5 ms·
The part that is baffling to me is, if there is a procedure in place to notify parents, and try to remedy the situation, how is it that almost half of the rest
by bluefirebrand 6y ago
The part that is baffling to me is, if there is a procedure in place to notify parents, and try to remedy the situation, how is it that almost half of the rest of the students have even worse attendance and worse grades?
Something stinks about this story. We certainly don't have the whole picture here.
Unrelated but when I read the article I assumed the school was a private school. I realize that doesn't really match up with "Single Mother of three working three jobs", but "Augusta Fells Savage Institute of Visual Arts" does not sound like a public school to me.
- dkhenry 6y agoThe Baltimore city-wide graduation rate is 70%[1]. Its not at all unbelievable that this single school would be below 50%. Public education in the US is a failed system, and we have rewarded it by throwing more money at the problem. 1. https://baltimore.cbslocal.com/2020/02/25/baltimore-city-schools-graduation-rate-went-down-slightly-in-2019-first-year-of-more-rigorous-graduation-requirements/ https://baltimore.cbslocal.com/2020/02/25/baltimore-city-sch...
- Retric 6y agoExtra money is rarely used to improve the schools at issue rather than testing and administration overhead. What I found interesting was: The district’s five-year graduation rate increased by .02 percentage points, to 75 percentage points overall. Since 2010, the four-year graduation rate has increased by 8.8 percentage points overall. “The new graduation requirements raised the bar for all Maryland students
- umvi 6y ago> Public education in the US is a failed system Public education failed? Or these kids' parents' failed? Doesn't seem fair to force schools to pick up the slack of failing parents and families and then chalk it up to school failures when the kids still aren't attending. You could have a gold-plated diamond-studded high school staffed by nobel prize winners, and it wouldn't amount to any value for the kids if they don't go...
- urban_strike 6y agoI'd agree that it's not fully solvable by the school alone. But zooming out, I'd be inclined to say the "society that forced a mother to work 3 jobs to get by" failed. I imagine it's hard to give each child individual attention/care when you're spread that thin, hence being essentially forced to offload chunks of that parenting-responsibility onto institutions. Which is a much larger and harder issue than a failure of individual responsibility. But it seems like that's the more foundational issue as far as I can tell.
- umvi 6y ago> But zooming out, I'd be inclined to say the "society that forced a mother to work 3 jobs to get by" failed But how did the mother get into position where a) she's single and b) she needs to work 3 jobs to get by? One situation is teen pregnancy. Say a girl gets pregnant as a teenager and the father flees (common for single moms). Now she has to raise a kid by herself and drop out of school, limiting her career options. Is this an individual responsibility fail or a societal fail? I guess you could argue "society failed by not providing her with free contraceptives and/or abortive services and/or social services" but it's just a bad, sad situation no matter how you slice it, and clearly there was some personal agency involved. Even worse, it's a self-perpetuating cycle (i.e. the pregnant teen's offspring is more likely to also be a pregnant teen)
- urban_strike 6y agoI think your teenage pregnancy example is probably reasonable, I could see that being a big turning point in a mother's life, where things began getting tougher/worse. I guess my point is that even if it's clearly an individual-failure, how long should that condemn her to a life of struggle and hardship, let alone her children? If one step off the straight-and-narrow in society means that you need to beat incredible odds to make it back onto the happy-path, we need to work to make that easier to do. Regardless of whether you fell off that path by your own actions today, last week, or decades ago when you were a child. I'd want to live a society where those struggling get repeated lifelines and assistance to help find some stability. I guess I don't see what the other option is; I don't think we can just give up and let them (and their children, and their children's children...) struggle and fail forever. Even if that means that they need more support/attention than the average citizen for however long it takes.
- washadjeffmad 6y agoFor people not from the US, selective defunding of education was part of a strategy begun in the mid-1800s to further disenfranchise free blacks around the nation. By shifting schools to local funded, areas with multiple (segregated) school systems used "plain and simple economic reason" to shut down excess schools to save cost, somehow always the black ones. The proof that blacks could not lift themselves out of these situations was used as further proof of their inherent inferiority, not the systemic racism they faced. To compound this, states that organized "literacy tests"[1] to vote rarely required them for whites. Further removed from the ability to affect their circumstances, many black communities languished for generations. As a natural extension of this, many school districts in the US are still operating under unequal resources while their constituents' tax revenues go towards the landscaping and infrastructure costs of wealthier areas, while the blame is placed on the victims (eg- "absent parents" who are largely working class victims of exploitation from extreme rent seeking, over-policing harsher monetary and legal penalties, payday loan traps, and other things you don't encounter in wealthy areas). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literacy_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literacy_test
- ggreer 6y agoBaltimore spends $16,184 per pupil per year.[1] That places it 3rd of the 100 largest school systems in the country and far above the national average of $12,201. This is not a funding problem. 1. https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2019/school-spending.html https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2019/school-s...
- prepend 6y agoImagine how much they would have if they weren’t systematically defunded in the mid-1800s.
- washadjeffmad 6y agoSpend per pupil isn't meaningful beyond showing administrative efficiency. Given the outcomes, intentionally and severely failing students to game well-meaning initiatives smells like high level corruption a la the Cash for Kids scandal. Someone's getting that funding, sure, but it's not the students or their families.
- bpodgursky 6y agoWhat stinks is the Baltimore public school system. Inner city public schools are, in most cases, corrupt (you can tell because the employees quoted here feared retaliation), worthless, dangerous, and too expensive (because of the corruption). There's unfortunately not a deeper conspiracy here than a public school system which advances students whether or not they learn literally anything. Also: I sympathize with a single working mother, but "notification process" aside, the fact is, this means she didn't look at her kid's report card in 4 years. She might otherwise be a perfectly great parent, but she was 0% engaged with his education.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoFeel bad for this poor kid and all of these kids. Their lives are significantly hurt by crappy parenting and a crappy school system. It's like they never had a chance.
- bluefirebrand 6y agoIn the article she admits she knew he was failing classes, but since he was still being advanced she thought it was fine.
- harrisonjackson 6y agoI am not trying to defend her but she was aware he was failing lots of classes but assumed it was not going to prevent him from graduating since he was promoted to the next class. Spanish 1 -> 2, English 1 -> 2, etc. How is someone going to pass Spanish 2 after failing Spanish 1?
- MattGaiser 6y ago> How is someone going to pass Spanish 2 after failing Spanish 1? Failure is not a barrier to passing evidently.
- bluefirebrand 6y agoIt is kind of a weird assumption on her part, but also weird behavior on the part of the school. It all just stinks is what I mean. Basically no one took any kind of responsibility for this kid's education and success.
- civilized 6y agoThe whole picture we're missing here is that everyone is failing, checked out, and has no goals other than shifting blame.