8 ms·
Blockchain study of 43 solutions finds 0.00% success rate
- Bluestein 6y ago"Though Blockchain has been touted as the answer to everything, a study of 43 solutions advanced in the international development sector has found exactly no evidence of success. Three practitioners including erstwhile blockchain enthusiast John Burg, a Fellow at the US Agency for International Development (USAID), looked at instances of the distributed crypto ledger being used in a wide range of situations by NGOs, contractors and agencies. But they drew a complete blank. 'We found a proliferation of press releases, white papers, and persuasively written articles,' Burg et al wrote on Thursday. 'However, we found no documentation or evidence of the results blockchain was purported to have achieved in these claims. We also did not find lessons learned or practical insights, as are available for other technologies in development.' Blockchain vendors were keen to puff the merits of the technology, but when the three asked for proof of success in the field, it all went very quiet."
- Stevvo 6y agoI think you forgot to include your comment after the quotations.
- ilammy 6y ago> when [...] asked for proof of success Never heard of it. But I can show you proof of work – as demonstrated by the papers – or proof of stake.
- weare138 6y agoIt's referring to the success of the projects themselves, not a blockchain related technical term.
- berenza 6y agoarticle is from 2018
- nwah1 6y agoThe difference between then and now is that they have given up attempting to use blockchains for anything, and simply now claim it is a "store of value." In other words, they've embraced that it is a ponzi scheme, and learned to love it for what it is.
- NoOneNew 6y ago>In other words, they've embraced that it is a ponzi scheme, and learned to love it for what it is. Sounds more like Stockholm syndrome rather than a loving embrace.
- imtringued 6y agoNowadays it's also a "settlement layer".
- ostenning 6y agoIf you had looked into the space with even just a small amount of depth, you’d find there are numerous applications. Decentralized finance, games, art, cdn networks, music distribution, video streaming alternatives. Some of them are promising and would address many issues we face; like the Audius project which aims to compete with Spotify and SoundCloud, but actually paying artists for their work. I think it’s fair to be sceptical and critical of speculative investments and get rich quick schemes, and eventually I imagine it will die down, and hopefully by the end of it all, we will have a more decentralised world.
- nwah1 6y agoYou can pay artists without a blockchain. No actual benefit is provided to this concept by adding one.
- 6y ago
- nomel 6y agoThe ~300% jump in stock prices seen when the Long Island Iced Tea Corp. changed its name to Long Blockchain Corp. [1] shows that the word "blockchain" is all that's required. I imagine some of these 43 solutions were playing the same angle. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2017/12/21/long-island-iced-tea-micro-cap-adds-blockchain-to-name-and-stock-soars.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/12/21/long-island-iced-tea-micro-c...
- Bluestein 6y agoWhich is ... fine, I guess? (It is the silence - as the article says - when pressed for further, perhaps useful, instructive, thoughts, experiences, best-practices ... ... that I find horrifying ...) It is as if the mere invocation of "blockchain" on anything supresses any further thought ...
- biolurker1 6y agoPrize for nihhilism
- egberts 6y agoBlockchain, perfect for ballot count and integrity thereof.
- tinus_hn 6y agoYea, it’s useful for when you don’t trust someone to not edit history. These days I’ve seen it as a vaccination record.
- GauntletWizard 6y agoI can achieve “don’t edit history” with a Merkel Tree; It’s what powers Git. Git also doesn’t consume the power requirements of a large developing nation.
- tinus_hn 6y agoBlockchain does not consume a lot of power, it’s just blocks that contain the hash of the previous block.
- kemonocode 6y agoGit also allows you to push --force if so you wish, something that would require a 51% attack if you were to do it in a blockchain-based ledger. I really don't think blockchains are a panacea and in many cases they're a solution looking for a problem, but that doesn't mean they're necessarily useless. EDIT: Also as a sibling parent said, it's just proof of work what gets the bad rap about power consumption, and there's nothing inherently costly in blockchains themselves.
- kemonocode 6y agosibling comment* I grumble at the time limit on edits for HN comments sometimes, even if I do understand why it's there.
- blakewatson 6y agoI don’t claim to have any insight whatsoever, but I can’t help but think about all those decades old (now hilarious) articles about how the internet is a buzz word and hasn’t really lived up to its hype.
- tjs8rj 6y agoCould you link one of these? Would love to relive the sentiment. There is a distinction: the birth of the Internet saw many seriously useful improvements for its users - instant information, infinite retail stores, unlimited selections, connecting to others effortlessly, and so on. As far as I’ve seen, there isn’t any companies I can think of achieving similar improvements because of the blockchain other than speculation with cryptocurrencies. I try to be very open minded and search for contrarian opportunities, but I really don’t see where those are here. I hear “decentralized” and “trustless”, but these are cultural terms like “privacy” that matter only when people want them to matter. If the culture doesn’t value “decentralized”, then the technology isn’t very useful. By contrast, all the skepticism in the world couldn’t stop the fact that Amazon.com was a massive improvement.
- Bluestein 6y agoI am looking for that "internet vs fax" article from the 90's, and cannot put my finger on it ...
- omilu 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5555461 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5555461
- reilly3000 6y agoI think these types of articles are the harbinger of greatness for a technology to have impact in society. This shows that 43 companies found it valuable to invest in understanding blockchain technology. It means that millions of people are imagining a decentralized world, and how that would upend institutional. By detracting the present over-hype, the dangers of the gold rush to the miners but not marketers, they acknowledge that we’re living in the birth of a new California. Give it some time. Sure blockchain has poor performance characteristics relative to other databases. They all do. Not all databases have the rather remarkable characteristics that globally-shared ledgers can have. When technology is nascent there is a void of history with it, there are no bounds for expectations. It’s inevitable that most early technology is coupled with broken expectations, as they are formed without substance. Most blockchain should be understood as a social technology that is predicated on internet technology. It’s also built for the assumption that brokers aren’t trustworthy and extract too much value. Whether that turns out to be true or not will take a generation or two to sort out.
- Bluestein 6y ago> his shows that 43 companies found it valuable to invest in understanding blockchain technology. It means that millions of people are imagining a decentralized world ... That's another way of looking at it ...
- ChrisArchitect 6y ago(2018) Here's plenty of prior discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18572482 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18572482