3 ms·
He apparently wrote, "Blog followers are useful to me because they expand my ability to spread important ideas and network with important people." [1] That to m
by wpietri 6y ago
He apparently wrote, "Blog followers are useful to me because they expand my ability to spread important ideas and network with important people." [1] That to me is very clear intent to influence. And it's not like this was a blog about knitting. So whatever the bar is, he's well over it.
Another way to come at it is not intent, but impact. Whatever one thinks of Metz's article, I think he's correct that a) Silicon Valley has huge influence in the world, b) that the people making big decisions there are worth covering, and c) the ideas that shape those decisions are relevant. More disputable is the last piece of his chain is d), SSC has some influence on those ideas, and is a useful case study. But given the strident defenses of SSC here and elsewhere, I think the reaction to the article proves that the topic is significant enough to merit coverage.
I agree one shouldn't get promoted to national prominence "by default". But spending years publishing something to the world with an ever-growing audience is not something one does by accident. I'm sure Siskind put at least thousands of hours into his blog, and now it's his full-time job. One can't reasonably spend years courting public attention and then be mad that the public will attend to something as they see fit. Freedom of speech goes both ways.
[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20210217195335/https://twitter.com/TopherTBrennan/status/1362108632070905857 https://web.archive.org/web/20210217195335/https://twitter.c...
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI have no idea who Topher Brennan is, and he appears to have deleted these tweets, so it's pretty hard for me to evaluate whether this is a credible accusation. I definitely agree that it's fair for journalists to unveil someone's pseudonym if they're networking with important people.
- wpietri 6y agoYou are welcome to evaluate his general credibility and the merits of the emails for yourself. He did remove the emails, but hasn't removed the claim that Siskind said a key point that was in them: https://twitter.com/TopherTBrennan/status/1360663056456450048 https://twitter.com/TopherTBrennan/status/136066305645645004... I'm open to finding out that they're fake, but on the "balance of probabilities" standard, I believe they're real.