3 ms·
Governments have way more of a history of psychopathic violence than corporations, on the order of 100-1000x more deaths in our recorded history. Corporations
by sneak 6y ago
Governments have way more of a history of psychopathic violence than corporations, on the order of 100-1000x more deaths in our recorded history.
Corporations aren't (generally) permitted to directly engage in violence. The defining characteristic of a government that distinguishes it from all
other groups of people is that it claims a monopoly on the legitimate use of force.
- gjsman-1000 6y agoActually, if you include all wars that have occurred from government in history, I'd say the number of deaths compared to corporations is a much higher multiple than that.
- ryanbrunner 6y agoI think it's an interesting question to consider how much of that is due to corporations being legally constrained from the sorts of violence governments engage in, particularly in a thread discussing relaxing legal constraints on corporations. If corporations were sovereign, I wouldn't be surprised at all if they participated in comparable levels of violence.
- acdha 6y agoThe East India Company would be a good supporting example or, more recently, United Fruit Company giving the world the term “banana republic”. I think the corporation versus government phrasing is obscuring the underlying problem of power without accountability to the people. That’s going to end poorly no matter the exact relationship between the private and public sectors.
- patcon 6y agoLet's be careful not to conflate "any aggression" with "psychopathic violence". The values at clash in past conflict are sometimes very human values, rather than manifestations of psychopathic anti-social mechanisms. (safe example: USA joining war against Germany) Though I'm sure the complexities of conflict make for a mixed bag of such overlapping actors and rationales...! I'm prepared to walk this thought back btw.
- sneak 6y agoThe third reich was a government. The CCP is a government, as was the USSR, as is the USA. I'll take Google antispam algorithms going haywire and suspending my electric power or fiber account and providing zero recourse to human support over a Great Leap Forward or a continent-wide Genocide any day of the fuckin' week.
- patcon 6y agoRespectfully, this feels like a bit of misdirection. Government is literally an institution grounded in collective welfare (albeit imperfect instantiations of this goal). Google has NO SUCH directive, and the only reasons we don't see companies doing worse (at least not since East India Company times) is because the very container you criticize has enough power to keep it anchored to ostensibly human values. We can just agree to disagree here, if you are truly deep in the anti-government camp (because I am pretty entrenched in the unfolding repair narratives of government, not disposal narratives) EDIT: Reworded to use less provocative language. Sorry if you read v1
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sundaeofshock 6y agoCorporations have a long history of violence against labor. I’d like to introduce you to the Pinkertons: https://www.teenvogue.com/story/who-were-the-pinkertons https://www.teenvogue.com/story/who-were-the-pinkertons Corporations will absolutely use violence if not constrained by the state. I trust a democratically elected government much then a random board of directors.