6 ms·
This is not how it works. Without the possibility to rent out or consolidate homeownership, the inflationary pressure on home prices collapses. You create an i
by sudosysgen 6y ago
This is not how it works. Without the possibility to rent out or consolidate homeownership, the inflationary pressure on home prices collapses.
You create an insane level amount of supply for homeownership on this market. An absolutely insane level.
Indeed, the vast majority of increase in housing prices is because rents are so high that 7% YoY returns are possible. Without these returns, then there is no way to justify inflation in housing prices for simple homeowners.
If somehow millions of people do buy houses in Berlin, then you build public housing to undercut the price of housing.
The idea that your scenario will happen is not really rooted in fact. To me, it seems like a way to rationalize the principle that rent control must always fail - whereas in the real world it doesn't, see Vienna.
Homeownership in Berlin is very low, at 17% or so. The absolute majority of the housing market is based on renting out units. Before saturation of homeownership happens, a gulf remains.
- gruez 6y ago>This is not how it works. Without the possibility to rent out or consolidate homeownership, the inflationary pressure on home prices collapses. No, as we seen in north america that's not really true. Homes can go up on speculation alone. >You create an insane level amount of supply for homeownership on this market. An absolutely insane level. Is homeownership a necessary component of this? Creating a insane level of supply for apartment rental achieves the same thing. If there are more units then there are renters, prices have to fall to meet demand.
- tom_mellior 6y ago> If there are more units then there are renters, prices have to fall to meet demand. Not if it's so cheap to keep empty apartments around that you would rather not make money now, in the hope that you will be able to make more money in the future. It's not exactly the same, but around here there is a huge oversupply of spaces for shops/restaurants. Owners prefer to keep them empty rather than have someone give them money. EDIT: Well, maybe it's not actually oversupply. There might actually be a lot of demand, but not at the excessive prices landlords demand.
- gruez 6y ago>Not if it's so cheap to keep empty apartments around that you would rather not make money now, in the hope that you will be able to make more money in the future. Ironically rent control laws that cause this. Accepting a lower rent now would mean locking in a lower monthly rate for the future, whereas if you left it empty you can hope that the rental market will recover and charge high rents in the future.
- brmgb 6y agoIf only the state could heavily tax empty apartments and cap resell price to counter that. But wait, it actually can. Pushing renters and speculators out of the housing markets in favor of people who actually want to settle in the city is probably the best you can do as a municipality.
- imtringued 6y agoI must absolutely thank you. I derive personal enjoyment from broken systems and the mass suffering that they produce. Everyone is happy. Isn't that nice?
- brmgb 6y agoMy personal enjoyment is watching people argue against measures which have demonstrably been effective in cities around the world (Vienna, Toronto) based on purely theoritical and ideological reasons while failing to address both their poor understanding a subject underpining their ideology and the fact that the current situation is actually broken.
- tom_mellior 6y agoCommercial spaces aren't rent controlled here, and many of them are empty. Many apartments are rent controlled, and I've never heard of them being empty for any appreciable amount of time.
- 6y ago
- sudosysgen 6y agoI'm not speculating at all. The article has the data to back the facts : house prices went down in Berlin. Yes, homes can go up on speculation alone, but this is a bubble that will pop. In North America, rising rents act as a backstop that prevent the bubble from popping, because of guaranteed rental incomes that protect you. It's not possible to create an insane level of supply for appartment rentals. There's two reasons for this. Firstly, there's the obvious limit to how much you can build within a reasonable commute time with reasonable infrastructure at a good quality of life. Secondly, studies have shown that 10% increases in supply lead to 1% decreases in price, more or less. Coupled with 4% rent increases over inflation every year, it's just not feasible to rely on additional supply. In the real world, free markets lead to rent increasing right up until the level where too many people are in poverty due to high rent. That's because the natural increase in rent is simply too high to be counterbalanced by supply. That's why from the worst planned cities to the very densest like Hong Kong, housing stays more or less as expensive as it can be without people moving out due to poverty. The only solution is to make real estate a barely profitable or depreciating asset. This is done here by aggressive rent control. As renting stops being so affordable, apartments are sold, homeownership increases, and renting becomes something you do to prevent depreciation, not to make profit. Crucially though, here, building more apartments stays profitable, because they can go to homeowners or to people who buy housing as a stable asset (and then rent it out). Coupled with public housing, you can get the best possible trade-off.
- gruez 6y ago> I'm not speculating at all. The article has the data to back the facts : house prices went down in Berlin. but supply has dropped as well. Freezing food prices would also drop food prices, but won't stop bread lines. >Yes, homes can go up on speculation alone, but this is a bubble that will pop. In North America, rising rents act as a backstop that prevent the bubble from popping, because of guaranteed rental incomes that protect you. Not exactly. Price-to-rent ratios are above 30 in major north american cities, reaching as high as 50 in SF. While future cashflows might provide some backstop in terms of your investment, that's really not much of a consolation when you can be doubling your money roughly every 20 years with stocks. >In the real world, free markets lead to rent increasing right up until the level where too many people are in poverty due to high rent. That's because the natural increase in rent is simply too high to be counterbalanced by supply. >The only solution is to make real estate a barely profitable or depreciating asset. This is done here by aggressive rent control. As renting stops being so affordable, apartments are sold, homeownership increases, and renting becomes something you do to prevent depreciation, not to make profit. I'm not sure how rent control fixes this. If you have 1M families but only 100,000 plots of land, they're going bid up the price until enough people can't afford it. This dynamic is in play regardless of whether there are landlords or not.
- criticaljudge 6y agoYou assume prices were merely driven by greedy landlords. That is of course untrue. Prices were driven up by the popularity of the city, with people seeking a place to rent outbidding each other and bidding prices up. That demand will not simply go away, but newcomers will have to buy instead to rent. Or, there will be a huge black market. I've read an article about Stockholm were that seems to be what has happened. A big irony is that the left who created the law has hurt some of their staunchest supporters, who did subsist by subletting their flats, which they had rented at old, low prices. That income is now also going away - it is not just "greedy rich speculators", but also transgender artists getting by on minimum income from subletting their flats whom they have hurt. It is of course possible to lower prices by making the city less attractive. Socialism has succeeded in doing that already once, that is why Berlin was so cheap in the 90ies.
- awillen 6y ago"You create an insane level amount of supply for homeownership on this market. An absolutely insane level." You're completely ignoring the fact that homeownership, even if prices aren't incredibly high, requires a large down payment that many people don't have, which is why they rent. Those people still can't afford to buy and are pushed out, and they're the ones you're supposed to be helping. "If somehow millions of people do buy houses in Berlin, then you build public housing to undercut the price of housing." This is where your argument totally loses steam. You can't just handwave and say you'll build public housing... that is an incredibly expensive and politically difficult thing to do. When your theoretical solution to the problem is something that is very much not guaranteed (or even likely), and you pretend it'll just be no problem at all, you're ignoring reality and not presenting a useful solution.
- sudosysgen 6y agoPublic housing is neither incredibly expensive nor politically difficult as long as you have a competent government and laws that don't artificially make it more expensive (see: US). The economics are very simple. The price of housing if it's not profitable to rent and even less profitable to hold will drop until occupancy is high. Those that can't put down a down payment will rent, the others will buy. If not, the price will just continue to go down. This argument isn't theoretical. It's an actual process that has been done and works.
- brutusborn 6y agoWhere abouts does it work currently and do you have any data to support this? I'm genuinely curious. Also don't forget about renters keeping tennancies vacant temporarily, to avoid losing their locked in rent control rate. I have heard many stories of affluent people keeping a "cheap" apartment in New York vacant for years on end.
- tormeh 6y ago> This is where your argument totally loses steam. You can't just handwave and say you'll build public housing... that is an incredibly expensive and politically difficult thing to do. When your theoretical solution to the problem is something that is very much not guaranteed (or even likely), and you pretend it'll just be no problem at all, you're ignoring reality and not presenting a useful solution. Just issue municipal bonds, and use that money to build. Investors pay the German government to hold their money. Building is not expensive at all.
- tormeh 6y ago> Indeed, the vast majority of increase in housing prices is because rents are so high that 7% YoY returns are possible. Without these returns, then there is no way to justify inflation in housing prices for simple homeowners. The market is constrained by supply, which is constrained by regulation. If you want to see how this works without any rental market, look at Oslo. The prices are truly something else.
- imtringued 6y agoIf there are 1000 units and they are being rented out then people are more willing to move to a residence that suits their needs better. When it makes sense people move away. Once you add rent control people might stay simply because of the low rent, even if they are fully capable of paying market rate rent. They might have to commute to the edge of town and it still is a better deal for them. You get a stagnant housing market where people rarely move. The vacancy rate goes down and instead of renters always being able to at least visit an apartment with the fair chance of competing with say 5 people at most you now have dozens of renters all looking at the same apartment. This gives the land lord more power to charge higher prices and since he has to cancel out the losses from existing rent controlled apartments he might not even have a choice and simply increases the rates when possible. The problem is that the land lord is being put under more pressure to perform and thus he becomes more selective and only gets the "best" tenants which favors the wealthy. Of course, all those people getting paying dirt cheap rent are happy since they benefit personally from an externality.
- llampx 6y agoThe inflationary pressure on Berlin housing prices has definitely not collapsed at any time in the last 10 years.