6 ms·
The lost sales argument generally only works in isolation. Imagine if Adobe, say, had come up with a way to do perfect DRM so that it was impossible to pirate
by tzs 6y ago
The lost sales argument generally only works in isolation.
Imagine if Adobe, say, had come up with a way to do perfect DRM so that it was impossible to pirate Photoshop back in the days when it cost several hundred dollars.
It's probably true that a huge number of the people who pirated it back then would not have bit the bullet and coughed up the hundreds of dollars for a license, and so them pirating it did not represent a lost sale to Adobe.
But...I doubt most of them would have thrown up their hands and said "I can't pirate Photoshop...so I'm just going to give up on graphics editing!" or decided to just do their graphics editing all in MS Paint.
A lot of them almost certainly would have bought some other commercial graphics editor that is much less expensive than Photoshop, such as Pixelmator Pro for around $40.
That's where the lost sales from piracy turn up--in the sales of the less expensive alternatives that people would have turned to had they not been able to pirate what they pirated.
- majormajor 6y agoFormer pirate here, I definitely would've shifted some spending around to get a few more games if I'd had to. I probably would've bought fewer DVDs. My money went to movies - harder to pirate at DVD quality back in the late 90s! - because they were better protected than a lot of the games in the late 90s. Or maybe fewer console games, same story there. But those we could rent, too... This wasn't "ecosystem" stuff like Photoshop either, this was games we played for a few months and then moved on.
- dehrmann 6y agoI wonder if Adobe putting more effort into anti-piracy would have made the GIMP better. For a while, I saw their stance on piracy as look the other way unless it's a business. Photoshop definitely has a learning curve (probably better than the GIMP's), and I could see amateur designers having experience with Photoshop as an asset. That said, Photoshop and Minecraft are completely different products and markets.
- orwin 6y agoOr more contributors to GIMP. Let take an art student PoV, one doing MANA in France right now (16-17 yo not eligible for free version) or at any study level before Adobe did this "free for student" stuff. If he can't pirate it, he will use GIMP, probably. Considering my CS school had 5% ex-art student (with or without a complete art degree), if those had used GIMP instead, i'd dare say GIMP would have been close to PS in GUI and ahead in functionalities. So piracy take contributor away from GNU projects!
- babypuncher 6y agoThis is purely anecdotal, but my own experience backs this up. I have known at least a dozen people who pirate software and entertainment purely because it's cheaper than paying for it. These are other software engineers, they all make plenty of money to afford this kind of stuff. I doubt they would stop watching TV or playing video games if piracy suddenly stopped being an option.
- mam2 6y agoWhy would you buy it anyway ? It's not like the music / cinema industry is in trouble. If it's only to be the "good guy" then well congrats.. here's your medal.
- leetcrew 6y agoI'm somewhat apathetic regarding the health of the music/tv/movie/game industries as a whole. I do care about specific shows, artists, and games though, and revenue is an important signal that businesses use to decide what to make more or less of in the future. if you don't pay for anything, you're essentially throwing away your vote. as a group, pirates are accepting that they only get to select from things that other people are willing to pay for.
- babypuncher 6y agoWhy would I not just leave my empty plastic bottle on the beach? It's not like the beach is in trouble because of my one bottle. People only avoid littering because they want to be the "good guy".
- thebigspacefuck 6y agoMainly my reason for not pirating is legal, but I think it’s actually cheaper to pay $2-$4 to rent something than spend the money on hard drive space and a faster internet connection.
- leetcrew 6y agoprobably not. you can just delete the file when you're done if you don't want to watch it again. 50 GB is more than enough to maintain a queue of a few movies/shows. if you have enough bandwidth to stream legally without buffering, you have (roughly) enough to do the same with torrents. most tv show torrents are just rips from legitimate streaming sites anyway.
- michaelbrave 6y agoI was actually of the opinion that Adobe for a long timer turned a bit of a blind eye toward piracy because many of the people who learned on it once they became professionals became paying customers. Almost like an unofficial free trial that felt more valuable in a way. They would stamp it out once in a while, but often it felt like until they became dominant that they were barely trying to do much about it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- daveidol 6y agoInteresting theory, although didn't they still make the DRM more advanced and harder to crack with each release?
- junon 6y agoThey changed it so as to invalidate old cracks. Whether or not it was harder is up for debate. There were certainly better ways to do DRM at the time (even now) that Adobe was well within their monetary limits and interests pursuing. But of course, it was still cracked. Also, for a hundred buck fee and some TPB/Demonoid credit, it's almost always worth it to a cracker to go after a flagship product. There's also the running theory that Adobe was the one to release some of the cracks, namely because new releases of the Creative Suite back when it was new would be cracked nearly "instantly". It's speculation, but the above theory would make a lot of sense - and, in my opinion, that's exactly what ended up happening, and what made Photoshop the industry leader over a pretty decent selection of alternatives at the time (though admittedly PS had already mostly established itself at the time anyway, but it could have probably been swayed).
- mayniac 6y agoI believe all this as well. If they wanted to, Adobe could invest heavily in DRM that would take at least a few months to crack. But it's far cheaper to stick a login wall in front of download pages and support forums, monitor for corporate email addresses, and spend the money on going after companies that pirate their software. e.g. https://www.theverge.com/2015/1/29/7948241/forever-21-pirating-photoshop-adobe-corel-autodesk https://www.theverge.com/2015/1/29/7948241/forever-21-pirati...
- hyperpallium2 6y agoApparently, Adobe deliberately allowed pirating of photoshop, to maintain its status as a standard. Deny oxygen to competitors. Adobe has always struck me as a company that understood software economics really well and really early on. They'd make money from proprietary stuff, then give it away before it made an opportunity for a competitor. Actually, it's probably less the understanding, than the actual acting on it.
- banana_giraffe 6y ago> Apparently, Adobe deliberately allowed pirating of photoshop, to maintain its status as a standard. Deny oxygen to competitors. I've often wondered about this claim. I've heard it as well, from many different sources. I could never find a source, every time I've looked, it's a web of "I've heard". Obviously Adobe wouldn't issue a press release to this effect, but does anyone know where this wisdom originated?
- boringg 6y agoThat's a good point could be just rumors but it does have a strong foundation of truth to it. One of those things that seems like we will never know for sure.
- vinger 6y agoI've seen an interview with the EA guys who say they would rather you pirate their product over someone's elses.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agohttps://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2006-apr-09-fi-micropiracy9-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2006-apr-09-fi-micro... If you do business, you will study the market, those are results of the study.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> Apparently, Adobe deliberately allowed pirating of photoshop, to maintain its status as a standard. Deny oxygen to competitors. I can't confirm whether it's true, but I once read that Microsoft takes a similar approach to the unlicensed use of Windows in less wealthy nations. Even disregarding that it would likely be a losing battle, they'd rather it remain the norm than push people to the alternatives.
- Skhalar 6y agoBefore I pirated PS I used GIMP. After years of pirating PS, I ended up paying Adobe for 6+ years for Adobe CC because PS and Illustrator didn't even compare to GIMP/other softwares. If they had perfected the DRM, and wasn't able to pirate. I don't think I would have ever paid for it.
- boringg 6y agoDo you think the guilt (was there even any guilt) of having pirated it for many years also made you guy in? I ask as a function of a business strategy they could have let people ride for free until at a certain point they might feel some kind of obligation. I doubt that was ever part of anyones strategy but in hindsight is kind of interesting to riff on.
- mywittyname 6y agoNon-business users will absolutely continue to pirate for as long as possible. Adobe products are basically unpiratable at this point, and the $20/mo subscription service is expensive, but reasonably affordable compared to the $600 or whatever the boxed software ran all those years ago.
- njharman 6y agoPart of the point is perfect DEn costs. Even shotty DRM costs a lot. To develop, to maintain and upgrade as it is defeated. On top of that is costs to customer frustration and loss of utility. It is better to spend on making your product better, your customers happier. Then chase tiny amount hostile users.
- bluedino 6y ago>> "I can't pirate Photoshop...so I'm just going to give up on graphics editing!" Jasc's Paint Shop Pro was ~ $99, Corel was about half the price of PhotoShop...
- vmception 6y agoDoubt. Obligatory photoshop piracy for an entire generation was the single biggest advertisement Adobe could have ever had. This is the happy meal of the 21st century.
- GuB-42 6y agoMy idea is that people pirating Photoshop were mostly hurting PaintShop Pro. PaintShop Pro has always been Photoshop's little brother. It is quite capable though not as much as Photoshop. It is also much cheaper. If piracy didn't exist, I would expect a lot more people to buy it, but since for a pirate, they are both free, there is not much reason not to go with Photoshop. And pros will also go with Photoshop because even with the high price, it is worth it, especially if they learned on the cracked version...