributed, trustless ledger of who owns a ticket when all of them are issued by and redeemed at the same location. The only real reason to push for blockchain in ticketing is to help scalpers hide what they're doing.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> The secondary markets in ticketing exist because there's an excess of demand I don't buy "excess of demand" as being fundamental, though, except in the most technical sense. Imagine a super niche event, where the organizers know there are exactly 200 fans on the entire planet, and they offer that many tickets on sale. It still makes sense for a random scalper to take a loan, buy all 200 tickets, and resell them with a markup. It would still make sense if the organizers offered 300 tickets, i.e. greater supply than demand in terms of heacount! A scalper could still come ahead buying all 300, selling 200 at a high enough markup, and feed the remaining 100 tickets to a cat. I think scalping (arbitrage) can occur in any situation in which the supplier isn't charging the maximum the market can bear (perhaps that's what is meant by "excess of demand" and I'm missing some technical definitions here).
- darawk 6y agoThere is a reason. Just not a technical one. It becomes obvious when you ask the simple question: why hasn't it already been done? The answer is that it's in no actor's local incentives to create the public commons. Why is there no global market place for reselling digital event tickets? Certainly Ticket master and the other retailers could agree on an open standard protocol, pay for a centralized clearing house, and create a digital market place. But they don't. And they don't because it isn't in any of their local interests to maintain such a thing. This problem, which is fundamentally social and economic in nature, is what is solved by smart contracts. It allows the creation of a public commons, not one that technically couldn't exist, just one that no private actor is ever incentivized to create.
- Traster 6y agoThe example you give - reselling tickets, is actually something that is directly something ticket sellers want to discourage, crypto doesn’t solve that.
- notahacker 6y agoAnd there's always a necessary third party to a p2p ticket exchange anyway: the entity that actually puts on the event the ticket gives entry to. Where they want ticket exchange (or at least refunds) to be possible they can do so in a centralised manner and when they don't, they're not a middleman that can be cut out.
- meowface 6y agoOne could imagine it being a kind of emergent community-organized event, somewhat modeling a decentralized peer-to-peer network itself. There will still technically be at least one intermediary of a sort, but hypothetically the only real intermediary could be restricted to the single person or group who initially proposes the event and issues the batch of ticket NFTs. There are plenty of major concerns here, like how security and access are physically enforced if there are no official organizers or designated volunteers, but in theory you could maybe distribute a phone app so everyone is automatically scanning for unauthorized people, and just rely on physically capable attendees and police to deal with potential security incidents. Still probably a recipe for utter Fyre Festival-esque disaster and lawsuits in many cases, but feasible in theory.
- lloeki 6y agoWhat does the tokens even mean anyway? It doesn't mean "I'm the owner of this one in five paper canvas art", it just means "I'm the owner of this one number, which someone decided is related to that digital piece of art for which there can exist infinitely many copies that are perfectly identical". What does it even mean? Let's say I buy a NTF $1000 and get a digital copy, what prevents me (barring legalities) to perfectly duplicate it and massively redistribute it (not the token, the distributed supposedly high quality file) for a fraction of $$$ and turn a profit (because since it had such a high price it must be in high demand)? The question is not about the legal consequences but about the thing you own: of you have one original painting you have only one, it's quite hard to exactly duplicate it for resale. I may be naive (the dropbox-is-just-rsync kind) but I've yet to see a tangible explanation of a use† of CryptoArt/NFT that could not be done with `xxd -l 128 -p /dev/random` and PGP[0]. † No. "being in the blockchain" brings absolutely nothing (except burning watts). If the author wants to reissue anything he readily can. You. Just. Own. A. Number. I also hear some picture the author getting a cut of resales of the token, which is even more crazy when you manage to entertain the thought while trying to keep a straight face. [0]: https://twitter.com/lloeki/status/1366804865943556106 https://twitter.com/lloeki/status/1366804865943556106
- detaro 6y ago> Let's say I buy a NTF $1000 and get a digital copy, what prevents me (barring legalities) to perfectly duplicate it and massively redistribute it (not the token, the distributed supposedly high quality file) for a fraction of $$$ and turn a profit The file is usually publicly accessible, why would anyone give you money for something they can just download?
- lottin 6y agoSome rich dude has bought the "first tweet" for $2.5 million, despite the fact that it's publicly accessible [0]. I imagine it's about showing off how rich they are. They could achieve the same result by throwing $2.5 million into a furnace. https://twitter.com/jack/status/20 https://twitter.com/jack/status/20
- dmurray 6y agoHow would you resell a stadium event ticket with a centralized setup? You'd need the event organiser to run the marketplace, which isn't always desirable.
- arcticbull 6y agoSame way this has been happening for as long as I’ve been alive.
- randomswede 6y agoWhy is a secondary market in stadium tickets a desirable thing? If you want to use your ticket to go see the event, use it. If you don't, simply do not go. If you do not want to go and want to recover your costs, sell it back to the venue at the purchase price.
- Paradigma11 6y agoThe blockchain is only infrastructure. It is an open decentralized cloud for financial services/contracts. Sure vendors could also have their own service and marketplace but why should they. This way they just print and sell some NFTs and that's it.
- koonsolo 6y agoWhen it's owned by an external party, you might not be able to (easily) trade it. When it's decentralized, nobody can stop you from trading it.
- cdata 6y agoIt is funny: there are essays in this thread, authors clearly breathless to explain the utility or lack thereof of NFTs. Yet your two sentence explanation is the most comprehensive. NFTs enable the possibility of a market that is orthogonal to the channel that distributed the token. The viability or existence of such a market is not guaranteed, but the likelihood that one could emerge at all has gone up thanks to the novel properties of NFTs.
- arcticbull 6y agoBut of course there’s only one place you can redeem them. That means either that party is ok with transfers (in which case your point is moot because they can offer that themselves like Ticketmaster does) - or they’re not ok with the transfer in which case they won’t honor the token, making your point moot.
- koonsolo 6y agoSo how does the party best offer a trading infrastructure when they are OK with it? Implement it? Good luck. Easiest right now is to offer an ETH based token, and you can trade it for anything you want.
- NoOneNew 6y agoWhen it comes to in game items... why should one game honor another game's items? EVE Online and World of Warcraft dont exist in the same context. Even if you did it between Guild Wars, Elder Scrolls online and WoW, you still cant interchange the items due to stats, style and general game mechanics let alone the coding rework to have these items function the same way between games. If there was an mmo framework that is shared between different games, I guess. But even then, why have a universal currency instead of just making it framework/platform specific? It's less work and is all handled in a fast centralized DB. At that why create the extra work of PoW or PoS or whatever algorithm solving process it'll use. currencyAmount += tradedAmount is way easier and makes more sense on the game dev side. All these anti NFT arguments amount to is, "This is solutionism at its finest, but people already bought koolaid in bulk...so enjoy the show."
- meowface 6y agoIn my opinion, it only has the possibility of making any sense if a game itself is (largely or entirely) an Ethereum dapp. I think a WoW NFT would make zero sense (and I think Blizzard would agree, barring the hypothetical potential of trying to exploit a fad purely for extra profit), but an NFT representing an asset in your Ethereum-based Second Life "d-game" could possibly make some sense. I know some dapp games exist and more will be made, but I'm not sure how practical or fun they are or can be. Even then, there are still a lot of questions: what makes the d-game actually interesting/novel/unique/fun and an appropriate, creative, and clever use of a decentralized blockchain. And although I mostly agree with this essay and the Medium essay it's referencing about environmental impact, I do think NFTs have some potential use cases outside of games, art, and bilking greedy people. I think those use cases just have to be a little further along the "blockchain from end-to-end" spectrum.
- NoOneNew 6y agoI dont know about theres a "use". Remember that crowdfunded, over engineered juicer? It was some $400 and claimed to do like 100 pounds of force on a pre-juiced juice packet to squeeze into a glass for you. Some other article showed you can just squeeze these packs by hand into your glass with barely any force. This was "the Keurig" of juicing. Total shit show of over engineering and solutionism. I see the same thing with crypto and NFTs currently. Everytime I have this discussion in person, I always say that I do believe there will be a viable digital currency of some sort in the near future. The current gen of tech has proved the want, which is important, but now a real how is needed along with commonsense. Like, theres a real want for an easy to go, healthy juice. Just bottle it and sell it that way. Why go through the extra step of a juicer if the shit is already juiced. I won't doubt their drinks were good. But they got caught up in solutionism gimmicks. Digital currencies are caught up in the blockchain gimmick.
- sneak 6y agoThis assumes that the centralized minter (and ultimately redeemer) of the, say, tickets, is both willing and able to run a secondary marketplace for them. Those two things are not a given.
- blockyhead 6y agoYes there is. If it is decentralized (properly), you can't be canceled or locked out of your account, you can trade your good at any time.
- ddeyar 6y agoThere is a collectible card game under development which i think is similar to Magic The Gathering. https://coa.se/ https://coa.se/ In this case it makes perfectly sense. It will be released on the Tezos blockchain which is already LPoS. https://tezos.com/ https://tezos.com/
- arcticbull 6y agoI guess, but if the web front end goes down all you own is some digits. Cool.
- ddeyar 6y agoWhen people loose interest in stamps you have some scraps of paper. :)
- hnick 6y agoIt serves the token holder if said party just declares the ticket or other item a forgery or otherwise invalid, and doesn't let you in the venue or locks your account. It also serves the holder if they want a safe secondary market to resell or trade tokens. So basically, decentralisation doesn't serve the vendor, only the consumer.
- funkshui 6y agoYes it does because within the token, you can program that the token creator gets a share of the profit. Mark Cuban talks about this regarding dallas mavericks tickets. Suddenly the ticket creator can still benefit from scalpers buying everything. Or, you can set the next sell price to be limited to only 10 percent more. etc. There is a reason for artists and musicians to move to NFTs as well, as royalty is built in. See kings of leon releasing their album as an NFT.