7 ms·
For the sake of discussion let's just say Google is broken up. Let's also say that it's broken up such that Google Search, Google Ads, and YouTube are separate
by endisneigh 6y ago
For the sake of discussion let's just say Google is broken up. Let's also say that it's broken up such that Google Search, Google Ads, and YouTube are separate entities (among others).
In this new broken up set of companies, what's stopping them from remerging like Bell? Also, what's stopping them from giving each other favorable partnerships?
Personally I find this entire exercise a waste of time - rather than break up Google we should just acknowledge that certain industries have certain types of attributes that result in necessarily "anti-competitive" behavior. In Google's case, since it's an internet company I would say the more users it has the harder it is to beat - with that being said they should just create some sort of progressive taxation as a function of users.
Your users in the USA equal 90%+ of the country, you are subject to rules A. Your users in the USA equal to <10%? You are subject to rules B and are subsidized directly by those whose users equal 90%+. If all companies are less than 50% than we use rules c, for example.
The same logic could be used for manufacturing, utilities, internet providers, and more.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xapata 6y agoIt's important to note that there are a handful of negative externalities created by market dominance. Even if it's not anticompetitive, it still creates systemic risk. The blast radius of an AWS outage is quite large. The tax should be proportional to the systemic risk created. This holds for tariffs as well. If we are overly reliant on imported facemasks, we should tax them to subsidize a small amount of domestic production in case of catastrophe.
- latch 6y agoAWS is a poor example because they aren't remotely close to having the market dominance of Google. They are more like McDonalds: a huge fish in an ocean. AWS is huge in a segment (cloud) of the industry, but that segment represents a very small % of the overall industry.
- xapata 6y agoBoth AWS and McDonald's are good examples, because we should have a policy that applies at all levels of dominance with no discontinuities. Just as in programming, special cases are (legal) code smells. If the policy can't cleanly handle industry segmentation, it's probably going to fail.
- runeks 6y ago> The blast radius of an AWS outage is quite large. The tax should be proportional to the systemic risk created. I disagree. If in a certain industry we cannot accept the risk incurred by being reliant on AWS we should legislate against that by requiring insurance.
- xapata 6y ago> requiring insurance That's effectively a tax, outsourcing collection to insurance companies. I'm fine with that, too.
- toast0 6y ago> In this new broken up set of companies, what's stopping them from remerging like Bell? Also, what's stopping them from giving each other favorable partnerships? The terms of the consent decree or judgement that gets issued. In terms of partnerships, the terms should require that all deals between the babyGs should be public, and a non-discriminatory, non-exclusive basis; along with requirements for some of the babyGs to not own or operate in some areas, or to only own or operate in some areas. I think that could go a long way towards making things competitive.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> In this new broken up set of companies, what's stopping them from remerging like Bell? Continued antitrust enforcement. Nobody should ever have approved those mergers. We can learn from our mistakes. > Also, what's stopping them from giving each other favorable partnerships? Why would they want to do that once they have separate owners? > just create some sort of progressive taxation as a function of users. How does this solve the monopoly problem at all? It has nothing to do with taxation.
- endisneigh 6y ago> Continued antitrust enforcement. Nobody should ever have approved those mergers. We can learn from our mistakes. That’s a nice thought but clearly doesn’t work in practice. I could be wrong though, are there any examples you can cite of monopolies being broken and staying that way in the USA? > Why would they want to do that once they have separate owners? They’re already familiar with each other. > How does this solve the monopoly problem at all? It has nothing to do with taxation. You don’t think a unavoidable tax that goes into smaller companies won’t hurt monopolies?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> That’s a nice thought but clearly doesn’t work in practice. It doesn't work if there is regulatory capture. But if the government is captured then you can't have your tax either, so then what are you proposing as a solution? > They’re already familiar with each other. Google and Oracle are familiar with each other. Apple and Intel are familiar with each other. Amazon and Netflix are familiar with each other. > You don’t think a unavoidable tax that goes into smaller companies won’t hurt monopolies? If they can keep abusing their monopolies to prevent there from being any competitors? There still won't be any competitors.
- endisneigh 6y agoI don’t see the connection between regulatory capture and what I’m describing. > If they can keep abusing their monopolies to prevent there from being any competitors? There still won't be any competitors. Which monopolies are you referring to have zero competitors? > Google and Oracle are familiar with each other. Apple and Intel are familiar with each other. Amazon and Netflix are familiar with each other. I don’t understand your point here, you’re listing pairs of competitors. Are you really not aware of large companies helping each other out?
- hervature 6y agoFor the sake of discussion, suppose your rules existed, I foresee dumb loopholes like creating a competing product (a la Google subsidizing Firefox) for the sole purpose of avoiding a now codified definition of monopoly. With regards to tariffs, we see this exact dumb thing happening with cameras only being able to record 55 seconds of video because if they record 1 minute then they are considered video cameras. Because the companies know their customers, inevitably they will just outcast the least productive users to the shoddier service.
- endisneigh 6y agoI completely agree - I’m not saying my proposal is ideal or even perfect, but rather there are alternatives to attempting to break up large companies in generals.
- stonogo 6y agoThey never did remerge to any monopolistic effect. I think you're strongly underestimating the degree to which the Bell System monopoly affected telecommunications. You couldn't even plug your own telephone into the wall; you had to give it to them and lease it back from them -- and pay an installation fee along the way, or you did without telephone service. Several of the Baby Bells got huge again, but none of them were in a monopoly position ever again. Many of them never even participated directly in the services market again, like LSI or Lucent. The other piece of the Bell breakup that people always overlook is that the federal directive did not merely break up the corporation. It also mandated that all Bell System patents be made available for use without fee by possible competitors. The result was an explosion of innovation and technological development (including within Bell companies!) and the consequences were massive.
- lumost 6y agoArguably, breaking up AT&T still forced competition into the telephone space for ~30 years. By the time AT&T had remerged to form at&t they were both a smaller portion of the economy and still had real competition in the form of Verizon, level3, StarLink and others. If Google was broken up it's entirely plausible that by the time it re-merged search would either be a commodity service or just not that important.
- adamcstephens 6y agoYes, this is very important. We need to break up and regulate the large firms to make room for competition. Many of the benefits of capitalism are actually destroyed by monopolies. We also need to continue to regulate monopolies, because if we lapse again and let the mergers flow we’ll be right back where we are again. And again.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoBreaking up the Ma Bell monopoly did create new opportunities. It also showed, at least to some extent, to those considering such opportunities that the gov was (semi) serious about the situation. Mind you, the Baby Bells were allowed to re-merge too quickly. We still lack competition in many areas. Imagine if there was no breakup at all.
- leoh 6y agoAgreed. We should focus on passing legislation around the behavior that we don't like as opposed to trying to break up these companies. There's a good chance that in the process of passing such legislation — for example, the kind that limits significant user tracking — that monopolistic effects would begin to fade.
- adamcstephens 6y agoWe already have the legislation that makes what they do illegal. We just need to enforce it.
- choppaface 6y agoWhat’s the probability that users could “choose their ad provider” for Google Search and ditch adsense? Would the break-up be like how Microsoft had to offer alternatives to IE? Perhaps more likely is that the auctions and search index material get regulated.
- ppf 6y agoI thought the accepted solution to entrenched incubents was "disrupt!".
- snarf21 6y agoWe really just need the SEC and FTC to do their job. They have completely failed us in the 21st century. And this is not just in tech. Look at media, banks, etc. It is no wonder the stock market is irrational, regulatory capture is a powerful multiplier.