4 ms·
This kind of excuse making is one of the reasons I got out of software development. It’s not just gamedev. Priorities are way out of wack when you have time to
by ryandrake 6y ago
This kind of excuse making is one of the reasons I got out of software development. It’s not just gamedev. Priorities are way out of wack when you have time to put in binary obfuscation, but no time to fix such a huge performance bottleneck. The idea that “it’s a miracle software works at all” demonstrates the chronic prioritization and project management competence problem in the industry.
It’s ok to recognize a thing as a business success but a technical failure. In fact many software projects are business successes despite awful and unforgivable quality compromises. You don’t get to whitewash it just because the thing prints money.
- systemvoltage 6y agoHow do we then address chronic incompetence? Never complain about it? This is not small. This kind of incompetency if employed in a different sector such as security would lead to losing personal data of millions. > “it’s a miracle software works at all” This is not the case here. Please re-evaluate your calibration on this topic.
- sillysaurusx 6y ago1. you replied to the wrong person. 2. this kind of incompetence exists in all other sectors. That's why pentests are so crucial, and why they guard the security of millions. 3. we'll have to agree to disagree that it's a minor miracle. Having seen the complexity firsthand, it's quite amazing.
- systemvoltage 6y agoAgree that this kind of incompetence exists in all sectors and I think we don't talk about it, it becomes acceptable. We're not trying to blame a single developer, that'd be inappropriate. But, the management and QA culture in a AAA game studio that rakes billions ought to be better. The complexity is in reverse engineering the binary. The developer has access to the full source code and the profiling tools I presume. Another one is in Microsoft Flight Simulator, instead of downloading multiple archives, it downloads one, unzips it using a single CPU core and then downloads another one. MSFS 2020 takes a few hours to install and that's not just because of the internet connection, but this shitty installation code.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoIf loading times were prioritized, features would be cut. Which features would you cut out of the game in order to have fast loading times? This is what you'd need to decide. And then afterwards, it might not print as much money as you think it will. It's easy looking at it from the outside. Not so easy from the inside.
- ianlevesque 6y agoDid you read the article? Zero features needed to be cut, this is a 30 minute fix.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoBuilding the engine alone takes 30 minutes after each change. You're not going to get anything done in 30 minutes. And the more you work on this, the less you're working on shippable features that make money.
- ianlevesque 6y agoIn the mobile space, an app opening faster is so valuable you can make a career out of just that. I haven't worked desktop/console games, but having load times be 6 minutes longer than it needs to be, when you're trying to make money on ongoing microtransactions, has got to be losing you so much more money than the time spent fixing.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoThat's a fine argument, and I'm sure that if management knew they could get a 70% decrease in load times in exchange for focusing on this one area, they would have done so. But nobody knew. And discovering that would have been expensive. I'll meet you halfway though: they should have had profiling sessions that pointed to the JSON parsing code as the issue. I imagine that all of their profiling efforts were focused on the runtime performance, not the load time. Simply put, no one did that profiling, and I don't fault them for focusing on runtime performance (which is where the real money is, as Cyberpunk 2077 demonstrated by not having it, and subsequently having their PS4 orders yanked and refunded).