4 ms·
The Times as presented in the medium posts was pretty clear about what they wanted: they wanted the story to quickly go away. They judged (likely rightly) that
by tsimionescu 6y ago
The Times as presented in the medium posts was pretty clear about what they wanted: they wanted the story to quickly go away. They judged (likely rightly) that the fastest way to do so would be for the journalist in question to issue a broad apology that admits to some wrongdoing without any kind of detail. This could then be spun down into a non-story (some kids were offended by what this guy said, you know how kids are; he later apologized for the dumb stuff he said, you know how old people are). The Times didn't care in any way if the reporter would remain with a reputation of being a bit of a racist, and the last thing they wanted was to give a point by point rebuttal that could in turn be rebutted point by point and endlessly discussed in forums and articles.
I'm not in any way claiming they were right to want this, that they were right to fire him over not agreeing with this plan, or that anything that happened here is good and normal. I'm claiming that the motivations are pretty transparent, though.
- jstrong 6y agoI disagree their judgement was right - I think it was catastrophically wrong. there are some things that you can treat this way (let it blow over), but a reporter saying the n word to a group of high school kids is not one of them. the fact that it was only said in a question to clarify what someone meant, rather than than as a slur, is also wholly exculpatory - making the real story a complete non-issue. also, think about how it actually turned out -- their strategy completely backfired, insofar as it was actually intended to limit the pr damage of the story.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI for one had heard nothing of this story before seeing this article (though I'm neither a resident nor citizen of America, so this is not that meaningful). We also don't know what the story would have been had he apologized as they wanted (again, I'm not saying he had any obligation to do so! His reputation was rightfully more important to him than the desires of the NYT PR team). Also, I don't agree that the context is wholly exculpatory and makes this a complete non issue. He was wrong in using this type of language with this particular audience, even if in a NYT article it would have been perfectly acceptable. He was misunderstood by the teens and seemed shocking to them, despite how he (or I, or you) views his own words. It would have actually been right to apologize to them, as he clearly failed in communicating the nuance he was trying to communicate. That's not to say that he is a racist! But he obviously misjudged his audience and caused them more harm than good with his words, even if he had the best intentions behind them. Especially since he was payed to be there and teach them, this is not some case of some teens finding someone's blog and taking offense at what they think is being said there.
- chokolad 6y ago> But he obviously misjudged his audience and caused them more harm than good with his words, even if he had the best intentions behind them He said that people should not punish 15 year old for something she said said offhand, when she was 12 years old. How is that causing more harm than good ?
- tsimionescu 6y agoThat is what he had intended to transmit, but it was clearly not the message that the audience received. Instead, the message they actually got from this conversation seems to have been more along the lines of 'this NYT reporter who is lecturing us about native ctures is throwing around the N word and claiming it's OK to use when he says it or something. This is uncomfortable and annoying'. If a class is just not learning from a teacher, both the class and the teacher share some of the blame. But since the teacher's job is to teach, and when the class is made up of children or teens, I always err on the side of accusing the teacher first. Again, not accusing them of Racism! Just of failing to create the understanding and environment they were supposed to create.
- 1024core 6y ago> Instead, the message they actually got from this conversation seems to have been more along the lines of 'this NYT reporter who is lecturing us about native ctures is throwing around the N word and claiming it's OK to use when he says it or something. This is uncomfortable and annoying'. Only someone with limited thinking skills would come away with that message. I'm not white, nor did I grow up in America, so what the fuck do I know, eh?
- tsimionescu 6y agoYou're probably also not a teenager, which I think is the most important distinction.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoIt's worth remembering that he was a journalist, not a teacher. I mean, he was acting as a teacher, but he was invited to do so because of his background as a journalist. He didn't have any pedagogical training. I do think it's relatively clear that something went wrong on that trip. Perhaps he should have been given more support from actual teachers, or perhaps he's just bad with kids and the position was always a terrible fit. But none of that should have significantly impacted his role at the Times, where mentoring teenagers was not a part of the job description.
- themacguffinman 6y agoI can see why most other corporations would behave like this even if it's not quite ethical, but the NYT crudely sweeping this kind of thing under the rug seems to more directly contradict their values and goals. I don't think it can produce honest, critical journalism if this is how it evaluates speech under attack. Journalism more than any other industry is vulnerable to this kind of shallow smear but it must bear it to do its job well.