4 ms·
It's the correct decision (although Facebook likely only cares about its bottom line). the YPG is designated as a terrorist organisation by the Turkish state an
by Barrin92 6y ago
It's the correct decision (although Facebook likely only cares about its bottom line). the YPG is designated as a terrorist organisation by the Turkish state and it's quite obvious that Turkey will want to exercise sovereignty over its communication channels rather than letting an opposing military force broadcast freely to its citizens.
It's not really the job of a private company to undermine nations in this way for simple reasons of sovereignty, and because even if Facebook were to somehow win in the short term, the five to ten year consequence would probably be that nations like Turkey decouple entirely and take control over communications back a la Russia or China.
- throwaway316943 6y agoIt’s the wrong decision but no private company should be in a position to make it. The power that we have granted to centralized extralegal entities is obscene and we’re going to pay for it in blood if we don’t walk this back quickly by breaking up these orgs and building technologies that decentralize that power.
- missedthecue 6y agoWhat would breaking up Facebook.com look like in a way that successfully prevents what you're describing? It's not an oil conglomerate. It's a social network. That's irreducible by definition. Most people seem to throw out suggestions like forcing them to spin off Instagram and WhatsApp. That clearly wouldn't fix what youre saying is the issue. IG and WhatsApp would still be run by the same people, still owned in part by Zuckerberg, and still have the same incentives and goals. Essentially the only difference is that the employer name on the W-2s would change.
- throwaway316943 6y agoA death knell legislation would be better. Like making social networks entirely responsible for the content posted by their users so that it’s impossible to grow beyond a certain scale and still be functional. Or maybe enforcing interoperability so that users can take their data and friends elsewhere.
- missedthecue 6y agoLike making social networks entirely responsible for the content posted by their users so that it’s impossible to grow beyond a certain scale and still be functional How would that fix the problem of Turkey's government controlling what gets posted and what doesn't? That'd exacerbate it.
- bcherny 6y agoI agree that decentralized moderation is right, in theory. What does that look like in practice — Reddit-style downvoting? And do you really think the really bad stuff — child porn, terrorist recruitment, and so on, that FB/Twitter/Google already detect with ML 99% of the time — should be decentralized too?
- toomanybeersies 6y ago> It's not really the job of a private company to undermine nations in this way for simple reasons of sovereignty That may be the case (or not), except this isn't a principled stance that Facebook is taking, but a business decision. Facebook have absolutely no issue with undermining a nation's sovereignty when it suits them. For example, in protest against Australia's new News Media Bargaining Code, they went and blocked Australians from being able to share news articles.
- nradov 6y agoI fail to see how blocking sharing of news links undermined Australia's sovereignty. The Australian government gave Facebook a choice to either pay up or exit the news business and they chose the latter. So they are in compliance with local law.
- toomanybeersies 6y agoThe News Media Bargaining Code is not yet law, and didn't even pass its final reading until after Facebook enacted their ban, so Facebook was under no legal obligation to block links to news websites. They were in compliance with local law regardless. What Facebook did was a blatant attempt to influence the legislative process. It was the equivalent of a nation enacting an export ban due to threats of tariffs.
- monadic6 6y agoIt's not really the job of facebook to do anything or care about anyone. It's on you and me to force them to do anything. Don't get me wrong, I will absolutely blame the corporate apologists when shit goes bad. It's assholes like you that create an abusive environment for the rest of us. Your hands are soaked with blood.
- Shivetya 6y agoI had a nice long reply but had some time to simply fit. The issue here isn't that Facebook is complying with a government's wishes it is that we don't hold our own governments liable first. As in, you should first blame your own government for turning a blind eye to events you find objectionable. People cheer on facebook and others here for locking out opinions they don't want, they just find a clean term to justify it (no fake news, hate, etc) However to be blunt. No government is without issues and it would be a better use of your angst to clean up your own government before asking your government or a private firm to interfere in the actions of others. As in, police yourself first.
- geoduck14 6y agoI actually agree with you, and FB. The YPG are considered terrorists by Turkey. Their content is no longer available - in Turkey. Do I wish FB allowed the content? Yeah, kind of, but I don't actually understand if the YPG is a dangerous organization.