5 ms·
"from a lower or even mid-tier college is a worthwhile investment " I always found this idea amazing, we just accept that univerities are not really there for
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
"from a lower or even mid-tier college is a worthwhile investment "
I always found this idea amazing, we just accept that univerities are not really there for education but instead a giant sorting machine to separate plebs from (rich/talented/dilligent/take your pick).
They don't work like a normal market, there best company grows their production, and supplies millions with the best goods.
Oxford/Harvard take their miniscule intake of a fraction of a percent every year, and opening door to unwashed masses would destroy their brand.
Do the best universities have best teaching technique, or are they best because they pick brightest students and they contribute nothing special?
A healthy market of affordable education cannot be build on this foundation of 16th century elitism, exclusion and zero-sum principle.
- alasdair_ 6y ago>They don't work like a normal market, there best company grows theur production, and supplies millions with the best goods. Oxford/Harvard take their miniscule intake of a fraction of a percent every year, and opening door to unwashed masses would destroy their brand. This is exactly how high-end luxury good markets work.
- dpoochieni 6y agoI agree, the unwashed masses do destroy most of everything. Granted Harvard is not what it used to be, same as an MS is not what it used to be, a Phd is not what it used to be. In the past the quality was even higher, more akin to an artisan workshop than whatever mass-anything you could conceive of.
- fossuser 6y agoRelatedly I read the top colleges try to get students they know they'll never admit to apply, because the more that apply, the more they can reject and the more selective they become. Selectivity is a status symbol, so you want as many as possible to apply so you can reject as many as possible.
- tryonenow 6y ago>A healthy market of affordable education cannot be build on this foundation of 16th century elitism, exclusion and zero-sum principle. Unless you recognize that human ability is not equally distributed. In which case colleges need to be exclusionary to maintain prestige. And that prestige is an important signal in a universe where success is dependent on competence. Conversely, when prestige signals are eroded, there are gradual, self-reinforcing downstream effects, wherein all of our institutions - industry, media, government, academia - are gradually populated with cohorts of reduced competence, and society at large becomes less capable of recognizing merit, particularly given that when once clear signals like alma mater are no longer accurate, laypeople are more drawn to the nonsensical belief that all humans are equally capable. And slowly the withering of these institutions, and recognition of/appreciation for competence, lead to a withering of society and, I think, this phenomenon is one of the drivers behind the ongoing collapse of the American Empire, for better or worse. The intent behind lowering standards for entry is amiable but based on a faulty and ultimately dangerous assumption.
- jankyxenon 6y agoIn many other countries, top academics and researchers are at large public universities. Maybe it would be money well-spent for the public-sector to poach top academics from private intuitions. It would lead to salary inflation, but might be the most cost effective way to sap prestige and inject into good public universities.
- ghaff 6y agoIt happens. University of Texas. At least parts of the University of California system. UMass Amherst is a pretty good school. At least main campuses of the upper tier of state universities can provide good educations. What's probably also true is that you can go to Ohio State and either take advantage of it or cruise through partying and taking X for jocks courses.
- phabora 6y ago> In many other countries, top academics and researchers are at large public universities. But that’s not even terribly relevant to the average student. An undergraduate won’t benefit from going down the same hallways as the world’s foremost expert on Nigerian guinea pig digestive tracts. But for some reason having studied at the top university (in terms of research, not teaching) matters a lot.
- keiferski 6y agoThe funny thing is how people constantly bemoan the state of politics, yet consistently argue for evaluating degrees entirely based on their financial outcome. As if an educated citizenry will just appear from the ether. The connection between the two seems pretty obvious to me.
- RealityVoid 6y agoThat is a good observation, but one that I see very few people make.
- labcomputer 6y ago1. Before the post-WWII GI bill, which sent an enormous surge of young men to college in the 1950's, the percentage of Americans with a college degree was measured in single digits (Bachelor degrees then were as common as Ph.D.s today). And, yet, we still somehow managed to have a functioning democracy[1]. 2. People evaluate degrees based on financial outcome simply because there is no other way to justify spending a quarter million dollars on a degree. That is an order of magnitude more than it costs to deliver a high quality education[2]. If college were truly just about learning, you could start cranking out college-educated citizens for $20k a pop. At price it's an easy decision to make. Instead, colleges have become luxury resorts with a classroom as one of the amenities. They compete on things like best food, recreation and nightlife. It's not (necessarily) a problem to bundle education with fun, but you have to justify the expense to your customers. Colleges have chosen to highlight the differences in earnings between those with degrees and those without. [1] Even worse: While I agree with premise that we should strive for a better educated electorate, someone arguing the opposite could easily point out that the increasing political discord is correlated with the increasing fraction of degree holders. [2] The cost of the primary input has decreased: Faculty salaries have been stagnant for 40 years--for a given "level". But faculty salaries have actually decreased when you account for "title deflation". Colleges increasingly rely on "adjunct" faculty and delay the promotion from assistant to full professor. It is now common for PhDs to do two or even three post-docs (which can include teaching duties) before getting a first appointment. Thus, a 40 year-old academic today has a lower title and costs less to employ than a 30 year-old academic from the middle of the 20th century.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago>They don't work like a normal market, there best company grows their production, and supplies millions with the best goods. If it was currently possible to take a group of 18 year olds, and transform them into highly motivated, highly intelligent people, I assume it would exist for sale. Unfortunately, the construction of a person seems to be highly complex, and is subject to genetics, home life and parental wealth, childhood experiences, peer and other influences, etc. Until then, humans will continue to use shortcuts for assessing the probability of one's future ability to "succeed" (however one wants to define it), one of which is attaining admittance at certain institutions.
- mcguire 6y ago"Do the best universities have best teaching technique, or are they best because they pick brightest students and they contribute nothing special?" They tend to attract the best teachers. And by "teachers" I do mean the best researchers in the given field. Which in turn attracts the brightest students.
- aarongray 6y agoThe best researchers are rarely the best teachers
- selimthegrim 6y agoThey won’t be stumped by a question from a smart undergrad. The best teachers might fail to make it a teachable moment.
- imtringued 6y agoWhy would I need a world class researcher for e.g. linear algebra? Lots of students struggle with it because of bad teaching, not because it's difficult to understand.
- mcguire 6y agoWho would you rather be taught by, someone who spends the rest of the week using what you are being taught, or someone interested in something else (at best, teaching itself, at worst, doing anything else)? I might suspect bad linear algebra teaching is caused by a lack of interest in linear algebra by the teacher.
- disqard 6y agoHaving seen world-class researchers up close, and having experienced their teaching first-hand over many years, I don't believe that being one is any guarantee of also being the other.
- abecode 6y agoI heard an interesting analogy that universities are more like religions than businesses. If you factor out all the beliefs/rituals in religion and knowledge/education in universities, they are both human organizations that seek to prolong/maximize their existence, rather than to grow or maximize shareholder value like in companies.
- credit_guy 6y ago> Do the best universities have best teaching technique, or are they best because they pick brightest students and they contribute nothing special? In the end it doesn't make a difference. Employers want to hire good candidates. Hiring is hard and the outcomes asymmetric: very good candidates can give at most 10x performance and for a company with 100+ employees that barely registers, while very bad candidates can create absolutely stunning destruction. So hiring good candidates is a high stakes game. There's lots of noise, any way to get signal out of this noise is valuable. Employers pay big fees to recruiting agencies to get good hires. A reputable university, like Harvard or MIT is like an ideal recruiting agency (and no fees): not only it finds the best candidates for you, it also trains them for 4 years. The 4 years of training function as a further filter as well. In the end, someone graduating for such a college will be quite a sure bet for employers, and so they'll have much, much better prospects in the job market. So they are willing to pay for this. Are they born smart and Harvard does not teach them anything new? Who cares? They'll get much better job offers than if they graduate from Tulane, and that translates in more money in their pockets.
- awillen 6y agoIf you think that we have anything resembling a healthy market of affordable education, I'm afraid we're not going to agree on much of anything. The point isn't about whether colleges are there for education or not, the point is that if you have to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars and years of your life you should get a return on that investment. The idea that people should go enormously into debt to become educated for the sake of it is crazy. If you want to educate people for the sake of society, then get society to pay for their education. Until then, people need to make rational choices about what for many of them is the biggest financial commitment they'll make.