6 ms·
Can Governments Stop Bitcoin?
- Triv888 6y agoThey already slowed it down by taxing it like it isnt a currency.
- fortran77 6y agoNo they haven’t. If I make money from trading rubles into yen, I need to pay taxes on the gain. Why should BTC trading be different?
- rtrdea 6y agoWhy should you pay taxes on trading currency? Why should I have to pay taxes when swapping between different cryptos and not just when I swap to USD?
- jqpabc123 6y agoBecause that is the law --- at least in the USA. Income / profit is taxable --- regardless of source.
- supercanuck 6y agoIRS treats it like property not a currency.
- 3np 6y agoI'm not sure what country you're referring to. In most jurisdictions I'm familiar with, if you exchange cash currencies and buy something (classic example; a cup of coffee), you are not expected to enumerate that transaction in your tax statement and calculate acquisition cost and liquidation P&L for each individual transactions. For bitcoin, you do (again, highly depending on country). This is the difference between classifying it as an asset or a currency. You may still be liable for taxes on your forex trading, but it's not the same kind of capital gains as for other asset classes.
- imtringued 6y agoYeah, the problem is that you cannot spend your Bitcoin directly. If you could use your dollars to buy Bitcoin and then proceed to buy a pizza you wouldn't have to pay taxes. In practice the only ones who are actively using their Bitcoin for consumer spending use a credit card where they deposit their cryptocurrency. Since the credit card company is automatically converting your cryptocurrency back to dollars you have to pay taxes on the gains.
- 3np 6y agoActually, no, that’s exactly the problem. Directly spending your bitcoin to buy a pizza would trigger a taxable event for the buyer. Enforcement of this might be weak so far, but technically that’s the case.
- fortran77 6y agoIn every place with an income tax, there are rules for taxing income. If you made money, don't expect to think you're so clever that the IRS or equivalent will say "Well, you got us! Enjoy your income without paying taxes." I'll give you an example that pre-dates bitcoin: There are U.S. Gold coins that have denominations, for example $50 https://www.moneymetals.com/images/products/1oz-gold-eagle-reverse.jpg https://www.moneymetals.com/images/products/1oz-gold-eagle-r... People have tried to pay others with these coins arguing that the face value is $50, so the income tax should be $50, and not the $1500 or whatever an ounce of gold was worth at the time. Guess what? They didn't get away with it. See: https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/tax/legacy/2014/08/05/Kahre_No_09_10471_DCCir2013.pdf https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/tax/legacy/2014/...
- 3np 6y agoThe comment you’re replying to is not implying that profits should be exempt from taxes, or have them lowered. It’s the mechanisms around capital gains tax (which is a particular kind of tax) compared to the requirements around profit made from appreciation of, say, fiat currencies. In fact, it’s completely different from income tax that you’re talking about. It’s not so much about having to pay taxes but on what amounts and overhead in how reporting is made. The hampering of growth (in terms of e.g. retail payments) and adoption is not due to the monetary cost of taxation, but on the mechanisms of them. Hell, you could keep or even increase the tax rate, but make it liable even just by holding cryptocurrency and having it appreciate (as opposed to “at liquidation”) and it would have the complete opposite effect. Now if only more governments would accept taxes paid in bitcoin (:
- jqpabc123 6y agoWhy? Why stop Bitcoin? Bitcoin is no threat to government or fiat currency. All government has to do to stop Bitcoin is --- nothing. Simply wait and allow reality to sink in. Under no circumstances should government move to regulate the Bitcoin "market". Nor should they allow government insurance programs (FDIC, NCUA) to be applied to Bitcoin in any way. Regulation would do nothing but add respect and credibility --- things that are otherwise sorely lacking. This is not to say that the fraud that is occurring with so called "stable coins" should not be prosecuted. Exposing this will directly impact the Bitcoin market but it is not regulating the market.
- rtrdea 6y agoAre you saying Dai and USDC are frauds or are you specifically referring to Tether?
- jqpabc123 6y agoAll of the above should be prosecuted if it can be shown that they are not fully backed or cannot be fully redeemed as claimed. https://breakermag.com/tether-now-admits-its-not-fully-backed-by-dollars/ https://breakermag.com/tether-now-admits-its-not-fully-backe...
- drdeca 6y agoMy understanding is that it is publicly verifiable that Dai is over-collateralized , and positions can be closed or whatever it is called without requiring any organization to do anything. I don’t know what smaller details there might be about the oracle information or other outside input things there are that people might complain about, but my impression is that it is a sound setup? The reason I say “impression” is because I’m not familiar with the details. I think all the details are publicly verifiable though.
- coolestguy 6y agoThe fact that you said that about DAI shows you don't know enough about the ecosystem and have just read articles about tether then drawn a conclusion about every single stablecoin
- SethTro 6y agoThis article took a more holistic view than BTC Endgame (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26198210 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26198210) but the author doesn't seem to have landed on a position only enumerated "maybe, maybe not"
- AnonsLadder 6y agoThis train has no brakes
- jcpham2 6y agoTotally agree with derailment and mass casualty very possible.
- slickrick216 6y agoYes but not for the reasons one might expect. Fiat collapse won’t be pretty.
- jariel 6y ago"But the reality is Bitcoin is a political project that threatens to fundamentally disrupt the Davos-led economic system, with everyone from Janet Yellen to Christine Lagarde expressing fear about its rise and demanding it be regulated." Enough with the inanity. BTC's are numbers traded between speculators for no reason other than speculation. Aside from the potential for money laundering, just ignore it, it's irrelevant. It's power is it's own PR, generated through ever more ridiculous claims to valuation.
- isitdopamine 6y ago> BTC's are numbers traded between speculators for no reason other than speculation. So are all derivatives.
- jqpabc123 6y agoTrue but most derivatives are based on an asset of some sort with real world value. It is not speculation based solely on the speculation that others will continue to speculate.
- MarkMc 6y agoThis is what worries me about Bitcoin. Right now total exposure to Bitcoin is a tiny fraction of the exposure to derivatives in 2008, but that could change as Bitcoin mania grows. Eventually a sudden drop in the price of Bitcoin could trigger a general economic collapse like in 2008
- ChainOfFools 6y agoIt certainly helps Bitcoin that the press makes no effort to contextualize let alone dissect the crude dimensions by which the success of Bitcoin is measured, namely price and market cap. Bitcoin's market cap is like a building erected specifically to claim an astonishing height record for skyscrapers, but in which the base of the structure consists of a dozen or so real floors topped by a constantly unspooling wire antenna held aloft by a weather balloon 5km up.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Cypher 6y agothey can try
- Lammy 6y ago"Previous attempts at parallel online digital currencies, like e-Gold and Liberty Reserve, were shut down by the US government before even making it to $10 billion in market capitalization. Bitcoin now has a market cap north of $1 trillion." I wonder if the different treatment is due to Bitcoin coming of age in the Obama era instead of the GWB era like those other examples? Forgive my naive question as I'm not into crypto, but is it even technically possible for them to shut down Bitcoin if they wanted to? I lived through the P2P file sharing era in the 2000s where ISPs were forced to block access to various things at the behest of the RIAA/MPAA, so it seems like they could just go after the P2P blockchain in similar ways if they cared. No consensus; no Bitcoin, yeah? If that were the case then I also wouldn't trust Tor to provide any privacy from the US government considering NRL created it. My assumption is that reality is probably somewhere in the middle, where the existence of Bitcoin doesn't harm the government's interests too much while also convincing the occasional egotistical giraffe that it would be safe to stick their neck out.
- jariel 6y agoIf it turned out that BTC was a primary vector of money laundering and means to pay for illegal stuff, the US could declare it illegal which would crash it instantly. EU and China probably and everyone else probably would as well if that were the case, and then it would be wiped out. Specific kinds of regulations might kill it as well - though most regulations probably validate it, there could be certain things that make it impossible to survive. Maybe some kind of regulation regarding asset size + value certification, or something about the security of the BTC numbers. Or possibly something about disclosure - since BTC allows you to keep 10 Billion in your drawer at home ... it creates a problem similar to offshore financing. Musk was maybe smart to buy BTC because he's the kind of guy who can give it hype and 'cred' ... but either 1) he doesn't realize what it actually is and is unknowingly pushing Ponzi or 2) he knows what he's doing and happy to take money from dupes and rubes. I suggest it's the former, as everything Musk says leads me to believe he has never opened a finance text. The paradoxes of great leader: their giant blind spots outside the realms of their interest. Gates, Musk, Jobs, Bezos, Soros ... they can be big visionary in some areas and insufferable fools in others.
- 6y ago
- OnlyRepliesToBS 6y agono and they will succumb to it
- NicoJuicy 6y agoWhy would they even need to stop it? They are already suing Tether and it will drop afterwards, because manipulation stopped. History has already shown that during normal days, the value of BTC drops ( 20 k -> 4 k.). So it's definitely not a store of value or a replacement for gold. I'm not really sure why Musk is promoting it though. Does he hate regulations this much ( = subjective) or does he really have some good opinions about it ? His tweets about it doesn't seem to prove anything except memes.
- jqpabc123 6y agoI'm not really sure why Musk is promoting it though. Profit. Look up "pump and dump".
- NicoJuicy 6y agoHe's practically the richest guy in the world. Big percentual risk for such a public figure
- jqpabc123 6y agoYou mean kinda like smoking pot on camera? And risk? What risk? With crypto, there is no risk because the market is "unregulated". There are dozens (probably hundreds, maybe thousands) of "pump and dump" crypto scams operating openly on the internet. Here is one. https://bigpumpsignal.net/ https://bigpumpsignal.net/ https://t.me/bigpumpsignal https://t.me/bigpumpsignal