9 ms·
As I've gotten older and seen predicted doomsdays come and go, I've started to think that expecting armageddon is an innate part of human psychology. I'm not a
by BurningFrog 6y ago
As I've gotten older and seen predicted doomsdays come and go, I've started to think that expecting armageddon is an innate part of human psychology.
I'm not aware of any era or place where many people have not expected the world to meet disaster soon. It's a part of all major religions.
- jaegerpicker 6y agoSure and I agree with that but that doesn't mean that armageddon isn't coming either. For example Climate Change and the Covid19 pandemic, both are examples of very real problems with the potential to severally harm/kill large numbers but both are dismissed with that attitude. I'm not sayin that the sky is falling in either case, though with Climate Change I can't imagine not thinking that, but if we continue to ignore them it's very likely that we will make human kinds worst nightmares come true.
- frockington1 6y agoThere have been doomsday Climate predictions as long you can go back. Historically, look at the flood stories and you can see climate worry in biblical times. More recently Miami Beach is always going to be underwater 5 years from the prediction date. It's a serious problem, but there has always been a cult like following to climate change. Personally, I think it's best to ignore the hysterical predictions and focus on your own impact and responsibilities
- ta988 6y agoThat's assuming that only controlling our own impact is sufficient to limit the problems.
- marshmallow_12 6y agoperiods of global cooling and warming have always happened (ice age). The fear is our activities are accelerating the change, not that it causes it
- BurningFrog 6y ago> For example Climate Change and the Covid19 pandemic, both are examples of very real problems with the potential to severally harm/kill large numbers but both are dismissed with that attitude. No. I have that attitude, and I'm not dismissing either! I think they're both serious problems that will cause a lot of pain as they're being worked through. What I disagree with is doomsday scenarios where they'll be the end of human civilization.
- csours 6y agoSee also radiation/nuclear power. The risks should ABSOLUTELY be taken seriously, but so should the alternatives to nuclear power.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> What I disagree with is doomsday scenarios where they'll be the end of human civilization. I don’t know anyone that’s concerned about end of human civilization. What they are concerned about is the end of their lifestyle, part of which is due to relative world peace, which is in turn due to resources being somewhat available, at least to those with power. Once those resources stop being so (cheaply) available, then you’ll see conflicts start emerging again. I already see it in my country, the US, with the widening gaps in places with economic opportunity and those left behind. Add in water, electricity, changing weather patterns and there will be some pain in the future.
- yongjik 6y ago> What I disagree with is doomsday scenarios where they'll be the end of human civilization. The problem I have with this argument is that "the end of human civilization" is such a high bar that it's practically a tautology that it won't be met. WW2 didn't end the human civilization - it didn't even make a dent. In fact, if the Axis had won the war, conquered the rest of the world, and massacred everybody between Moscow and Shanghai, the human civilization still wouldn't have ended. So any talk about whether the civilization will end or not, ultimately doesn't mean much.
- everdrive 6y agoI think the earth is too large to have an Armageddon over a very short period of time (perhaps the span of one life.) Instead, things become worse at local scale. Yemen has been having (and continues to have? I haven't kept up) a nice, local Armageddon. The United States is large, and well resourced. Short of nuclear war, there will be nice places in the US for a long time, even if the overall measure of things becomes objectively worse. It may just be that "disaster" and "Armageddon," as BurningFrog has suggest is a pretty bad heuristic. The climate crisis is quite real, but it won't make the whole earth unlivable in a short period of time. Instead, some places will get worse, and humanity will be squeezed into different locales. [edit] I do accept that it could become a whole-earth disaster that affects everything, but my point is that this may take generations.
- plutonorm 6y agoWell, you've jinxed it now.
- yellowstuff 6y agoJust because you're paranoid doesn't mean they're not out to get you. It could be that worrying about doomsday is an innate human trait, and that as the article asserts, certain types of worries are motivated by racism. I still think it's a good idea to allocate some resources towards mitigating low probability, high impact events.
- basilgohar 6y agoAn even more rational approach is think about it in terms of classes of scenarios to prepare for – many threats can be averted and/or mitigated through common preparations. Seed stores, distributed infrastructure, general survival training, and so on. But given how remote many scenarios seem to most people making decisions, the extra effort for long term benefits over short term gains tends to favor the latter over the former.
- OrbitRock 6y ago> Seed stores, distributed infrastructure, general survival training, and so on. If we actually thought like this and prepared ourselves in this manner during good times it’d increase the resilience of our species so profoundly.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoWe can. Now is good times. Apart from the pandemic – but that's only one type of bad time; we're mostly okay as regards climate change, we don't currently have much crop blight, nuclear armageddon seems far away… and we're mostly in a position to prepare and mitigate those issues, even if we missed the boat on this particular pandemic.
- tharkun__ 6y agoSome of this does exist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svalbard_Global_Seed_Vault https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svalbard_Global_Seed_Vault
- reducesuffering 6y ago
- dwaltrip 6y agoI agree that it is a shame that many people make over-confident predictions such as “in exactly 10 years, X will happen”. You often have to dig when reading a story to find out which parts are strongly supported by our scientific understanding, which can be frustrating. However, nonsense like that doesn’t change the fact that more co2 in the air increases the Earth’s temperature. And unfortunately we don’t seem to be that interested in significantly reducing our emissions anytime soon.
- phkahler 6y agoIf humans did nothing, we could expect glaciation in the next 100 years or so. Do people really think what we're doing can prevent that? If so, do they really think we can regulate the planet well enough to avoid both bad outcomes?
- weakfish 6y agoSource?
- phkahler 6y agoSorry, I meant 1000 years. Source: the historical record shows the planet has been in cyclical glaciation for several million years. Edit: ok maybe several thousand years: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_age https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_age But the norm seems to be an ice-free planet. Remember, there are plant remains buried under the arctic permafrost.
- quercusa 6y agoFrom the article: “The situation in the United States is that to get a response, the need must be somewhat overplayed”
- duxup 6y agoPopulation crisis, peak oil, 'kids these days', rando 'not enough people believe in my ideology' driven crisis, 'Rome fell because people did a thing I don't like'... It's funny to watch, a lot of these have seen before and will again.
- reader_mode 6y agoClimate change ? I don't doubt it's happening but the doom scenarios seem in line with all those predictions
- duxup 6y agoAny prediction being right doesn't really have much to do with all the wrong predictions IMO.
- Enginerrrd 6y agoIt does if taken in the context of all the wrong ones being taken as a bayesian prior, and that strategy will have predictive value.
- xyzzyz 6y agoClimate change definitely is the next one. It is most surely happening, and probably faster than we want or expect, but if you listen to scientific consensus (eg. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report), it is pretty clear that, while serious and troublesome issue, it most definitely is not an existential threat.
- eloff 6y agoProbably not directly. It will cause mass migration and refugee crises as coastal cities and low lying areas slowly flood. That seems inevitable at this point. That could maybe lead to wars, and nuclear war is still an existential threat. If the changes somehow disrupt the ability to support cereal crops in the northern hemisphere (which actually is also the biggest risk from nuclear winter), that could lead to widespread starvation and more wars. Not an existential crises necessarily, but not pretty.
- curation 6y agoAgreed. I take it to the end here and argue that what it is to be a free human is to make cuts to the regular order of functioning power instead, in other words to ask whatever powers preside over the order we are born to 'am I what you say I am' and to keep power afraid of human solidarity in the struggle to be against power.
- wyldfire 6y ago> I've started to think that expecting armageddon is an innate part of human psychology. Sci-fi novel plot starter: it's a quality that has been selected for by interstellar progenitors who seeded life on Earth, so that we would be wary of the need to mitigate real planet-scale disasters.
- marcosdumay 6y agoOr a very realistic hypothesis that the trait has been selected due to numerous tribe-ending disasters in prehistoric times.
- throwanem 6y agoHow do the "Precursors" get around evolution? I've seen this used as a plot seed for any number of space operas, but as far as I can recall, I haven't seen any that used it and also explained how they were able to somehow instill traits which, over hundreds of millions or billions of years, could not only remain present but unexpressed in the genomes of Nth-generation offspring, but could then, in response to some kind of extremely specific and complex stimulus, be expressed - but only when needed, and in perfect accord with the original intelligent design. It sounds like I'm making fun here, and I'll admit I picked the phrase "intelligent design" with puckishness aforethought. But it's a serious question, and what I'm really looking for is media recs. Does anyone actually reckon with this, in a way that's plausibly compossible with our current understanding of genomic heredity? (Introns and pseudogenes don't count, and yes, I remember that hilarious TNG S6 episode that used them as an excuse to give Barclay even more not-very-well-depicted psychological problems. Sure, these regions aren't translated into proteins, but they remain as susceptible to all the ordinary mechanisms of mutation as any other part of the genome. Not only that, being unexpressed, they are if anything less likely to be conserved than exons, so the "alien space magic hidden in non-coding DNA!" thing doesn't fly.)
- wizzwizz4 6y ago> How do the "Precursors" get around evolution? Easily. Make the genetic machinery responsible for the trigger hideously complex, redundant and, if possible, self-repairing (perhaps via a gene drive), and have loads of other genes rely on specific bits of it, so that a single alteration in that machinery will make life suck for the mutant without much preventing the trigger. Evolution can't make big changes, because there is no guiding intelligence behind it, only statistics; that's why our retinas are still backwards, and why a giraffe's laryngeal nerves take five metres to connect points ~30cm apart. Even though life without this massive lump of “junk DNA” that everything seems to rely on would work better, evolve faster, thrive more, waste fewer resources, reproduce more efficiently… it'll take a lot of mutations for it to unravel, none of which are selected for. Parts of it might get corrupted by sheer fluke, if the corruption also disables each anti-corruption mechanism and happens to coincide with a beneficial mutation, but that's what the redundancy's for. You'll never keep the phenotype the same, but you can keep a certain mostly-useless genetic mechanism intact, à la Robin Hood and Friar Tuck: http://catb.org/jargon/html/meaning-of-hack.html http://catb.org/jargon/html/meaning-of-hack.html
- thenoblesunfish 6y agoIt is weird, indeed. Every so often I’m amazed at how many people will say yes, on surveys, if you ask them if they are living in the end times.
- leppr 6y agoGiven that humans are the most successful species on the planet, if this is "an innate part of human psychology", then this trait is probably useful. Beware of survivor bias.
- kiliantics 6y agoWill be hard to consider humans successful if they don't prevent the human-made climate catastrophe from completely destroying most sustainable life-supporting ecosystems on the planet.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoThen stop it, or support the people who are. Vote with your feet and your wallet to the extent you can, and add your voice to the clamour. Don't just complain about the problem; complain about its instigation too. See if you can get just one change made; there are enough of us that that could add up.
- xwolfi 6y agoYeah exactly the same here. Sometimes big awful crisis appear in a country but more often than not, people scoff and get on with their life. As I grow older and start raising a child, I realize why the anger and will for change, the passion and hysteria you show when you're young are never followed by those who ve seen a bit more. This all doesn't matter, and living a regular monotonous life, making your little monkey turn into a human, is all most people end up caring about.
- carapace 6y ago> ... there is an unavoidable anthropic counterargument, which is for the people who do in fact live in some kind of end times, this is exactly how it will seem to them too. We can't just rely on induction, you still have to at least attempt the deductive due diligence. ~ ppod https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21433419 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21433419
- esja 6y agoPerhaps we can thank evolution for that. The people alive today are descended from the survivors of disasters.
- lurquer 6y agoEach of us is heading to our own personal Armageddon. Could happen at any moment. Perhaps the dread and angst is projected into concerns about society as a whole. Easier for some to worry about the coastline of Miami in 100 years instead of the indisputable fact that death is approaching.
- munificent 6y agoI read an interesting anecdote years ago hypothesizing that the impulse to imagine the end of the world is a selfish subconscious response to not being comfortable imagining the world continuing on without us. If the world blows up in your life time, at least it means you aren't missing out on anything after you're gone.
- solarengineer 6y agoSeveral warnings have come true: rising sea levels, disappearance of bees, extinction of several animal species, melting of glaciers, disappearance of coral reefs, loss of soil surface due to deforestation. Armageddon for me is thus not a one-day event like in movies such as The Day after Tomorrow, but a gradual and accelerating destruction all around. This is a “boil the ocean” project that humans have inadvertently initiated and it is taking the required time to complete.
- Nasrudith 6y agoI suspect it is fear of death and the world moving on without them gone somewhat narcissistic. So as they fear their own uncertain death in their lifetime they project it onto the world.