4 ms·
I'm not speculating at all. The article has the data to back the facts : house prices went down in Berlin. Yes, homes can go up on speculation alone, but this
by sudosysgen 6y ago
I'm not speculating at all. The article has the data to back the facts : house prices went down in Berlin.
Yes, homes can go up on speculation alone, but this is a bubble that will pop. In North America, rising rents act as a backstop that prevent the bubble from popping, because of guaranteed rental incomes that protect you.
It's not possible to create an insane level of supply for appartment rentals. There's two reasons for this. Firstly, there's the obvious limit to how much you can build within a reasonable commute time with reasonable infrastructure at a good quality of life. Secondly, studies have shown that 10% increases in supply lead to 1% decreases in price, more or less. Coupled with 4% rent increases over inflation every year, it's just not feasible to rely on additional supply.
In the real world, free markets lead to rent increasing right up until the level where too many people are in poverty due to high rent. That's because the natural increase in rent is simply too high to be counterbalanced by supply.
That's why from the worst planned cities to the very densest like Hong Kong, housing stays more or less as expensive as it can be without people moving out due to poverty.
The only solution is to make real estate a barely profitable or depreciating asset. This is done here by aggressive rent control. As renting stops being so affordable, apartments are sold, homeownership increases, and renting becomes something you do to prevent depreciation, not to make profit.
Crucially though, here, building more apartments stays profitable, because they can go to homeowners or to people who buy housing as a stable asset (and then rent it out). Coupled with public housing, you can get the best possible trade-off.
- gruez 6y ago> I'm not speculating at all. The article has the data to back the facts : house prices went down in Berlin. but supply has dropped as well. Freezing food prices would also drop food prices, but won't stop bread lines. >Yes, homes can go up on speculation alone, but this is a bubble that will pop. In North America, rising rents act as a backstop that prevent the bubble from popping, because of guaranteed rental incomes that protect you. Not exactly. Price-to-rent ratios are above 30 in major north american cities, reaching as high as 50 in SF. While future cashflows might provide some backstop in terms of your investment, that's really not much of a consolation when you can be doubling your money roughly every 20 years with stocks. >In the real world, free markets lead to rent increasing right up until the level where too many people are in poverty due to high rent. That's because the natural increase in rent is simply too high to be counterbalanced by supply. >The only solution is to make real estate a barely profitable or depreciating asset. This is done here by aggressive rent control. As renting stops being so affordable, apartments are sold, homeownership increases, and renting becomes something you do to prevent depreciation, not to make profit. I'm not sure how rent control fixes this. If you have 1M families but only 100,000 plots of land, they're going bid up the price until enough people can't afford it. This dynamic is in play regardless of whether there are landlords or not.
- joshuaissac 6y ago> when you can be doubling your money roughly every 20 years with stocks. With housing, a poorly-capitalised speculator can get a mortgage to buy property, and pay it off using rental income, with a deposit of maybe 15-20% of the value of the property. This lets them capture the price increase on a multiple of their deposit. It is much harder to do something similar with the stock market and loans. Amount loaned would be lower and interest rates higher.
- sudosysgen 6y agoNowhere does it say that supply has dropped. If renting is less profitable, then supply of houses to be sold will actually go up. The ability to rent is not the primary driver of speculation. But it drastically lowers downside risk, which gives less incentive for anyone to pop the bubble. >I'm not sure how rent control fixes this. If you have 1M families but only 100,000 plots of land, they're going bid up the price until enough people can't afford it. This dynamic is in play regardless of whether there are landlords or not. Well, empirically, it does fix it, doesn't it?
- awillen 6y ago"If renting is less profitable, then supply of houses to be sold will actually go up." You wrongly assume that the landlord gets to make this choice. In this situation, the landlord does not - the tenant does. If renting is made more attractive by rent control, then fewer renters move out and supply is thus lessened.
- selimthegrim 6y agoYou could try the Japanese solution of treating houses like cars, with strict inspections and tearing down/rebuilding essentially buying a new one every 10-20 years. (Obviously they can't export the used houses so it's not a complete analogy)
- ProfessorLayton 6y ago>Secondly, studies have shown that 10% increases in supply lead to 1% decreases in price, more or less. Source? This also hand waves the fact that a 1% decrease is still great in the face of say, a 4% increase, totaling a 5% spread — even more if factoring in inflation. Sounds like increasing supply is still one of the best ways to keep prices in check.
- sudosysgen 6y agoI don't have the time to dig up the study, but it already factored in inflation. Even with a 5% spread, to hold off real rent increases for ten years, you'd need to increase housing by 116%. Which is completely unrealistic. This rent control policy had the same effect as reversing 12 years of rent increases, which would require you to multiply supply by 2.5 over those twelve years. Needless to say, this is not possible. Increasing supply is assuredly important and necessary for keeping prices in check. But it will have a much smaller impact than rent control. The main purpose it will serve is to make sure mobility is still good.
- ProfessorLayton 6y agoThe affordability crisis many cities are facing are not caused by the fact that rent increases exist, it's that they're increasing faster than wage increases. One does not need to hold off rent increases for an arbitrary amount of time, they just have to stay inline with wages to remain affordable. With that in mind, it is certainly not impossible to build enough to keep up with job/wage growth. I agree that no single policy can fix everything, but the current status quo of pitting the haves (rent control) vs. have-nots (newcomers/movers) is not working.
- sudosysgen 6y agohttps://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us-workers-real-wages-have-barely-budged-for-decades/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us... The average hourly US wage has not increased or barely so. Therefore, the inflation adjustment done above corrects for it. If you want rent increases to stay in line with wages, they will need to be held off entirely.
- 762236 6y agoBased on what I've seen elsewhere in Germany, Berlin will start seeing lots of empty apartments now that it is too much of a gamble whether you'll earn profit renting (since Germany's laws protect the renter more than the landlord, which you can combat with a portfolio of properties that earn a certain level of rent to cover the non-paying tenant that you can't evict), and because there isn't much of a good reason to sell (maybe in a few years things improve, or maybe the apartment is useful for family, or one's own future retirement home).
- bluGill 6y ago> It's not possible to create an insane level of supply for appartment rentals This is technically true, but not for the reasons you list, and it isn't the case here. You can always build up. 150 floor buildings are not possible - if rent goes high enough they are worth building. Nobody is going to build that if they don't expect a return on investment though. It isn't a problem in reality because jobs face the same pressures. eventually some company will decide rent in those dense neighborhoods (sometimes cities as well) are too high, and move. That moves some housing demand with it. Secondly, studies have shown that 10% increases in supply lead to 1% decreases in price, more or less. Coupled with 4% rent increases over inflation every year, it's just not feasible to rely on additional supply. That doesn't follow. To build more supply the question how much it costs to build vs how much you can rent for. A a landlord the total profit in rent for the city isn't my concern it is my marginal profit that matters. Even if we double the supply of apartments in the city, my building 100 more isn't going to make much a difference in that, but I get a larger share of that 10% decrease in price and so my profit is still higher building 100 apartments than zero. I don't know what is going on in Berlin (I can guess). I know in San Francisco the city has for many years refused to allow building at anywhere close to demand. Thus more people want to live in the city than actually can get an apartment there. Plenty of builders are willing to build more supply, but they are not allowed to under reasonable terms so they don't. (as a result of this there is a lack of experienced people in construction and so even if SF allowed unlimited building in practice there would only be a gradual uptick in building over 10 years while the industry gets experienced people back)
- sudosysgen 6y agoYou are assuming that the only reason anyone would build is to rent things out. This ridiculous. A great many constructions are for people that own their houses. That alone solves the conundrum.
- chipsa 6y agoIt doesn't in SF, because the problem there is that they can't reasonably build anything. Whether it's a house or an apartment building, it's not really getting built. And building a new house to replace an existing house (which is happening), doesn't increase housing stock. It just makes it newer.
- imtringued 6y ago>Secondly, studies have shown that 10% increases in supply lead to 1% decreases in price, more or less. That's more than enough to justify building an infinite amount of housing.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIs that a joke? You... can't build an infinite amount of housing. That's the reason why land is a separate asset class.
- brutusborn 6y agoThat's not the only solution. Georgist policies do the same thing without disincentivising developmemt.