6 ms·
Kicking people out of their homes doesn't solve the supply problem, because it doesn't create new housing. It just shuffles around who lives in existing houses.
by vkou 6y ago
Kicking people out of their homes doesn't solve the supply problem, because it doesn't create new housing. It just shuffles around who lives in existing houses.
If you have a housing problem, and you want to solve it, you need to do two things.
1. Not kick people out of housing that they have. (Because it is incredibly disruptive to people's lives.)
2. Build new housing, until demand is met.
Rent control accomplishes #1, proper city planning accomplishes #2. If you're not doing #2, complaining about #1 isn't going to solve the problem.
If you are doing #2, then #1 isn't a problem.
- kmeisthax 6y agoYou can't do #2 without doing #1 - most in-demand land is already occupied and unused land is typically not worth developing (or doing so would cause environmental harm). In an all-owner-occupant suburb, this isn't so much of a problem: you're literally paying people lots of money to accept the disruption of having to move. However, in almost every other kind of housing arrangement, ownership over the building is separate from occupancy, and it's not the occupant's choice to make regarding increasing the housing supply. This is the left-NIMBY trap: any action to increase housing units necessarily displaces the most marginalized parts of society. If your pro-development policy doesn't include a plan to house people who are being displaced without increasing their expenses, then you're likely to make people start protesting the new buildings that need to be built in order to accommodate demand and actually cap rent growth. Other than that, yes. Make housing printer go brrr.
- zamfi 6y agoThis is one of the most reasoned explanations of the key problem where development meets rent control that I've ever read. If you turned it into a longer piece that explored the monetary and non-monetary incentives on all sides I would send it to everyone thinking about this issue. If I can help please let me know.
- ghaff 6y agoThis is the bulldoze the Mission and replace it with at least midrises plan. But it will be fine. For tech people.
- stale2002 6y ago> you can't do #2 without doing #1 Of course you can. The law can be that normally rent control applies, but if you are building a new building, that doubles the amount of housing supply on the land, you can kick out the existing residents if you pay them a large payout. This would allow new housing to built in the obvious places where it should be, and the obvious cases where a huge amount of new housing is planned to be built.
- kmeisthax 6y agoI'd actually totally love to see this proposed in more left-leaning city councils. This is sort of the idea I've had in my head for how to short-circuit the left-NIMBY trap, but I have no idea how good or bad it would actually be at moving the needle in favor of growth. Part of the problem I could see right off the bat would be the fact that owners and occupants are inherently antagonized to one another; as in, the more money you require to be given as a displacement subsidy; the less is available to actually incentivize land development. Of course, in places like SF the market rate for housing is so hilariously high that there might actually be enough money for both parties, at least for a little while.
- kelnos 6y agoAnother idea might be to require that the developer first offer to rent a unit in the new building to all the old tenants, at their old rent, if they want to move back after construction is complete. A side-effect is that this doesn't encourage the developer to build something nicer than what was already there. But in some cases that might actually be a good thing. But yeah, these sorts of things generally reduce the amount of money available to do the new development in the first place. But maybe that's ok too?
- throwaway12903 6y agoI don't think it's about housing supply. People want to live in the city and in desirable suburbs. These suburbs have existing tenants who could not afford the market rate of rent today. Gentrification basically. The question is how much should existing tenants be entitled to their apartments just because they lived there for a long time, balanced against the impact on investment in new real-estate because of lack of incentives due to earning caps.
- jdxcode 6y agoThe major flaw in your argument is that you can't do #2 with rent control in the picture. From the economist[0]: > Rent controls are a textbook example of a well-intentioned policy that does not work. They deter the supply of good-quality rental housing. With rents capped, building new homes becomes less profitable. Even maintaining existing properties is discouraged because landlords see no return for their investment. Renters stay put in crumbling properties because controls often reset when tenants change. Who occupies housing ends up bearing little relation to who can make best use of it (ie, workers well-suited to local job opportunities). The mismatch reduces economy-wide productivity. The longer a tenant stays put, the bigger the disparity between the market rent and his payments, sharpening the incentive not to move. [0] https://www.economist.com/leaders/2019/09/19/rent-control-will-make-housing-shortages-worse https://www.economist.com/leaders/2019/09/19/rent-control-wi...
- swiley 6y agoGermany is one of the counties that tries to avoid getting themselves into situations where a violent revolution is the best path forward for most young people. I'm sure they'll figure this one out.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Rent controls are a textbook example of a well-intentioned policy that does not work. They deter the supply of good-quality rental housing. With rents capped, building new homes becomes less profitable. Rent control tends to be adopted with the fairly explicit goal of prioritizing affordability for existing tenants in their current residences over either encouraging maintenance/updates or improving housing supply for people who aren't current tenants, so I don't think it's at all a policy that doesn't work. A policy whose purposes are at odds with other, arguably more important, policy goals, sure, and possibly even with other more important, if less inmediate, interests of current tenants. But saying it “doesn’t work” bases on it not encouraging things it is not meant to encourage is...not really useful.
- edbob 6y agoYour technical analysis is correct as usual, but I agree with sologoub's comment[0], "That’s not success, that’s picking winners and losers." [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26316547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26316547
- HotHotLava 6y agoEven if you put all of your efforts into #2, it will take years from the decision to ramp up the planning and construction efforts until enough houses are actually built to have a noticeable impact on the market. And you still have to do something about the situation in the meantime. That's why the rent freeze in Berlin is limited to 5 years.