5 ms·
Electricity needed to mine Bitcoin is more than used by 'entire countries'
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- space_rock 6y agoI would hate to rely on newspapers for any topic. You can tell the writer has limited knowledge and you couldn't get enough info here to have an opinion that wasn't anything more than noise
- imtringued 6y agoI'm tired of these articles. Yes, everyone knows that by now. Bitcoin holders don't care about the lack of transaction throughput of Bitcoin. They don't care about the ability to use Bitcoin as a currency. They don't care about the energy inefficiency of PoW. It's time to move on and stop caring about Bitcoin instead of giving it more media attention.
- zepto 6y agoPerhaps these articles in mainstream media outlets are informative to people who are not bitcoin holders, and don’t know much about it yet.
- spicybright 6y agoPeople uninformed should be informed. Energy consumption and pollution effects everyone.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 6y agoElectricity needed to maintain the petrodollar is more than used by entire countries, too.
- uncoder0 6y agoYeah... those F22's aren't powered by magic.
- lwansbrough 6y agoPlease spare us the Whataboutism. Even if the current global financial system was a power hog (it isn’t, and is incentivized by market forces to be incredibly efficient), it doesn’t excuse Bitcoin’s total disregard (and, more accurately) encouragement of energy waste by design. Yes, we have a system that uses a lot of energy but does so very efficiently. Bitcoin don’t solve any of the problems it alleges to, so all that has been accomplished is the establishment of a worse secondary system that doesn’t do 1/100th of what the existing system does but uses infinitely more power on a per-unit basis. It’s not as if with Bitcoin you suddenly don’t need a military or financial institutions.
- solosoyokaze 6y agoIt’s not whataboutism. You need to secure value somehow. USD is secured with banks and bombs. BTC uses energy to secure value. We will never meaningfully cut our energy usage as a species (with or without BTC) we need clean energy not to move back into the Stone Age.
- lwansbrough 6y agoIf I hide gold at home, that’s virtually zero energy and is fairly secure. It’s not perfectly secure but it’s good enough for a lot of people. It’s distributed and zero energy. Bitcoin will require banks at scale and an increasing amount of energy for the duration of its existence, or at least until mining is done. The network can’t handle transaction volume so people are forced to settle transactions off network. That’s the job of a bank. The US is secured by its foreign policy. The foreign policy exists to protect the world’s strongest economy. The dollar’s value is a product of the strong economy. It is not directly secured by the military. Without a military there would be no US, and no economy, only then could you say there would be no dollar. So unless you plan to eliminate the US economy, Bitcoin’s existence doesn’t affect the need for a military, even if it was the world’s standard currency. If you actually care about the environment, I can’t think of a worse idea than promoting an energy black hole powered by coal and tech garbage.
- solosoyokaze 6y ago
- zepto 6y agoIs it? How much is it compared to maintaining Bitcoin?
- bluefirebrand 6y agoComparing the dollar that is basically the foundation of the entire world's financial system to Bitcoin which is basically a niche hobby currency is a bit disingenuous...
- kruxigt 6y agoThe thing is, Bitcoin is becoming the new gold, not the new money. Gold is energy/capital expensive to mine which is related to its property as a store of value. Just as most of the gold now in the world took great effort to mine, so maybe must bitcoin. Maybe there could be a better way, maybe not. It is clear that it's not a good idea to have money which requires large amounts of energy for circulating, but it could be that a reasonable way to create the "gold" base for digital money is the energy expensive way that is the path chosen by Bitcoin. Maybe not.. or maybe. Other ideas?
- Proven 6y agoAnd what are you going to do about it? That's what I thought!
- sova 6y agoHow much electricity is required to keep credit card infrastructure up?
- doc_gunthrop 6y agoAnybody with a general understanding of how blockchain works should not find this conclusion surprising. Each subsequent block in the chain gets larger, increasing the cost of the necessary resources to sustain the cryptocurrency. > A single transaction of bitcoin has the same carbon footprint as 680,000 Visa transactions or 51,210 hours of watching YouTube, according to the site. And it will continue to increase. Common sense may suggest that, consequently, the seigniorage of BTC should naturally dip below zero. But then again who could've predicted its value would ever have exceeded $50K USD?
- tashbarg 6y ago> Each subsequent block in the chain gets larger, increasing the cost of the necessary resources to sustain the cryptocurrency. That's not correct. The effort put into any block, past and future, is (long-term adjusted) directly connected to the payout, since the effort is algorithmically self-adjusting. It follows, that the effort put into any current block is worth ~$300k, and therefore worth ~$300k of electricity. If bitcoin is ever going to be valued less again, the necessary resources to sustain bitcoin will shrink accordingly. Additionally, they automatically shrink, by design, in ~2024, ~2028 and ~2032.
- doc_gunthrop 6y agoI miswrote the part regarding the size of each subsequent block getting larger. However, the part about the rising cost of resources to sustain the cryptocurrency is valid in practice (assuming the current trend continues and BTC continues to gain further widespread adoption). > If bitcoin is ever going to be valued less again, the necessary resources to sustain bitcoin will shrink accordingly. If I'm interpreting correctly, this will occur because the number of miners will decrease as the reward incentive decreases. Or do you mean something else?
- tashbarg 6y agoYou are interpreting correctly.
- 6y ago
- betwixthewires 6y agoThe person who wrote this article doesn't even know what they're talking about. >The more bitcoin that is mined, the harder the algorithms that must be solved to get a bitcoin become. Now that over 18.5m bitcoin have been mined, the average computer can no longer mine bitcoins. The difficulty has nothing to do with the supply, the difficulty is entirely a function of the amount of hash power on the entire network. I know people make mistakes, but one thing that bothers me is when people write articles about things they genuinely never took an interest in. You've got no business informing people. Also, an article written about something by an author who does not know about said something screams "agenda". This feels like a hit piece on Tesla (for not being green), and a "don't get excited about bitcoin just yet (pleeease)" article.