4 ms·
The amount used in these drives is minuscule, akin to a single party balloon. Given these drives are to be used for many years at a time, I'll go after them af
by sandworm101 6y ago
The amount used in these drives is minuscule, akin to a single party balloon. Given these drives are to be used for many years at a time, I'll go after them after I manage to stop all the birthday balloons.
- rbanffy 6y agoDoes anyone have a number on how much Helium is produced in the Earth's crust by radioactive decay?
- sandworm101 6y agoNot enough. It is generally known that we are using helium faster than the planet can naturally produce it. We currently get helium from natural gas deposits. In the future we might end up puling it from the air, but that would be very expensive. For many use cases it might be easier to switch to hydrogen. For those interested in SETI, excessive atmospheric helium might be a detectable techno-signature, a sign that someone is digging into deep crust presumably for hydrocarbons.
- system2 6y agoWhen we use the reserves completely and prices sky rocket, probably unnecessary entertainment use of it would stop.
- rbanffy 6y agoI am sure we are using it faster than we are extracting it, and it'll be interesting to see what happens when selling hydrocarbons no longer offsets the cost of extracting it, but I was thinking about how much is actually produced.
- FooBarWidget 6y agoA party balloon full of helium is a minuscule amount?
- sandworm101 6y agoNote this is liquid helium in one operational MRI machine: "Let’s say you have an MRI scanner with the OR76 magnet with the full capacity of 1800 litres of helium. Your system consumes approximately 4% of its helium capacity per month, that sums up to 48% per year (4%12 = 48%). That means that 864 litres are consumed per year (1800 litres 48% = 864 litres)." https://lbnmedical.com/liquid-helium-in-mri-machine/ https://lbnmedical.com/liquid-helium-in-mri-machine/ That is liquid, so for the gas we can multiply 864 by about 1000. So this MRI machine is using 86,000 liters of helium gas per year. That is what, 40,000 party balloons? Say each machine does 1000 scans per year, that is a good-sized cluster of party balloons for every scan. So yes, a single party balloon pales in comparison to the amount of helium being used for MRI scans. (There are near-zero helium MRI machines, but there are also plenty of older machines in use out there.)
- m4rtink 6y agoMany modern liquid rocket engine powered space launchers also use quite a lot of helium for tank pressurisation in flight. Helium being inert with very low melting point is ideal for this use case, especially with cryogenic propelants. With the most modern generation of reusable space launchers such as SpaceX starship an alternative solution is being worked on, possible thanks to both fuel (methane) and oxidizer (oxygen) they use being cryogenic. Instead of pressurizing with helium they heat up a bit of the cryogenic liquids using the rocket engine heat, let it expand into gas and use it to pressurize the tanks, no helium required! One of the reasons is that for fully reusable space launchers the main cost is the propelant and helium in the amounts needed would be a big part of that!
- Gravityloss 6y agoIn some cases the helium cost is comparable to that of the propellants! Both are negligible compared to the total cost of space launch currently, but once reusability and operations become more streamlined, they start mattering more.
- gibspaulding 6y ago
- plutonorm 6y agoJust use hydrogen for the party balloons
- pfundstein 6y agoThat'd be an exciting party!