19 ms·
"Killing TurboTax" is essentially a meme until we meaningfully simplify the tax code. There is no software development team on earth who could catch up with th
by bob1029 6y ago
"Killing TurboTax" is essentially a meme until we meaningfully simplify the tax code.
There is no software development team on earth who could catch up with the full capabilities of TurboTax without some sort of fundamental shift in the business. I really hate to say this as someone who makes a living out of it, but dealing with the current amount of complexity in the tax code with a piece of software that a non-expert could use is virtually impossible.
For the happy path (i.e. single individual, no dependents, no investments, no retirement, rents home), you could certainly build an application that handles these scenarios. The moment you factor in individuals who are bringing stock sales, multiple investment properties, ownerships/K1s and other complex scenarios to bear, its a different hellscape altogether.
Also don't forget that most states have their own independent tax codes as well, which further complicate matters. There's difficulty multipliers all over this problem domain, and you can be certain that the lobbyists employed by Intuit, et. al. are encouraging this.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- namdnay 6y agoHmmm, how does the IRS check? Purely manually? Surely there are some alternatives out there. Worst case scenario, the government buys a turbo tax competitor
- astura 6y agoThe IRS themselves need to provide this "auto tax" service.
- bob1029 6y agoAs noted in other comments here, an "auto tax" service only really works on the happy path. There are parts of the tax code which are highly subjective in more complex situations and require explicit elections on part of the filing party. These elections can have consequences far beyond the immediate tax filing transaction.
- astura 6y agoNo, it can work with the complicated path too, they present you with what they already know about you and give you the opportunity to add more information that they don't yet know. They then calculate what you owe and tell you. At some point they are going to calculate what you owe based on what you provide them and what is reported to them, no matter what. Laws that authorize "auto tax" can also come with extra reporting requirements.
- dave5104 6y agoNot to mention, I'm sure the "happy path" will accommodate a significant number of tax payers.
- robert_foss 6y agoThis is how it is done in Sweden. And after having lived in 2 other countries it is clearly the way to go. The tax authority sends you a summary and you just approve it.
- sfteus 6y agoThis always made the most sense to me. You get your return and review it; sign off if it's good, modify and return it if you have more claims, something is wrong / missing. I'd wager the majority of people wouldn't have a reason to submit a revised return. And if the federal government generated your return, hopefully that would give them reason to automatically exclude you from audit, (ideally) reducing the burden of auditors.
- peter303 6y agoThe tax prep industry lobbied Congress to prevent the IRS from auto-tax filing. The compromise was "free filing" for those with median incomes and below. For a majority, W2s, 1099s and the previous years return can provide an auto-filing framework. The IRS would send your their draft and you agree or modify. Other countries do this.
- alkonaut 6y agoIf I saw a proposal to make tax codes simpler, have people file taxes with a good app provided by the IRS etc and then I saw a politician vote against it, while being funded by companies benefiting from the status quo... I'd just not vote for that person again.
- benmw333 6y agoThis is 99.9% of politicians.
- alkonaut 6y agoVoters get the politicians they deserve. In some systems it's easier to be corrupt. IIif there are only 2 major parties so you don't need to good just better than the other guy, or if politicians are funding their own campaigns so you are indebted to sponsors and companies before you are even elected. But voters are also responsible for those systems being in place.
- bobthepanda 6y agoSuch a proposal can be killed at various steps before it gets to a floor vote. It’s part of why Mitch McConnell was majority leader; he isn’t necessarily well liked, but he is willing to take the heat for not taking up a bill and letting his colleagues avoid awkward votes.
- Spivak 6y agoWhile many people are "single issue voters" [1] it's not too often that someone would vote for an otherwise worse candidate over $50-100/yr tax prep bill. [1] I hate this term but it's the one that caught on. Almost no one votes positively based on a single issue but many people have disqualifying issues which people treat as the same thing. "Sure they're pro baby eating but their stance on taxes is really quite progressive."
- masklinn 6y ago> The IRS themselves need to provide this "auto tax" service. Interestingly, they now can: under the Free File program, tax prep companies would offer free filing (for taxpayers below 72k AGI) and the IRS would not compete with their service. After a ProPublica investigation in their dark pattern shenanigans (leading to about 3.5% of taxpayers to use the program when 70% are eligible) confirmed by the HSGA Senate Committee and NYS DFS, the IRS both updated its rule to preclude e.g. hiding Free File programs for search engine, and removed the rule which prevented them from competing. Sadly the IRS has been hamstrung time and again by the GOP, both financially and politically. They can't even do their core jobs of collecting tax and auditing the taxpayers they need to, so it's unlikely they'll have the clout and funds to set up a free filing program any time soon, let alone one properly integrated with their likely antiquated and in dire need of updates computer systems.
- kleton 6y ago> the GOP We now have an opportunity to test your hypothesis- for at least two years there will be single party rule by the other party.
- anadem 6y agoSingle party rule would be true only if the Senate was not encumbered by the filibuster.
- leereeves 6y agoThe majority party can remove the filibuster rule anytime it likes, as they have done for several special cases in recent years.
- kn0where 6y agoThe current majority party has just enough DINOs to prevent that from happening.
- AndrewUnmuted 6y ago
- executesorder66 6y agoWe have this in South Africa. It was always easy to do your taxes before, but since last year they do what they call an "Auto assessment". The South African Revenue Service collects all the documents they need (payslips, medical aid, pension etc.) from the respective organizations, fills out the tax form for you, and lets you know it's ready. I logged in to check that they did it correctly, which they did, and approved it. Literally took ten minutes. Nine of which were just reviewing all the fields on the form. Obviously this does not work for people who have very complex/unusual tax situations, but for your average person it's great.
- zo1 6y agoThey don't simply collect all "documents" they need. They hoover up the data directly from various institutions. Your employer being one, your bank another, your medical aid, etc. Not only that, but they're getting involved with the IRS now via FATCA. It's actually awesome that they're probably doing a better job than the government itself when it comes to having an all-encompassing view of the tax-cattle that they oversee.
- executesorder66 6y agoOh, I am under no illusions that this was not a pursuit of excellence, but rather a way to make sure they get as much tax money as possible. Considering how 90% of all other government services are complete garbage. But I still believe that paying taxes is the right thing to do (how else do you keep a country running, even a corrupt one?). And as someone who really hates doing any kind of admin, this was a breath of fresh air, and highly appreciated, even if their motives are not perfect.
- xtracto 6y agoSame here in mexico. Its wonderful to file my taxes because i only login into SAT website, check the prefilled data, click accept and I get my tax refunds due to my mortgage credit. It blows my mind that The USA doesn't have something like this. It's basically taxes at work
- SubiculumCode 6y agoIn one sense I totally agree, but in the other sense, it seems like it could be terribly invasive privacy wise.
- anoncake 6y agoOr just make their implementation of the tax code public?
- tppiotrowski 6y agoMy employer didn’t send me a W2 this year which caused me to seek another method to access this information. I created an account on irs.gov and was surprised to find a single PDF for each tax year containing W2’s, 1099Ints, 1099Divs that I assume were given to the IRS on my employers/bankers behalf. Now it would be great for a tax program to ingest this PDF and auto-populate your tax return. Unfortunately no PDF for 2020 exists yet and it says it might not be available until October? I don’t know if generating this PDF is a slow process or if this information is intentionally withheld until after the tax filing date to make sure you are “honest” on your taxes.
- rainyMammoth 6y agoyou made me curious and I logged into the IRS to find those "transcripts". I really cannot tell if they generate that information from your own tax report or if they generate it from what they already got in their own databases.
- tppiotrowski 6y ago> Wage and Income Transcript - shows data from information returns we receive such as Forms W-2, 1099, 1098 and Form 5498, IRA Contribution Information. Current tax year information may not be complete until July. This transcript is available for up to 10 prior years using Get Transcript Online or Form 4506-T. https://www.irs.gov/individuals/transcript-types-and-ways-to-order-them https://www.irs.gov/individuals/transcript-types-and-ways-to...
- jonahhorowitz 6y agoIdeally there would be a "tax dashboard" on the IRS site where you could log in and see your (YTD): - Income reported - Taxes paid - Tax credits and deductions - Expected balance (+/-) Then at the end of the year, you'd log in and click one button to verify the numbers and either pay or get a check.
- djxfade 6y agoThat is essentially how we file our taxes in Norway. You don't really have to login to verify the numbers, only if the numbers (that the government calculates for you) needs revision
- dopidopHN 6y agoI grew up in France, our bureaucracy is pretty intense and old school. But they send you a nice little note with your W2 and how much you own them. If they missed anything you can amend their draft. Usually it take 15min to complete the whole yearly process. Even with some midly complicated situation like renting and being landlord, living between two countries, cryptos.
- azog_alone 6y agoThe reason the tax code is so complicated is BECAUSE OF TurboTax. They lobby heavily to keep things complex and have brought down potential competitors through legal means. As such, "killing TurboTax" is the correct first step.
- ghaff 6y agoI know it's nice to have a corporate bogeyman to rail against but it's not that simple. For example, there have been all sorts of tax deductions over the years to incentivize things like home energy efficiency improvements, EVs, solar power, charitable contributions, etc. And the mortgage deduction was/is intended to promote home ownership. I could go on. Someone can disagree with some of the choices around tax rates and certain weirdly specific deductions. But most people wouldn't argue that, for example, encouraging people to donate to charities is a bad thing.
- drdeca 6y agoThere are some people who are weirdly anti-charity, saying that all of it should be done through taxes? I don't understand their point of view.
- ryandrake 6y agoThread drift, but my objection to encouraging charitable giving is that the more you rely on charity to fund the public good, the more you rely on (largely) millionaires and billionaires to decide what counts as a public good. In other words the average citizen doesn’t get to vote on what good gets funded. This means givers’ pet causes get funded rather than projects that are democratically chosen.
- drdeca 6y agoIt is possible (even likely) that I've misunderstood people who were just being hyperbolic and didn't mean to be taken literally, but my impression was that some were saying that literally no charity organizations should be necessary? I (somewhat..) understand the "but then the wealthy are determining what gets done" thing, as a reason to not rely too much on it, but it seems clear to me that there are also major inefficiencies in having to go through a consensus process of government democracy, rather than people simply acting in smaller groups, independent of a larger consensus, to further charitable causes. It seems clear that there are cases where charities work better than govt programs alone, and it is a clear error to think that all charities would be better handled as a govt service, even if some would be better handled by one. Hmm, if the government were to run a quadratic funding of charities thing, with only rather limited requirements for eligibility, perhaps that would somewhat alleviate the "undemocratic" complaint? (It would have to make it illegal to pay someone else to participate in your stead though.)
- lallysingh 6y agoI think if there was a basic extensible system, that could grow into a full product. Start with 1040EZ in year 1, then grow with your customers' needs as they age and need more. TT has a large moat but behind it must be a ton of technical debt. Would an open source solution work here?
- jnwatson 6y agoYou’re imagining an army of tax accountants to continually keep a system up to date to put themselves out of business?
- lallysingh 6y agoThey use software too. Their competition is turbotax.
- sokoloff 6y agoIn many cases, that software is Intuit’s ProSeries which has obvious TurboTax code sharing when I interact with my preparer.
- Larrikin 6y agoThere's atleast one Show HN every year that does that and promises support for the more complicated cases "in a few months".
- codegeek 6y agoAgreed. This is primarily not a "software" problem. Unless we simplify our tax codes in the US, tools like turbotax will stay. In fact, to be honest, turbotax was great when I used it last in 2009ish (I know they got acquired by Intuit and have gone downhill due to Intuit ) but the point is that it is overall an excellent software that really makes it easy to calculate and file things based on current tax codes. I would love to not have that dependency but that's not possible only when the tax codes are simplified.
- carabiner 6y agoIt's still excellent. I just did my taxes in FreeTaxUSA this year for the first time and it's not nearly as good as TT last year. FTU is like manually filling in the IRS PDF's except as webforms, whereas TT imports PDF's and parses everything correctly, leaving you to do a quick scan. FTU is free because it's just a light GUI layer over the 1040 and various Schedule forms.
- jimmaswell 6y agoFTU does at least direct you to the correct forms for your situation, tell you what to do with deductions etc.
- BEEdwards 6y agoI've used FTU for the last 2 years and it's all I need, it has all the forms easily searchable and you just next next finish your taxes basically. There isn't a need for anything else...
- woobar 6y agoTurboTax was sold to Intuit in 1993. Not sure why do you think it would get worse under Intuit, considering you liked it in 2009.
- codegeek 6y agoOh my bad then. I guess I got confused because for some reason, I always they were acquired after I initially used them. You are correct though. So I guess the software has always been good.
- derekp7 6y agoTo give an example of complexity that can hit "normal" people, something I just learned yesterday. If you are between 18 and 24, and a student, then if you had received unemployment income that income is considered "unearned income". Therefore it is subject to the highest marginal tax rate (tax bracket) that your parents fall into (which is 22% - 24% for quite a few people). To me, that is kind of nuts, and not something that follows from normal logic (i.e., it isn't something that you will "get right" by just filling out a standard 1040 form).
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoBy “and a student” do you mean claimed as a dependent by someone else?
- dsr_ 6y agoYes, because if you aren't a dependent, it's income for your own return, not theirs.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoCool, yeah just wanted to clarify so the comment didn't confuse any non-dependent students.
- munk-a 6y agoI disagree that it's nonsensical for it to work this way since that unemployment benefit is being granted after your parents are claiming that they are supporting you - so essentially they're getting a big tax deduction on their income for your costs but then the unemployment benefit is being claimed to make sure for a lack of them covering costs - in a simple world one might make the other ineligible but that could result in some folks being put through unreasonable financial hardships due to poor planned or ill-intended returns from their parents so this allows that benefit to be given while also recognizing that something going on here is double dipping. If you are financially independent then you should make sure your parents aren't claiming you as a dependent, if you aren't then you should be receiving those covering funds from your parents since that's the sort of dependency the dependent class is all about.
- dllthomas 6y agoNot that I expect it to succeed, but I wonder what would happen if you tried throwing machine translation at the raw tax code.
- bob1029 6y agoWhat if we rewrote the tax code with code? There are many high level languages (especially functional ones) which could address this problem domain really well if we had the courage to start completely over. Imagine a legal document that is written using terminology that is ultimately just a series of higher-order functions. A human could make sense of it with some training, and a computer could directly execute it with determinism.
- spiralx 6y agoLegal documents are already a combination of data values and custom rules, they just also reference external rule sets such as legislation, regulation or case law. I work at a company where we use the same data points to generate the legal documents for a funding round as well as the cap table before and after the round is closed. Term sheets are just a very verbose data file lol.
- marshallward 6y agoFiling taxes online in Australia is free, and I'm sure it's of comparable complexity. This does not exist in the US the highest levels of government have no incentive to provide it.
- mooreds 6y ago> This does not exist in the US the highest levels of government have no incentive to provide it. This is a valuable podcast episode to listen to to learn more about this: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/04/03/709656642/episode-760-tax-hero https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/04/03/709656642/epis...
- sjy 6y agoFrom what I can tell, the system in the US is significantly more complicated for individuals (mortgage interest deductions, 43 different state income taxes, “alternative minimum tax,” gift tax, estate tax...)
- marshallward 6y agoAs someone who has to file both, I found that the federal taxes to be comparable, perhaps I'd even say the Australian was more complex. The games played with real estate can be rather complex. But what I also saw was software doing most of the number crunching for me, and even fetching the numbers from my various employers and assets. But your point about the state income tax is well taken, this does make it a much harder problem here than in Australia.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoTo be fair: Filing your taxes in the US is free. No one is going to force you to pay someone to do them for you, which is what TurboTax and the like are doing, usually through software. If you don't understand the tax forms, though, or can't figure out the codes, you are stuck paying someone. The IRS won't give definitive answers if you call them.
- dan-robertson 6y agoIs there some software solution that may make things easier. For example if rules are written in a language like prolog could you have the system ask you the relevant questions? Would the set of rules be easier to maintain?
- maybelsyrup 6y ago> "Killing TurboTax" is essentially a meme until we meaningfully simplify the tax code. [...] There is no software development team on earth who could catch up with the full capabilities of TurboTax without some sort of fundamental shift in the business. So let's just nationalize TurboTax.
- kbenson 6y agoThat would a) never happen in the current US political climate and b) provide enough ammunition to those against such a mode as to be extremely counter-productive towards other social programs that could deal with more government support. In other words, think back on all the talk of Democrat being "socialists" over the recent years and imagine the field day conservatives would have if any national figure mentioned this as an idea out loud, and how that might be used to shift the balance of power such that other meaningful programs that could deal with additional governmental support and regulation (healthcare) get set back.
- maybelsyrup 6y agoThanks for your reply. I hear you 100%, and a few years ago your objections would've appeared in my own head were I to have even considered writing what I wrote. I simply wouldn't have written it. But it's really interesting to me that what you wrote is about the feasibility of the idea and not the idea itself. Of course, you may think it's a shitty idea - and it may indeed be! But I'd claim that it says something really fucked up about America that your first response was what it was: "couldn't ever happen, plus it would hurt what we do have if this were 'mentioned out loud'" instead of "here's why that's a bad idea". > imagine the field day conservatives would have if any national figure mentioned this as an idea out loud, and how that might be used to shift the balance of power such that other meaningful programs that could deal with additional governmental support and regulation (healthcare) get set back. "Shhh! Don't say that too loud -- they'll hear you and then take away our nice things!" My reply to this is that "other meaningful programs" are already being set back with or without talk of currently-insane ideas like nationalizing a ghoulish company like Intuit/TurboTax. They've been getting set back since the 70's at least, and so-called "conservatives" are coming for more! Let's ask George W. Bush, who at the end of what he deemed a successful presidency only regretted that he wasn't able to kill Social Security!! These peoples' mission is to ensure that any vestige of a welfare state in the US is not only erased, but that merely talking about such a thing becomes so ludicrous-sounding that people dismiss it as impossible. It's working! The other part of this is just this: love him or hate him - and yes, he's not the president - Bernie friggin' Sanders has walked around this country extremely visibly for the past half-decade calling himself a "socialist" in public, advocating for a complete "political revolution" and millions upon millions of Americans heard him and went "actually that doesn't sound so bad". I believe that the world we live in is one we made. That's scary, because look at this fuckin' place, but it's hopeful too: we can make a different one. If there are obstacles to doing so, so be it -- but our silence, no matter how rational, doesn't need to be one of them.
- Cd00d 6y agoAnd the full capabilities of TurboTax still aren't that great. I never felt confident that I was interpreting every question properly. As soon as my tax situation got even the slightest bit complex I started using an accountant. They use TurboTax, I'm pretty sure, but they also know all the questions and what they really mean and can answer my questions on what the tax impact of various situations I encounter might be. They also go to bat for me if I have an audit. Not only do I consider that far more valuable than the $500/year it costs, but I'm also confident my tax savings more than cancel the expense. Just my experience, but I recommend a tax accountant to all adults.
- enos_feedler 6y agoNo rule changes needed. Apple is at the point where they are really pushing up against the limits of consumer spending. Spending $140 on TurboTax is a prime target. Thats $140 where a fraction can get funneled back to Apple purchases. It is now worth it for them to make sure iPhone users never reach a TurboTax checkout flow. Apple is just getting started with finances built right into the iPhone. The credit card is already rolled out, and now comes a built-in bank account that can accept your payroll. This is just too valuable for Apple to pass up. The next step is push-button tax filing. Classic innovator dilemma where you start with basic returns. Think Uber driver.
- paulpan 6y agoInteresting take. If it really comes to pass, will Apple be preferable to Intuit? Or for that matter, would Google or Robinhood enter the industry?
- enos_feedler 6y agoI use TurboTax and I can't wait to get off it. They nag you to upgrade. The web app UX is really bad. I would certainly use whatever solution Apple provided if it was easy and supported my use case. I have complex tax situations. With Apple it's like anything else, if you are fully bought into the ecosystem it's going to be the best. I think there is a reason Apple Card isn't compatible with Intuit Mint right now. From a privacy and business model standpoint, Apple thinks they can do better. What I think we'll see soon is a budgeting tool similar to Mint built into the iPhone, with the Apple Card supported and a way to link 3rd party credit cards, with a pro-privacy data sharing model. Apple spins up a bank account for you via Goldman Sachs new platform. Apple encourages/incentivizes payroll deposits. Tax filing gets added to this product.
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y agoNo, it is (and always has been) dead simple. The IRS has all the information they need already. They completely eliminate the need for the vast majority of people to file taxes if they were simply told to do so. The problem is corrupt politicians who are deliberately complicating the tax code and hamstringing the IRS. The solution is to vote them out. That's easier said than done, but it's not complicated.
- jppope 6y agoMost of the US is W2'd with a house, limited investments, with some dependents sprinkled in utilizing the standard deduction... it wouldn't be that hard. For everyone else there is a justification for tax professionals.
- bshoemaker 6y agoAren't there a number of tools that people use already other than TurboTax? This seems incorrect.
- closeparen 6y agoThe tax code is complex because the economic realities we want to assess taxes on are complex. A naive treatment would be both trivial to bypass and ruinous to unlucky innocent people.
- null0pointer 6y agoI agree, a vastly simplified tax code is needed. Here's my dream for a simpler tax code: The only tax is a Sales tax/VAT/GST. Pros: - Individuals never have to think about tax. It would completely eliminate tax returns. That alone is worth it's weight in gold since tax returns are such a time and money burden. - It would close all the loopholes megacorps/wealthy individuals use to pay less tax. You cannot avoid spending money in the place where you operate. - To add to that, if every country implemented this system we would be able to move freely between countries, spending as much time as we desired, without having to worry about tax implications. Obviously that's a much much longer term vision. Cons: - Won't this disproportionately tax the poor? - Firstly, the existing tax code already does. Poor people don't have the time to understand the tax code enough to get everything they can out of their tax return. The also don't have the money to hire an accountant to do it for them. They also don't have the tax avoidance opportunities available to them that come with the scale of being a wealthy individual. - Secondly, many countries already discount or eliminate the ST/VAT/GST on essential items. You could even have a higher tax on luxury goods. You could even have a negative tax (subsidy) on essential items if you desired. The point is it changes the framing of tax discussions to "where does this good/service fall in the scale of essential item to luxury item" which is much much simpler for people to understand. - Won't prices have to rise for the same tax revenue to be collected? - Yes, but now you have all this leftover money that used to just go to income taxes which you can use. Plus prices might not rise as much as you think now that the tax loopholes used by megacorps are closed. Look, I know it's pretty radical, but I think this is the only sensible taxation in the future.
- Others 6y agoI think this is fundamentally a regressive idea. Currently the very poor pay zero (or effectively zero) income taxes. No matter how you structure the sales tax, you cannot go below zero. (I think negative sales tax is not actually realistic, nor particularly progressive.) A system that only taxes spending fundamentally has problems in that the richer people can afford to save and invest.
- null0pointer 6y ago
- mNovak 6y agoI assume a huge quantity of TurboTax users are in the simplest scenarios. As others have said, once there's any level of complexity, there's likely an accountant involved anyway. I don't think this is much at all a technical problem. I suspect most people use TT because it's convenient--it files for you, they'll even pay themselves from your refund. And TT knows well this is a huge user base, as you'll see them hide away little features like education credits into the premium version. I agree though that state taxes are part of the moat here, let alone municipal. In the few states I have experience though, state taxes are vastly simpler than federal. Still it'd be great to see some kind of centralized digital infrastructure that states could all normalize around instead of each building their janky web portals.
- k_sze 6y agoYep. As a Hong Konger, it boggles my mind that tax codes in other 1st-world countries are so complex. In Hong Kong, you literally get about 3.5 pages of A4 to fill for your annual income tax returns, the vast majority of which you can leave blank unless you are one of the richer people and do rich people things. And then we have taxes on very few other things, which you simply pay at the time of purchase: - Alcohol - Motor vehicles - Real estate - Stocks I don't think I'm missing anything important. We have no other sales taxes otherwise. And look at us, we are a 1st-world economy, despite being such a small city.
- refurb 6y agoHong Kong's top bracket is 17%. Of course it's simple because the gov't doesn't collect much tax so doesn't need a bunch of exceptions and rules for tax relief.
- freddie_mercury 6y ago> There is no software development team on earth who could catch up with the full capabilities of TurboTax This is obviously false. The IRS software handles everything TurboTax does and more. As does the software that professional accountants use, such as ATX Also: TurboTax's many retail competitors like HR Block.
- sdenton4 6y agoSounds like they just buy up potential competition early... So let's get started writing /something/ and get an easy pay off when they buy us out!
- grumple 6y agoI strongly disagree with this. The tax code is relatively straightforward for a programmer. It’s a bunch of conditional statements and simple math. Even the cases you mention are straightforward compared to the usual ambiguity that comes with engineering a product. TurboTax is awful software. One question at a time, their user flow is AWFUL. Truly abysmal design for even the simplest of tax situations. The IRS’s free file fillable form site is similarly awful; their asynchronous, background xml validation of forms after they’ve been submitted to notify you that their system let you input something invalid is a laughable system design. This market is ripe for disruption. I do feel that should come from the government itself, but that seems unlikely for political reasons.
- sneeze-slayer 6y agoYou mean for free file forms you don't like getting an email with some incomprehensible language? Oh, don't worry they provide a tool. Just copy the _entire_ email they send you and paste in some tool. Genuinely it is a horrible experience, but I suppose it is better filing by paper and waiting a few weeks for a small correction.
- grumple 6y agoWell, I thought so too. Until I realized six months later that I hadn't gotten my refund. Turns out that I'd gotten an email shortly after submission that had gone unnoticed saying that my return had failed xml validation, just like you. What was the point of the frontend validation before submission? Why isn't the full validation done before submission properly? Total nonsense. I re-filed with paper... still hasn't showed up on the IRS website.
- zero_deg_kevin 6y agoMost US federal and state taxes can be computed by a rules engine. The big annual challenges are: updating the interviews, QA-ing the rules/engine, fed/state rule-making delays/defects, and ensuring that required printable forms are pixel-perfect replicas of their government-published sources. For tax year 2017 (a pretty typical year), there were over 5000 Federal/state forms/interview scripts to be updated. This requires a seasonal army of tax accountant/developers to update the app "content." It's not uncommon for providers to be updating forms/interviews well into March (when filing opens in January). Source: worked for a Turbotax competitor