17 ms·
Meat consumption and risk of 25 conditions: outcome-wide analyses of 475K people
- m4tthumphrey 6y agoSo... don't eat processed meat. Doesn't this just correlate with what we already knew?
- pedro-guimaraes 6y agoDo you even find unprocessed meat these days?
- eptcyka 6y agoYou can just buy cuts of meat at any grocery store in most western countries, can you not?
- qayxc 6y agoDefinitely true in the EU and most of Europe in general. Not sure about other parts of the world, though.
- analog31 6y agoYes, in the US. But a large (possibly dominant) fraction of food consumption in the US is via prepared food purchased in stores, or from restaurants. To use raw meat, you have to know how to store and prepare it yourself. If you know how to cook, you can tell what it is, just by looking at it.
- relativeadv 6y agoI take processed meat to mean deli meats, bacon, and cured ham. Additives are one of the things that make them damaging. Is a filet mignon, ground beef, or chick thighs processed? Sure. But i don't think that is what we're talking about here.
- ciceryadam 6y agoFresh meat can be processed by injecting it with water + various salts to bulk up the weight/volume by up to 15%. Depending on the legislature, it could be legally still considered fresh meat in some countries. See plumping: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plumping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plumping It's not just chickens, I've seen ground meat, and pork tenderloins in supermarkets with the same processed treatment.
- relativeadv 6y agoGood point!
- NoOneNew 6y agoI thought pre-cook and/or treated meats meant processed in terms of the general consumer. Raw cuts of steak, pork loins and drumsticks isnt typically considered processed for the consumer. From what I know, you only call cut up raw meat "processed" if you handled the full carcass, like a butcher. But like you said, it's the additives that we really think of as "processed". If you home make sausage with just ground meat and pork casing is that "processed" if you didnt add nitrates or edta? Technically yes, but that's where I think clear cut definitions need to be in place.
- ciceryadam 6y agoHere in Czech republic / Slovakia it's enough to read the label - if it says fresh meat, it's unprocessed meat. If it's processed, the label cannot say fresh meat anymore, it has to say meat product.
- pndy 6y agoSame in Poland; all information you need is on label and AFAIK is sorted by amount of components and that also applies for variety of packaged food.
- dmos62 6y agoI'm not sure what the conclusion of this study is, but I'd like to point out that it is not the role of science to be controversial or surprising. It's really a pity that researchers who get non-exciting results feel like they've failed.
- loceng 6y agoIt's the role of science to be as accurate and precise as possible, and the vast majority - perhaps even all of them - fail to take into account enough variables to make it actually relevant; e.g. observational studies that target red meat being eaten don't usually differentiate from a healthy diet with red meat, high fat vs. low fat meat consumptions, nor account for what else a person is eating - e.g. ketogenic diet, if no sugars/carbs, etc.
- adtac 6y ago>Unprocessed red meat intake was associated with a higher risk of IHD (ischemic heart disease), pneumonia, diverticular disease, colon polyps, and diabetes Lower risk of IDA (Iron deficiency anaemia), but you have a higher risk with the above five
- pgt 6y agoThe term "positive association" makes it hard to parse. The results state: "most of the positive associations observed for meat consumption and health risks were substantially attenuated after adjustment for body mass index (BMI)", but the Conclusion says: > Higher unprocessed red meat, processed meat, and poultry meat consumption was associated with higher risks of several common conditions; higher BMI accounted for a substantial proportion of these increased risks suggesting that residual confounding or mediation by adiposity might account for some of these remaining associations. Higher unprocessed red meat and poultry meat consumption was associated with lower IDA risk. So basically 'Red meat is fine but we found a correlation between heart disease and obesity'?
- pedro_hab 6y agoThey have a "Role of BMI" section which strengthens your point. > BMI accounted for a substantial proportion In the "Role of BMI" they also say that BMI isn't perfect to detect adiposity, suggesting even further that being fat is what you want to avoid. > Finally, given the observational nature of this study, it is possible that there is still unmeasured confounding, residual confounding, and reverse causality. Studying human diets is hard.
- autosharp 6y agoNo, that is not what it says. > In multi-variable adjusted (including BMI) So after correcting for BMI, meat consumption is still bad.
- tankenmate 6y agoNo, that is not what it said. The summary says "higher BMI accounted for a substantial proportion of these increased risks suggesting that residual confounding or mediation by adiposity might account for some of these remaining associations" That means that a substantial proportion of the increased risk is explained by a higher BMI. Unfortunately the summary doesn't say how much "substantial" is.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fr2null 6y agoFrom my personal experience, people that eat less or no meat have a healthier lifestyle in general. I am wondering if that also plays a part in the results.
- skinkestek 6y agoIt is a general thing. Back when being atheist was a tough choice and being some kind of religious was the default choice I think there was more thoughtful people in the atheist camp. Today as the tides turn one finds that the same annoying thoughtless people are atheists if that is the default. Im the same way it doesn't surprise me at all that one find some of the healthiest people are vegerarians (or mostly meat), I think there's a huge overlap between those groups and those that generally think carefully about what they eat instead of just eating whatever processed food is cheap. Going forward I think we'll see more unhealthy vegetarians.
- bena 6y agoYou already do. Oreos are technically vegan. Margarine is already a plant-based butter substitute. The Impossible Whopper is no better or worse for you than a regular Whopper by any metric. It is pretty easy to be a fat vegetarian today.
- Karawebnetwork 6y agoAs someone who cut meat out of her diet, I can attest to that. On days when we have time to cook, we make good, healthy meals. However, unhealthy alternatives are always present and very tempting. The curfew has been hard for me and I have resumed my bad habits. I ate plant-based burgers, non-dairy ice cream, cookies and cakes almost every day. Most fast-food restaurants near me will ship from apps and offer meat-free alternatives for the same price. Plant-based food is not necessarily healthier. It is simply meat-free.
- vlod 6y agoPlant-based food generally means whole grain, minimally or unrefined. The things you mention wouldn't fall under that category, just vegetarian junk food.
- satellite2 6y agoSo it seems that high BMI / adiposity is still the leading cause for those 25 adverse health outcomes and that high meat consumption is simply correlated with high total energy consumption. It will be interesting to see if WHO revise its recommendations regarding meat consumption.
- dawg- 6y agoInteresting. Maybe the new rule should be "Eat red meat if you want, just don't let it make you fat".
- virtuallynathan 6y agoIf you eat almost exclusively red meat, and not the things that commonly go with it, it’s quite hard to get fat. Meat is very very satiating.
- nkozyra 6y agoStudy: Exclusive Meat Consumption and Risk of Rickets and Scurvy in Low BMI Individuals
- virtuallynathan 6y agoEat some sardines and cod liver too for vitamin D. Scurvy doesn’t occur, fresh meat contains vitamin C, about 10-15mg per lb.
- oblio 6y agoYeah, but there's also gout.
- virtuallynathan 6y agoEating meat does not seem to cause gout, fructose and ethanol seem to be the big players.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- irjustin 6y agoThe title seems to muddle the conclusion. higher BMI accounted for a substantial proportion of these increased risks suggesting that residual confounding or mediation by adiposity might account for some of these remaining associations. I'm confused. What is a "substantial portion" of the increased risk?
- tralarpa 6y agoYou can see that in table 6ff in the "additional file 1" (it's a docx file). For example, before adjustement for the BMI, the increase of ischemic heart disease per 70g/daily red and processed meat consumption is 1.26 (model 2). With BMI adjustment (model 3) it's 1.15.
- fastball 6y agoI'm just gonna say it: epidemiological studies suck and we need something better. Humans and their lives are just too multi-variate, even with nearly ~500k people in a study. All you end up with are correlations – I've basically never seen a study like this that manages to demonstrate causality convincingly.
- nextos 6y agoTo infer causality you need interventions. Although there are some methods to infer causal relationships from observational data (e.g. see Pearl or Spirtes' work, which is ignored by most epidemiologists). I think the biggest problem is that they are not measuring low level molecular variables like metabolites, or abundances of gut bacteria. Hence, it's pretty hard to infer a causal chain. And since controlling for covariates is so hard, inferring something useful is difficult.
- hntrader 6y ago> controlling for covariates is so hard Especially when the purported effects are small/clinically insignificant.
- diydsp 6y agoThe gold standard to establish causation is the 2x blind random placebo-controlled study. There are many of them assessing various types of foods, from meat to lychee to soy and everything in between. Many biomarkers in the body can be studied such as stress hormones, markers of inflammation, lipid panels, arterial wall thickness, etc. If you poke around on youtube, you can find smart people presenting this research! Most of them are health influencers. Personally, I follow Drs. Gregor, Rhonda Patrick, Fung, Mike Hetzel Thoms Delauer and the rest of this particular cohort. They all have their separate biases and areas of interest, such as fasting, muscle gain, veganism, grass-fed beef, ketosis, etc, but if you find the intersection of their work, you'll have an excellent idea what is good and bad for you and how much you can get away with! To distill two of the most valuable things I've learned: 1. The Mediterranean diet seems to be the healthiest and closest to the Western and American diets, although its actual form has some key differences from the received wisdom. In particular, its pasta is a whole-grain variety and the fish consumption is less than once per day. 2. Most people are not fat-adapted and their bodies do a poor job of metabolizing fat! Typically this requires fasting or other forms of intermittent ketosis to get the body producing fat-burning enzymes. This is likely the source of a lot of conflicting info on fat. It's perfectly excellent for you - if you are fat-adapted, you will use it for energy and won't experience 3pm brainfog. But if you're not, it will very quickly create adipose tissue (body fat!) that continuously emits cytokines (poison) that sabotage your health. 3. Stress alters our metabolism for the worse! Since so many of us are stressed we're not performing proper digestion and not getting the right benefits from what we eat! Breathing exercises, etc. can help improve this.
- amarant 6y agoGood study! Results aren't terribly surprising, but verification needs doing too!I for one applaud it!
- jtdev 6y agoI see that Bill Gates has moved on from forcing elderly people with Coronavirus into nursing homes and is now fixated on telling us what we can eat.
- samblr 6y agoWish there was a better way to represent these stats.
- zpeti 6y agoSo, for someone who isn't good at reading scientific papers - if my BMI is low but I consume a lot of meat, how much worse is that than being vegetarian?
- qayxc 6y agoNo one can say. It depends on many factors: your general health, age, genetic disposition, the composition of the rest of your diet, your general lifestyle (e.g. exercise, drug consumption, social status, mental health, ...). If you are a homeless drug addict, being a vegan or vegetarian won't help improving your overall health. Likewise, being a well-off employed young individual in a stable and happy relationship who does regular health-checkups is more than enough to counter the daily 250g rare steak...
- vlod 6y agoDepends what kind of death you're trying to avoid. :) BMI is not the 100% indicator of being healthy. i.e. you can still be 'skinny as a rake' and be type-2 diabetic.
- vharuck 6y ago>Higher consumption of unprocessed red and processed meat combined was associated with higher risks of... pneumonia (1.31, 1.18-1.44 [95% CI]) That surprised me. The article later gives a hypothesis that plentiful iron is good for pathogens, citing a separate and interesting article: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23684303 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23684303
- hfsp 6y agoLet's follow the money. Said "scientific study" is funded by Wellcome. An arm of WHO, unelected crisis manufacturer supreme. On wellcome's site: "Reducing meat intake, particularly in the USA where meat consumption is highest, should be a global priority." Show me the incentives and I'll show you the outcome.
- boldslogan 6y agoCan you link to the part of Wellcome being against meat consumption? They look like a charity about vaccination or such? I couldn't find anything here about meat consumption: https://wellcome.org/about-us https://wellcome.org/about-us
- nathanasmith 6y agoThe page on the site with the specific quote by GP is here: https://wellcome.org/grant-funding/people-and-projects/grants-awarded/reducing-meat-intake-mitigate-climate-change-and https://wellcome.org/grant-funding/people-and-projects/grant... You may already realize this but if you type site:wellcome.org "Reducing meat intake, particularly in the USA where meat consumption is highest, should be a global priority." into Google you'll find it.
- boldslogan 6y agothanks, didn't know that.
- La1n 6y ago>This work was supported by the Wellcome Trust, Our Planet Our Health (Livestock, Environment and People - LEAP) [grant number 205212/Z/16/Z]; Cancer Research UK [grant numbers C8211/A19170 and C8211/A29017]; and the UK Medical Research Council [grant number MR/M012190/1]. AP-C is supported by a Cancer Research UK Population Research Fellowship [grant number C60192/A28516] and by the World Cancer Research Fund (WCRF UK), as part of the WCRF International grant programme [grant number 2019/1953]. And cancer research. But you didn't bring that up. edit: Also not "An arm of WHO", they partner with them cause priorities (public health) are aligned.
- pfortuny 6y agoCaveat: UK citizens all of them. Not the best country for an healthy diet.
- simonsarris 6y agoAlmost all studies of this kind are extremely confounded because food survey data is close to universally bad. It is especially bad on this topic in the US and UK, because many people's idea of a serving of meat is actually closer to fried breaded bread, with condiment levels of meat on top. It would be crazy to lump those people in with the "steak and eggs for dinner 3 times a week" crowd, but they always are. Results are different, often opposite, in countries that have a better relationship to meat, like the big Austrian food survey study from 2014: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3917888/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3917888/ > Moreover, our results showed that a vegetarian diet is associated with poorer health (higher incidences of cancer, allergies, and mental health disorders), a higher need for health care, and poorer quality of life. Other survey data across several countries often replicate the meatless = lower mental health claims, eg: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10408398.2020.1741505 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10408398.2020.1... (This should come as no surprise to people who have read about B12 and mental health, which is a relationship so extraordinary that I'm surprised its not more front-and-center.) But again, food survey data is generally bad. Some are okay, when they are very focused, like the Swedish studies on dairy product consumption. But most of them are bad, and the more general, the worse they are.
- blfr 6y agoFood surveys and food diaries are hilariously bad[1]. I'm surprised any studies based on them are still getting published. There was literally a reality TV show in England based around how terribly inaccurate food diaries are. It's on YouTube[2]. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4527547/figure/F1/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4527547/figure/... [2] https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=secret+eaters https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=secret+eaters
- jtdev 6y agoStudies like this are published for political reasons, not scientific reasons. I wouldn't be surprised if the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation is behind this study.
- johndoe42377 6y agoWhat would we do with Tibetans, Chinese, Pakistanis and other meat eating cultures? Oh, there are other factors?
- rcpt 6y agoI don't know what it is about diet research but it seems to really bring out strong opinions on hackernews. Given that we're the target market for Soylent I guess it makes sense.
- ddorian43 6y agoIn some forums, when you want to post something about body-building,training or what to eat, you also have to post your body picture. Keep that in mind whenever you hear opinions about food.
- foxhop 6y agoThat's a great point. Let's do a real study with real people and real diets, collect their blood type, an auto immune disorders, any allergies or food intolerance. Bundle that with a relevant body photo.
- tpush 6y agoAny thread about nutrition devolves to an absolute shit show.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoMost nutrition research is bad. Everybody gets a chance to espouse their favorite theories in the comments. How could it be otherwise? Doing good research in this space is expensive.
- bookmarkable 6y agoThey'll keep coming after meat eating with every angle - health, ecology, economics, emotional appeals - but humans can live a long, healthy life with meat in their diet. That doesn't mean industrial burgers daily or portions that look like a carnival hot dog eating contest, but 4 to 6 oz of quality meat from animals is healthy. I think the US especially would be far better served to appeal to people to reduce portion sizes rather than insist on industrialized plant based food. Minimally processed foods in smaller portions is far more sustainable and healthier than vegan radicalism and scientifically formulated plant-based edible substances.
- aquaticsunset 6y agoIf you can figure out how to successfully market and sell "Eat less, eat quality" to American consumers while maintaining food supplier revenue growth, you'll solve a lot of problems. My personal opinion is that we're so growth and value oriented - and that's fundamentally incompatible with a healthy diet. Look at CostCo! They have an amazing amount of fresh, healthy meats and vegetables. But you're still walking out of that store with a twelve-pack of fish and the barrel of cheese puffs you saw on the way out. The majority of Americans simply lack the self control. The food production companies know this and take full advantage of it.
- bookmarkable 6y agoI think it has been figured out, it is just heavily lobbied against. In general, you have to flip normal. Every time I get my Butcherbox pasture raised beef out of the freezer, I'm aggravated they have to print "pasture raised"... that should be the standard, not the luxury brand. A few ideas off the cuff... - Make food companies label non-organic food and say why they aren't organic, vs. making organic declare themselves, certify and therefore cost more. - Raise minimum grades on beef and poultry. Low grade meat is the only way to make large portions work economically. - Require food with meat ingredients to list what grade of meat is being used, hormone use, etc. - Disallow mixing of multiple animals in ground meat products... or at least cap it. Right now, fast food works because you can grind up hundreds of cattle at once.
- giantg2 6y agoI ate an 8oz bag of potato chips and an 8oz can of onion dip for dinner last night. Just wanted to throw out there how healthy my vegetarian dinner was.
- TheButlerian 6y agoOk soyboys. Why don't you feed me the finest cuts of meat and let me drink the finest wines...then sit and watch me die.
- magwa101 6y agoHigh temperature cooking of meat produces all sorts of toxic chemicals. Feed lot meat has a poor Omega fat balance. Grass fed, cook on low heat (pressure cooker is actually just 240°). I'd like to see that study.
- foxhop 6y agoI feel strongly that people should eat based on their blood type. For example O type appear to do best with a meat based diet. Blood type A should eat more plant based diet. Human bodies are N+1, each body is different, there is not one diet to rule them all. Please be mindful of what you are eating and how it makes you feel. Get in touch with your unconscious and body.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoSo, eat red meat for the iron, but not so much it makes you fat (and sick).
- phkahler 6y agoI am sceptical due to this: and most of the positive associations observed for meat consumption and health risks were substantially attenuated after adjustment for body mass index (BMI). I didnt read all the details, but that seems like a sneaky way to invalidate the benefits of eating meat. If sounds like the benefits correlate with low BMI, so they want to dismiss them. But what if eating meat helps one to maintain a low BMI? Suddenly the picture is cloudy. As for heart disease, there is always the iodine rabbit experiment from the 1930s.
- DC1350 6y agoI’m interested in seeing what kind of research gets released once we find out how cheap it is to make bug patties from harvesting locust swarms.
- boatsie 6y agoSo, fat is bad. Carbs are bad. Meat is bad. Assuming you eat calories (ie leafy vegetables are not a large source of calories), what are you left with? Plant based low fat, low carb lean protein? Peanuts are high in fat. Beans are high in carbs. There’s like nothing you really should eat.
- Karawebnetwork 6y agoYou should eat a diversified diet and with moderation. All of those are not necessarily bad. Take peanuts for example, they are a great tool to reach certain goals. But eating only peanuts every day would make you ill quickly.
- vlod 6y agoI think I read what would our poor great-great-grandparents think of the food we eat today? What did they eat, meat rarely (they couldn't afford it all the time), mostly vegetables (mostly home grown), salad-stuff, beans, maybe fruit and the odd nut. Maybe going back to this direction, is the way we should be leaning.
- wly_cdgr 6y agoNow that there is money at scale to be made from vegetarianism, this will all be over quickly