7 ms·
> In a food shortage, for example, regulating the price of bread only trades one expression of scarcity (high prices) for another (empty shelves). This is the
by robertlagrant 6y ago
> In a food shortage, for example, regulating the price of bread only trades one expression of scarcity (high prices) for another (empty shelves).
This is the key statement to refute if you want to argue for rent control.
- tom_mellior 6y ago"Proof by analogy is fraud." -- Bjarne Stroustrup Even if you don't fully agree with this quote, claiming that only arguments by analogy can ever be valid arguments for rent control is... surprising.
- crote 6y agoIf the bread price explodes, poor people will starve and the rest of the population ends up paying a boatload of money to the lucky few bakers. If the bread price remains stationary, people will starve randomly. People are going to starve either way, why not skip the whole "make the bakers filthy rich" part?
- krcz 6y agoWhen the price explodes, bakers may hire more people and bake bread during night and day, increasing the supply.
- sudosysgen 6y agoYes, they do this even if the price only goes up 3-4x, it's not needed for the price to increase thousandfold. Also, this doesn't really apply to housing.
- krcz 6y agoI fully agree, thousandfold price increases would suggest that processes that control prices in free market system had become unstable. In such cases I'd agree with state intervention. Fortunately it doesn't happen that often. > Also, this doesn't really apply to housing. Correct, it's more complex there and some of the reasons are mentioned in the article.
- La1n 6y agoAnd Berlin needed rent control exactly because this didn't happen.
- alacombe 6y agoThat's petty resentment right here found in both communist ethics and catholicism... "if I can't get filthy rich, nobody shall be". If the bakers gets filthy rich, kudos on them !
- dahart 6y agoWhy? That argument doesn’t address the fact that many cities have an absolute limit on supply in the form of space, and no amount of construction that starts today will bring prices down today. Here are some arguments to refute if you want to oppose rent control, particularly the first one (copied and pasted directly from investopedia): “Rental prices in many U.S. cities are rising far faster than wages for moderate-income jobs. [edit: note here that most of the US has banned rent control, and this is happening regardless] “Rent control enables moderate-income families and elderly people on fixed incomes to live decently and without fear of a personally catastrophic rent hike. “Neighborhoods are safer and more stable with a base of long-term residents in rent-controlled apartments.”
- bradleybuda 6y agoBerlin has 4,227 inhabitants/km², Hong Kong (widely considered to be a very livable city, and also one with hard geographic constraints on expansion) has 6,300. So we have existence proof that Berlin, if it chose to, could support an increase in housing of 50% or so, which would certainly drive rents way down. Edit: Not sure why I looked so far away, Paris is at 21,000. Like virtually every housing story, this is an example of the people who live in a place deciding they don't want anyone else to live there, and putting up economic walls that only the rich can surmount.
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago>Hong Kong widely considered to be a very livable city By whom? Ricchie McRich? Every working class Hong Konger I talked to (even highly skilled ones) said living there is cramped and brutally expensive and would like to emigrate.
- tom_mellior 6y ago> Berlin has 4,227 inhabitants/km² [...] Paris is at 21,000. These numbers aren't comparable: The municipality of Paris is just the small urban core of a much larger metropolitan region. Berlin has about 3.7 million inhabitants on 890 square kilometers, Paris 2.2 million on 105 square kilometers. A fairer comparison is with the Petite Couronne consisting of Paris + the innermost ring of its neighbors (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%8Ele-de-France#Petite_Couronne https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%8Ele-de-France#Petite_Cour...), which has 6.7 million people on 760 square kilometers. Still denser than Berlin! But the ratio is far less extreme than you made it look. For an alternative approach, take Berlin's densest districts: Friedrichshain-Kreuzberg, Mitte, and Neukölln add up to about 100 square kilometers (like Paris) and a bit over a million people. So about 2x less dense than Paris rather than 5x.
- lasagnaphil 6y agoOkay, I'll try. Given the unmeasurable social costs of people starving and dying when there isn't enough food (you can say similarily for people not having houses and freezing to death when there's a blizzard, but also read the sidenote at the end), the capitalists involved in selling and distributing food should not be compensated equally in monetary terms (by selling at higher prices) when there is a shortage of food, since they are the ones at fault of not having reserve resources and prepare their production line from various disasters such as storms and droughts. Even people from the ancient times built and used granaries to store food for years and opened it up to their fellow villagers when storms/droughts happen (even without any profit motives, there wasn't even a notion of "profit" at all!) Capitalists in the current era should prepare far better than them, as our knowledge of biology, climate, and logistics are much more sophisticated than before; a shortage of food should be outright unimaginable given the advanced technology we have. Once there are empty food shelves, the disaster's already happened (at least in the short term you can't materialize food anymore by doing smart "economics"), and really at that dire point capitalists don't deserve the right to receive profit in the same way as normal times. If the moral argument for this doesn't convince you - then there is a much more convincable political argument (of "dialectical materialism"), which basically goes as: once basic things like food and shelter aren't a given, and then capitalists gouge prices up creating an even bigger moral catastrophe among the poor, enough people would be fucking mad at them and band together wreck shit up, and some people would eventually have their heads cut off (as happened in many points in society, for example the French revolution). It's only that the current structures of power (the state & capital) are much more powerful than the past that this is more unlikely to happen, but if I were really in power I wouldn't dare try to steer closer to this event, as bloodshed doesn't really feel that good to participate. And that's the most uncontroversial center-wing take I can create. Sidenote: I think your analogy of bread isn't really comparable to the housing problem though, since housing acts less of an ideal commodity than food in economic terms. Housing is far more troublesome if you approach it in a free-market lense, since it's far easier to create a natural monopoly on land than anything else, and thus it is hard for free markets to create a "fair" price that matches with the actual use-value. That's why even some libertarians in support of free markets also think economic rent from land is unfair business practice and should be controlled by heavy taxes (such as the economic ideology of Georgism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism)
- La1n 6y agoI think you would first need to show that bread and housing follow the same rules if you want to say that analogy applies to rent control
- robertlagrant 6y agoThis is an odd statement. The claim is - I think correctly - that regulating a price to combat scarcity will never help. Why should this statement apply to bread and not housing, or vice versa?
- AlexandrB 6y agoThis is a silly simplification that posits that sticking the word "market" on something means that it will behave the same way and is beholden to the same forces. The bread "market" and the housing "market" are not comparable in this way. I think a lot more nuance is required for convincing case against (or for) rent control.
- robertlagrant 6y agoSaying "these markets cannot be compared" and "more nuance is required" without justifying either statement is pointless.